The problem as I see it, is that the faction that trades entitlements for votes and the faction that trades tax breaks for votes are both simultaneously in control. The low taxes people win all the fights about taxes, and the high spending people win all the fights about spending.
The bug in democracy that led to our deficit problem is the lack of anything to prevent us from voting to have our cake and eat it too.
http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Alexis_de_Tocqueville#Misattrib...
Here's a more extensive (and accurate) one.
What makes you think that a faction that represents business interests does not also trade entitlements for votes? The real problem is that ALL factions in a democracy demonstrate the universal human tendency to take benefits today and put off obligations for the future.
The problem is that nobody has a long term sustainable point of view. Why worry about the eventual cluster#$%@ when you can stuff your pockets today?
Did it work?
Of course not. They passed an absolutely fictional budget. It not only depends on California getting three times its previously anticipated tax revenue but it also depends on tax hikes that haven't been passed (passing a budget requires a majority while passing a tax increase requires a 2/3rds vote where at least a few Republicans have to sign on)
Bottom line: Government can always redefine terms
And in our sophistication pretty much all the intellectuals we've got busily tearing apart all the foundation that "government of laws, not men" is built on. So back to government-of-men we go. Hooray.
Hopefully that would inspire them to take a longer term view, and they would be less able to redefine terms when they are being applied as they are no longer in power. Probably hopelessly naive thinking though ...
http://www.zerohedge.com/article/aarp-screams-blood-murder-w...
Orwell was an optimist.
Great idea by Mr. Buffet. Similar to Brazil's balanced budget laws, btw.
Next up: funny ways of counting GDP ;-)
"Once a social or economic measure is turned into a target for policy, it will lose any information content that had qualified it to play such a role in the first place."
http://lesswrong.com/lw/1ws/the_importance_of_goodharts_law/
It was not until the communism of China was mitigated that their economy began to take off.
I understand that the same thing happened with India and their socialist policies, but I am not as versed in India's history.
There are heavy negative effects that come into play when large-scale growth happens. The Industrial Revolution is the history of the West's large-scale growth. It's taking place in China now too.
Let us not delude ourselves that sunshine, rainbows, unicorns and world peace will suddenly come about. Futurama provides a humorous glimpse into that sort of future.
People are always self-interested and selfish, in the governmental scale. While we might not like that... we always prefer better things to happen to us and our little domains.
How do we use that motivation to nurture society as a whole? I don't know. Taxes are not good enough, as we can see today, they can always be outsmarted. You can't outsmart human nature, which means billions of people struggling towards a single goal.
We cannot expect to solve the problems of human nature via economics or public policy when the philosophical and religious landscape has shifted.
See, this just isn't true. The fact that this idea is taken for granted gets at the root of the problem.
I'm happy to pay my taxes, although I don't pay more than I legally need to.
Well that's what I meant. You have no particular wish to pay taxes. You wouldn't mind stop paying them. You would mind stop having sex though. I'm talking about motivations that can't be shut off and don't need to be taught to every new kid, because you are born with them. We need to somehow harvest them to make working together attractive.
I would argue that all successful policies somehow come down to the fact that people want them in place. In that regard, taxes are clearly a failed experiment. You cannot force people to do anything (not for long, not forever as we can see from history). The only really effective law, is the one that people love to obey.
The apportionment of the seats to the various states is based on population, but the overall size is not.
Then again, it would be difficult to bribe >50% of the population to pass a bill.
Another variable, you mention, is term of office. If voters only "remember 6 months back" then would having elections every 6 months instead of 2 years help?
This is the main issue with FPTP voting. If you wish to disempower fringes, require majority approval.
You largely vote not on the issues the candidate says he supports, but on how trustworthy they seem and how well their interests align with yours.
At it's best, this means that even people who are quite apathetic get properly represented.
Also, who would propose the votes, check legislation for consistency and loopholes, etc? If you crowd-source that, chances are 100% that there will be some decisions with unwelcome consequences. If you appoint people for doing that, how is that different from letting those people make the decisions, too?
I don't expect anybody to vote on all laws. It makes more sense for people to vote on the laws that are relevant/important to them. If I don't know anything about a certain issue, I shouldn't be voting on it anyway. This way, people would vote on issues relevant to them, and for people who don't care, then well, they don't care...
Upending congress might be tumultuous, but compared to bankrupting the nation it still counts as the lesser of two evils.
Or just some way to save in the good times, and spend in the bad times.
Buffett's proposal would patch this historically reoccurring weakness of representative forms of government. As hnsmurf points out, it would also create a slippery slope where no representative could be reelected if they vote for X, Y and Z policies that are not systemic threats.
As our government is not responding to an issue which can literally ruin us all, it seems to me that Buffett's proposal is the lesser of two evils. Stability demands a solvent government.