In practice, poor development practices and incompetent product management has left some bits hard to change. The search provider used to be hardcoded with no way for the user to override it. That only changed when some early Android phones began shipping with Bing as the default. To this day, it is impossible to allow any non-system app store to update apps in the background. This hasn't changed only because Amazon, Samsung, and many other OEMs failed to get developer traction with their own app stores. Now that there are antitrust rumblings, Google has hinted they will finally fix this, but once again, this isn't a threat to the core Android strategy of removing gatekeepers.
It can be, and is, both.
Similarly, Google doesn't give itself a privileged separate settings for marketing data collection that ignore global settings. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202074
If the point of Android were data collection and marketing, Google would abuse configurability of data collection at least as much as Apple does, but it does not, not even on devices that Google itself sells.
https://venturebeat.com/2008/08/07/first-android-phones-push...
I had a family friend that was a tech writer in 2007 or so. He proudly mocked my interest in the first iPhone. Pulling me aside and showing me how his blackberry had a mini trackball and a mouse cursor and just how precise this all was.
It’s obviously funny now, but yea I remember a lot of the “smart money” was against the modern smartphone at the time.
There’s one other thing Google does a lot of: try to foresee and actively forestall how someone else might cut-off or divert the flow to the existing hose. While both Chrome and Android evolved in directions that explored potential new hoses, they were clearly both initially directed at protecting the existing hose from being choked off or diverted by monopolies on the client side; Android was purchased and engineered to prevent Apple gaining the kind of dominance in mobile to do that, Chrome and Chrome OS against the desktop Windows monopoly and IE.
Google+ was deployed against Facebook and abandoned once it was clear that Facebook’s position, while making it something of a competitor for ad dollars, wasn’t, even without a competitive Google alternative, an existential threat to Google’s money hose.