Isn't it a bit more complicated than that though? While you certainly aren't entitled to republish things, you (ie anyone and everyone) have traditionally been free to consume public material in whatever way you see fit. The precedent from the recent LinkedIn case regarding scraping supports this.
Also you focus on Google, but anyone with sufficient resources can scrape the public web (anti-bot cat and mouse games notwithstanding I suppose).
(Paywalled sites that allow Google to scrape them for search indexing purposes are an interesting edge case though.)
Even if you got an answer to your question, how would it affect the the parents assertion?
Should the internet provider of the person reading the blog post get royalties for the book the person wrote? Should you be paid for your snarky question, as the generator of content?
If you break the distribution model of content producers there won't be any new content, and the old content will simply rot away.
Radio broke the distribution model of record disks.
YouTube broke the distribution model of old content producers.
People still make music and more content than ever before. People are not gonna suddenly stop generating knowledge because of Wikipedia. The prediction that "there won't be any new content" is hyperbolic and just plain wrong as demonstrated by history.
The interesting point here is: can a non-free site let Google crawl it in order to be searchable, while not allowing them to exploit their content otherwise?
I don't see any legal ground for such a limitation, so I can't imagine what would e.g. eBay or Walmart put in their suit if they tried to put such a limitation and then saw Google not honor it. Maybe someone with a legal background could comment.
On one hand, Google is in large part responsible for the idea that they’re just a free service and anyone can use them without payment, so they’ve trained users to in essence think of them as a non-profit utility which they’re obviously not.
On the other hand, how do you allocate Google’s value when no-one has ever paid for it or been asked to pay for it?
You can legislate Google into the ground (unlikely, but theoretically possible), but what would replace it? Any other similar service operating at their scale would need to make money too.
The appearance is that it’s about AI being responsible for advancing corporate image and interests.
Embedded in this answer seems to be the mindset that only buying things will solve problems.
Don't get me wrong -- I'm not a consumerist luddite, I use my credit card points like any good and proper citizen -- but when your mindset is "all problems can be solved by buying more shit", well, that's a pretty lonely existence.
Google's gotta make money, and helping people buy useful shit is a fine way of doing it, but just don't fall into the mindset trap that everything solution in life is just a Google Pay away.
But if a problem being solved necessitates linking to something, then what kind of problem is that likely to be? Usually one where you need to stare at something, mull over a bunch of details, and make a decision. What kinds of webpages are those? Usually — for public clients — those are product pages.
(Another potential use-case is that a conversational agent could help people configure to software/services by deep-linking to configuration screens — but that's not really a thing Google Search could integrate with.)
> It could also understand that, in the context of hiking, to “prepare” could include things like fitness training as well as finding the right gear.
> fall is the rainy season on Mt. Fuji so you might need a waterproof jacket.
> MUM could also surface helpful subtopics for deeper exploration — like the top-rated gear or best training exercises
> you might see results like where to enjoy the best views of the mountain, onsen in the area and popular souvenir shops
Or, my favorite line:
> MUM would understand the image and connect it with your question to let you know your boots would work just fine. It could then point you to a blog with a list of recommended gear.
(in other words: "Thanks for showing you're interested in hiking gear. Here's a lot of hiking gear you can buy.")