News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Went Wrong? by Aeolun on Saturday July 17, 2021 @07:13PM (#27869536)
I care about the issues (as an angineer), but my experience with raising any security issues is that it results in a lot of pain for me personally.

You report something to the ‘security’ team, and suddenly you’re responsible for doing all the work, as well as the prime suspect in an investigation ‘why didn’t you fix this before, since when did we know about this?!’

I’m absolutely incentiviced to just let any issue lie until it is discovered, because then it actually is the security teams problem.

Re:What Went Wrong? by jbuhbjlnjbn on Sunday July 18, 2021 @07:11AM (#27872067)
Jup.

To summarize, engineers mostly don't live security not because they don't care, on the contrary, but because doing so is the fastest way to sabotage yourself in the workplace and make enemies.

Two of my own examples

1) A coworker had the task of updating aged signal generators, because we had reported a bug which was then fixed. The signal generators worked without memory, a USB Stick was used as storage memory. As he plugged said USB stick into the work laptop, which he had never touched before, a virus warning popped up. We decided to do the right thing and tell our IT department about it and ask for further steps.. What followed were ridiculous hostile accusations, threats and pressure by the IT people, instead of a sensible reaction.

2) We had a safety instruction at work and it was pointed out anyone should follow safety rules and remind colleagues to spread awareness. Few days later I entered through a security door and two unknown colleagues followed right behind me. As I noticed, I politely asked them to show their access credentials. I was met with hostility and disgust. Later I learned those two were higher ranged managers, anytime I met one of them later, they remembered and treated me badly, for doing exactly what was asked.

I even went so far and told my supervisor of both instances to "raise awareness" of the reality, but only got shrugs and a blank face.

Re:What Went Wrong? by arch-ninja on Saturday July 17, 2021 @08:22PM (#27869845)
I was expelled from a university for reporting security flaws, the solution we all seek is the simplest one and for administrators it's easiest to hurt the people making noise which commonly results in the noise going away. fight-or-flight response at it's finest.

Edit: reminder that for the "common folk" these "security issues" are not a 5-minute fix, they are fundamentally different realities which require every machine on the network to be re-checked before they can be used again. There is a clear communication failure between the ones who want security and the ones who want "security".

Re:What Went Wrong? by kwhitefoot on Sunday July 18, 2021 @04:44AM (#27871583)
Which university? People should know so that they can avoid it.
Re:What Went Wrong? by wkavey on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:06PM (#27870043)
Would like to hear the story behind this one.
Re:What Went Wrong? by jacobolus on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:00PM (#27870496)
A high school friend (2 decades ago) told a teacher that the system keeping track of student grades was vulnerable to attack. The teacher asked the student to demonstrate by attacking the system and adjusting one of his test scores down by 1 point. My friend obliged, and the teacher reported the vulnerability to the administration. An administrator threatened my friend with expulsion, but when he proposed to go public with his story in response, they decided they wouldn't expel him. The resolution was "please don't tell anyone", and the vulnerability was never fixed.
Re:What Went Wrong? by Game_Ender on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:14PM (#27870073)
It’s common, a friend almost got expelled for reporting a flaw in the universities ID card system. That friend did not brake anything, they did not sneak into any protected spaces. Just discovered and validated a flaw and then reported it.
Re:What Went Wrong? by taneq on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:13PM (#27870325)
Once in a past life I discovered that the asset tracking system I was maintaining had no actual security on any of the data it returned. Once you'd logged in as one user you could just change the URL to access whatever user's data you wanted.

I raised the issue with my manager, we had a meeting about security, I explained that I wasn't a security expert but that this was a big problem and we needed to do a full security audit. I guesstimated 3 months to go through the codebase looking for security holes (in hindsight, a huge underestimate) and they said it was too expensive. Talking to fellow ex-employees the issue was still there 10+ years later.

Re:What Went Wrong? by foobiekr on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:41PM (#27870432)
Not to scare you, but I know a power plant operator who has that issue on its plant operations system. It's pretty amazing.

I know another company where anyone in the company, anyone at all with a login into account in the Active Directory SSO of any privilege at all, even a janitor, can sign any code they want with the release keys.

Nobody cares.

Re:What Went Wrong? by R0b0t1 on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:25PM (#27870571)
In a way this is similar security to what you get at a single office with no internal security. For the vast majority of history it worked.
Re:What Went Wrong? by concordDance on Sunday July 18, 2021 @05:45AM (#27871744)
The wonders of a high trust environment. The vast vast majority of people will not exploit security holes.