There is no way you can financially prepare for the magnitudes of repairs needed in their case.
We looked at a large number of buildings in the area, and was surprised that maybe 1% of the information you need to assess board/management competence is available online. Generally we'd have to do our own DD talking to people in the buildings.
IMO it makes a huge difference, >10% of the purchase price should be on the quality of the board and management.
Seems like a startup opportunity to be Yelp for Condo Boards/HOAs. (I'm sure there are a dozen+, of course. I haven't done the DD on that!)
A forum can also be setup if necessary.
* ticketing system with management company
* way to set up ACH/dues payments
* ways to look at docs and minutes
* way to communicate with the board
* calendar of the board meetings
* way to communicate with the other owners
Sure, you could put that together mostly with Gsuite functionality, but an integrated modern product would be really great.After a few startups, I've learned that you have to love the problem domain to survive the startup grind.
I don't love the problem domain of HOA and HOA management.
I'm also unsure what the sales cycle would be like, so the first step, if I (or anyone else) were to head down the path, would be to call up a bunch of boards and/or management companies and see how they buy.
We have a management company, but working with them sucks. There's no good ticketing system or visibility from board to the management company to make sure follow through happens or is fair.
From what I could tell, most of the software in this space is marketed to management companies, not HOA boards. Of course the management company doesn't want to pay for it, so we're stuck. And this is the best of 3 management companies I've worked with.
Board meeting minutes are not hidden from owners, but probably are not public info. (Stuff like bids and fines are recorded there.)
But we were able to pay for repaving the parking lot (5 figure project, I think, I was off the board by then) and replacing two elevators (6 figure projects) without a special assessment.
I would much much rather have dues increase regularly and not have special assessments than the reverse. Deferred maintenance is not good (and obviously can be dangerous). It's one thing when it is happening at a single family home, where all the risk and reward are localized. But when it happens at the group level, being proactive is a huge win, even when it is painful.
I can't imagine a world where you get an inspection done and residents get told congrats! you owe $100-$350k (depending on the size of your unit) where that isn't a glacially slow process that doesn't generate lots of pushback.
Particularly in Florida where I bet you have lots of retired folks living in those condos.
edit: I was off on the numbers. $80k for the smallest units to $336k for a penthouse [1]. Doesn't really change my conclusion about how folks react when they wake up and get a low six figure bill
[1] https://www.cnn.com/2021/06/28/us/surfside-condo-owners-asse...
We were lucky to have a decent management company that provided a lot of guidelines and information about what we should be doing. As well as the things we were obligated to do (either because of bylaws or laws, in Texas). Still, any time there was a storm resulting in additional costs for landscaping/cleanup, or work on a damaged/degrading stone wall, or the pool area, etc. We heard about it from some neighbors who didn't want to spend any money, because it didn't directly affect them.
It's definitely an area that more regulations would help everyone involved. We were not experts, but could make some decisions if we had the right information (or knew what questions we should ask).
Fannie mae and freddie mac require at least 10% of gross dues go into reserves. FHA and VA have higher standards. So only cash buyers, or buyers with non standard loans can buy condos that don't meet this requirement. But unless a condo is a townhome style building where there is very little common property this should really be 25% or higher
Yet they choose to live in a collective structure. It's essentially another level of government entered into via contract. Maybe they should choose to live in an independent residence if they didn't want that.
I think there is an underlying trend of that due to certain populations’ socioeconomic status slipping, and I think with the slowdown in population growth, we will be seeing more if it as society decides how to allocate fewer resources.
In your example, the neighbors are the tribe. The other people on the other side of town who are poorer, for various reasons, simply will not get a park.
However, if the economy is growing and everyone is moving up the ladder, then it will be easier to spread the fruits around to everyone. You are likelier to support taxes and condo fees to assist others, since you yourself are not stagnating or moving down the ladder.
It depends, but I generally agree. I would say the mentality should be that it benefits the community and not necessarily any one person.
"The other people on the other side of town who are poorer, for various reasons, simply will not get a park."
