News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by mlinsey on Monday July 11, 2011 @01:47AM (#2749628)
We'll see. I agree that Facebook Groups is much less powerful than Circles and much less fundamental to the core Facebook experience than Circles is with G+.

On the other hand, Facebook Groups takes less effort to use - each person does not need to sort their friends, a small number of curators can organize the group. More importantly, it is clearer to the user just what is going on. I have been trying to talk to as many non-techie non-early-adopters as possible about Circles, and many get it and love it, but several don't really understand it.

In particular, the asymmetry of circles is overlooked by a lot of people, even by some casual users who think they understand how Circles works. On Facebook, there is one authoritative list of who is in the group, and posts to the group stay in that group. On Google+, your circles are not my circles. I may have you in a "close friends" circle, you may have me in a big "co-workers" circle, or you might have all your friends in one circle. When I am browsing my "close friends" feed and see a post by you, I may guess wrong about the social context that you are sharing that message in, and make an inappropriate comment, not realizing who else received the message. (The way to determine on G+ who received a post is by noting and clicking on the gray "Public" or "Limited" in the upper right of the post) Maybe I am underestimating people, or maybe comments are just much less big a deal than posts, but I think this lack of clear social context for individual messages within Circles is going to lead to some serious privacy/sharing accidents.

If I had to make a prediction, I'd think that the ease-of-use and clarity of FB Groups will trump the power and flexibility of Circles. I could be wrong, so it'll be interesting to see what ordinary users prefer.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by waterlesscloud on Monday July 11, 2011 @01:54AM (#2749636)
There are a number of areas in G+ that seem like they're going to lead to highly-publicized mistakes, and the asymmetry of circles is certainly one of them. You basically have no way to know who can see your comment on a post (outside of the fact that everyone can see it on a "public" post).

I also suspect an Weinergate style mis-post of something that was supposed to be private will occur fairly early on. Though to be fair, nothing is as easy to misdirect as a twitter DM.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by henrikschroder on Monday July 11, 2011 @03:13AM (#2749794)
But you can do the same mistake on Facebook, if I post a story to my wall and you comment on it, then you don't really know who gets to see it. The default sharing mode is "Friends of friends" if I remember it right, and that means my friends of friends can read your comment, and you can only see who my friends are, but not who my friends of friends are.

On the other hand, I think most people are used to the fact that posting on Facebook is pretty public, and that the Circles feature might give people a false sense of privacy so they are more likely to make that mistake.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by sootzoo on Monday July 11, 2011 @09:27AM (#2750551)
Adding to this, if I comment on FB about any other member and use the @-mention feature, but they're not authorized to see the original post, they won't be able to read what I wrote or what anybody else did either. Compare that to G+, where a +-mention actually grants access for the post to the mentioned user whether they originally had it or not.

Imagine planning a surprise birthday party, where someone +-mentions them, even by mistake. So much for surprises!

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by omouse on Monday July 11, 2011 @10:35AM (#2750828)
How about don't +-mention them? Just use their name and then attach a link to their Google+ profile instead? That won't count as a mention.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by sootzoo on Monday July 11, 2011 @12:24PM (#2751344)
How often does one refer to somebody by URL? You may have noticed (I have, anyway) that FB now "helpfully" defaults to an @-mention if you start typing a person's name, essentially offering it as an auto-complete option.

As long as G+ doesn't go down this path, I can live with it, but I don't like that a "mention" automatically implies "full access" to whatever has been said, especially given that the choice of whether or not to share a particular post with that person is presumed to be up to the author of the post, not anyone else who was also included.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by grey on Monday July 11, 2011 @11:53AM (#2751219)
Agreed, The surprise birthday party is one exact case where this would be annoying, in almost every other situation most users would prefer the current behavior (In my experience anyways)
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by DavidSJ on Monday July 11, 2011 @01:59AM (#2749643)
You basically have no way to know who can see your comment on a post (outside of the fact that everyone can see it on a "public" post).

On private posts, the word "Limited" appears next to the post, on which you can click to see who it's visible to. It's not as obvious as it could be, but it's there.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by waterlesscloud on Monday July 11, 2011 @02:06AM (#2749650)
Actually, you can only see icons for 21 of the people (and the total number) it was shared with in that case. Only the poster can see the whole list.

There's a problem with even being able to see the 21, from the pov of the poster...

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by ben1040 on Monday July 11, 2011 @02:19AM (#2749690)
If I am at a cocktail party, and something is said among a group of friends, I know I won't "out" anything if I only discuss it later with those who were originally within earshot.

