News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by Clewza313 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @11:13PM (#27806553)
> Third, a lot of Pichai's big bets have failed: Google Glass, Google Plus, Google Wave, Project Loon

Every single one of these predates Pichai, who only became CEO in 2015:

* Google Wave was already turned down in 2012

* Google Plus launched in 2011 and the writing was on the wall by 2015

* Google Glass consumer edition was discontinued in Jan 2015 before Pichai started

* Loon is the only arguable exception; it was started in 2011 but only promoted into an official Bet during Pichai's tenure in 2018. However, it was also an experiment from day 1, not "the next big thing" like Wave/Plus/Glass were supposed to be.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by retox on Sunday July 11, 2021 @11:23PM (#27806621)
Now you've seen how a "journalist" doesn't have the patience to spend 60 seconds searching for something you're knowledgeable about, will you (not you specifically) take as gospel anything they say about something you're not knowledgeable about?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Crichton#GellMannAmnes...

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by jancsika on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:04PM (#27811671)
It appears you are attempting to indict the entire field of journalism by referring to a cocktail story told by a sci-fi writer.

Wouldn't it make more sense to study the field and sort journalists into groups based on their performance over time? Even casual sports fan do that kind of work reflexively. I don't get why journalism should be treated any different, and I especially don't get the desire to find an anecdote that could reject the entire field out of hand.

Put differently-- if Glenn Greenwald publishes another leak-based story about state-level corruption, I'll read it and ascribe more veracity to him than I will Crichton's cocktail story. I'll bet you a dollar that when/if I do that, nothing bad will happen as a result.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by knolax on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @06:17AM (#27819295)
I think most people have never in their life read an article by a journalist about something they're knowledgeable of that wasn't complete dogshit. You mention Glenn Greenwald because presumably you're not an expert on state-level corruption. Pretty much any piece of journalism on any topic you can poke plenty of holes in with some research. Hell some articles you can use the article itself to disprove the main point the journalist was trying to make. At some point overwhelming empirical evidence can elevate a "cocktail story" to a rule of thumb.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by zimpenfish on Monday July 12, 2021 @03:59AM (#27808089)
I have to say, I find this bit amusing:

"That is the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect. I'd point out it does not operate in other arenas of life. In ordinary life, if somebody consistently exaggerates or lies to you, you soon discount everything they say."

The last 4 years of US politics (and 20? of UK politics) have given the lie to that belief.

[edit: added UK politics because they're just as bad]

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by Dah00n on Monday July 12, 2021 @09:48AM (#27810220)
Are you saying most people would answer Yes to "Are politicians trustworthy?" because then I clearly live in a completely different bubble than you do and have a very different interpretation of TV speaking heads talking about the issue. In my bubble at least 90% would say that US politicians are not trustworthy (no idea about UK). Not much different if you ask about Trump or Biden either.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by zdragnar on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:57AM (#27810923)
Individual congressmen and women tend to have high favorability ratings in the locality that voted for them, despite congress overall consistently having practically nonexistant support, and political parties not faring significantly better.

In short, every politician is trustworthy to the people who voted for them, but not the rest- kindof an inverse of the effect, really.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by saalweachter on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:25AM (#27810602)
Eh, your view of other people's cynicism is too absolute.

People distrust politicians ... except. Except for their favorite politician, except for their party, except for the ones they voted for, except...

You see this with Congress writ large. People hate Congress, its approval ratings are through the floor. But they like their own Congresspeople. Sure, gerrymandering, safe districts, etc, but by and large people are much happier with their own Representatives than everyone else's.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by Dah00n on Monday July 12, 2021 @11:00AM (#27810958)
>Except for their favorite politician, except for their party, except for the ones they voted for, except...

As I wrote in another reply I believe this to be A Very American Thing. At least I have never heard of anyone here (in Denmark) seeing themselves as represented by a person. It is more of a party thing. I'm sure I live in a bubble (don't we all) so my experience might not match any official numbers but in my experience people seem to just change to another party at the next election if they feel the representation does not match their expectation. This likely makes it easier not to get caught up in having to defend a specific person that "can do no wrong". But again, I have not looked it up and it is all based on my own experience and intuition. I do know that election day sees a much higher turnout here (~%85) than in the US (>65%?) though, but is it related to distrusting politicians? Who knows.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by pessimizer on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:27PM (#27811958)
> At least I have never heard of anyone here (in Denmark) seeing themselves as represented by a person. It is more of a party thing.

This might be a parliamentary democracy thing. In the US, everything is about borders and leaders. You're happy with corrupt politicians because corrupt politicians are connected politicians, and they might bring benefits to your state/district.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by BobbyJo on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:23AM (#27810571)
I kind of see it both ways. 90% of people would call all politicians liars, but every person in that 90% has their pet politician that can do no wrong.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by Dah00n on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:42AM (#27810752)
I'm guessing a "pet politician" is a very American Thing -though I have nothing to base it on but my own opinion- since US politics are very much based on specific persons while I'm used to people looking at politics as a big group of people they vote for out of many parties.

