News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by _ph_ on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @06:36PM (#27694310)
Wouldn't solar be much better for powering desalination than nuclear power? It is way cheaper per energy produced than nuclear, especially in those countries, which need desalination most. Also, it doesn't take a decade to set up. Not even mentioning proliferation issues.
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by state_less on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @06:53PM (#27694465)
Yes, solar is dirt cheap energy and you wouldn’t need much of a battery (or any?) in this case, since you can store the excess product water in a tank.

I power my water maker with about 1400 watts and can make 35 gallons an hour. The panels, electronics and water maker were ~ $5000. I did the work myself at a slow pace, so not sure what the labor costs would be.

I set my system up in about 2 weeks. The requirements are a bit of time, seawater access and some capital.

https://seawaterpro.com/

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by jeroenhd on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:28PM (#27694741)
$5000 in a third world country is quite a lot.

For context, according to CEIC data [1], the average salary in Algeria is about $300 per month. That "dirt cheap" project of yours is more than a year's worth of labor.

Locally priced goods may be cheaper, but the US does benefit from a more direct shipping line with China (where most of these products come from, especially cheap solar panels). There's repair costs to be taken into account and if these become a necessity, you'll also have to take into account some kind of protection for when those without the means to buy one of these setups become desperate.

It's true that solar is relatively safe and cheap compared to other power sources, but projects like these are difficult to map to places where they can make a life-or-death difference. If things were that easy, we'd probably cover a patch of Sahara desert with solar panels and power the entire African continent for decades, with power to spare to export to other continents.

[1]: https://www.ceicdata.com/en/algeria/average-monthly-wages

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by state_less on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @09:06PM (#27695303)
Yeah, it’s tough out there. I think the capital cost might be around $15 to $40 a month depending on how generous the lender is.

Evaporative is interesting too, but solar isn’t too bad to maintain. Most of the maintenance would probably be keeping the filters, pumps and membranes in working order.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by Johnny555 on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:55PM (#27694903)
That seems like a lot of cost and complexity for a rural installation in a 3rd world country. How does the water output compare with, say, spending $1000 a simple evaporation design? The size of the evaporation pool would be larger than 1400W worth of solar, but it's much simpler and easy to repair.
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by state_less on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @09:45PM (#27695521)
I agree there is more complexity, but it may be worth it. Making electricity buys a good deal of versatility. If you have a bit extra, you can run an inductive burner, charge your phone/laptop or charge a house battery (if/when you can afford one).

I think in either system, teaching the locals to setup the system and maintain it themselves is important for keeping the costs down.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by Johnny555 on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @09:57PM (#27695572)
But my question is, what's the cost benefit?

$1000 would buy a pretty large solar still and you can spend the extra $4000 on a solar phone charger if that's something the locals need. Meanwhile there's little that can go wrong with a solar still and if something does go wrong, they can likely fix it (even if temporarily) with duct tape. Losing their cell phone charger and cooktop to electrical failure sounds like less of a problem than losing their water source.

An inductive burner, cell phone charger, desalinator, etc all sound great on a $200,000 boat where the owner is wealthy enough to keep it maintained and probably keep spares. But putting expensive and complicated electronics in a village so remote that they don't even have reliable water seems like a mistake.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by state_less on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @10:33PM (#27695756)
I wouldn’t discount people’s ability to do some basic electrical repair. And maybe the neighbors can lend you some water till you get back up and running.

You might be right though, if it’s remote enough and you have room, perhaps a solar still is the cheapest and simplest option. It seems like it would have to be very large to give comparable amounts of water. Do you know someone selling such kits?

In any event, maybe this gives folks some ideas for lowish cost options.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by drran on Thursday July 01, 2021 @08:57AM (#27698629)
Yep, evaporator + condenser works very well in nature for billions of years.

For example: https://news.mit.edu/2020/passive-solar-powered-water-desali...

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by bin_bash on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @06:46PM (#27694398)
Solar doesn’t provide nearly as much energy and for desalination you need a surprising amount.

Nuclear is a great use-case since the problem with nuclear is it needs a constant water source. If you’re desalinating you’ve got that problem covered.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by _ph_ on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:26PM (#27694720)
Solar doesn’t provide nearly as much energy and for desalination you need a surprising amount.

