Re:Waymo AV Freaked Out by Traffic Cones, Blocks Traffic, Ev...
by 988747 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @11:54AM
(#27174506)
> > Example running over an animal to avoid an accident
> Depends on the kind of accident you have in mind, so I can't give real feedback here.
Typical scenario here is a dog appearing on your lane in a high-traffic, multi-lane road. You don't swerve, you don't even break too hard, because hitting the dog is much better outcome than hitting another car, or landing in a ditch, or getting rear ended.
Re:Waymo AV Freaked Out by Traffic Cones, Blocks Traffic, Ev...
by michaelmrose on Sunday May 16, 2021 @09:58PM
(#27179314)
In many situations hitting the ditch at 20 is unlikely to kill you but hitting the pedestrian will still probably kill them.
Yeah but not trolley problem style. "Don't swerve" is a valid strategy for a car.
> Example running over an animal to avoid an accident
Depends on the kind of accident you have in mind, so I can't give real feedback here.
> getting rear ended to avoid hitting a pedestrian
Always brake to avoid hitting a pedestrian. You don't choose whether to get rear-ended and it won't be your fault either.
> taking a calculated risk of being hit by oncoming traffic on a 2 lane situation when coming across a stalled car without optimal view on the road ahead.
When one of the choices is "sit there and wait longer", that's definitely not a trolley problem. It either thinks going forward is sufficiently safe or it doesn't. It can wait all day for someone to intervene.
> Imagine on a 2 lane there is a pedestrian and oncoming traffic and insufficient time to stop. Do you kill the pedestrian or risk ending up in the ditch.
If it's programmed not to swerve, it will hit the pedestrian, which is an acceptable outcome of an unacceptable situation.
> If you are going 60 and ending up in the ditch would likely be fatal is it ok to just smear the pedestrian?
It's sufficiently ok when the only alternative is so reckless. Getting into that situation is the not-ok part.
> What if you can slow to 20 and then ditch?
If you can slow to 20 then hit the pedestrian at 20.