News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by gandalfian on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:44AM (#27164704)
In practice the UK already pays the price for a universal basic income. Most poor people get some sort of tax credit and/or housing benefit. What we don't do is allow people to use it to rise out of poverty. A disabled lady thought saving some of her disability was the responsible thing to do, despite further impoverishing herself, once she built up some savings she was prosecuted for fraudently claiming benefits while having savings. There is this tremendous destructive fear that no one should build up any capital with the help of benefits when this is precisely what would lift people out of poverty long term and reduce the costs on society.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by kebman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:00AM (#27164804)
The laws are like that, because someone feels that it's not in their interest that people actually get out of poverty. The logic behind that interest is simple. You can't make people dependent on you if you simultaneously give them the tools to achieve independence. And these guys love dependent people, because it gives them power. However this attitude is ruining most Western societies.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by mycologos on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:31AM (#27165043)
There's a weird chicken-and-egg quality to these arguments where the pro-state party wants to expand benefits, the anti-state party wants to limit them, and we end up at this equilibrium where benefits are good enough for some people to cobble together lives based on them, but not good enough for most of those people to build better lives and get off them. I think it's overly simplistic to put all of the blame on one party (as a sibling comment about Democrats does).
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by LordDragonfang on Saturday May 15, 2021 @02:42PM (#27167779)
I think it's disingenuous to categorize the parties as "pro-" and "anti-" state, when the "anti-state" parties generally contain all the nationalists, supporters of the police state, and those who are willing to increase state military expenditures (and at least in the US's case, increasing government subsidies for their own constituents).

It's pretty clear that "anti-state" in this context actually means opposition exclusively to policies that help the poor and hinder exploitation by the rich.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by usrusr on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:01AM (#27165326)
I call that problem the how-much-vs-how: there's a permanent battle about the amount of transfer with exceptions and special cases pushed in from both sides at every opportunity, and result is continually worse incentives and complications like that effective tax rate problem at the thresholds of the receiver side.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by shoo on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:08AM (#27164851)
do you have any hard data or research to back that up?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by monoideism on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:23AM (#27164966)
Hypothetically, if something like that were happening, do you think any of the politicians voting such legislation in, with such an intent, would admit to it in an open forum, for a study?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by kebman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:26AM (#27165516)
Well, if you're willing to look for it, there does exist research within political science that shows that "the elites" are systematically favoured in representational democracies, as far as policy implementation goes. In short, these analysis show that policies that has the favour of the elites gets voted in far more often than policies that only has the favour of the regular population.

Two great outliers here are of course the vote for Brexit, and the election of Trump. The elite hated both of those. An interesting paper would thus be to compare the contentedness of these "factions" with their political system between countries that have representative democracy, vs. countries that have a more direct style of democracy such as Switzerland.

Speaking purely from logic, neither the political nor the monetary elite would rationally want regular people to get a possible advantage over them. Moreover, they want people that are dependent on them, because that makes them far easier to control. You do that by making sure they only ever get enough money for their daily bread, without getting so much as to cut into what keeps the elites rich, which is a combination of real estate, banking and industry ownership.

This means both some right leaning, but also left leaning parties, might want to ensure that regular people are never given more than exactly enough for mere survival, but not a penny more. This also goes for education, btw. You don't want to over-educate these guys, lest they become a competitor to the job you're looking for. If you give them any less, you'll have riots on your hand. If you give them any more, you lose control over them.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by kebman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:36AM (#27165592)
> You see this a lot in immigration policy. Why do we have so many uneducated and unskilled immigrants with no legal recognition whatsoever, and so little immigration of skilled workers, much of it hobbled by restrictions on labor mobility (like those around the H1B visa)? Follow the money.

Well, in some sense you could also follow the labour organizations. Look, if you're a poor migrant who just got a hold of a job, would you love the idea of ten others standing in line for that same job, ensuring that you can't ever ask for a raise? No. If you were a rational human being, you'd start voting for the populist anti-migrant parties in your country of residence, like many immigrants are these days. This is proven by the wages in immigration heavy professions, that have been all but standing still for decades now.

Some people even call this effect reverse colonialism. It's when you're not allowed to earn money off colonialism anymore, so you simply invite the impoverished people for similar jobs in your own country instead. What's worse is that many Labour Party equivalents across the West have even been welcoming this change, since they hoped it would make more people vote for them. But now most of them see that this stance has backfired badly for them. Hence many of them are now experiencing the lowest approval ratings in decades, as many now view them as the direct cause for many of the problems Western countries are now experiencing.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by zozbot234 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:33AM (#27165568)
> You don't want to over-educate these guys, lest they become a competitor to the job you're looking for.

