News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by SCHiM on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:19AM (#27290793)
I mean, just imagine, you go the the slave market and they tell you that the court ordered them to stop selling slaves on the basis that some laws say that you cannot do so!

Burning fossil fuels is bad. Shell is in the business of producing fossil fuels to burn. Shell needs to leave that business in the very long term. What's the problem here?

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by xyzelement on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:28AM (#27291797)
> Burning fossil fuels is bad.

I would say that like many things in life, it's a tradeoff. There're costs and benefits to using these things. Talking about one side but not the other doesn't make sense.

Quick personal example - I lived through energy shortages as a kid in the Soviet Union. Situations where there was no heat in the winter and/or no fuel for cars and public transport.

From pure fossil fuel consumption standpoint, these were great times, as we weren't using any. From a quality and sustainability of human life, these were terrible times.

At the very least "burning fossil fuels is bad" is a statement of privilege. A person who's cold or unable to travel or get necessities delivered would never say this.

None of this is to say that we shouldn't move towards primarily nuclear in the long term - we should but we need to talk about this in a mature way.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by skeeter2020 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:00PM (#27292222)
Most people equate reducing fossil fuels with buying an electric car or public transport. They are woefully oblivous to the impact on food production, bulk transport and shelter & heating impacts.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by Isinlor on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:49PM (#27292889)
The court ruling is mature, we need more decisions like that across the world.

We also need to keep pushing and monitoring schemes like European Union Emission Trading Scheme and Chinese National Carbon Trading Scheme.

The goal is for global carbon emissions to peak in 2030 and be gone by 2050.

Hopefully USA will follow too.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_Emission_Tradin...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_national_carbon_tradin...

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by kemitche on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:38AM (#27291935)
> From a quality and sustainability of human life, these were terrible times.

Unchecked, climate change will ALSO lead to terrible times for humans. Just because it's not immediately impactful, does not make it ignorable.

From that perspective, it's arguable that our options are "Some amount of near-term lowering of quality of life" or "A large amount of long-term, in the future, loss of quality of life." Continuing to burn the levels of fossil fuels we currently do is borrowing against a debt that may be literally impossible to repay.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by xyzelement on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:54AM (#27292130)
I think you're saying essentially the same thing as the last paragraph of my post, so not sure why there's an argument.

But sure, there's a long run place we want to get to. Today, we're not at that place and we're depending on fossil fuels. So why are we vilifying them and the companies that provide them? Sounds like we should simply work on replacements, like nuclear.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by rkk3 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:50AM (#27292090)
> At the very least "burning fossil fuels is bad" is a statement of privilege. A person who's cold or unable to travel or get necessities delivered would never say this.

You could extend this argument "Slavery is bad", "Genocide is bad", "War is bad" etc. are all statements of "privilege".

Completely ignoring climate change, particulate pollution from fossil fuels has killed a terrible amount of people and will continue to do so for some time. Currently its around 13,000 per year in the US.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by nradov on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:59AM (#27292206)
How many people would have died if they didn't have affordable access to power, heat, and transportation from fossil fuels? Particulate emissions are a risk but tighter emissions standards have done a lot to mitigate that problem.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by rkk3 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:13PM (#27293260)
Isn't there a difference between tradeoff's in the 1800's and 2021?

The benefits of fossil fuels is not the issue, the cost is. If today we in fact have alternative's that do not inflict such a terrible cost on human life, is it incorrect to say the choice is "bad".

The WHO estimates 7 million people a year are dying from air pollution. https://www.who.int/health-topics/air-pollution#tab=tab_1

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by kokanator on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:21PM (#27292455)
It could be argued that CO2 emitting fuels have propelled most world advancement we account to pulling countries into prosperity.

It is necessary for any trade of goods with other countries for instance. Think ships for a minute, huge fuel consumers. Without them you wouldn't even have the computer you are reading this on.

The course is to change culture so it collectively seeks alternative fuels not damn the corporation that has done the very thing we have asked them to do.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by gruez on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:45AM (#27291127)
> I mean, just imagine, you go the the slave market and they tell you that the court ordered them to stop selling slaves on the basis that some laws say that you cannot do so!

I'd be pretty pissed off too if one day [item] were legal and the next day the courts declared them to be illegal because of some vague law (ie. because of a tort or "the right to life and the right to family life"). In your comment the [item] was something most people would find objectionable (slaves), but you can very well substitute this for other stuff you enjoy, eg. beef, coffee, chocolate, etc.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by chefkoch on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:50AM (#27291213)
>I'd be pretty pissed off too if one day [item] were legal and the next day the courts declared them to be illegal

They lied for decades about the dangers of climate change.