I appreciate how Google has brought this into the electronic realm. I do wish there was not a 21 person limit because I already see people sharing with much larger pools and you don't know who persons 22...n are who can also see the discussion.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by tonfa on Monday July 11, 2011 @02:53AM (#2749752)
If there's more than 22 persons I assume it is somehow public.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by ramanujan on Monday July 11, 2011 @04:47AM (#2749962)
Circles are ok to set up at the beginning, but many people belong in more than one circle and it gets cognitively tiring to sort people appropriately into one-and-only-one circle.

It's also cognitively tiring to work out the consequences of sending a message to a circle larger than what you might type into an email "to" field.

You can work out the consequences of a broadcast announcement to the world/all your friends/your whole company. And you can work out the consequences of a private message to a few friends.

But in between is hard, and kind of unnatural. Maybe people will learn, but I think most people will only use a few circles (Public/Private) at most.

Random thought: the main reason for Circles is to reduce the negative consequences of sharing an identifiable message with someone inappropriate. If that could be predicted via machine learning, that'd be interesting.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by guptaneil on Monday July 11, 2011 @05:23AM (#2750015)
Why sort everybody into just one circle? Most of my contacts are sorted into multiple circles so that I have more fine-grained sharing control. G+ also makes it fairly easy to create new circles on the fly for when I want to share a message with an even more specific group. I think of Circles more like tags that I can use to control visibility of my posts.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by masklinn on Monday July 11, 2011 @06:35AM (#2750130)
> I think of Circles more like tags that I can use to control visibility of my posts.

That's exactly what they are: a visual interface to tags and tagged social graph nodes.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by sunchild on Monday July 11, 2011 @06:03AM (#2750085)
Google has always favored many-to-many "tags" over one-to-many "folders". Gmail brought that distinction to the mainstream. Circles are really just tags on the user object, in the end.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by edanm on Monday July 11, 2011 @09:05AM (#2750476)
I'm not sure just how "mainstream" Gmail is.

I've always heard that only 5% of email users use Gmail, but I don't actually have a source. Does seem to be accurate based on my (non-techie) friends.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by saucetenuto on Monday July 11, 2011 @10:19AM (#2750759)
I got curious about this a while ago, so I polled my nontechnical friends (artists, lawyers, that kind of thing). Out of 18 respondents, 100% of them used gmail as their primary personal email client. The lawyers all used Outlook at work, of course; maybe that 5% figure is for corporate clients?
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by ChrisArchitect on Monday July 11, 2011 @11:35AM (#2751135)
think this has gone way up in recent years with ppl with old hotmail whatever accts fed up of spam,more people on gServices etc....more exposure to gApps via android etc (not to mention being forced into using a gAccount/gMail for android things...)
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by Pyrodogg on Monday July 11, 2011 @12:13PM (#2751306)
Gmail integration with a number of universities is also a great way to get a new, large batch of young and fairly intellectual people familiar with Google products every single year.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by clobber on Monday July 11, 2011 @12:44PM (#2751444)
I have an email list with 304,985 contacts:

34.5% yahoo.com

24.0% other

13.9% aol.com

9.9% gmail.com

2.6% comcast.net

2.2% msn.com

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by patio11 on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @04:42AM (#2754031)
Clobber's list is similar to BCC's user base. In particular, a lot of ISP email addresses.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by kenjackson on Monday July 11, 2011 @02:50PM (#2751961)
Really... more msn.com than hotmail.com?
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by clobber on Monday July 11, 2011 @03:03PM (#2752016)
Oops, thanks for asking. I left out hotmail.com which was 13%

My mistake.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by dunmalg on Monday July 11, 2011 @10:07AM (#2750709)
"it gets cognitively tiring to sort people appropriately into one-and-only-one circle."

That's not how it works. You can put people into as many circles as you like.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by adrianwaj on Monday July 11, 2011 @09:12AM (#2750501)
It should be possible to extract circles from one's email and messaging behavior, to find friends and cliques. It should be automated as best as possible.

Even simply the most contacted people in the last week - and sharing to those people the most, even though you might have a friend you haven't seen for a long time, and they might be a great friend, that doesn't automatically mean you want to share with them. To assume that people want to share more with better and older friends and less with newer friends is wrong.

Users should get a menu of content automatically provided based on prior contact and clique analysis, and pick the items and people they find interesting to ensure more permanent viewing, which in time can fade over time if that content isn't liked. Even tracking what is clicked can automate this without having to manually like or +1 something - it's like listening to a person speak.

The last thing I want to do is setup a G+ account and start customizing friends lists, circles, clicking like and dislike buttons - it should be automated, and Google should delve into my GTalk and Email to see people I've been in contact. Whose emails am I replying? What people am I having conversations? I don't quite know who all my online friends are - G+ should work that out for me and cement those relationships without my input. Online friend dynamics are too liquid to be manual.

The problem isn't circles, it's the way they are created, edited and devised.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by owenmarshall on Monday July 11, 2011 @09:17AM (#2750515)
Google has already started down this path in Gmail -- when replying to a message, it suggests that I consider including one of my other contacts, and selects the suggestion fairly accurately.

