News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sony's Captcha. View source to see why they don't "get" s... by riobard on Saturday July 23, 2011 @04:46PM (#2797780)
I know, I know. I like the idea of reCAPTCHA to crowdsource a very hard problem for the common good. I know how it works in and out. It is awesome.

The only problem: things sound nice in theory do not always work well in practice. I ran into multiple occasions where reCAPTCHA presented me impossible to recognize scans, one extreme example is a printed texture pattern with not a single letter on it.

Your average, non-tech-savvy customers will never know how the system works. They shouldn't either, otherwise the whole idea of reCAPTCHA would have been defeated.

Judging by the volume of complaints about it on various support forums, it is really a bad idea to deploy it in production when you care even slightly about usability, user experience, or simply conversion rate.

Unless your application is a must-have.

Re:Sony's Captcha. View source to see why they don't "get" s... by drivebyacct2 on Saturday July 23, 2011 @04:47PM (#2797786)
Interesting, I'd never really given it a second thought. I appreciated the drop-in ease bit and hadn't considered its effect on conversion.