[dead]
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by acdha on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:18AM (#27291641)
Do you have any citation? This is a common claim by deniers, many of whom are paid to create the illusion of scientific disagreement, but it's not true.

If you look at, for example, the 1990 IPCC report the subsequent 3 decades were within the report's estimated ranges:

https://arstechnica.com/science/2012/12/ipccs-climate-projec...

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97...

Similarly, while certain people like to repeat the claim that scientists predicted global cooling in the 1970s it's grossly overstating the degree to which that was taken seriously by the academic community back then and how quickly it was conclusively rejected long before the turn of the century.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2016/06/that-70s-myth-did-cl...

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by tzs on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:25PM (#27292511)
Also worth noting about cooling predictions was that the models that predicted cooling still predicted warming from greenhouse gases.

They predicted net cooling because smog and other particulate emissions were also rising, and those have a cooling effect. They were assuming that smog levels would continue to rise faster than greenhouse gas levels, and so the cooling effect would beat the warming effect.

Around that time people get serious in the US and much of the rest of the world about air quality, and smog not only stopped increasing in many places actually decreased significantly.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by chefkoch on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:19AM (#27291653)
Judges hate this trick.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by aaronbeekay on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:53AM (#27291255)
Firstly, I think there’s a pretty clear difference between enslavement, which is a practice that intentionally deprives human beings of their rights, often violently and often en masse, and beef, coffee, and chocolate, which are food products that are enjoyed by consumers around the world.

Secondly, neither slavery nor the use of CO2-generating industrial processes were suddenly found to be objectionable overnight. Both have been the subject of intense attention across the globe and over decades. Nobody at Shell is surprised that carbon dioxide is a problem. They have made the choice to continue to invest in and defend their business model for many years.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by gruez on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:11AM (#27291524)
>Firstly, I think there’s a pretty clear difference between enslavement, which is a practice that intentionally deprives human beings of their rights, often violently and often en masse, and beef, coffee, and chocolate, which are food products that are enjoyed by consumers around the world.

But which one is fossil fuels closer to? I think it's clear that fossil fuels is closer to beef, coffee, and chocolate than slavery.

>Secondly, neither slavery nor the use of CO2-generating industrial processes were suddenly found to be objectionable overnight. Both have been the subject of intense attention across the globe and over decades. Nobody at Shell is surprised that carbon dioxide is a problem. They have made the choice to continue to invest in and defend their business model for many years.

Should beef, coffee, and chocolate producers also watch their back? They all have issues as well. eg. beef: cow farts, deforestation for pastures/soy production, negative health effects of red meat.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by sp332 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:16AM (#27291610)
Beef, at least, contributes in an outsized way (per kilogram, say) to climate change-related disasters and water shortages. While there are many causes of these harmful effects, it makes sense to address the biggest ones, including banning them.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by r00fus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:24AM (#27291738)
Most e.coli outbreaks in the US found in spinach or romaine lettuce were actually caused by farm runoff issues.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by kansface on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:22PM (#27293378)
The problem is that this ruling was unequivocally outside the rule of law in my estimate. You want to stop climate change? Great! Pass some laws via the legislature, enforce them via fines and jail through action initiated by the executive branch under the oversight of an impartial judicial system. Exactly which law could not be enacted by a judge under this precedent/newly found tort? Why are we foisting our collective guilt as a society onto a single hate-able company as if ordinary people making quotidian decisions lack fault, agency, and responsibility?

Yes, I realize we are not talking about the US...

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by whatshisface on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:59AM (#27291358)
>I mean, just imagine, you go the the slave market and they tell you that the court ordered them to stop selling slaves on the basis that some laws say that you cannot do so!

Last time they tried this the United States rent itself apart in its bloodiest war.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by 1cvmask on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:04AM (#27291434)
They just reinvented slavery with prison labor of blacks under Jim Crow laws (and plea bargain scammery) that are still used in the worlds largest concentration camps ever:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_ra...

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by whatshisface on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:12AM (#27291556)
It's a mischaracterization to say that Jim Crow made emancipation pointless. It may have been an attempt to reduce its practical importance, but it didn't come close to reversing it in the vast majority of cases.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by aww_dang on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:17AM (#27291627)
Surprisingly, there's a connection to the topic at hand if you look at the parallel of prohibition and economic situations resulting from highly regulated markets.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by jayd16 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:13AM (#27291564)
Better than the alternative.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by barelysapient on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:59AM (#27291349)
The problem is that this is one company in the EU. It won't change how America, Russia, the middle east, or anyone else produces fossil fuels. Shell will desiccate from this action. And people will declare victory. But EU member states will simply import more fossil fuels from elsewhere. And the environment will not be helped.

