News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by HenryKissinger on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:37AM (#27569811)
What does Amazon need thousands of engineers for, exactly?

Amazon.com is a fine website. It is finished. It is complete, perfect as it is. The website could remain the exact same for the next ten decades, with minor adjustments to the product menus to reflect new products, and it would serve its purpose perfectly without risking being dethroned by competitors.

Why do millions of lines of code need to be written each month? It certainly isn't reflected in my browsing experience.

The British cracked the German naval codes with no more mathematicians than can sit at a table. But Amazon needs thousands of engineers to run an e-commerce website (and its concurrent AWS, which could be run by less than 50 engineers)?

(Not a software engineer or someone who's ever worked for $AMZN)

Edit: Woosh, way too many people failed to understand that this post was mostly sarcasm. Cunningham's Law in action.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by brazzy on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:44AM (#27569887)
>AWS, which could be run by less than 50 engineers)?

What the...

> (Not a software engineer

Ah, yes.

It shows.

50 engineers is probably less than the size of some support teams within Amazon that handle a single large corporate AWS customer.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by middleclick on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:48AM (#27569921)
This is a peak HN comment (the one you are replying to)! The other day on the Wikipedia thread, there was a data scientist who said he could run a website like Wikipedia all by himself. "How hard it is?". And here we have the same thing for Amazon..
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by ghaff on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:08AM (#27570124)
Admittedly I've even heard senior executives rhetorically ask "What do all those people at $LOCATION even do?" At scale, you need a lot to sell, support customers, put marketing programs in place, do developer outreach, test, be on call, etc. etc. But, yeah, you'd think it would obvious that even just talking about straight engineering, you need more than a fraction of a person to develop and enhance each AWS service.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by earth2mars on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:04AM (#27570079)
AWS have close to 200 services. If the origina cmmenter js saying each service has 50 folks, it is 10k people. Which sounds about right the company have more than a million people working across all sub organizations. So you can imagine all kinds of work environments
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by stavros on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:50AM (#27569938)
Listen if you can't run 33% of the internet with 50 engineers what are you even doing?
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by hermannj314 on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:43AM (#27569877)
Amazon also sells hardware (kindles, echo, sidewalk), has a media platform through Prime, has logistics software for vendor and order fulfillment, in addition you are underestimating the cost of running a global e-commerce site (legal complicance, security, privacy, accessibility, etc. are constant technical draws on even established products)
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by nuclearnice1 on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:10AM (#27570142)
Well this controversial opinion sure got pounded down.

> The British cracked the German naval codes with no more mathematicians than can sit at a table.

The Government Code and Cipher School employed almost 10k people during ww2.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by oblio on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:55AM (#27570626)
Yeah, but you couldn't fit all those 10k people in a Hollywood movie.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by Rebelgecko on Monday June 21, 2021 @12:16AM (#27576275)
And the Polish mathematicians who reverse engineered the Enigma machines weren't invited to sit at the table once they shared their work with the British and French
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by a4isms on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:51AM (#27569948)
Consider this metaphor:

You go on vacation. You stay at a hotel, not a “B&B.” Your vacation, your money, so you find a place close to the things you want to see, with plenty of free amenities like free continental breakfast and free WiFi.

It’s somewhat reasonably priced, too.

Now you go on a business trip financed by your employer, who books you into a “business class” hotel. It’s also close to things you want to see, and it has a few nicer finishes than your vacation hotel.

But the service is worse! You have to order WiFi, and they have some annoying provider that puts roadblocks between you and their slow WiFi. There’s free coffee in the room, but if you want breakfast, you pay nosebleed prices for room service or you have to line up for a table in their brunch restaurant.

And their “rack rate” for rooms is double what you paid on vacation! How could your employer be so stupid as to book you into this expensive hotel and force you to suffer worse service?

Makes no sense. Ok, what’s the connection?

———

Well, WHY does your employer prefer the expensive place with bad service? The answer is that it provides good service for your employer, but not for you. YOU AREN’T THEIR CUSTOMER.

