Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by neilv on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @02:33AM
(#27351293)
One way that an, er, cloud-encumbered IoT product might be able to shut down with some class... is to open-source everything necessary for "the community" to do sustaining engineering and evolution of the product.
It's still not good to break something after you sold it, but at least open sourcing has a good chance of keeping the product useful, like people expected when they bought it.
(Barriers to this include not having rights to open source all the IP necessary, and creditors wanting you to fire-sale some of the IP, rather than open source it. Those barriers are easier to avoid proactively.)
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by bottled_poe on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @06:55AM
(#27352749)
I know I’ll get downvoted, but.. perhaps the consumer should have considered an open alternative in the first place. Consumer mentality should change, as well.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by syshum on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @03:33PM
(#27360057)
People want convenience, nothing else matters.
All that will happen is the small new comers to the market will be avoided and people will simply put their "trust" in big names like Amazon, Google, and Apple.
Events like this ensure that more and more IoT/ home automation will actually end up being LESS open and more consolidated into the big 3 locked down echosystems.
Those of use that I not want to use Alexa, Google home, Or Apple HomeKit will be screwed.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by ping_pong on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @01:33AM
(#27351013)
Why should the remote stop functioning just because the company doesn't exist? That's a bunch of BS in my opinion. Remind me to never support anything from these founders in the future.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by ohazi on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @01:56AM
(#27351110)
I agree that it's bullshit, but a boycott is not going to accomplish anything. To many devices work like this (phone home else brick), and too few people care enough to allow this failure mode to influence their behavior. Most people just want the shiny thing.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by ping_pong on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @02:18AM
(#27351213)
A boycott perfectly accomplishes this. I don't want to purchase devices that arbitrarily shut down. It protects me from spending money on bad devices and from people that create devices and companies with bad practices.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by londons_explore on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @02:22AM
(#27351232)
Someone needs to make a "yelp for business owners" where you can review previous businesses all the directors have been involved in, and if they treated customers and suppliers in a decent way.
Even a tiny bit of attaching moral standards to individuals in the business will have a big effect - people will leave a company if they see something immoral happening, so as not to hurt their own employability.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by londons_explore on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @02:20AM
(#27351221)
Don't care. Responsible business owners will take basic steps to ensure customers of the business are not screwed over when the business folds.
That could consist of opensourcing the code, handing the servers over to someone else to run, making the product have a fallback mode where it runs without a server, etc.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by syshum on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @03:19PM
(#27359892)
Cloud encoubmered technology, once the "cloud" servers go down, the device stops.
This is true for about 90% of all IoT "things" on the market, and dont thing your immune if you buy form a "big brand" like Google (who has already done this to products of theirs see Revolv and Nest both)
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by kleiba on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @06:06AM
(#27352439)
That's the "smart" in "smart remote control" apparently.
Given that it's 2021, I wouldn't be surprised if their tech was that the remote control first connects to their servers to do <something> and you're actually subscribed to a cost plan in order to control your devices.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by Urgo on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @01:03AM
(#27350869)
I was a backer of their kickstarter in 2016. I remember the pitch. It made me feel like the remote was going to be out of the Jetsons or something. You walk around your house, point it at something and it knows what it is and you can instantly control it.
The actual product though sorta like that didn't really work out that well. First it wasn't really whole house it was more room based.. and since all my TV equipment was all in one place the point at it and it knows which item it is trick didn't really work as hoped.. not to mention when watching TV you don't really want to have to think about where you are pointing the remote.. and then yeah just using a touch screen instead of buttons was awkward.
Long story short, I still actually do have the remote plugged in.. but haven't used it since I set it up several years ago.
It's sad that they're shutting down. I really did want to like their product. But if everyone had the same experience as me I can't say I'm super surprised.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by rjzzleep on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @01:08AM
(#27350898)
The xiaomi phones still have IR blasters. I can see the appeal of the photos on the sevenhugs website. But it's kind of an ambitious niche product. Looks like something that's not really sustainable by itself without acquisition.
I feel like there's really only a few ways to handle this. Buy devices from the same vendor. Buy devices with another value proposition such as Amazon Alexa. A universal standard with industry backing, but those also usually end up with bigger enterprises putting a lot of unusable stuff in the standard. Or treat it as non standardized and put an IR blaster on top, but then why do I need a physical remote. (I realize the spotify thing looks quite beautiful)
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by jsjohnst on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @08:50AM
(#27353629)
> But if everyone had the same experience as me I can't say I'm super surprised.
Article submitted here: Your experience as written could be nearly a word for word summary of my own. Enough so that I’m not going to duplicate content and just say read what you read.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by formerly_proven on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @01:26AM
(#27350980)
The whole "universal remote" thing seems like laziness to me, because e.g. Pioneer did this very well in their home theatre systems - the AV receiver obviously is the centerpiece of the system, so why would you need more than the touch-screen remote for that?
