News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:43PM (#27212690)
I'm not sure how much that definition holds water. Am I disabled if I'm temporarily not able to do cognitive work?
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by wittyreference on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:31PM (#27213311)
Yes.

As a physician, I wish more folks appreciated that “disability” is a property of the relationship between a person and their environment, and can emerge (or disappear) based on changes in that persons capability as well as changes in their environment.

For an obvious example: a patient with reversible heart failure can’t walk without severe shortness of breath today, but they can in three months. Today they need disabled parking; three months from now they do not.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by sethjgore on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:47PM (#27213539)
Exactly! I am deaf and when I’m in an environment that’s fully signed, I cease to be disabled. Truly! And those who aren’t signing-aware in such environments become disabled language-wise.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by noneeeed on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:48PM (#27214279)
That reminds me of a time I went to the pub with friends after work. I was sat at the table with my back to the rest of the pub. After a while I though "wow it's really quite in here tonight" at which point I turned around to find that the pub was packed, but with deaf people all signing to each other. Turns out it was a monthly deaf meetup at the pub.

It really demonstrated your point. I was quite jealous of their ability to hold a conversation with people all the way across the pub :)

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:44PM (#27213491)
Can we apply "disability" to all abilities, like being hungover and therefore temporarily sensitive to light and sound, or should it apply to specific ones, like being injured and therefore temporarily sensitive to light and sound?
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by Judgmentality on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:56PM (#27213668)
You are really hung up on trying to reconcile that 'disability' has a different meaning in an English dictionary as from a court of law. In different contexts, the word will mean different things. When in doubt, provide additional details to alleviate any confusion - this will vary on a case by case basis.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:24PM (#27214022)
The meaning of words will always depend on the context they are used in. Even outside of a court of law, there are still people here who disagree that a person with an occupied hand is still disabled.

That seems like something that will shift towards one or the other as society talks more openly about disabilities.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by microtherion on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @10:37PM (#27216734)
I'd probably call that a "hands busy" situation rather than a disability situation, but some of the same computer features may be helpful for both situations.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by _jal on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:56PM (#27213666)
I don't know what a doctor would say here. Just noting that medical jargon sometimes carries moral or legal tones independent of any actual medical distinction.

For instance if you're taking a legal drug that habituates you, they don't like calling you an addict, so you're experiencing cessation syndrome. A change in legal status of the drug would presumably lead to a terminology change.

And I'm not going to revisit DSM fights, but suffice to say, a number of changes made to certain diagnoses over time reveal more about sociopolitical changes than anything having to do with psychiatry.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by nkmnz on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:29PM (#27214720)
Your statement regarding legal status of a drug and addiction is wrong. Alcohol and tobacco are legal drugs and you can not only evolve a dependency on them, but if your addicted you’ll be called an addict. The same is true for other legal drugs used as medication, e.g. benzodiazepines or opioids. If you’ve developed physical and/or psychological dependence on such a drug, you might suffer from withdrawal, which is not a different thing than discontinuation, but rather a special case thereof. Addiction and withdrawal compare to dependency and discontinuation like a hoarder compares to someone who relies on the service of a cleaning lady.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by _jal on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:19PM (#27215263)
I won't argue the point, it very much is not my area. But that is not the understanding I left with when I quizzed my doctor on the topic.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by villasv on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:03PM (#27213752)
In the language of product design and experience, yes you can apply to all abilities. More specifically, all abilities required by your product.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by philipyoungg on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:47PM (#27212721)
You take the word "disabled" literally.

And yes, it's situational. That's what we learned in experience design.

Another example: a parent holding their baby. They "lost" one arm in that situation.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by anticristi on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:00PM (#27212896)
Trust me, I got super powers during parental leave. Some days I wondered why we need a second hand at all!
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:56PM (#27212842)
We are in agreement on being technically disabled. But having a disability also has a legal meaning that is separate from that. For instance, we as a society don't call someone disabled for not being good at math, unless something else has been diagnosed that causes that. If you created technology that assists with mental math, we wouldn't call it "a tool for the mathematically disabled".
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by akiselev on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:08PM (#27213004)
> For instance, we as a society don't call someone disabled for not being good at math, unless something else has been diagnosed that causes that.

It is part of the definition for intellectual disabilities though. From [1]:

> An individual is generally diagnosed as having an intellectual disability when: (1) the person's intellectual functioning level (IQ) is below 70-75; (2) the person has significant limitations in adaptive skill areas as expressed in conceptual, social, and practical skills; and (3) the disability originated before the age of 18. "Adaptive skill areas" refer to basic skills needed for everyday life. They include communication, self care, home living, social skills, leisure, health and safety, self direction, functional academics (reading, writing, basic math), and work.

Being bad enough at math that it impedes day to day life is not sufficient to qualify for intellectual disability under the ADA but it's one of the major factors.

I think the point is that even capable humans are often in situations where they are functionally disabled - like when they're really exhausted or inebriated or mentally/physically overloaded - and all of these accessibility technologies are helpful in those situations. It's not about the ADA definition but humans in practice.

[1] https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/persons-intellectual-disa...

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:12PM (#27213056)
We are just talking about being bad at math temporarily. Let's take a physicist who is having brain fog for a day. In this case, it would be weird to say they are situationally disabled or disabled at all. I think your term "mentally/physically overloaded" would be closer to what I am speaking of. Not sure about "functionally disabled".
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by mynameisvlad on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:49PM (#27213575)
You’re talking about the legal term “disabled”. Some have opted to refer to it as a “situational limitation” or “situational impairment” to distance from the legal term which can have additional implications.