I'd imagine this will be expanded and soon find its way into Google+.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by joeburke on Monday July 11, 2011 @02:46PM (#2751948)
> Circles are ok to set up at the beginning, but many people belong in more than one circle and it gets cognitively tiring to sort people appropriately into one-and-only-one circle.

A person can belong to more than one circle (that's why you have a list of checkboxes, one per circle).

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by DannoHung on Monday July 11, 2011 @12:55PM (#2751495)
There is no effort involved in putting people in multiple circles. You just drag them into whichever ones you want or click on multiple checkboxes from any of their profile chiclets.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by bad_user on Monday July 11, 2011 @02:41AM (#2749725)

     FB Groups will trump the power and 
     flexibility of Circles
FB Groups are more like mailing-lists. Useful of course, but I'm subscribed to 4 groups already, neither subscription being my choice, and I find the feature itself useless for Facebook.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by richardw on Monday July 11, 2011 @05:45AM (#2750052)
FB for me (and it seems, for many) is an inherently private thing. I don't want groups outside of my real-life friends. That's the fundamental break here - I'm being followed (and following) much more widely, similar to Twitter. What Google has done is made Twitter for people who don't get why 140 characters is a feature.

So: FB for my friends, G+ for the digerati and my real interest groups. Frankly, the latter has a better chance of improving search for me than my friendship groups, which is (or should be) the real goal. I've never seen a useful Facebook ad. I've seen many useful Google ones.

Edit: The question is: can FB change the culture of how users use FB faster than G+ can capture "those who matter". Make it more public? There's a lot of resistance to making our profiles more public.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by discodave on Monday July 11, 2011 @06:20AM (#2750107)
In response to making our profiles public or not...

I think a killer move from facebook would be a 'SHOUT IT FROM THE ROOFTOPS' button for each post. It would be effectively like tweeting (individual posts) and would have critical mass pretty quickly due to fb's scale.

Maybe it would be a nightmare building another twitter overnight or they would be pilloried for copying so blatantly. Additionally, it's occuring to me right now that a big issue would be deciding how to integrate those shouts into the newsfeed... oh wait by following people.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by mattdeboard on Monday July 11, 2011 @08:14AM (#2750326)
Every post on FB is a "shout it from the rooftops" post, that's the whole point of Google+.

Unless you meant 100% publicly available posts? That's the opposite of something Facebook ever would (or should) do. FB is a walled garden.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by richardw on Monday July 11, 2011 @03:50PM (#2752215)
You'd need that button plus a change in the relationship model so non-friends could subscribe
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by ajross on Monday July 11, 2011 @07:11PM (#2752858)
I think this lack of clear social context for individual messages within Circles is going to lead to some serious privacy/sharing accidents

Facebook already has those, though. There's a whole genre of comedy dedicated to exactly this problem already. Browse through /r/funny or /r/wtf for an hour and you'll find dozens of facebook screenshots, almost all of them basically a variant on "dumb commenter didn't know who was reading".

I don't see how circles make that any worse. At least a the poster side of the problem they make it easier to be clear about who you want to read it.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by nikcub on Monday July 11, 2011 @03:20AM (#2749806)
when I first used Circles the first feature that came to my mind was the ability to make a circle public and to add other administrators to it and allow other people to 'follow' it, or add it to another circle

I think starting with private circles and making them public is a better feature than fb groups, which are just annoying and spammy

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by lmarinho on Monday July 11, 2011 @07:07AM (#2750185)
That problem is related to the fact that Circles can be both used as (1)a privacy group of people to which you push stuff and (2)a filter for content published from that same group. To avoid this kind of confusion maybe Google should separate those uses more clearly or just drop (2) altogether.

Another way out for (2) would be doing some kind of circle matching: if someone has shared something with you and a circle very similar to your "Close Friends", it should show on the filter for that circle, if not matched to any circle it should go to a 'general' stream.

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by joebadmo on Monday July 11, 2011 @01:09PM (#2751549)
I agree that the asymmetry of Circles is a cognitive issue. Facebook groups actually work more like "Places"[1], which I think is a lot more intuitive, but I don't think FB makes the metaphor clear enough to leverage that intuitiveness. I also don't think FB takes the issue seriously enough.

[1]: (I wrote more about this on my blog: http://blog.byjoemoon.com/post/7072771434/a-new-metaphor-for...)

Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by ohyes on Monday July 11, 2011 @11:06AM (#2750976)
Yes, circles could horribly magnify the ever embarrassing 'your mother rehashing the details of your childbirth in a Facebook post' problem.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus by zem on Monday July 11, 2011 @07:15PM (#2752869)
yep, i'd love to see google+ groups as a feature orthogonal to circles