You see this a lot in immigration policy BTW. Why do we have so many uneducated and unskilled immigrants with no legal recognition whatsoever, and so little immigration of skilled workers and business-oriented people, much of it hobbled by restrictions on firm-level mobility (like those around the H1B visa)? Follow the money.

[dead]
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by amanaplanacanal on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:23AM (#27164971)
The people who supported segregation mostly abandoned the Democratic Party decades ago because of the civil rights issue. It’s one of the prime reasons the south used to be solidly Democratic and is now solidly Republican. Neither party is the same as it was in the nineteenth century.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by yonaguska on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:57AM (#27165290)
In case you haven't noticed, segregation has made a huge come back, and it's mostly supported by Democrats.

I'm talking the "everything but white people spaces", militant groups like NFAC, etc. We're also now segregating federal aid based on race, with federal aid for farmers being initially restricted to all groups except white men as well as federal aid for restaurants with the same requirements. If you are a white male restaurant owner, you cannot apply for federal aid due to covid-19 restrictions until they are sure enough minority/female owned businesses get aid. There is a finite limit to aid available.

It's also a cultural segregation that's being pushed. I identified as black for a long time. All my life in fact. My mother is black, my skin is white. I have been told on a number of occasions that my identification is not valid, that I don't have a right to speak on certain topics, and that I don't belong in certain spaces due to the color of my skin.

I experience way more racism in the north than in the south fwiw.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by zozbot234 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:28AM (#27165018)
> The people who supported segregation mostly abandoned the Democratic Party decades ago because of the civil rights issue.

Yup, that's what people like to tell themselves but much of it is wishful thinking. Look at how long people like Robert Byrd stayed around. Look at who actually supports, e.g. extreme NIMBY policies in urban areas to keep undesirable "demographics" out of the neighborhood, and "fights gentrification" to keep them boxed in with substandard amenities. How is that not modern segregation?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by imtringued on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:46AM (#27165655)
I agree. A lot of zoning is intentionally based on the idea of raising the cost of living so that the poorer part of the population is driven out. Things like rent control primarily benefit those who were not struggling in the first place. They just get to pay less on their expensive apartments. If you were struggling to pay rent, then rent control does nothing for you because the rents you were paying were not significantly above the mandated rent control level to begin with. However, since you are struggling, landlords are not willing to rent out units to you because any missed payment is a loss for them. They can't price that risk into their rents so they simply take someone with a better economic background.

That's how you get systemic racism without any single individual even thinking about skin color.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by dd36 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:41AM (#27165125)
It’s historical fact.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by enkid on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:49AM (#27165208)
Senators from West Virginia do not represent the mainstream Democrat views, so let's not cherry pick an example that ended over a decade ago. Instead, let's have a substantive conversation about policy. What specific policies are you referring to as NIMBY?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by zozbot234 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:58AM (#27165305)
> let's have a substantive conversation about policy

Right, that's what this thread is for. Is there anyone in the "mainstream Democrat" area who actually supports UBI? Who took the step to actually mail COVID relief checks to people with few if any strings attached, Republicans or Democrats?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by enkid on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:31PM (#27168164)
This has nothing to do with my question, and is suggesting that Republicans sent out more stimulus than Democrats when we passed bipartisan bills for stimulus checks under both Republican and Democrat administration. Republicans have continually taken steps to do things like limit unemployment benefits that Democrats have fought for.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ryukafalz on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:10AM (#27165388)
Not GP, but: single-family-exclusive zoning for one, which props up home values and is the norm in almost all US suburbs. Who benefits when home prices are high? Who benefits when they're affordable?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by zozbot234 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:14AM (#27165416)
Single family exclusive zoning also drives urban sprawl and the apparent "white flight" from areas that could be host to vibrant diversity. It's amazing how much of what we sometimes take for granted is actually the result of policy failure.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by enkid on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:35PM (#27168198)
Biden is purposing giving tax breaks to cities that stop this practice.[0] How is does this support the other poster's argument?

[0] https://www.usatoday.com/in-depth/news/nation/2021/04/14/zon...

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ryukafalz on Sunday May 16, 2021 @11:15PM (#27179749)
This is a good thing and I support it. Zoning decisions though tend to be more at the local level than the federal level, and I don't think there was much of any federal policy on it until now.

Anecdata: my local area leans heavily Democratic, and exclusively single family zoning is the norm almost everywhere around here. (Though thankfully the city I actually live in is mostly an exception.)

