News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:43AM (#27957472)
That's not a valid comparison. Mobility and transportation is a necessity for a functioning society. Your food doesn't make it onto the table without being transported there. Are you going to fetch the eggs out at the farm on foot? No, seriously, I am asking you a direct question: how are you going to transport food if you are not going to use any cars or trucks anywhere along the process?

Cigarettes are not a necessity for a functioning society.

Stick also doesn't work as well as carrot. You could tax fuel to discourage "unwanted behavior", but it doesn't have the consequences you want. It drives up prices, which affects the population unevenly.

I can afford at least one doubling in fuel price without it affecting me. Perhaps even two. Do you think the guy who has to drive 2 hours to work from the middle of nowhere to work in an Amazon fulfilment center can afford this?

Electric cars becoming a viable option for more people is a positive change. That's how we solve problems: by creating better alternatives. And if they do not emerge easily: help these industries along by providing them tax breaks and help.

I live in a country that has some of the highest gas prices in the world. High taxation of gas did _nothing_ to reduce the use of cars. It might have made the needle shiver a bit, but it didn't move it. I also happen to live in the country that has the most electric cars per capita. Electric has 70% market share among new cars sold. In 20 years, you will not even be able to buy a new gas powered car here.

That's change. That's the all-important break between hydrocarbons and land-based transport. That's the hard part.

This didn't happen due to gas tax or any other disincentives. It _ONLY_ happened by providing a better alternative. By cutting tax on electric cars so the market could reach the critical point where electric is viable. Now that we're there, we can slowly start to roll off the tax cuts as prices on electric vehicles drop.

It is tempting to piss on the things you don't like. But just being against things and not providing viable alternatives is not a plan. It is also not a plan to have vague dreams of things you cannot execute on. (If you think this constitutes a plan, ask the Chinese about "the great leap forward" or the Russians why the Soviet industry didn't become the envy of the world).

It doesn't create any lasting change. Lasting change comes from providing people with better alternatives and the enthusiastic participation of the masses.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by roenxi on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:53AM (#27957538)
Mobility and transport by car aren't necessary for a functioning society. Trains, buses, bicycles and walking can build a perfectly functional society. It'd be disruptive, certainly.

Smoking was taking a group of people and telling that they can't do something they want to do. Banning cars would be similar. People don't really seem to be honest about how arbitrary the anti-smoking campaign is. I'd much rather people smoked than drank.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:04AM (#27957620)
In your imagination this is true. In real life it is not. Sure, in theory it is possible to imagine a world where powered personal transportation doesn't exist. It might even be possible in a limited sense (for instance in densely populated, well funded cities it should be eminently possible. But not everyone lives in a well funded, densely populated city).

If you want to have adult conversations with people who feel you are taking the subject seriously, you must acknowledge reality and the non-trivial delta between it and what you suggest.

And I am serious about the "adult" part. By pretending you "know" your utopian view is possible, you expect other people to take you seriously despite not having made any effort to show your math. That's pretty disrespectful to other people. It also shows you learned nothing from past history where utopian political fantasies coupled with power ended up costing tens of millions of lives.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by Fricken on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:08AM (#27958014)
I've been hearing about the climate crisis since I was a kid in the 80s. I was also taught that an adult is someone who takes responsibility for their actions. So I've had my whole life to set my life up in a carbon conscious way. What have all the other uhh, 'adults' been doing this whole time?
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by roenxi on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:13AM (#27957682)
Most people do live in large densely populated cities. That is the thing about large areas with high population density - it means there are a lot of people there.

> you must acknowledge ... the non-trivial delta between it and what you suggest.

Yeah, it would be radical change. People aren't give up their cars by choice. But people didn't give up smoking because of their personal health concerns.

If the argument is to get rid of cars then I'm with the thread ancestor - it is better to be direct about what you want. A cars-lite future is not only possible, it is reasonable and even likely. Electric cars are not cheap and it seems optimistic to say that the grid will support them any time soon. Maybe hydrogen will work out, but these alternatives are all fundamentally uncertain technologies.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:46AM (#27957893)
Somewhere north of 4Bn people live in cities. The vast majority of which are nowhere near the utopia hinted at. Perhaps somewhere on the order of 100-200M people live in sufficiently dense and modern cities that are even capable of envisioning a path towards zero powered personal transportation.

In addition, roughly 4Bn people who do not live in cities. Densely populated and well funded or otherwise. So no, even if we are to consider only the first half of the population, your assertion does not hold in any meaningful sense.

If the goal is to get rid of powered personal transport then it begs the question "why?". Is this really a useful goal? What problem are we really trying to solve? For half the human population it makes very little sense, which means that adopting it as a sort of universal solution to all problems is a bit silly.

I can recommend reading Hans Rosling's "Factfulness" for some perspective. Because the book talks a lot about perspective and why most people in the richest part of the world tend to have a very hard time understanding what it means to be in the various wealth segments. In particular it bears thinking about what access to efficient transport means in terms of quality of life.

First you need to understand the numbers, then you need to focus on solutions. And then change can happen. The thread ancestor makes no effort to even look in this direction.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by roenxi on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:13AM (#27958048)
> ...it begs the question "why?"...

If roads were only for arterial traffic flows that would enable very high density areas without roads or parking, where people could walk to all the places they want to get to. It'd be cheaper for everyone, probably have better health outcomes and be a bit more communal. Plus safer for children because they can't be run over. Just look at how much space is wasted leaving it empty for light amounts of traffic.

And I'll also add that you are the only one who wants this to be utopian. It is transport policy. That is pretty mundane, mostly practical details and not all that exciting. The goal here would be maybe increase urban density by 20%-40%, and there are trade offs to the benefits. If you think that is a utopia then I admire how achievable your goals are.

