That IBM is a competitor increases my trust in their refutation. IBM could have raced to to the same test, but on 56 qubits or whatever, and claimed quantum supremacy themselves.
I've seen a lot of criticism that DWave is only good at making hardware that's hard to simulate without doing anything useful with it. What's different here?
My understanding was that dwave was easy to simulate (albeit using a different algo than it was allegedly using)
Has their Feb '21 paper been refuted? They claim a scaling advantage (in addition to a large speed advantage) over path integral Monte Carlo, which appears to be best in class for simulating their hardware. Do you know of a better algorithm?
Also, what do you mean by "allegedly"? Aren't the basics of their hardware pretty well-understood, or do you think they're sitting on a secret classical algorithm that's fooled external researchers (including Google) into believing that they've demonstrated multiqubit entanglement?
Re:Unveiling our new Quantum AI campus
by anon_tor_12345 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @10:21AM
(#27209019)
>Ibm is a competitor in this space
I'm well aware - doesn't mean they're not right.
>You make a hello world program before making actual useful programs.
how hilarious would it be if some chip manufacturer bragged about the performance of a hello world on their chip...?
As far as point 1 goes, nobody ever claimed otherwise. Its just an arbitrary milestone. Walk before you run. Quantum supremacy is a step in the journey, not the destination. You make a hello world program before making actual useful programs.