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ryukafalz on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:01AM (#27165790)
Although there's much we likely agree on (as you can see downthread), I downvoted this comment due to your use of "Democrat party" as an epithet. I think there's room for substantive conversations about these policies that cross partisan boundaries, but epithets are going to work against that. Even if you mean "Democratic politicians" and not "Democratic voters," that's not necessarily how Democratic voters are going to interpret it, and you're reducing the chance of communicating effectively across party lines.

Related: I think many Democratic voters would be highly receptive to discussions about how policies they might support or that they haven't thought much about contribute to structural racism and class inequality. I'm one such example (registered Democrat and typically vote Democratic, but I've been reading a lot about the effect of these policies lately), and I've had such a discussion very recently within my friend group. It's not a message that's lost on us. Just don't present it as a partisan battle against the people you're talking to, because you will get tuned out quickly if you do that.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by zozbot234 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:30AM (#27166081)
See, this would be a reasonable point of view if only we weren't currently seeing far more strident rhetoric coming from the other side, routinely accusing Republicans, white folks, those who care about traditional values, etc. etc. of furthering "racism and white supremacy".

This kind of divisiveness does far more in practice to "reduc[e] the chance of communicating effectively across party lines" than a mere quip ("Democrat party") that's essentially intended to unambiguously convey the intention to say not-really-nice things about Democratic policymakers, and that I've also striven to reasonably back with facts unlike so much recent discourse about "the evils of white supremacy".

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ryukafalz on Saturday May 15, 2021 @12:15PM (#27166485)
The people you're referring to are also engaging in partisan battles. As you can probably tell, it's not very convincing to those on the opposite side (yours, in this case). I agree, it's divisive. It's why I try not to do so whenever there's a chance that I might change someone's mind.

Quip or not, it frames the conversation in partisan terms, and people on the other side are going to check out if you do that. I'm not defending partisan warfare, but being divisive in response isn't going to contribute to making the conversation any less divisive.

I can't stop you, obviously, but realize that you're doing your own position a disservice by making it less likely that people will listen.

Or, if you like, think of it this way: the country is divided about equally politically. You only need to sway a small portion of people to win an election. If you can engage with like-minded people who lean the other way but the opposing party can't, you're likely to win consistently. Don't you want to win? (Democrats, you take note too.)

[dead]
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by hhvn on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:21AM (#27165478)
There is no alternative, that's why tactical voting[1] exists.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tactical_voting

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by pjc50 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:33AM (#27165062)
The drive from this comes out of the right, who believe that work is the only valid route out of poverty. Regardless of actual capacity to work.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by usrusr on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:16AM (#27165431)
Actually you can find strong feelings in favor of strictly demand-based transfer on both sides, that's the one thing they agree on. On one side it's "the money should be given to someone who needs it even more" and on the other it is "the money doesn't need to be transferred at all", but the result is the same. Effective tax rate in the vicinity of 100% (sometimes higher!) for people at the threshold and all that (like the lady who dared to save).
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by kebman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:58AM (#27165754)
Believe me, this drive also comes out of the bureaucratic left too, because dependent people give them far more power then a liberated people with means of their own. Panem et circenses!
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by chii on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:01AM (#27165325)
> only valid route out of poverty

well, what other routes are there?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by growse on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:22AM (#27165482)
If you can't think of any, do you think that means that those who can't work (disability, illness, dependents) deserve to be poor forever?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by chii on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:39AM (#27165611)
i'm not saying the deserve to be poor, but they cannot be rich - and at best, society can keep them alive and provide the minimal, necessary sustenance for survival. While they wait for technological improvements to cure them of their illness (if such tech comes to pass).

What would be a viable alternative? If this had happened in the jungle pre-historic times, they'd just be dead. So is it not an improvement?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by alephu5 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:05AM (#27165830)
Some of the richest people in the world do no work at all. Their parents give them an immense fortune, which is moved around by employees in such a way that earns in a day what most people get in a year. They consume to their heart's content, without ever having to actually work. Breed, die, repeat.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by bradlys on Saturday May 15, 2021 @02:39PM (#27167752)
Indeed.

The person above clearly doesn’t value the lives of the those who are unable to work like those who can. Thus, why they think giving them the littlest as they can is fine. After all, we as a society are only mildly capable of being better than a pack of wild animals. It says a lot about how this person views others, themselves, and humanity in general. Overall, they believe humanity has no hope or worthiness of existence.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by mrow84 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:59AM (#27165765)
> at best, society can keep them alive and provide the minimal, necessary sustenance for survival

There is no constraint on a society enforcing this level of support as an upper bound. A society can dedicate as much or as little of its resources as it chooses to supporting those unable to support themselves, each possible amount having a different set of consequences.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by teachingassist on Monday May 17, 2021 @08:21AM (#27182620)
> If this had happened in the jungle pre-historic times, they'd just be dead.