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by aulin on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @02:57AM
(#27351412)
you sure? anynet+/hdmi-cec has been around since quite some time, most people just don't know about it as it's usually poorly documented and buried in not so user-friendly config menus.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by jsjohnst on Wednesday June 02, 2021 @06:10AM
(#27366902)
> anynet+/hdmi-cec
Sometimes it doesn’t work due to manufacturer bugs. I have a TV that has a bug in their implementation on a specific series of theirs where it won’t turn on/off the TV, but volume does work via HDMI. From doing extensive research I’m not alone.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by jeroenhd on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @06:38AM
(#27352637)
That being said, Sony just released an update to tons of their devices that fixes a bug where this functionality never really worked. The standards are moet certainly there, but getting manufacturers to implement them well can be quite the challenge.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by cameldrv on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @02:03AM
(#27351141)
This article says that there is this huge value in the IR code database, but what's to stop a new entrant from just buying a harmony remote and paying someone to go through all of the possible devices and recording the IR codes? IANAL, but I don't think that this would be covered by copyright.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by firefoxd on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @02:40AM
(#27351335)
Ah yes. Then a remote will find its way in the electronic rack in TJ Maxx a few years from now [1]. An excited customer like me will find it, buy it, only to forget it in a closet for a few months. Until the return policy expires.
Then the excited customer will stumble upon it excited to try it out...
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by Ice_cream_suit on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @04:16AM
(#27351827)
So this is the founder:
"“When starting Sevenhugs in 2013, we realized the tremendous potential of UWB technology in consumer products and formed the belief that UWB would eventually be embedded everywhere, in our smartphones, smart home devices, and our cars”, said Simon Tchedikian (Sevenhugs’ CEO & Founder)"
Perhaps he could be contacted and asked what his plans are on opensourcing.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by ghostDancer on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @07:19AM
(#27352900)
I remember using a program in WindowsCE/PocketPC in an Axim that you could program the IR codes to control "any" thing, like the TV , Stereo , ... .
Of course used it to turn off TVs at bars.Temptation too big.
Re:Sevenhugs exits the universal remote business
by tweetle_beetle on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @07:16AM
(#27352879)
The bizarrely named Sofabaton U1 is a good halfway house in my opinion. It lacks some polish, but is good enough in every respect and much better value than Logitech equivalents. It's a bit annoying to have to use an app to update it - there's probably some crap in it, but it's only needed for mapping buttons and can then be uninstalled.
It's still not good to break something after you sold it, but at least open sourcing has a good chance of keeping the product useful, like people expected when they bought it.
(Barriers to this include not having rights to open source all the IP necessary, and creditors wanting you to fire-sale some of the IP, rather than open source it. Those barriers are easier to avoid proactively.)
The first half of that happens all the time. In my experience, it's the second half that's missing.
All that will happen is the small new comers to the market will be avoided and people will simply put their "trust" in big names like Amazon, Google, and Apple.
Events like this ensure that more and more IoT/ home automation will actually end up being LESS open and more consolidated into the big 3 locked down echosystems.
Those of use that I not want to use Alexa, Google home, Or Apple HomeKit will be screwed.
Even a tiny bit of attaching moral standards to individuals in the business will have a big effect - people will leave a company if they see something immoral happening, so as not to hurt their own employability.
That could consist of opensourcing the code, handing the servers over to someone else to run, making the product have a fallback mode where it runs without a server, etc.
This is true for about 90% of all IoT "things" on the market, and dont thing your immune if you buy form a "big brand" like Google (who has already done this to products of theirs see Revolv and Nest both)
Given that it's 2021, I wouldn't be surprised if their tech was that the remote control first connects to their servers to do <something> and you're actually subscribed to a cost plan in order to control your devices.
The only exceptions I grant at the moment are T2/M1 macs - they cannot be factory restored without an internet connection to Apple.
The actual product though sorta like that didn't really work out that well. First it wasn't really whole house it was more room based.. and since all my TV equipment was all in one place the point at it and it knows which item it is trick didn't really work as hoped.. not to mention when watching TV you don't really want to have to think about where you are pointing the remote.. and then yeah just using a touch screen instead of buttons was awkward.
Long story short, I still actually do have the remote plugged in.. but haven't used it since I set it up several years ago.
It's sad that they're shutting down. I really did want to like their product. But if everyone had the same experience as me I can't say I'm super surprised.
I feel like there's really only a few ways to handle this. Buy devices from the same vendor. Buy devices with another value proposition such as Amazon Alexa. A universal standard with industry backing, but those also usually end up with bigger enterprises putting a lot of unusable stuff in the standard. Or treat it as non standardized and put an IR blaster on top, but then why do I need a physical remote. (I realize the spotify thing looks quite beautiful)
Article submitted here: Your experience as written could be nearly a word for word summary of my own. Enough so that I’m not going to duplicate content and just say read what you read.
https://mattstoller.substack.com/p/why-logitech-just-killed-...
https://www.commandfusion.com/aboutus
Sometimes it doesn’t work due to manufacturer bugs. I have a TV that has a bug in their implementation on a specific series of theirs where it won’t turn on/off the TV, but volume does work via HDMI. From doing extensive research I’m not alone.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right
Then the excited customer will stumble upon it excited to try it out...
[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22083759
"“When starting Sevenhugs in 2013, we realized the tremendous potential of UWB technology in consumer products and formed the belief that UWB would eventually be embedded everywhere, in our smartphones, smart home devices, and our cars”, said Simon Tchedikian (Sevenhugs’ CEO & Founder)"
Perhaps he could be contacted and asked what his plans are on opensourcing.
I've had great experiences with remotes from: https://www.oneforall.com/universal-remotes#/
None of them need to talk to a server to function.
I have a logitech harmony, and it's a really useful tool. But the cloud-connection is really a double edged problem, especially with poor internet.
is this Onion?