The business-class hotel integrates with your employer’s billing and expense systems. Your company can easily book dozens, hundreds, or even thousands of rooms when they’re putting on a conference. They have incentive pricing that appeals to companies, not people.

They have GREAT customer service when you’re calling about a billing code, but not when you’re calling about an extra pot of hot water for your tea.

We don’t see that as guests of the hotel. So if we were to discover that the big hotel chain has hundreds or even thousands of programmers, we’d ask, “What do they need so many engineers for? All they have is a crappy web site that can take a reservation, in a crappy way.”

We don’t see the people putting in the work to integrate with systems we can’t see, serving the needs of people and companies we don’t even know exist.

I betcha it’s the same at Amazon. We can’t judge the complexity of their operations looking at the page they serve us when we buy a book online. We have no idea what’s involved integrating with the corporations that provide them with music, TV shows, and movies to stream.

We have no idea how complicated it is to integrate with all the logistics systems around shipping products around the world, in real time.

There’s a massive machine we can’t see. That’s what all those programmers are building and maintaining.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by ghaff on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:59AM (#27570017)
While I don't disagree with your general point, I'm not sure it broadly applies here.

Honestly, a nice B&B is probably priced pretty similarly to a business-class hotel.

Why do I usually stay in business class hotels in cities? Chain hotels like Marriott's brands are pretty consistent quantities. A random B&B really isn't. Business class hotels also tend to have 24-hour desks, I can leave my luggage after checkout, etc. If I don't really care much about the hotel, which tends to be the case when I'm traveling in a city on business, some mid-level chain hotel is just less mental overhead.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by a4isms on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:04AM (#27570082)
All true, but I’m not comparing a business-class hotel to a B&B, I’m comparing one kind of hotel to another. All the major chains have offerings in both markets I describe:

1. Hotels that appeal to guests who pay their own way, and; 2. Hotels that appeal to companies with business travel needs.

The second type of hotel has the massive machine hidden from guests.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by ghaff on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:12AM (#27570167)
Certainly all the business class hotels have the ability to reserve room blocks, cater events, pre-book rooms, etc. But those are essentially additional profit centers. I'm just saying that many/most of us essentially deal with hotels 1:1 even for business travel.

But, yes, there are some brands of e.g. Marriott that are in part oriented to corporate events and the like and other that are mostly for individual travelers whether on vacation or business.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by cduzz on Sunday June 20, 2021 @12:30PM (#27571582)
My wife and I were recently escorted from a Ritz (a sub-brand of Marriot);

We were paying in points (a lot of points), they checked us in but still couldn't figure out their back-office payment processing or something because they confronted us at 9:00pm and asked us to swipe a card because "they couldn't verify the certificate"

After much back and forth between us and the front office and a customer support rep on the phone (who repeatedly suggested that the "certificate" was there and valid), we decided we didn't really want to deal with the hassle of staying where we were being treated like criminals.

I went up to get our stuff from our room and my card had been deactivated; I had be escorted to the room by a member of the Ritz security staff to get our luggage.

So, you're not really assured a good experience no matter where you stay.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by a4isms on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:16AM (#27570223)
Of course we do. I’m just explaining why such a place might have many, many more programmers and other employees than we would guess are needed judging by our experience out at the periphery of their business.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by ghaff on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:24AM (#27570304)
Absolutely, and I'm usually perfectly cool with some nice B&B having some janky third-party website or even, gasp, having to call them on the phone to make changes etc. I'm not fine with Marriott not having a streamlined mobile app, a loyalty program, 24-hour customer service, etc.There are certainly economies of scale with companies generally but there are also costs.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by wdb on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:28AM (#27570344)
I have to meet the first employer that does the hotel bookings for me. I always need to sort it myself and expense back. The only thing the employer did is arranging a discounted room price.

Normally, meant that I spend at least one day a month doing my hotel/travel expenses. That's ~40-46 lost working days :)

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by a4isms on Sunday June 20, 2021 @11:38AM (#27571078)
Pay yourself and expense it back is usually an SMB strategy for keeping costs down by offloading work onto employees. It’s not just your time that’s wasted, but all the work to organize expense reports, make sure you used the right codes, &c.