Going back to your point, though, would you say someone with a concussion is situationally disabled? I suffered from a pretty bad concussion last year which definitely caused a lot of brain fog for weeks. At the beginning I could barely think for a few hours. Would you not call this a situational or temporary disability? It’s certainly more than “brain fog for a day”.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by KittenInABox on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:37PM (#27213398)
I think it's fair. That's what temp disability is for, workers comp, etc? If I strain my back and I'm bedridden for a few days I think I'm pretty disabled. Similarly, if a vaccine knocks me flat on my butt for a day, people get it, I'm disabled for that day and I need accomodation.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by pseudalopex on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:44PM (#27213499)
The technical meaning of disability is broader than the legal meaning. The legal meaning is broader than most people would define it.

Using a wrist mounted touch screen is hard if you can't use the other hand. It doesn't matter if it's because the other hand is missing, in a cast, or just holding something. So people in relevant fields talk about permanent, temporary, and situational disabilities.

You don't have to like or use the term. But arguing with people who do won't be productive.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by b3morales on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:10PM (#27213029)
As a thought experiment we could consider whether the legal specifications would be necessary if this awareness of situational and widespread ability differences was more established in our culture. What if all doors, everywhere, were easily opened by anyone regardless of whether they were standing, around a certain height, and had free use of their arms?

I think likely we would still need some kind of formal recognition, but it's interesting to ponder.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by pseudalopex on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:02PM (#27212921)
It's called dyscalculia when severe enough.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:07PM (#27212985)
So someone who doesn't have dyscalculia, but is just having a bad day and isn't doing math well...we wouldn't say they are still disabled, and we wouldn't call it a situational disability.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by pseudalopex on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:14PM (#27213073)
We wouldn't call them not good at math either.

Most people wouldn't call it a situational disability because they don't know the term. But it's a common term in relevant fields.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:24PM (#27213206)
I have seen multiple people throughout my life say "I can't do math today" while referring to their work and then avoid doing computationally-heavy tasks for the day.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by pseudalopex on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:26PM (#27213232)
"Can't do math today" and "not good at math" are different.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:29PM (#27214062)
It's "temporarily being not good at math", which is the point.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by pseudalopex on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:58PM (#27214381)
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by kristofferR on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:08PM (#27212995)
Exactly. I'm sitting on the couch now with my laptop on my lap, so I can't walk right now, but I'm not leg disabled.

I'm not partially blind just because I can't see with my eyelids closed.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:27PM (#27213245)
Perhaps I should have led with those examples.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by shadowoflight on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:54PM (#27212818)
Yes, and if we as a society were more accepting of these types of situational disabilities, workplaces would be much healthier.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:59PM (#27212876)
All situational disabilities? Should workplaces cater to people who are emotionally disabled in some way? Not that I completely disagree with you, I just want to understand what we are defining.

edit - Yes, workplaces should cater to legal disabilities. The question here is if employers should in any way cater to functional disabilities, not disabilities as diagnosed in the DSM. See elsewhere in this thread.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by macintux on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:11PM (#27213043)
> Should workplaces cater to people who are emotionally disabled in some way?

Not the person you're replying to, but certainly if you e.g. lose a child, your workplace should be sensitive to that and not fire you because you're unable to show up to work that day.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by heavyset_go on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:29PM (#27213281)
> Should workplaces cater to people who are emotionally disabled in some way?

If they don't want to violate the ADA, yes. For example, major depression can be a disability, and employers are bound by the ADA to not discriminate against people with that disability and to provide them reasonable accommodations.

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:31PM (#27214092)
I think we are confusing the casual term disabled with the legal term disabled. Of course employers should work with legal disabilities. We are talking completely about "functionally disabled" such as your arm being temporarily occupied, or you having a foggy brain and can't to math that day.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by dkonofalski on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:05PM (#27212964)
Yes, you would be. I don't understand what the importance of the distinction is in terms of being able to use a device like an iPhone, iPad, or Apple Watch.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by legostormtroopr on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @07:06PM (#27215601)
This is how the W3C defines it for WCAG standards. In part this is because good acessibility helps everyone, whether you realise it or not.

For example, if you are in cold weather you have gloves on which limits your manual dexterity - you can't touch the watch without taking off your gloves, or can't turn the dial - in that situation you have the same dexterity as someone with one hand or limited finger grip. The same goes if you are holding a basket or child.

Alternatively, you have good eye sight and good hearing... for now - unfortunately this probably won't always be the case. But as you age (or if you go to a loud concert) this can change rapidly - having alternate ways of using technology will come in handy in unexpected ways.

Designing for situational disability, ie. I cant use a device in this way right now, will have dramatic impact on users with permanent disabilities - but also helps people with situation disabilities right now.

(Also I'm not sure why this comment is being so viciously downvoted, its a good question.)

Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by pseudalopex on Thursday May 20, 2021 @01:07AM (#27217610)
I think the votes are because the asker argued so stubbornly with answers they didn't like.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by dylan604 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:03PM (#27212940)
Maybe impaired is the better word? Similar to you are not driving while disabled from drinking, but you are driving impaired?
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by tolbish on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:08PM (#27212997)
That would be a more accurate term.
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by zepto on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:46PM (#27212710)
Yes?
Re:Previews of software updates designed for people with dis... by bruce343434 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:18PM (#27215254)
not able = disabled