I like how English managed to offset for his relatively simple grammar by totally destroying its spelling. The whole fact that things like "spelling bees" can exist was very hard to grasp to me as a kid watching stuff dubbed in Italian.
Seven years old me was always very confused by why the kids in TV shows were rewarded for knowing how to spell stuff, which is something every second grader can do in Italy for any arbitrary word. In Italian you just write things the way you hear them, and there's an almost 1:1 strong correspondence between written and spoken language. If you don't know how to write something, you also don't know how to say it.
To make it obvious, I'll use the Romanian spelling for vowels, which is practically Latin (except for "ă" which is pronounced "uh").
A became ei.
E became i (ok, this one's the exception, but in practice it's still crazy, "Mercedes" manages to have 3 - three!!! - pronunciations for it).
I became ai.
O became ău.
U became iu.
So if you look at them, they're all 2 distinct sounds (ergo the 2 letters in the Romanian spelling, except for E, which is crazy enough anyway).
I'm not counting W, Y and such because I think they weren't used in Latin.
[1] I.e. they're need a single sound to be pronounced, don't need an additional supporting sound.
Used to be written that way; compare Calcutta -> Kolkata, suttee -> sati.
> (Examples used assume a General American accent that pronounces "cot" and "caught" differently)
In combination with the directive to read "a" as in "caught", I don't know how to take this except as a call to add lip rounding to the pronunciation of foreign "a". But that can't be right?
Not an expert, but I can't offhand think of a language where this is even approximately how a is pronounced—which ones are you thinking of?
I'd say a good first guess is the "a" in "about" instead.
Our parents, who were born in the 1920s, both made the cot/caught distinction. Our mother was from the midwest, but our father grew up in the same Southern California city as we did. This suggested to me that, with respect to at least this one phonemic distinction, our language acquisition was influenced more by our peers than by our parents.
I should note that my sisters and I were initially flabbergasted that anyone pronounced those words differently and had trouble hearing the difference, while our parents were upset to learn that we pronounced them the same.
* French: "pas"
* Italian: "casa"
* Mandarin (written using pinyin): "bàng"
* German: "katze"
* Japanes (written in romaji): "arigato"
* Bahasa Indonesia: "bahasa"
Note that the sounds in these various languages are not exactly the same, but the "au" in "caught" is the closest sound in the native phonological inventory of a General American speaker (given said speaker pronounces "caught" and "cot" differently).
Also, if I listen to the audio examples at https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cot%E2%80%93caught_merger then it's exactly the other way around, that the "merged" pronunciation seems like an appropriate representation of "a" in words like Italian "casa", with "non-merged" "cought" sounding very different from that?
I personally have the merger, and so I misunderstood which direction the split went.
This too can be looked up
Please stop making up stuff like "an Indian language". If you mean Hindi-Urdu and that language family, then just call it that, don't subtly encourage people to think that is the language for all of India.
* "A" as in "ah" (like "ah, I see")
* "E" as in "e" in "pet", or the "ai" in "pain"
* "I" as in the "i" in "pit" or the "ea" in "peat"
* "O" as in the "o" in "cot" or the "o" in "cone"
* "U" as in the "u" in "put" or the "oo" in "doom"
(Americans might notice that this approximately reflects the sounds those letters represent in Spanish)
Exception/refinement: If you know the name is from an Indian language, read "a" as the "u" in "putt"
(Edit: Improved the example given for "a")