I don't think you understand just how small most small towns are. Many times there's only one park. If it is tribal at all, there tends to be only one tribe (or there are personal issues).
"we’ll raise money for our neighborhood park, but of course they have money since their ancestors got there first (or maybe worked harder?) and passed down their land or whatever other structural advantages."
The current generation (and previous one or two) are worse off than before. The mines and mills have shut down. The vast majority of the factories have been offshored. The industries that have replaced them, like tech, have mostly consolidated in just a handful of large cities. Most have little to no money.
The land you talk about is really a negative point. The family farms generally get divided when handed down. Or they simply are too small by today's standards. They get consolidated by corporations. The land in these areas isn't worth very much either ($500-1000 per acre).
So what assets they get handed down are diluted, and aren't worth much in the market (even depreciated). The structure has been going against them for decades (jobs move out, people move out, demand drops, prices drop). The region is severely economically depressed. These are people working and organizing to make their community better. This is what government should be. Not some distant vague entity that wants to solve everything through taxes.
Here's an example, in the area I'm in now I am part of an organization. They wanted a few trees cut down that weren't near anything. It would be easy to do. The people cutting them down could even use or sell the wood. It would be no risk and no cost to the organization. Instead they chose to hire someone at a cost of a few thousand dollars...
But collective structures are difficult at all scales. Some people have a fair bit of money and want issues, even just aesthetic ones, fixed now. And others are probably living paycheck to paycheck.
The frustrating part for me as a homeowner was that dues were assessed based on square footage, but out of 200+ homes, ours was one of the only 15 or so that were fully detached. We had use of a communal driveway we shared with 5 neighbors as well as a small private park 2/3rds of a mile down the road, but other than that, we were fully responsible for all of our unshared infrastructure. If our roof had a problem we had to fix it at our own expense, even though we paid in to the roof repair fund.
There were were many more homes (ie. a city or a country instead of a neighborhood) or if there was a greater variety of homes (ie. a larger percentage of detached homes) or if there was some obvious wealth disparity (ie. our detached home wasn't smaller than many of the attached homes) or some other mitigating factors, I'd have been happy to pay in on the assumption that "what goes around comes around" and "rising tide raises all ships", but in this case, my partner and I felt pretty cheated. That said, we didn't make a stink. We just paid the damn dues (...and then later moved somewhere without an HOA).
I lived in a condo complex where the association had its VP resign, so I put my hat in the ring, and even though my track record was only speaking up and attending meetings, I won with N-1 votes out of N.
The board put forward a resolution, which passed by a huge majority, to make most large, non-monthly costs special assessments. The resolution came with written language about how people were going to have to fund their share of large costs like roof fixes from their savings. I though this was reasonable.
The special case here is that 60 units were owned as individual residences and 300 units were owned by a corporation and rented like apartments. So I was amazed that they voted all their votes for me in the VP election, and not amazed that they would want to fund roof repair and such the new way.
The Surfside situation would not have been changed by the resolution about funding repairs. If that corporation had looked at our building before taking over, and saw what the inspectors saw in Surfside, they wouldn't have bought in in the first place.
I was on the board of a 10 unit condo building. The annual budget for the association was ~$60k. We had a reserve provision of 10% of dues, plus whatever was leftover in the budget at the end of the year.
Even with that budgeting provision we had several additional assessments over the course of a decade. Those assessments were used to address roof issues and interior renovations.
If something more structural had come up, that would have led to another (large) assessment, for sure.
We shouldn't have a democracy; people won't vote for reps who will vote to pay for things that don't directly affect them.
It's a problem as old as time :)
Buying into a condo has the risk of this sort of thing happening. It has to be carefully assessed.
IMO for condos specifically, the board shouldn't have to hold a referendum to do special assessments. It should be a majority of the board.
Nobody wants to pay for what is a collective problem. Sometimes I think condo's shouldn't even be legal because of this. They should all be apartments with a central management company.
The solution is really tightening fiducial regulations on condo HOA's. There could easily be a formula of like 10% of annual dues need to be put in a rainy day fund or something... Banks have started to tighten their lending around condos and ask for more up front financial info.