They might not All want to quit All the time, but many of them hit their bottom and look for help. The problem is that it's hard to stay sober even if you try.
The only implication I would want to think about more is what happens next. If all or most high schoolers had been inoculated against hard drug use, does that just mean that people would buy larger quantities? Would the market simply adjust? Would more new designer drugs enter as alternatives?
If a vaccine like this existed, it would be easy to get addicts to use it in periods where they are trying to kick the habit. And that would (for most) end the nightmare. Unless you've been close to a family going through this, it is hard to explain how much of a difference that would make.
Edit: I guess most people think that crippling their children, quite possibly before they are mature enough to give consent, is fine and dandy.
This concept is nothing new; an analogous drug that provides tolerance for heroin already exists. But heroin addicts who are forced to take methadone (as opposed to those who take it to assuage withdrawal symptoms) typically just turn to other drugs.
This drug would be useless for parents - it shouldn't be used to try and force someone else not to use cocaine, since they'll just turn to other drugs. Its only potential use case is the current drug user who wishes to stop but is afraid of the withdrawal period.
This is the first time that I've heard the claim that giving someone methadone actively causes them to go to substitutes.
There are no generics for cocaine. It is a fairly unique drug that people either free base or snort.
The next jump for someone who wants to get "up" would be meth but you don't see these two being used interchangeably for the most part. I think this proposed drug has viability.
The apparent assumption here among many people that these substances are intrinsically bad is baffling to me. Where do you draw the line? Surely it can't be "legality", because several of the "schedule 1" drugs are completely harmless, and possibly even naturally occurring (in your own body!). If potential for bodily harm is the deciding factor, then we should be discussing alchohol "cures" looong before anything else. It is absurdly common and absurdly addictive.
Yes.
Good parenting decreases the chances a child will break the law in general, or be in a self destructive place.
Parenting has a lot of influence on children contrary to some peoples beliefs...
Good parents should also teach their children the difference between legality and morality.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Kohlbergs_stages_of_mo...
Smoking tobacco is legal (for now), but is increasingly being made illegal (public places, restaurants, etc). Which is a good trend IMHO.
As for antisocial? Well I can't speak for your experiences but for myself and the people I know it has been nothing but the opposite. Everyone needs to decide for themselves, including your kids.
Aside: Interesting fact about those restaurant/bar smoking ban laws: the reason they need to pass laws specifically for that purpose is because air filled with second hand smoke does not exceed the relatively very loose air quality regulations OSHA has in place. If that smoke were put there by anything besides smokers, nobody would say a thing.
Where do you draw the line. I am ok with banning something for health reasons. Not so much merely because a subset of people find it "antisocial".
Cocaine is used in doses (tens of milligrams) that are gigantic by the standards of the immune system. It takes aggressive immunization to create enough antibodies, which would produce frequent autoimmune disorders in a large population.
I don't understand what you're saying.
It sounds like you're advocating slipping your children some drug without their knowledge, in order to prevent them from doing cocaine.
Protip: My mom slipped me anti-depressants while telling me they were "vitamins". When I found out, I never trusted her again. Ever. I felt violated. Do this at your own risk.
Protip #2: If they want to do cocaine, you're not going to be able to stop them. I don't know the answer, but slipping your kids some anti-drug drug probably isn't it.
That appears to be what the original person you were responding to was suggesting. I share your concern.
Maybe people who are addicted and want to stop using?
Still, I'm skeptical as there's no mention of problems due to withdrawal.
Why would there be enough demand for the drug to create funds from VCs and grants but nor enough demand for big pharma to do something? I have no idea about Phase 3 requirements but I imagine it is not a friendly to startups.
Interesting idea, not sure how practical or ethical it is though.
That's the kind of thing that can really can bring about the downfall of an entire civilization.
It ranks right up there with "stop talking about sharks, you're scaring away the tourists" and "lets split up so we can cover more ground".
If they really want to see their vaccine approved for use, maybe they should start their own company to produce it. If there is enough of a need for the vaccine, the should be able to find funding (VC or grants).
Now, I could really see their nicotine vaccine doing very well, since there are lots of people who would voluntarily take a vaccine to stop smoking.