News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by StavrosK on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:42AM (#27232786)
> Battery powered cars are going to be the next disaster

> I'll keep my very efficient Audi diesel car (79g/km CO2) for now thanks.

"Battery powered cars are a small disaster, so I'll keep my big disaster instead".

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by daniellarusso on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:44AM (#27232804)
It uses waste vegetable oil.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by cduzz on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:59AM (#27234055)
This is a laudable and reasonable small scale approach to personal transportation.

There are certainly enough old diesels out there and enough people willing to go around collecting old oil to keep a small number of people occupied and mobile.

It is also not really a viable large scale solution to "how do you move people around?"

There are lots of really good answers (walking, public transit, electric bicycles) but one obvious answer is "cars" and electrifying those is probably a good solution.

Electricity can be generated from fossil fuels more efficiently at large scales than small (a power plant produces less CO2 than a car for a given amount of work). Electricity can also be generated by extracting "free" energy from the environment (wind / solar / hydro / dogs on treadmills). The distribution system for electricity is already quite robust and is already everywhere, and people like cars. There's even lots of inexpensive electricity available at night, when most people aren't driving their cars. All we need is a way to get the power to the cars that park where people don't own the parking space.

Disposing of the waste stream of parts of the cars has always been a problem. Hopefully people come up with a way to solve it; there's enough valuable metal in a car battery that it is likely they will.

There are already all sorts of terrifying industrial processes which I can't imagine are possibly cost effective and yet they're the foundation of modern society. There are also all sorts of hideous "farm out the cost to someone else" processes relying on destroying somewhere else / poisoning someone else.

People refine gasoline by boiling crude oil in a rusting metal tank; people refine gasoline in trillion dollar oil refineries. Why and where and for who answers how it gets done.

Can one cost-effectively convert refined materials in a battery (cobalt / nickle / lithium) back into raw inputs for a new battery? Can it be done profitably by a child in a toxic fire pit or can it be done profitably by a chilled shredder in inert gas?

Not a simple problem, but probably one that can partially be solved with market incentives and partially solved by laws and partially it won't get solved. But we should probably try, right?

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by dd_roger on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:15PM (#27236910)
> It is also not really a viable large scale solution to "how do you move people around?"

Not every solution needs to be large scale to be usefull. I think biofuels should be promoted and used as much as possible (obviously within the limits where it makes sense ecologically speaking, e.g. not destroying ecosystems to plant more biofuel crops or burning coal to synthetize (m)ethanol). Both the idea that EVs are suited for every purpose and that they'll quickly take over the entire ICE car pool are ludicrous. Where EVs can not / not yet be used it makes perfect sense to use alternative fuel sources.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by alkonaut on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:54AM (#27232882)
Unless I drive to a specific gas station to get 100% recycled fuel, the normal diesel only has 10-20% such products, and likely less in summer.

It's not nothing and certainly better than just a few years ago, but it's still not exactly like a significant fraction of diesels use a significant fraction of vegetable oil.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by namdnay on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:59AM (#27234058)
When you're mixing in chip-shop oil, you're waaaaay off the constructor Co2 emissions (which themselves are way off the real world Co2 emissions)
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by volta83 on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:45AM (#27232808)
Are they the small disaster ? What do you think is going to happen with all the lithium after being bounded by a 10 year old with a rock?

Probably just going to land in the river, and then the sea.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by adrianN on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:08AM (#27233530)
How much Lithium needs to end up in the sea to be a comparable problem to even one broken oil tanker? Lithium salts are not terribly toxic.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:13AM (#27233575)
I wonder too. The sea is the world's largest store of Lithium already.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by StavrosK on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:47AM (#27232828)
Whereas extra CO2 in the atmosphere is fine? Or do you mean that it's easier to sequester the CO2 than to get children to stop pounding things containing lithium?
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by FridayoLeary on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:54AM (#27232883)
Sounds reasonable. Plants absorb carbon. I'm not aware of anything organic that absorbs lithium.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by StavrosK on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:58AM (#27232912)
If nothing organic absorbs lithium, what's the problem?
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by volta83 on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:03AM (#27232955)
absorbs lithium naturally.

