News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by cma on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @10:34PM (#27216716)
Should human experts, like someone preparing a blog post on gear, also have to pay all the blogs and books they read in their research?
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by judge2020 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @10:41PM (#27216768)
I'm not proposing a link tax, i'm just saying that websites should be able to opt-out from their content being used for some Google products just because they have to give google a very permissive license to transact online business and be found in search results.
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by joe_g_young on Thursday May 20, 2021 @01:06AM (#27217602)
Would it be reasonable that a vendor to put their merchandise by behind an login page?
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by selfhoster11 on Thursday May 20, 2021 @10:04AM (#27221216)
What possible reason would they have for doing so? They would lose sales and search engine originated traffic.
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by nine_k on Thursday May 20, 2021 @02:45AM (#27218136)
No, because it makes finding the merchandise hard, and sales will tank.
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by sitkack on Thursday May 20, 2021 @02:05AM (#27217958)
I am sure your left field question has a fancy term in the encyclopedia of fallacies, but are you equating Google's crawlers and AI equivalent of humans.

Even if you got an answer to your question, how would it affect the the parents assertion?

Should the internet provider of the person reading the blog post get royalties for the book the person wrote? Should you be paid for your snarky question, as the generator of content?

Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by cma on Thursday May 20, 2021 @01:32PM (#27224268)
We shouldn't extend IP protections to general knowledge gleaned is my point. If we start overreaching into that for AI there would be little stopping overreaching into that for humans.
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by lumost on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @10:41PM (#27216763)
There is a reasonable risk that future research material will not be publicly available by the traditional copyright system. Effectively an "uber" google could leverage all previous content to answer your query severely limiting the utility of producing any new content or maintaining accessibility to pre-existing content.

If you break the distribution model of content producers there won't be any new content, and the old content will simply rot away.

Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by thanhhaimai on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @11:24PM (#27217021)
Record disks broke the distribution of taverns and pubs.

Radio broke the distribution model of record disks.

YouTube broke the distribution model of old content producers.

People still make music and more content than ever before. People are not gonna suddenly stop generating knowledge because of Wikipedia. The prediction that "there won't be any new content" is hyperbolic and just plain wrong as demonstrated by history.

Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by lumost on Thursday May 20, 2021 @08:51AM (#27220449)
The previous examples disrupted content distributors. An advanced q&a system disrupts content creators.
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by 42droids on Thursday May 20, 2021 @01:38AM (#27217816)
When the content people create is pushed aside and instead used by a giant corp. without any payment, it is safe to assume that people will stop writing content.
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by carschno on Thursday May 20, 2021 @02:09AM (#27217974)
Books are typically paid for indeed (even if you get them through a library etc.). Blog posts are an edge case, but the rise of paywalled sites indicate that more authors think they should be paid for their work.

The interesting point here is: can a non-free site let Google crawl it in order to be searchable, while not allowing them to exploit their content otherwise?

Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by nine_k on Thursday May 20, 2021 @02:52AM (#27218176)
The site can ask for such a setup, but Google is very much in a position to refuse and just don't index that site, unless it's one of, say, top 1000 sites.

I don't see any legal ground for such a limitation, so I can't imagine what would e.g. eBay or Walmart put in their suit if they tried to put such a limitation and then saw Google not honor it. Maybe someone with a legal background could comment.

Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by d110af5ccf on Thursday May 20, 2021 @03:07AM (#27218262)
There isn't currently a legal ground for that (in the US). The context of this thread, though, was to propose that such grounds ought to be introduced by the legislature.
Re:MUM: A new AI milestone for understanding information by headmelted on Thursday May 20, 2021 @05:58AM (#27219282)
I can see the rationale but at some point Google needs to make money on what it contributes to the picture.

On one hand, Google is in large part responsible for the idea that they’re just a free service and anyone can use them without payment, so they’ve trained users to in essence think of them as a non-profit utility which they’re obviously not.

On the other hand, how do you allocate Google’s value when no-one has ever paid for it or been asked to pay for it?

You can legislate Google into the ground (unlikely, but theoretically possible), but what would replace it? Any other similar service operating at their scale would need to make money too.