News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by Zenst on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @04:03PM (#27200285)
> I was sceptical because 'AI' and 'quantum' seems to be used interchangeably and fits your regular snakeoil salestalk

That was my first take - and akin to saying "quantum intelligence" which just reeks of marketing on a synergy overdrive mission.

Of course they are just using quantum hardware/software approach towards AI type problems. So for me it may of been better to say Quantum Annealed AI. But then, as a campus name, it don't have that marketing ring going for it.

One question though that will arise down the line will be ethics, with a classical computer you can drill down and understand fully every bit of decision making if needs be. With a quantum computer, not so easy at all. Maybe possible that they create a good quantum AI system but equally at the same time it is also an evil AI system, only that they observe only the good as that is what they are looking for.

Philosophy is going to have a whole avenue of debate over this in years to come and who knows - AI psychology might be the future job we never expected to happen.

Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by ampdepolymerase on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @05:02PM (#27201086)
You realize quantum computing is ultimately just a few linear algebra operations right? There is no more magic in it than conventional neural network based models. Standard ML ethical frameworks are more than sufficient.

Adding "quantum" simply means speed ups for a few specific types of operations. You are not going to get an AGI with the current state of the art in quantum computing.

Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by floatboth on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @06:16PM (#27201996)
Are those quantum speed ups for neural nets even good?

More specifically, are they better than the ones from "neuromorphic" chips like Intel Loihi?

Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by FuckButtons on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @07:25PM (#27202626)
I suppose that’s the reason google made the investment- to find out.
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by enkid on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @08:10PM (#27202999)
I'm not an expert on either, but based on my one course in neural networks I took, they are basically a series of linear algebra equations.
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by hdivider on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @08:53PM (#27203308)
>You realize quantum computing is ultimately just a few linear algebra operations right?

Quantum systems have wavefunctions though, which collapse to a state. And before collapse, these can interfere. The math of this involves way more than normal linear algebra. Especially when you consider the things we've simplified away -- e.g. how exactly the wave function collapses. (We just say it's 'abrupt' and kinda leave it there. But it's possible this has implications for quantum computing, once we think in quantum theory terms rather than CS.)

Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by foxes on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:10AM (#27204473)
A significant part of quantum computation is just a sequence of unitary transformations, represented by matrices. So essentially just a series of big matrix multiplications. The nonlinearity is introduced in the measurement. You have to repeat the calculation several times to build up a probability distribution.
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by krastanov on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:47AM (#27205035)
Wave functions are just another type of vectors. Measurement (and collapse) is just an application of matrix diagonalization. It has its complications and its own beauty, but it is indeed just fanciful linear algebra (I work professionally on this).
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by senkora on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:39AM (#27204644)
> Standard ML ethical frameworks are more than sufficient.

Agreed. All ethical frameworks should include Hindley-Miller type inference.

Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by inasio on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @05:46PM (#27201661)
No. See for example the Grover search algorithm. You can use to find whether an item is inside a list in O(sqrt(n)).
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by spxtr on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @06:07PM (#27201913)
I don't understand what you are saying. The parent comment said that quantum allows a few types of operations to get faster, and your response was "No," followed by a specific algorithm that is faster. Where do you disagree?
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by BobbyJo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:07AM (#27204443)
I think the point was it doesn't only speed up a small set of linear algebra calculations, but allows other, more complex, operations to be sped up as well.
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by klyrs on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @07:06PM (#27202457)
How big does n need to be before the expected runtime is less than n/2? And at that n, what gate fidelity is necessary to ensure that the answer will usally be correct?
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by haecceity on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @07:30PM (#27202668)
Slightly tangential but how significant is O(sqrt(n)) speed up? Fast algorithms are slightly faster but intractable algorithms are still intractable?
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by eximius on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @09:14PM (#27203452)
It makes memory, not compute, the limit.

It halves the exponent on the number of operations. 2^128 - reasonably secure by todays standards! 2^64 - horribly insecure.

(CAVEAT: where the speedup is applicable, which is often hard.)

Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by bawolff on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:35AM (#27205670)
2^64 is hardly horribly insecure. Its on the edge of what a gigantic compute cluster can do. So its not secure, but hardly horribly insecure. Especially even if you can get a quantum computter working, its not going to be on the same level of operations that a million dollars in AWS credits will get you. At least not for a very long time.

Besides,in most places where that is an issue, its trivial to switch to 256bit algorithms

> (CAVEAT: where the speedup is applicable, which is often hard.)

Grover's algorithm has pretty wide applicability. Its the exponential speed ups like shor's algorithm that have super limited applicability.

Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus by haecceity on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:35PM (#27213382)
I think the point is it lowers security by a factor of 2 in the exponent. Going from 2^64 to 2^63 lowers the amount of time to bruteforce a key by half.