There’s one other thing Google does a lot of: try to foresee and actively forestall how someone else might cut-off or divert the flow to the existing hose. While both Chrome and Android evolved in directions that explored potential new hoses, they were clearly both initially directed at protecting the existing hose from being choked off or diverted by monopolies on the client side; Android was purchased and engineered to prevent Apple gaining the kind of dominance in mobile to do that, Chrome and Chrome OS against the desktop Windows monopoly and IE.
Google+ was deployed against Facebook and abandoned once it was clear that Facebook’s position, while making it something of a competitor for ad dollars, wasn’t, even without a competitive Google alternative, an existential threat to Google’s money hose.
In practice, poor development practices and incompetent product management has left some bits hard to change. The search provider used to be hardcoded with no way for the user to override it. That only changed when some early Android phones began shipping with Bing as the default. To this day, it is impossible to allow any non-system app store to update apps in the background. This hasn't changed only because Amazon, Samsung, and many other OEMs failed to get developer traction with their own app stores. Now that there are antitrust rumblings, Google has hinted they will finally fix this, but once again, this isn't a threat to the core Android strategy of removing gatekeepers.
It can be, and is, both.
Similarly, Google doesn't give itself a privileged separate settings for marketing data collection that ignore global settings. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202074
If the point of Android were data collection and marketing, Google would abuse configurability of data collection at least as much as Apple does, but it does not, not even on devices that Google itself sells.
https://venturebeat.com/2008/08/07/first-android-phones-push...
I had a family friend that was a tech writer in 2007 or so. He proudly mocked my interest in the first iPhone. Pulling me aside and showing me how his blackberry had a mini trackball and a mouse cursor and just how precise this all was.
It’s obviously funny now, but yea I remember a lot of the “smart money” was against the modern smartphone at the time.
This has two logistical consequences: 1 - it's more valuable to launch a new product that it is to successfully maintain/grow a current one. 2 - the person running these new projects tends to get promoted away, leaving it rudderless.
Google could change all this overnight by restructuring what these review boards prioritize.
This is very stale information at this point. Product launches are now pretty heavily gated, and promotion criteria are far less based on launches than on overall impact, including but not limited to improving/maintaining products.
(Googler but interpretation is my own)
(Also a Googler.)
If you don't believe it, try selecting 10 of their supposedly killed products at random. Had you honestly heard of them ever before? Do they look like something that would have had a significant user base? Hell, do they even look like they were actual products?
So, two things:
1) Changing culture is really hard, especially at a company the size of Google, and
2) Even if they could change the culture, it's possible they simply don't care or they believe the benefits outweigh the cost.
Always building new infrastructure, and not maintaining the existing one.
"Zircon is the core platform that powers Fuchsia. Zircon is composed of a kernel (source in /zircon/kernel) as well as a small set of userspace services, drivers, and libraries (source in /zircon/system/) necessary for the system to boot, talk to hardware, load userspace processes and run them, etc. Fuchsia builds a much larger OS on top of this foundation."
- Fuchsia Docs, https://fuchsia.dev/fuchsia-src/concepts/kernel
Sometimes they stumble upon something another PA needs, but often it just ends up as a patent or research paper.
Guido van Rossum (creator of Python) is a Distinguished Engineer at Microsoft. Before that, he worked at Dropbox.
I get the quarterly check-ins from the "alumni recruiting" team, and can assume Guido does too.
Who can divert from Google's massive ad income funnel?
Apple.
Facebook.
(Also maybe several foreign governments' antitrust cases.)
An engineer on your payroll is an engineer not on the competition's payroll.
Look no further than you're being _upvoted_ for quintupling down on inanity completely divorced from the article that's we're supposed to be discussing, even with schoolyard debate nonsense like "can you name even one thing backing up your thesis statement?" (back in the day, or still with more traditional HN posts, you'd get something more like: 'I find that surprising, what makes you feel that way?'. Dang calls this "coming with curiosity" or something like that)
Meanwhile in the sibling thread, we have a guy with a year old account neener-neering me for daring to mention things are bad because it's a noob fallacy, and people who have actually been here a while getting flagged/dead through the floor for pointing out this _isn't actually some steadfast rule_, its a classic HN "rule". Meanwhile, I've been here for 12+ years and its never been close to being as bad as it is right now.
This site, and you, are getting what always happens to these sites: too large of an audience to preserve quality of discussion over group dynamics. You shall inherit the board, but, no one will be the wiser for you being here - it's all half-baked assertions, schoolyard bully absolutist nonsense that you know isn't argumentation, you'd never talk like that to someone in real life. Then add the thesis here being that people _in the actual company_ aren't seeing the truth, their coworkers are engaged on makework PhD bullshit because otherwise they'd jump to Apple (never mind that the #1, #2, and #3 pieces of career advice in the valley is to leave so you get promoted)
As for your "coming with curiosity" scolding attempt? Please review the first two words of my comment.
Searching for sources of income ?
It seems online advertising has a strong network effect[1], where website owners use Google ads because that's where most advertisers are and advertisers use Google ads because it has most reach (and therefore tracking). This naturally creates a monopoly, just like with Facebook, twitter, LinkedIn, AirBnB, Uber etc.
In 15 years, we'll either say "Fuchsia was a brilliant move, I'm so glad my home runs on that OS" or we'll say "Remember Fuchsia? lol".
Here's what I mean. Acquisitions by Google in 2005: Reqwireless (mobile ads, merged with google analytics); Dodgeball (social networking, later Google Latitude); Akwan (Search tech); Skia (graphics library); Phatbits (Google Desktop); allPAY (???); bruNET (???); Android (cheap OS for mobile devices).
In 2005, which of these were going to change the world?
It wont. From what I understand this new OS will replace others over time. Also it is way better than existing options.
QNX appears to already be in every market where Fuchsia wants to go.
Google could have bought Blackberry and used QNX in Android 5, rolling it up to Chromebooks. Why was this not the path they chose?
I have given only very cursory look into QNX and Fuchsia/Zircon and it seems that one of the main difference is the capabilities-based architecture in Fuchsia. It's a big change in the API/conceptual model, but we'll have to see if that actually translates into a meaningful difference at the application level - e.g. whether it allows building new types of applications, or allows building meaningfully more secure/fast/reliable applications.
> For more than two years, a small and stealthy group of engineers within Google has been working on software that they hope will eventually replace Android.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19702968
> "And while Android is reaching EOL in the next 4-5 years, most of this work will be carried on in Fuchsia OS, which is set to eventually replace Android"
I wouldn't bet on it. Sounds like IBM OS2 all over again.
General information suggests this is one of those long term things if successful would be massively game changing.
They're not innovating at this point. They're twiddling thumbs.
If we broke up Apple, Google, Facebook, and Amazon, then they'd be forced to fight for survival.
Struggle births innovation.
"Google discovered a hose that money poured out of. It's called 'online advertising'. All that we do now is find ways to make that hose go faster, and desperately search for another hose."
Why does Google develop 3+ different OS's? In case one of them is a money hose. Why has Google created thousands of products, only to cancel most of them once people fell in love? Because they decided that they weren't money hoses.