That statement doesn't make any sense to me. If you need more power, install more panels. Space certainly isn't an issue in like northern Africa. It is cheaper to order a gigawatt or more of solar panels than building a new nuclear reactor, and faster to set up too. Even Germany today has way more solar capacity than it ever had in nuclear, and it is less a great place for solar than Africa.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by akiselev on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @08:31PM (#27695117)
The vast majority of our freshwater comes from sources that cost us effectively zero in energy: the water cycle moves water towards higher elevations and it flows down towards our populations. Worst case scenario, water in ancient underground reservoirs is pumped to the surface.

If we had to desalinate all that water and actively distribute it instead, it'd be a significant fraction of our current global power consumption. The power sources need to be concentrated near the desalination plants and at least half the world lives 100km+ away from a coastline. At 3 kWh per m^3 of water[1] and ~3.5 m^3 per person per day [2], that's an extra ~3800 kWh per year, which would increase per capita energy consumption by 25-30% [3] in the United States just for desalination.

We have enough challenges replacing existing power infrastructure with solar and wind. Placing the burden of desalination on top of that is unrealistic, especially since the NIMBY fight over solar installations of that size would probably be just as fierce as for a nuclear reactor.

[1] https://res.mdpi.com/d_attachment/energies/energies-12-00463...

[2] https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/scie...

[3] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.USE.ELEC.KH.PC?locat...

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by _ph_ on Thursday July 01, 2021 @02:06AM (#27696694)
I have never claimed, that we would replace all fresh water used on this planed by desalinated water. This certainly is neither feasably nor necessary. At best, it can be an important contribution to water supply in many regions.

I was only answering to the original post which suggested we would build nuclear power plants to desalinate water. There I commented that solar would be cheaper (and more environment friendly) for the same task.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by scraptor on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @08:05PM (#27694965)
> Even Germany today has way more solar capacity than it ever had in nuclear

That's because it never had much nuclear capacity, not because it now has a lot of solar

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by _ph_ on Thursday July 01, 2021 @02:02AM (#27696675)
I don't know what you mean by "much", but Germany has a peak power capacity of 56 GW of Solar. On good days the output comes close to the nuclear output of France, which is mostly nuclear in power production. German wind power occasionally eclipses French nuclear power production.
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by koyote on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @09:58PM (#27695578)
The Sydney desalination plant is entirely powered by Wind:

https://www.sydneydesal.com.au/caring-for-the-environment/10...

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by jeroenhd on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:32PM (#27694762)
Nuclear power is severely restricted and building a nuclear power plant in a country dealing with active terrorist movements is probably something to be avoided.

Solar is relatively inefficient, but it can't be used to build a dirty bomb or worse. With large patches of uninhabit{ed,able} desert, many African countries have more than enough space to build large solar farms if they can find a solution to the sand blowing onto the panels.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by stavros on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:10PM (#27694610)
Does nuclear need fresh water? I'd imagine salt water would wreck all the equipment, and you probably don't want to use up all the fresh water you generate...
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by akiselev on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @08:49PM (#27695221)
The water is just there for thermal mass to conduct waste heat away from the condenser. The water that gets heated by the reactor core and turns the turbines is isolated and highly purified, since many of the internals can only be accessed during refuels. Some designs go further and separate the reactor coolant system from the steam generator to prevent contamination, but AFAIK there isn't a single commercial design that allows outside water to feed into the reactor cooling or power generation systems. The parts of the condenser that touch the external body of water are basically just blocks of metal that have to be scrubbed on the outside from time to time.
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by AngryData on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:47PM (#27694850)
The turbines do but you can recycle much if not nearly all of that water by cooling the steam and condensing it, which you could use sea water to heat exchange to for it.
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by m4rtink on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @09:19PM (#27695386)
You have heat exchangers between saltwater and clean freshwater that circulates through the sensitive parts of the plant.
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by b0tzzzzzzman on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:15PM (#27694650)
You need very pure water for most portions of a nuclear power plan.
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by justshowpost on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @08:24PM (#27695076)
Not really. Pure heavy water along with pure uranium and pure CANDU reactors are imported components. The quality of cooling water and feed water doesn't matter much.

Remember, nuclear power plant is merely a very large heat engine. The main problem is terrorism there.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by gruez on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:25PM (#27694715)
that'd depend on the reactor type, no?
Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by gruez on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:25PM (#27694712)
> Solar doesn’t provide nearly as much energy and for desalination you need a surprising amount.

Are there numbers for this? One one hand solar might provide more energy than nuclear if you're only interested in heat generation, but on the other hand using heat to desalinate (ie. boiling water) is also less efficient than using reverse osmosis.

Re:Heat dome causing record breaking heat wave by lebuffon on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:31PM (#27694758)
Last I checked Algeria has a bit of solar energy hitting it. :)