As to your point, Captchas have a completely legitimate use-case that you can sometimes see on Google and Amazon. If they start to have some doubts about whether you are a human being they will present you with a Captcha image to solve. Otherwise, you should be regarded innocent until proven guilty.
1. Prevent prefab'd spam bots from being able to spam your site. Almost anything, including trivial questions and Sony's "captcha", works for this. Some bots will randomly try values for unknown fields, and note if a value apparently succeeds where others failed; against such bots, questions like "2 + 2 = " or "type 'orange':" are bad. A decade ago, people were writing irc bots that could answer most trivial captcha questions. A question like "Who was the U.S. President in 1993-2001" has a better chance of going uncracked.
2. Prevent a targetted spam bot from being able to submit arbitrarily many forms on your site. "orange", "3 + 5 =", 31337e^(-pii), and sony's captcha will not work for this. If there's a question pool, someone will solve most or all of them and program the bot to respond correctly, most of the time / all the time.
The idea that someone would only ever want to do (1) is flawed. If someone's bot is flexible enough, and your question pool is shallow enough, it may be worth their time to code in responses to your custom questions even if your site caters to a relatively small audience.
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=Who+was+the+U.S.+Presid...
When the question as originally posed is asked to Alpha, it barfs with no answer:
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=Who+was+the+U.S.+Presid...
One could argue that the leap from form one to form two of the question is trivial (and it is for a thinking human), but if such a thing were so trivial for a machine then why doesn't Alpha do it? And if Alpha doesn't do it, what makes you think a random spambot will be capable of doing it?
You're right, captchas aren't supposed to be difficult, they're just supposed to prevent automation.
Second, captchas are designed to prevent automation entirely, including custom made automation targeted to a specific site. This sort of thing is less important for, say, blog comments since the value of a typical blog comment is extremely low. But there are lots of free accounts out there, for example, and if you use automation to set up new accounts you may be able to game certain systems to your advantage, corrupting the normal process of the market.
It's an interesting problem. If they make it too clear that they don't know the right answer, quality of submissions will plummet. If they keep the current form, then usability suffers.
You don't have to get it right, and in fact you can type in gibberish if you like, as long as you get the known one right, and the known one is very easy for a human to read.
The only problem: things sound nice in theory do not always work well in practice. I ran into multiple occasions where reCAPTCHA presented me impossible to recognize scans, one extreme example is a printed texture pattern with not a single letter on it.
Your average, non-tech-savvy customers will never know how the system works. They shouldn't either, otherwise the whole idea of reCAPTCHA would have been defeated.
Judging by the volume of complaints about it on various support forums, it is really a bad idea to deploy it in production when you care even slightly about usability, user experience, or simply conversion rate.
Unless your application is a must-have.
Not sure about that. Certainly tough, but crackable.
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/448963/has-recaptcha-been...
http://www.allspammedup.com/2011/01/google-recaptcha-cracked...
> reCAPTCHA uses a “one-off” system. That means a letter in a word can be incorrect, and it will still be accepted by the system.
It was however, nice of them to label the spot where my breaker should scrape the characters. (Bonus points for that label being pseudo-code for my scraper)
codinghorror.com (iirc) was using "captcha" which never changed, you just had to enter "orange". Or was it tbray.org? Anyway, Atwood claims, that naive approach was 99.9% effective: http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2006/10/captcha-effectivene...
My position is that ANY form of captcha which requires some action by visitor is broken by design and should not be used at all.
Simple captcha like this will stop most of the automattic not targeted attacs. And if someone decides to write CAPTHCA breaker specifically for this site, nothing can help—then you either degrade to the level than even humans cannot say what characters are on the screen or it is cheeper to hire Mechanical Turk to do the job.