I agree that we need to cut CO2 emissions. But we need global solutions to these problems. Not one-off court victories in small municipalities with liberal trade policies.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by archontes on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:02AM (#27291395)
Or they implement carbon fixing, and the EU implements tariffs on non-carbon-neutral petro such that the environment is helped...
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by barelysapient on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:14PM (#27295500)
Great ideas. Sadly not the direction being taken by the EU.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by kokanator on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:24PM (#27292504)
Did you hear that? All the other oil companies just cheered! What a great day when a huge competitor is taken down by the very government it supports.

( sarcasm intended )

The other opportunity was to find a way to work with Shell to change the world. They are a huge power. Not make room for the others listed above to fill the void.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by dylan604 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:43AM (#27291098)
>Shell is in the business of producing fossil fuels to burn.

Playing devil's advocate, but what about all of the oil that is not burnt but turned into plastics and other products?

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by brtkdotse on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:49AM (#27291190)
Best case: It will end up burnt as trash.

Realistic case: it will end up in the oceans as microplastics

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by yholio on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:18AM (#27291646)
Nonetheless, have the plaintiffs proved that Shell is responsible for plastic that is burned or thrown in the ocean, as opposed to those that burn, dispose or produce plastics? Have they proven that there is NO legitimate and lawful use of oil?

This is most likely a vacuous decision of one trigger happy judge with an ax to grind. The idea that global climate change is "tort" is absurd, the phenomenon is a defining feature of the Anthropocene.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by FooHentai on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:58PM (#27293039)
Best case is likely putting it back in the ground. Burning it results in a release of it's stored carbon to the atmosphere.

Still not a perfect solution, since many plastics will leach harmful substances into the ground without robust containment measures, but of the outcomes realistically available to us, plastic ending up in properly-run landfills is probably the best case.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by eloff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:49AM (#27291185)
It's a very tiny percentage of oil that gets used in this way.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by dredmorbius on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:36PM (#27297957)
Roughly 15% of petroleum goes into chemical feedstocks.

Not all of that is plastics. I suspect natural-gas-fired ammonia synthesis (Haber-Bosch process) is a major fraction.

But it's not a tiny percentage.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by skeeter2020 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:04PM (#27292270)
about 3/4 is used as fuel (gas/diesel/jet) with the rest building your roads and the plastic life we all enjoy.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by eloff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:37PM (#27294370)
This source puts it at 86% as fuel:

https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/oil-and-petroleum-produc...

Not sure why the discrepancy.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by ffggvv on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:04AM (#27291427)
can you not compare the brutal practice of slavery (and accompanying rape and torture) to fossil fuels?

it’s deeply offensive to those whose ancestors actually were slaves

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by mikeyjk on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:46AM (#27292043)
Is the issue that the comparison is bad and/or doesn't add much value - or just that we should generally avoid discussing that topic unless directly related?
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by ffggvv on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:34PM (#27292635)
in general imo one shouldn’t make comparisons to:

1. nazis/holocaust 2. slavery

etc…

as it devalues the actual event you’re comparing it to. i get that it’s just meant to make a point but even over using the comparison in everyday speech devalues it

it’s fine talking about those issues in general.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by FridayoLeary on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:20PM (#27294139)
Not sure why people don't get it. It leaves me with a bad taste in my mouth.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by phkahler on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:02AM (#27291399)
>> Burning fossil fuels is bad. Shell is in the business of producing fossil fuels to burn. Shell needs to leave that business in the very long term. What's the problem here?

Shell doesn't burn fossil fuels. As you note they produce them (or pump them out of the ground and refine them). Telling Shell to produces less in one country means the people buying those fuels will simply get them from somewhere else, probably at higher price.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by berkes on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:39AM (#27291047)
What is more, Shell already planned to divert investments from fossil fuel to renewables.

The court ordered them to do this earlier and in larger numbers.

That would be like IKEA telling you "we don't have those shelves. See, were already working on selling less wooden furniture over the coming ten years, but the court ordered us to this now. So we now already have these awesome cardboard shelves for you. And next year we'll have plastic and metal ones too".

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by FridayoLeary on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:44AM (#27291122)
I don't think anyone can churn out, overnight an entire new line of products, while simultaneously scrapping their old line. I think it would be wiser to work with Shell to see if their timeline can be compressed, their investments expanded etc. rather then throwing out unreasonable demands.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by berkes on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:09AM (#27291491)
> I don't think anyone can churn out, overnight an entire new line of products, while simultaneously scrapping their old line.