It’s a headache for you and the folks in accounts, but at small scale, that works. But as the company grows, this becomes harder to justify. At some point they centralize a lot of this stuff, and when they do, many choose to start booking people into hotels that cater to businesses who book people into hotels.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by ghaff on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:01AM (#27570040)
Seems like you should get off your butt and create an AWS competitor with 50 engineers. You'll be able to underprice them by so much you'll completely eat their lunch.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by terafo on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:46AM (#27569899)
AWS alone requires thousands of software engineers. And there is Amazon Echo, Twitch, Prime Video, a lot of software for warehouses and logistics, their autonomous stores, game studios, Kindle, Amazon Fire devices, their app store, Audible and I barely scratched the surface.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by bennysomething on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:45AM (#27569892)
How do you know it's "finished"? You could have said the same thing in 2006 and been completely wrong. What makes you think the customer front end of Amazon is where the bulk of the engineering is?

Edit: engineering and maintaining the infrastructure of Amazon compared Vs cracking a code in world war two seems like a strange comparison.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by padastra on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:06AM (#27570095)
You should ask yourself how you can be so self-assured yet wrong by several orders of magnitude. I'm not saying that as an insult -- it's probably worth re-evaluating your confidence : accuracy relationship.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by lucasyvas on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:14AM (#27570194)
Indeed, a truly remarkable disconnect with reality that honestly makes me question the point of having an account on a site called "Hacker News."
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by thesuperbigfrog on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:11AM (#27570148)
>> Not a software engineer or someone who's ever worked for AMZN.

Exactly. There is SO much more going on than you realize.

The Amazon retail website gets hundreds of thousands of orders every second. New code gets deployed literally every night.

The retail website is like the tip of an iceberg floating above the water. There are hundreds of web services underneath that provide the backend and data stores. Each one of those services has a team of engineers to maintain the service with one engineer oncall 24/7.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by rytill on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:46AM (#27569902)
> and its concurrent AWS, which could be run by less than 50 engineers

One engineer for every four offerings.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by aetherson on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:38AM (#27569831)
Most Amazon engineers do not work on the amazon.com front end.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by 0kl on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:43AM (#27569880)
Amazon web services runs a fair share of the internet. Around 33% as of Sept 2020 according to Forbes [^1].

[^1]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/danrunkevicius/2020/09/03/how-a...

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by jlund-molfese on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:49AM (#27569924)
Heavily-utilized websites are like icebergs. You see the homepage, but what about the constant ongoing work to ensure sellers don't game your review system? What about emergent product categories? What about integration with your competitor's new smart home device? Amazon doesn't pay most of its engineers to sit around.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by Tabular-Iceberg on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:15AM (#27570202)
They have a big product portfolio, so less than 50 engineers is a big stretch even in the best of circumstances.

But they are clearly in a very deep hole of technical debt that they will never be able to dig themselves out of, so all they can do is throw more people at the problem.

I don’t think this warrants being downvoted to the point of being barely readable. The estimate may be way off, but it’s a perfectly good basis for a discussion. Please don’t do this when you can use words instead.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by tequila_shot on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:39AM (#27569836)
They have other suites of products apart from the AMZN.com. - AWS and the shitload of solutions on AWS come to mind. - A lot of internal tools for managing supply chain, financials etc also come to my mind.
Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by lwhi on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:50AM (#27569931)
Too many assumptions here.

You need to consider the number of the tech products and the number of markets.

The resulting number would be vast.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by amazon_throw on Sunday June 20, 2021 @11:39AM (#27571092)
HAHAHAHHHHa hah... hah. ha hah cough

Oh, wow, what an amazing take. You owe me a new keyboard.

Re:Hire-to-fire at Amazon India? by luma on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:43AM (#27569873)
AWS is a money printing machine in a very dynamic market. They need to keep the pace or MS will eat their lunch.