Go ahead and try drinking a glass of lithium, or try growing vegetables with lithium instead of water.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by FridayoLeary on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:14AM (#27233053)
Don't. You'll thank me.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by volta83 on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:25AM (#27233132)
Thank you, I just dodged drinking a glass of lithium.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by volta83 on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:01AM (#27232933)
> Or do you mean that it's easier to sequester the CO2 than to get children to stop pounding things containing lithium?

The claim that electric cars are good for the environment is a lie. They are not "good", they are not even "neutral". They are "bad".

People that really care about the environment ride a bike. They don't buy an electric car and try to justify the currently unknown long term environmental consequences of their purchase as somehow being better than the known consequences of gasoline and diesel cars.

Today we just ship car batteries oversees to be scrapped for parts in the cheapest possible way by children. That doesn't sound good to me at all.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by gambiting on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:10AM (#27233017)
>>The claim that electric cars are good for the environment is a lie. They are not "good", they are not even "neutral". They are "bad".

So....exactly like normal cars then? Buying a brand new car is bad for the environment, full stop, ICE or EV.

The statement above makes sense if taken in isolation - take an existing ICE car and an existing EV car - the EV car is undoubtedly better for the environment, there is no discussion. But it would also be a lot better if neither existed, as manufacturing new cars is EXTREMELY wasteful and produces incredible amounts of CO2 debt, again, EV or not.

>>oday we just ship car batteries oversees to be scrapped for parts in the cheapest possible way by children.

As opposed to stripping out electronics and precious metals from ICE cars, which is only ever done by well regulated workers in rich western countries, right? /s

Like, come on - I get your point. Shitty "recycling" practices exist. That doesn't mean that's the standard or the default, and it definitely can be fixed going forward. We aren't destined or doomed to only recycle our lithium batteries with 10 year old children with rocks, and for some reason you're framing it as if that's the only available method.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:15AM (#27233586)
Its been claimed that riding a bike is the worst thing you can do for the environment. The fuel for a human is the most ecologically disastrous fuel we make. Billions of acres clearcut; chemicals in the soil and air; CO2 by the gigaton. No, increasing human output has the largest impact on CO2 we could create.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by formerly_proven on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:14AM (#27234198)
Assuming ~1 kgCO2e/kJ food and ~0.2 kJ/km riding a bike, well that's just about 200 g CO2e / km. Pretty bad actually.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by phillnom on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:24AM (#27235244)
Weird how in your scenario only people riding bikes need food.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:08PM (#27236800)
Now that's deliberately being dense. Riding a bike means you'll eat more to fuel that effort.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by poopypoopington on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:54AM (#27234004)
This is wrong and stupid
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:36AM (#27234511)
Look into it before posting insult, perhaps? Its reasonable, arguable, and probably right.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by rspeele on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:26AM (#27235273)
I think it's a clever point, but it falls flat for me on closer inspection because:

#1: The whole point of preserving the environment is to keep it inhabitable for humans. Fueling humans is non-negotiable up to at least a baseline level of survival, and still desirable beyond that level because we like being well fed.

and

#2: Due to that whole "we like being well fed" thing, most humans in the first world -- the part of the world where people worry about things like whether biking to work is good or bad for the environment -- are already overfueled. We have a surplus of human fuel that we're consuming anyway because it feels good. Might as well burn some of it off on transportation.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by endemic on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:15AM (#27235117)
Your argument boils down to "people are bad for the environment." True, but not helpful.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:06PM (#27236779)
Boils down to "Riding a bike instead of driving a car is a net negative for the environment". Reframing or changing the subject doesn't affect that.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by Forbo on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:57AM (#27234030)
Want to reduce the ecological impact of food? Go vegan.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by imtringued on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:59AM (#27233451)
Buying a car or riding a bike isn't a choice. It's something forced upon residents by the local zoning plan.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by SyzygistSix on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:35AM (#27234501)
In many places people can make the choice to bicycle. That they don't choose it is why so few places have infrastructure for bicycling.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by ryukafalz on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:00AM (#27234895)
I live in one of the few places in the US that has the geography and density to make bike commuting one of the fastest and most efficient ways to get around. I would gladly ride a bike almost everywhere if it were safer.