If you cannot adjust to clearly visible, external requirements or demands, you honestly don't deserve to be kept in business.

Everyone knows fossils are at a dead end. Shell has known this for over 60 years now; they acknowledge that themselves!

Requiring the change that apparently a corporate moloch is not able to make themselves is neither unreasonable nor overnight. As I point out elsewhere in this thread: competition manages fine to pivot to renewable fuels (diesel, ethanol, kerozine etc) and beyond that, in far less time, as can be seen in action with e.g. Neste Oyi

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by kokanator on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:25PM (#27292521)
>If you cannot adjust to clearly visible, external requirements or demands, you honestly don't deserve to be kept in business.

There are 1.4 Billion cars in the world. They are obviously focused on the demand. [0]

https://www.carsguide.com.au/car-advice/how-many-cars-are-th...

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by FridayoLeary on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:33AM (#27291869)
>Everyone knows fossils are at a dead end

If that is true Shell should die naturally. Images of stranded fish, flopping and gasping for breath springs to mind. This court order indicates otherwise. I'm under no illusions that orders like this won't hurt me in a real way. And i am not a fan at all of EV's in their current format. Despite (what i perceive) propaganda (NOT a negative connotation, mind you) to the contrary, i don't think they are mature enough to replace ICE.

Slightly off topic but i'm a huge fan of those electric scooters and bikes. I think they are the way forward, not some huge EV. They should definitely be made legal, anyway everyone uses them. I just have a depressing feeling that they shall be slaughtered, hamstrung and/ or castrated on the altar of pedestrian safety.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by KptMarchewa on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:09AM (#27291496)
They were poisoning planet for decades, so now we have to pay them to find other business.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by trueluk on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:53AM (#27291259)
Don't be daft. His comparison to wood is legitimate as trees are a natural resource and their conservation has a similar effect on climate change compared to reducing the burning of fossil fuels.

> Burning fossil fuels is bad.

Why is it bad? Becuase the temperature will go up a couple degrees. Who cares! We're engineers and we build solutions to adapt to an ever-changing world. We don't make progress by stifling productivity.

> Shell needs to leave that business in the very long term.

No, they don't NEED to do that. Well, not until the government mandates it anyway. And that's the problem. Perhaps they will leave the business, but they shouldn't until renewable energy becomes more economical than producing fossil fuels. In the meantime, it makes more sense to move production to developing countries so they have the same opportunity we had here to benefit from cheap energy.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by brendanmc6 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:12AM (#27291540)
> the temperature will go up a couple degrees. Who cares! We're engineers

Sorry, this is one of the worst takes on climate I've ever seen on HN, and the bar here is very low...

Take time to actually study the problem and you will come to the same conclusion: it can only be solved with government intervention. The most efficient government intervention would be a carbon tax set at the estimated social cost of carbon, but that (being a tax) is also extremely politically unpopular.

So we are left with less efficient policies, like outright bans, court orders, expensive subsidies, and emissions caps.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by yholio on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:11AM (#27291535)
> trees are a natural resource and their conservation has a similar effect on climate change compared to reducing the burning of fossil fuels.

What the hell? Trees grow using CO2 from the air, and then release that same carbon back when the wood is burned or rots in a forest somewhere. Conserving trees does nothing for climate except for a very small amount of carbon sequestered by tropical forests in their soil.

Meanwhile, oil is 100% carbon that has not been in atmosphere since Jurasic times. If you like Jurasic climates, I guess that's perfectly fine.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by zackees on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:57AM (#27291325)
To add to this... the government killed the alternative which was nuclear. If the government were serious about ending CO2 emissions they should start building a massive number of nuclear. Hitting Shell like this is a disaster of policy.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by FridayoLeary on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:58AM (#27291335)
>His comparison to wood is legitimate as trees are a natural resource and their conservation has a similar effect on climate change compared to reducing the burning of fossil fuels.

Thanks for that! I do try and pick my comparisons and words carefully. I sometimes fail miserably but i'm glad you picked up on it.

Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by aww_dang on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:09AM (#27291501)
There's an argument for storing carbon as finished wood products.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by FridayoLeary on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:36AM (#27291916)
But that was not even a tangential side point of mine. To my mind it was just a pertinent comparison. I'll bear in mind what you said but i'm slightly disappointed.
Re:Shell ordered to cut CO2 emissions by 45% in landmark cli... by aww_dang on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:04PM (#27292258)
I agree that it is tangential. Perhaps one of the safer topics to discuss in this whole debacle.