> I can recommend reading Hans Rosling's "Factfulness"...

In which you will discover that most people can't even afford cars and nevertheless the globe keeps spinning.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @08:14AM (#27958463)
> In which you will discover that most people can't even afford cars and nevertheless the globe keeps spinning.

Then I think you have to read the book again and pay attention to what happens when people move between the bottom 3 tiers. He also spends some time describing the "view from above" problem that we experience.

I think you missed the entire point of the book. Solutions have to provide a plan for the majority of human kind. Not just the top few percent. Especially since the bottom two tiers are moving really rapidly.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by tonyedgecombe on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:01PM (#27961085)
>In real life it is not.

My grandparents never owned a car along with most of their generation.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by chii on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:57AM (#27957573)
I'd like to see you transport your mattress or ikea shelf via public transport.

Cars are a luxury that people have gotten used to, and to remove it is to remove quality of life.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by vincnetas on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:00AM (#27957593)
You don't have to get rid of ALL cars. computer cars would be 99% enough. People somehow manage to get by without car in countries like Netherlands, and till have they furniture moved around when they move.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:12AM (#27957675)
You are being dishonest here by implying people in the Netherlands do not have cars. Since you chose to make a claim without presenting any numbers I'll do it for you.

The Netherlands has about 499 motor vehicles per 1000 people. That's about 38% fewer cars per capita than the US, but it still in the top 30 countries in the world and it is about 12% lower than the european average.

Your statement is, at best, grossly misleading.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by eulenteufel on Monday July 26, 2021 @08:15AM (#27958471)
The comment is neither dishonest nor misleading. It is a fact that many people living in dense areas live a normal live without owning a car. GP was just responding to the problem of transporting large objects without owning a car and correctly stating that there is some amount of people getting by without car in the Netherlands. The solution is of course to just rent a transportation car for a few hours when you need it.

I live in a high density area (Berlin) myself with 1.4 Million cars on 3.6 Million cars. Obviously living in Berlin without a car is possible without much hassle for lots of people. Claiming that doesn't mean that nobody in Berlin needs a car. But because most of the 3.6 Million Berliners manage to move and transport furniture sometimes, we can conclude that they definitely do not need it to transport their Ikea purchase.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @08:52AM (#27958745)
The implication was that the Netherlands exemplified a country with a remarkably low number of cars per capita. The numbers do not support this assertion regardless of what GP might "feel".

It is true that most urban dwellers do not need a car. But that point can be made without trying to amplify it with false assertions.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by cwilkes on Monday July 26, 2021 @09:08AM (#27958894)
Of the 3.6M people living in Berlin how many are under 18? How many are couples that need only 1 car?
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by vincnetas on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:46AM (#27960893)
i think youre to picky. i will simplify for you: there are people who move their belongings without owning a car. there are services for that. so car is really optional thing in above. montioned usecase.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by chii on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @04:28AM (#27969994)
tell me a moving/delivery service which is available on demand, and can have it move where i want, when i want, at any time i want, and available to me 24/7, without prior notice. Because that's what a car is - you have the ability to move on demand. It's a step above rentals, because for rentals, you will have the possibility of not getting a car, or an unsuitable one.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by tonyedgecombe on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:03PM (#27961118)
Ikea deliver.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by teucris on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:37AM (#27960761)
Very few of the people on this forum are advocating for a complete removal of vehicles from society! Cars and trucks have a purpose and we should always use them when it’s the best choice for hauling goods. But we overuse cars because our infrastructure is designed for cars, causing a negative feedback loop.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by vincnetas on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:59AM (#27957585)
Having to drive 2 hours to work from middle of nowhere does not sound like good base for functioning, SUSTAINABLE society. You want to live in the middle of nowhere, you have to factor in the costs of your choice.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by throwaway0a5e on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:57AM (#27957953)
Millions of people have decided that it sucks less than the alternatives so IDK what to tell you. Sustainable or not, until something better comes along society is just gonna keep doing it.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:06AM (#27957632)
Off the top of your head, can you think of some reasons why people might end up living some distance from where they work?
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by thefr0g on Monday July 26, 2021 @09:08AM (#27958890)
They bought a house or apartment and can't sell it or rent it out fast enough when they had to take a new job?
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:59PM (#27967022)
Or perhaps they simply cannot afford to live where they work or earn a living wage where they live?
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by msk-lywenn on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:00AM (#27957591)
« Are you going to fetch the eggs out at the farm on foot? » (France) We used to, when I was a kid. But more and more gigantic supermarkets put the little farms out of business and now we can’t anymore.

So, to answer your question: yes. (Maybe on a bike though, it’s faster and I enjoy it more than walking)

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by bborud on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:28AM (#27957775)
OK, now go through the rest of your shopping needs and tally up the amount of time you are going to spend fetching these items. And no cheating by buying anything that had to be transported by truck or long haul.

I'm assuming you have a job. This provides you a basis for calculating the cost of having to spend more of your time bicycling these errands.

For my grandmother, maintaining the house, washing, running errands and cooking was more than a full time job. Meaning, she worked more than a 12 hour day and her daughter had to help her. This meant they couldn't have a job outside the household. Nor did they have much free time.

My wife has a full time job, which essentially doubles our income. The amount of time spent on baseline "errands" is approximately 2 hours per week in total (shared between the two of us). I spend on average 1-1.5 hours per day in the kitchen cooking.

The rest of the time is either income-generating work or it is spare time.

Are you willing to give up much of your spare time and cut back on your income?

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by msk-lywenn on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:06AM (#28105025)
I don’t own a car, don’t even have a licence. I bike everywhere. Yes I have a job.