There are currently 15 parties to vote for here in Denmark, with a government on average being based on 2-3 of them. A single person rarely get more votes than 1% in our elections because most vote for the party, not the person.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by BobbyJo on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:16PM (#27811821)
I'm speaking specifically about individuals people vote for among the hoard in any given party or set of parties. For instance, my grandfather who thinks all politicians are crooks, believes almost everything Trump says, and my girlfriend who likewise thinks all politicians are liars, takes everything AOC says as gospel. Both disagree with a lot of what the respective parties do, or want.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by ar_lan on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:26PM (#27811934)
I'm fairly confident you cannot get to the higher levels of politics without skeletons in your closet.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by Tarsul on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:00AM (#27808737)
It's the same with typical sales persons: Even though they constantly exaggerate, you want to believe (unless there's animosity). So you take it into account that they exaggerate, but not by as much as they do exaggerate. Which means it's still better for them to do it than not. At least that's my impression of these dynamics, would love good studies about it.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by alisonkisk on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:14AM (#27809121)
It's well studied that over time people believe lies even if they know they are lies, because we remember things by association, not rigorously. We easily remember that X is associated with Y, but it's hard to remember if the correlation is to Y or to NOT Y.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by visarga on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:38AM (#27810718)
You mean people are not perfect causal reasoning agents? The shock. /s

So many AI models have been ridiculed for the same flaw - learning correlations.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by majormajor on Monday July 12, 2021 @11:11AM (#27811074)
If somebody consistently exaggerates or lies to their boss, they just might get promoted!

Let's not act like news readers or politicians are different sorts of humans than anyone else.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by moritzwarhier on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:01AM (#27808741)
I'm not convinced. The wiki article you linked to is a paragraph in an article about a novelist, not an article about widely-accepted term. And rightfully so.

Google Plus and Google Glass were big bets in my view. That doesn't take away from Google being unscrupulous in ending unsuccessful offerings. That's part of what made them succesful, I assume.

Journalists often use hyperbole or simplify complex facts to deliver an interesting and easily understandable story. That doesn't make every sinplification a gross misrepresentation.

You're free to dive deeper into any topic you want, but it's delusional to expect every reader to be an expert in every field.

Bashing journalism as a whole has become common gospel, but to me it seems that the effect of that thinking is not that people become better informed.

The article sounds Google-friendly and uncritical to me, but it's also very common to cover interviews in a way that represents the views of the interviewed person.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by moritzwarhier on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:05AM (#27809071)
OK, after reading a bit more about the persons responsible for the mentioned products, I'll admit the "big bets" part maybe was a gross misrepresentation.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by onion2k on Monday July 12, 2021 @05:17AM (#27808487)
Pinchai joined Google in 2004, and was "Product Chief" prior to becoming CEO. He's been responsible for a lot of Google products.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by Clewza313 on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:45AM (#27809300)
His leadership roles were in Chrome, Gmail and Android, not any of the four products mentioned.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by ahiknsr on Monday July 12, 2021 @05:44AM (#27808632)
> Third, a lot of Pichai's big bets have failed: Google Glass, Google Plus, Google Wave, Project Loon

> He's been responsible for a lot of Google products.

He might have been responsible but i wouldn't call those projects as Pichai's big bets.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by moshiv on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:03AM (#27808755)
Pichai is there to keep the factory lights on and the assembly line running. Nobody is expecting anything more from him.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by sn41 on Monday July 12, 2021 @11:58AM (#27811600)
You're wrong there I think. I personally was surprised by Chrome and the way it took off - initially when it started it looked like a me too product, it seemed pointless to repeat the good work at Firefox. And Android was also a good bet, though in my humble view, not as good a one as Chrome. Sundar got some big calls right.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by sjg007 on Monday July 12, 2021 @03:45PM (#27814201)
Chromebooks too.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by shric on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:25AM (#27810598)
The most accurate analogy for that responsibility would be Benjamin Treynor Sloss
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by detaro on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:05AM (#27808765)
> was "Product Chief" prior to becoming CEO

for about a year, so still after all those dates. I'd guess Wave fell into his previous responsibility though.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by sulam on Monday July 12, 2021 @09:45AM (#27810181)
Google doesn’t have a Product Chief responsible for all the products. It’s not organized that way.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by allyourhorses on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:10AM (#27808792)
> However, it was also an experiment from day 1, not "the next big thing"

Not sure I understand that distinction. If I label all my projects as experiments, do I also get to escape culpability for their failure while loading on the self-praise when they succeed?

