Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus
by discodave on Monday July 11, 2011 @06:20AM
(#2750107)
In response to making our profiles public or not...
I think a killer move from facebook would be a 'SHOUT IT FROM THE ROOFTOPS' button for each post. It would be effectively like tweeting (individual posts) and would have critical mass pretty quickly due to fb's scale.
Maybe it would be a nightmare building another twitter overnight or they would be pilloried for copying so blatantly. Additionally, it's occuring to me right now that a big issue would be deciding how to integrate those shouts into the newsfeed... oh wait by following people.
Re:Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus
by mattdeboard on Monday July 11, 2011 @08:14AM
(#2750326)
Every post on FB is a "shout it from the rooftops" post, that's the whole point of Google+.
Unless you meant 100% publicly available posts? That's the opposite of something Facebook ever would (or should) do. FB is a walled garden.
So: FB for my friends, G+ for the digerati and my real interest groups. Frankly, the latter has a better chance of improving search for me than my friendship groups, which is (or should be) the real goal. I've never seen a useful Facebook ad. I've seen many useful Google ones.
Edit: The question is: can FB change the culture of how users use FB faster than G+ can capture "those who matter". Make it more public? There's a lot of resistance to making our profiles more public.