Yea this isn't true. Their 54 qubit machine can simulate random circuits pretty fast but
1) that's not at all useful and specifically contrived as a test of "quantum supremacy".
2) totally debatable whether it's actually out of reach:
>In the paper, it is argued that their device reached “quantum supremacy” and that “a state-of-the-art supercomputer would require approximately 10,000 years to perform the equivalent task.” We argue that an ideal simulation of the same task can be performed on a classical system in 2.5 days and with far greater fidelity
https://www.ibm.com/blogs/research/2019/10/on-quantum-suprem...
As far as point 1 goes, nobody ever claimed otherwise. Its just an arbitrary milestone. Walk before you run. Quantum supremacy is a step in the journey, not the destination. You make a hello world program before making actual useful programs.
I've seen a lot of criticism that DWave is only good at making hardware that's hard to simulate without doing anything useful with it. What's different here?
Also, what do you mean by "allegedly"? Aren't the basics of their hardware pretty well-understood, or do you think they're sitting on a secret classical algorithm that's fooled external researchers (including Google) into believing that they've demonstrated multiqubit entanglement?
I'm well aware - doesn't mean they're not right.
>You make a hello world program before making actual useful programs.
how hilarious would it be if some chip manufacturer bragged about the performance of a hello world on their chip...?
That was my first take - and akin to saying "quantum intelligence" which just reeks of marketing on a synergy overdrive mission.
Of course they are just using quantum hardware/software approach towards AI type problems. So for me it may of been better to say Quantum Annealed AI. But then, as a campus name, it don't have that marketing ring going for it.
One question though that will arise down the line will be ethics, with a classical computer you can drill down and understand fully every bit of decision making if needs be. With a quantum computer, not so easy at all. Maybe possible that they create a good quantum AI system but equally at the same time it is also an evil AI system, only that they observe only the good as that is what they are looking for.
Philosophy is going to have a whole avenue of debate over this in years to come and who knows - AI psychology might be the future job we never expected to happen.
Adding "quantum" simply means speed ups for a few specific types of operations. You are not going to get an AGI with the current state of the art in quantum computing.
More specifically, are they better than the ones from "neuromorphic" chips like Intel Loihi?
Quantum systems have wavefunctions though, which collapse to a state. And before collapse, these can interfere. The math of this involves way more than normal linear algebra. Especially when you consider the things we've simplified away -- e.g. how exactly the wave function collapses. (We just say it's 'abrupt' and kinda leave it there. But it's possible this has implications for quantum computing, once we think in quantum theory terms rather than CS.)
Agreed. All ethical frameworks should include Hindley-Miller type inference.
It halves the exponent on the number of operations. 2^128 - reasonably secure by todays standards! 2^64 - horribly insecure.
(CAVEAT: where the speedup is applicable, which is often hard.)
Besides,in most places where that is an issue, its trivial to switch to 256bit algorithms
> (CAVEAT: where the speedup is applicable, which is often hard.)
Grover's algorithm has pretty wide applicability. Its the exponential speed ups like shor's algorithm that have super limited applicability.
"Nature is quantum mechanical: The bonds and interactions among atoms behave probabilistically, with richer dynamics that exhaust the simple classical computing logic."
"Already we run quantum computers that can perform calculations beyond the reach of classical computers."[citation needed]
[1] https://www.deepmind.com/blog/article/AlphaFold-Using-AI-for...