I don't, because I don't feel like putting my life at risk on a regular basis just to get where I need to go.

There's a reason that bike ridership skyrockets when useful protected bike infrastructure gets installed. The demand is there.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by volta83 on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:26AM (#27235278)
Also many people can make a choice to where they live.

Not all, but many.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by seoaeu on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:45AM (#27235528)
Sadly many places impose tight limits (via zoning) on the total number of people who can live in a specific area.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by StavrosK on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:06AM (#27232985)
Is the energy required to ride a bike somehow free? How do you ride a bike for hundreds of kilometers?

> People that really care about the environment ride a bike. They don't buy an electric car and try to justify the currently unknown long term environmental consequences of their purchase as somehow being better than the known consequences of gasoline and diesel cars.

This is so much false dichotomy that I'm having trouble assuming good faith.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by ryukafalz on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:08AM (#27235017)
>How do you ride a bike for hundreds of kilometers?

In many parts of the world, you would take a train or other forms of public transport to travel distances too far to ride by bike. Those often have last-mile problems when the train doesn't go quite where you need it to, but given sufficient density at the source/destination bikes are an effective solution to the last-mile problem.

Of course, in the US, we typically have sprawl at the source/destination, unsafe infrastructure for bicycling, and often not-very-useful public transport, which does rather limit this option.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by mrob on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:25AM (#27233681)
Humans require exercise to maintain good health. The energy required to ride a bike replaces energy that would otherwise be wasted on exercise equipment in a gym.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by StavrosK on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:27AM (#27233702)
So you'd only ride for an hour a day, and you'd stop where you were and take a taxi the rest of the way, or what?
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by mrob on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:43AM (#27233911)
If it's too far to ride then a taxi (ideally, an electric vehicle) is a reasonable option. It's even reasonable to stop where you are and switch to a taxi. I don't know if it's possible with Uber or similar, but with traditional taxi operators you can call them and arrange for them to carry the bicycle too. The front wheel will have a quick release mechanism, and you can put down some sheeting to protect the interior of the taxi from grease/oil, or they might have an exterior bicycle carrier frame. But this will only be a minority of journeys.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by dukeyukey on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:50AM (#27233973)
Myself, I ride my bike to work and back (about 25 mins each way) and around the local area, otherwise I use the excellent public transport in my city (mostly electric-powered trains and occasionally electric/hybrid buses). If I need to go out-of-city, I use mostly-electric trains.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by ninjamayo on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:52AM (#27232872)
Lithium mining is an issue and can be improved. Lithium on its own ending up in the rivers and sea when it is a valuable commodity? How is that going to happen?
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:27AM (#27233150)
Mining lithium is cheaper than recycling
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by epistasis on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:07AM (#27233520)
Really? Where are the numbers for that assertion?
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Friday May 21, 2021 @01:07PM (#27236783)
Right now it's a fact that does not need numbers to prove.

Hopefully by 2030 there will be a robust network of recycling facilities around the world, for the majority of exhausted lithium batteries.

https://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/batteries-storage/lithiumio...

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by selectodude on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:02AM (#27234084)
The part where we mine lithium instead of recycle it is a good indicator.
Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by epistasis on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:23AM (#27234336)
Only if there were waste streams of lithium of comparable scale, which there are not.

We are enormously expanding our use of lithium, and the biggest problem for the places that are currently trying to recycle lithium batteries is that there aren't enough of them to recycle. A big source of their current batteries are just the defects from the current manufacturing process.

Re:What happens to all the dead electric-car batteries? by mstipetic on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:56AM (#27232904)
Well let’s change it, things evolve, markets and regulations are set up