News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by whoisvince on Sunday July 03, 2011 @02:42PM (#2724277)
I was never one to argue that apps don't sell on the Android Market; however, I do believe that it's a tough business decision for a startup to invest time and resources to a platform that has a sell-rate worse than a fixed las vegas digital slot machine.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by jrockway on Sunday July 03, 2011 @03:11PM (#2724346)
Are you sure it's a good idea to develop iPhone or Windows Phone apps either? On average, those don't sell either... and they can be deleted by the Overlords for no reason whatsoever.

Despite the extremely high risk, people do it anyway. I'm guessing the risk vs. reward is about the same with Android, but since there's no Kool-Aid to drink, there are more people wasting time on iOS apps. Just a guess, though.

(As an Android user, I do think it's strange to pay $15 for the home screen when the whole OS is free.)

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by micampe on Sunday July 03, 2011 @03:31PM (#2724390)
> (As an Android user, I do think it's strange to pay $15 for the home screen when the whole OS is free.)

Why should the value of an application have anything to do with the price of the operating system that hosts it? Why not apply the same reasoning to the hardware you run it on?

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by jrockway on Sunday July 03, 2011 @03:49PM (#2724430)
Because the OS already includes a home screen. When CyanogenMod ships with a processor, I'll be upset about paying for that, too. I'm not holding my breath, however.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by Hostile on Sunday July 03, 2011 @04:45PM (#2724552)
Writing a launcher takes work. I don't think it's ever strange to expect payment in return. Just because Google wrote a launcher at some point in the past doesn't mean that all future programmer's work in that area should be released for free.

I happen to think this particular launcher is a gimmick, but it's clear that they put work into it and that it's very different than what Google ships.

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by jrockway on Sunday July 03, 2011 @06:43PM (#2724804)
Cyanogen uses ADWLauncher, not the one that Google provides :)
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by micampe on Sunday July 03, 2011 @10:02PM (#2725130)
> Because the OS already includes a home screen.

Right, but if you are looking for a different one it means that you need/want something different than what's provided and satisfying your need surely must have some value to you.

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by rimantas on Sunday July 03, 2011 @04:10PM (#2724480)

  > and they can be deleted by the Overlords for no reason
  > whatsoever
Please, name a few deleted for no reason.

  > Despite the extremely high risk, people do it anyway
Extremely high risk of what? 400 000+ approved apps is an indicator of extremely high risk, I guess…

  > but since there's no Kool-Aid to drink,
Only money to be made.

  > there are more people wasting time on iOS apps
And getting more then $2 billion paid.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by patrickaljord on Sunday July 03, 2011 @04:26PM (#2724513)

    > 400 000+ approved apps
    > And getting more then $2 billion paid.
Which is an average of: 2 000 000 000/400 000= $5000 per app since 2008. How is that a good source of revenue again? It's the same as Android, only a very small percentage make a descent living out of it. It may be a bit more for the iPhone (for paid apps only because android apps make more on ads on average) but it's still very unlikely you'll make enough money to survive.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by rimantas on Sunday July 03, 2011 @04:33PM (#2724525)
Your math implies that all apps are paid and each is developed by different developer. Both are false.

And it is not the same as Android by far.

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by ceejayoz on Monday July 04, 2011 @03:36PM (#2727590)
Remove the free apps, the poorly designed apps, and the one-app-per-ebook spammy apps, and you're left with a much smaller number to divide the major portion of that revenue against.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by nextparadigms on Sunday July 03, 2011 @05:06PM (#2724603)
400k apps out of 500k submitted in total.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by rimantas on Sunday July 03, 2011 @05:21PM (#2724633)
Where did you get those numbers? Apple claims 96% approval rate, you claim 80%.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by hardik on Monday July 04, 2011 @07:20AM (#2726190)
> (As an Android user, I do think it's strange to pay $15 for the home screen when the whole OS is free.)

Just saw this app in action on a friends Samsung Galaxy S II.. worth every cent!

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by fleitz on Sunday July 03, 2011 @04:22PM (#2724502)
There are a few advantages to writing apps for iPhone / Android, one lots of people are looking for consultants, when people hire consultants they want to see a portfolio, so you can increase your skills and possibly make some money building a portfolio while there is the chance of making money. It's much better than doing spec work.

So what you do is to write trivial apps, when you get consulting gigs you can say "30 apps in app store", and have a portfolio of apps that look good, also, you write apps around features so you teach yourself the feature, etc, GPS, Gyro, Camera, BUMP API,FB Connect, etc. This is also an important part, spend time making your app look good. Customers can't see code quality, but they do see graphics. To customers good graphics == good code quality.

Now if you have 30 apps and one happens to hit a niche you've got a great way to promote your other apps and don't have to do consulting BS anymore, and because you have lots of apps in the app store and lots of experience writing against the various features you can justify a much higher hourly because you'll be delivering their app faster.

I definitely agree with you that writing a single app to try and strike it rich in the app store is foolhardy, unless you already have people signed up to buy it.

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by arpit on Sunday July 03, 2011 @02:50PM (#2724301)
I think it depends on the kind of startup. If your startup is trying to grow an audience around a service with a free app, Android is a good place to start, if you are dependent on sales of the app for revenue, I'd go with iOS.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by Roritharr on Sunday July 03, 2011 @04:06PM (#2724468)
That was my thinking initially. I went to Android to create the first fundraising app for my competitive fundraising platform because i figured after some research that it would be easier to get people to try it out.

The app was never intended to be paid so making a free app with the ability to use a proprietary in-app payment mechanism (PayPal) was what lead to a really easy decision (PayPals Android Developer Challenge was another nudge into the Android direction).

The next step will be a webapp to which i'll redirect the iPhone customers. I didn't start with it initially because from the little research i've done, "wizard of oz"-style, people didn't find iPhone webapps stable and trustworthy enough to Donate Money via them.

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by Skroob on Sunday July 03, 2011 @03:03PM (#2724336)
I don't see the compelling reason to start with Android in the free-app-as-front-end-to-web-service case. Is it because Android phones (briefly) outsold iPhones? Last I heard, iOS still has something like a 60% lead in install base, and the latest data says iPhone sales are outpacing Android phone sales again.
Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by nextparadigms on Sunday July 03, 2011 @05:09PM (#2724611)
iPhone sales don't outpace Android. Android has a 50% market share in new sales last quarter in US, and iPhones have I believe 28-29%. The news was that Android dropped from 53% to 50% when the Verizon iPhone was launched, not about iPhones outpacing Android in market share.

They tried to make a big deal out of it, trying to show that it could be a downward trend, but it's nonsense. Android sales keep growing worldwide, and I'm sure it will rise above 50% in US by the time iPhone 5 launches (and take a hit again for a few months, and then rise again).

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by cageface on Sunday July 03, 2011 @11:22PM (#2725257)
http://blog.nielsen.com/nielsenwire/?p=28237

Android has 38% install base vs 27% for iPhone.

Re:Some Apps Do Sell: Developer Makes $750K in 3 Weeks on An... by cageface on Monday July 04, 2011 @06:10AM (#2726052)
Hacker News, where the facts count for a downvote.