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by wutbrodo on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:53AM (#27810885)
> If I label all my projects as experiments, do I also get to escape culpability for their failure while loading on the self-praise when they succeed

Sure, if your funding sources are okay with spending 100% on a high-variance, low-hit-rate manner of output. Every single Google earnings call I've been on has the CEO reassuring investors about their high-risk "moonshots", emphasizing that they're only 5% of Google's budget. You'll note that the parent comment didn't use that reason to justify the other failures, which were not explicitly classified pre hoc as high-risk experiments.

I'm not sure how you think the answer could be anything other than yes. If you were working on high-risk moonshot private projects and either self-funding them or being funded by someone comfortable with the risk of your endeavor, do you think you _wouldn't_ "escape culpability" yet be rewarded for successes?

(Note also that you're using an extremely odd definition of "escaping culpability". Moonshots failing is the _expected_ outcome, and pointing that out isn't helping anyone "escape culpability".

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by Clewza313 on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:44AM (#27809292)
Kinda? All of Alphabet's Bets including Loon are explicitly high-risk, high-reward "moonshots", meaning it's expected for many if not most to fail.

By contrast, Wave, Plus and Glass were all consumer products from the mothership that were heavily hyped as being the Next Big Thing that would revolutionize work/IM, social networks and mobile phones respectively.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by dekhn on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:16AM (#27810508)
loon was neither high risk or high reward. it was just an internet balloon.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by nostrademons on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @01:35AM (#27817882)
A lot of Loon's early engineers were drawn from a team I was on, because Loon's founder (Mike Cassidy) was our PM's boss. When our PM left to work with him, he said "It's a crazy idea. Less than 5% chance of success." He joined it anyway. The team certainly felt it was both high risk and high reward.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by dekhn on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @09:56AM (#27821003)
But... why? It's just a balloon with internet. All the failures would be a lack of business model, not the technology.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by nostrademons on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @01:54PM (#27823971)
A quick list of issues that early engineers had to solve with Loon:

1. Can you get wi-fi reception on the ground from a balloon? How big a transmitter, how big a power source, how long can you keep it going for, and how much weight do you need to spend on batteries for this?

2. Will your wi-fi reception cut out if a tall building happens to pass between you and the balloon? How do you mitigate this? Do you need duplicate coverage from multiple balloons? (Starlink is dealing with this now.)

3. How do you keep the balloons in one place, or at least control where they go? If one goes out of range, how do you make sure there's another covering all its receivers?

4. How much propellant/battery can you carry on the balloon for course adjustments? How long can it stay aloft before this is exhausted?

5. Where do the winds go in the stratosphere? If the balloons are not propelled, where will they end up? Can you use altitude changes to get into different jet-streams and reduce propellant use?

6. How do you respect country's airspace? How do you avoid causing international incidents? If a balloon does come down, how do you ensure it doesn't harm anyone and can be retrieved? Early in the project, Loon had an ops team of former navy SEALs whose job was to retrieve any crashed balloons without starting any wars.

And I wasn't even on the team - this is just what I got from a few lunchtime conversations. They had to invent new algorithms, first to model the wind systems in the stratosphere and then to optimize balloon placement given that wind. I know their CTO - he's got a Ph.D in stochastic optimal control (pretty appropriate for this problem). The math behind control theory, once you get past simple PID controllers, is hard.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by dekhn on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:44PM (#27835115)
Much of what you describe are pedestrian problems that could be addressed by straightforward, low-risk engineering. The issues with wifi reception around buildings were solved by AT&T when they developed the tech for mobile phones long ago. All the balloon control stuff- people have navigated balloons around the world for a while now. Using the altitude changes to navigate is standard.

That you need a team of NAVY SEALs to clean up your messes is a sign you're doing it wrong.

After working at Google for 12 years, I am always amazed at how people talk up their projects as risky when really, there's little or no risk involved, and the majority of the problems are political or social opposition to your plans, as well as the lack of a business model.

Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by allyourhorses on Thursday July 15, 2021 @04:30AM (#27842551)
Parent comment is classical old guard mentality Googler who thinks if something sounds big and impressive it automatically is big and impressive. It was a marketing trick that weirdly infected employees throughout the org, glad to see here the trick has all but completely lost its effect.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by alisonkisk on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:15AM (#27809126)
Yes. The best baseball players miss almost every swing. The best poker players lose almost every hand.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by sgift on Monday July 12, 2021 @03:36AM (#27807980)
And isn't Google Glass redirected at companies were it enjoys (a moderate) success?
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by codyogden on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:05AM (#27808121)
Correct. It’s been utilized in a highly limited capacity in enterprise conditions, like manufacturing. The Community Edition (aka consumer version) was killed.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by ipaddr on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:06PM (#27817032)
And not because of lack of demand because of fears we would be recorded everywhere. Fast forward and we are recorded everywhere anyways.
Re:Sundar Pichai warns of threats to internet freedom by vkou on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:00AM (#27806896)
Wave also largely turned into Enterprise Apps - docs, hangouts, etc.

Plus was Larry's and Vic's baby.