Then you're stuck: the community member could certainly fork the project with their new feature, or maintain a patchset and forward-port to each new version of the original software, but both of those things are a ton of work.
Meanwhile, users are the ones who lose out; someone decided to build the feature and give it away for free, but users have to jump through hoops to use it.
As someone who has done a lot of open source work over the past ~20 years, I don't think anyone is entitled to find a business model in there. Sure, if you can find a way to work on your project full time but still support yourself, that's great. But often the ways people do so make for some (IMO) bad trade offs and perverse incentives.
I like the dual-licensing approach, where commercial users need to pay, but that's not workable for all projects.
It doesnt benefit from the massive scale revenue, but if it's paid for your time...
See VirtualBox, and to some extent Chrome. For VirtualBox, I'm sure that the Extension Pack could be covered with an open-source effort by the community, and in the case of Chrome, their refusal to accept *BSD patches.
Accepting 'portability patch' isn't free..
IIRC, for a while cemu (a Wii U emulator) had builds with support for Breath of the Wild gated behind Patreon early access as well.
Happy that they got rid of it, but there was quite a bit of community pushback needed.
BOTW would still play just worse, then they'd release the next version on patreon and make the last one free.
Now it just runs well.
Checkout the following links:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Si3PMUJGR9KrpE5lngSk...
Chess.com is for profit, so they have to maintain some profit margin and lock features behind paywalls to incentivize people to pay. The free experience is worse than Lichess.
My parents wouldn't let me buy M-rated games, so the easiest way for me to play MGS was on my Dreamcast with a copy of Bleemcast that I found used at Gamestop for four dollars with a pirated copy of the game.
P.S.: Some googling suggests that it played "backups" just fine.
It seems they got the business model right this time.
I've been curious whether Switch libraries will follow you to whatever the next Nintendo console is. They haven't done that in the past, but online purchases might be so common now that they can no longer get away with not doing it.
Like still being able to watch that old VHS movie on BluRay HD, or listening to Swing records from 1920 in 2021.
I recently paid five dollars for redream Dreamcast emulator. Totally worth it. There's a free version that doesn't run hi Res and that's fine.
They even paid the developer several thousand dollars so that they would improve the debugger function.
This was all unofficial, of course - Nintendo had no idea and would not have been happy if they found out.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dsemu.dras...
Over one million downloads, price £4.99
;)
My point still stands though for emulators on PC where I believe software piracy remains popular.
> Unlike most emulator projects, Kemulator turned out to be closed source abandonware
It is amazing that in the past two decades most emulators transitioned from closed source closely guarded secrets to open sourced and often under a popular license.
The preservation is unparalleled.