You're arguing for "The Protestant work ethic", which certainly isn't pre-historic. It's associated with the advancement of capitalism.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Kliment on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:05AM (#27165360)
For the fuckers currently running the UK, primarily a combination of inheritance and corruption.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by pessimizer on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:33AM (#27166118)
It's worse than that. The drive comes from people who employ labor who believe that poverty is the only way to keep wages low.

This attitude is very topical right now, playing out in US politics: https://theweek.com/articles/982343/republican-theory-unempl...

(Ignore the Republican part; most Democratic politicians would go in the same direction, but Republican belligerence gives them the cover to be silent, and to not alienate a portion of their base which would endanger their tiny majority.)

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by pbronez on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:30AM (#27165032)
Do you think it’s honestly that sophisticated and malicious? Public policy is hard. Adjusting benefits appropriately as people climb out of poverty is a known challenge. It’s called a “welfare trap” and has its own Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_trap

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by joeberon on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:58AM (#27165300)
Yes, there is a huge sentiment among the conservative public in the UK that people should not use benefits to gain capital or for social mobility. This isn't just a policy issue, it does come along with a commonly held attitude.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by belorn on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:15AM (#27165950)
Can there be social mobility that is independent of social social status, or does "social mobility" have a literal definition where if someone gains social status someone else must by definition be lower on the social ladder. If one follows that definition it seems not too strange logic that social support should go towards those at the bottom of the social ladder, and if you change the social ordering then who receive support will also change.

One way to resolve the problem seems to be to decouple benefits from social status and instead see them as human rights. Health care is not something that you buy, but rather a service that the government provide to every citizen equally. The top 1% get the same cancer treatment as the homeless and both pay zero.

Decouple benefits from social status does not seems to be strictly a left vs right issue, at least not here in Sweden. Is the UK different here?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by joeberon on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:41AM (#27166194)
Yes it's a left vs right issue here. This interpretation will seem very biased, since I am very left wing, but it really is this way:

The left see benefits or welfare as a right, and as a very important way to help people who have found themselves in difficult situations. Here in the UK, left wing people often view those on benefits as victims of their situation or upbringing. They do not think of them as of low social status.

The right see benefits or welfare as just a necessary evil to prevent mass death. Here in the UK, right wing people often view those on benefits as leeches and criminals, who have made the choice to be ineffective at achieving and maintaining a high enough income. They think of them as of low social status.

Sweden is very differently politically to a lot of countries, at least I've heard you have far less party politics. The UK is absurdly polarised on these issues.

For your cancer treatment thing, that's not how it works here in the UK at all. While we do have universal healthcare, unfortunately it varies drastically based on where you live, and if you live in a poorer area, you are much more likely to get overwhelmed and struggling hospitals. So really a hospital in a richer area will give totally different care to one in a poorer area.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by belorn on Saturday May 15, 2021 @05:30PM (#27169215)
We do have a somewhat similar problem where depending on where you live you get slightly different social support, but this comes as a consequence of local government. Local government need to have a balanced book where those that pay more local taxes than the resources they consumes from local government matches those that consume more than they pay.

If a local region has an influx of citizens that consume more of local resources than they pay in local taxes, the local government then only really has one primary option: reducing who get support and how much support. Health clinics can as a result vary greatly between regions, but since there much fewer hospitals, multiple regions have to join up to a single one and thus the difference get more smoothed out.

With covid-19 pandemic there has been one political change where the right has gone out with the goal of fully nationalizing healthcare, which is a bit odd in terms of left vs right.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by gandalfian on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:18AM (#27165445)
I really don't think it's hate. I think it's fear and cynicism clouding the bigger picture and keeping us all stuck in a trap of our own making.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by te_chris on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:56AM (#27165281)
Yes, it absolutely is that sophisticated and malicious. Have you seen the political environment in the UK?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ktzar on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:15AM (#27164910)
What is outrageous if that the UK prevents you from getting any benefit of you have any savings. It's basically encouraging you to not save any money.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by dazc on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:43AM (#27165634)
Not true. Job Seeker's Allowance is not means-tested. https://www.gov.uk/jobseekers-allowance/eligibility

If you are still unemployed whan that runs out your savings are taken into account but you can still have £16K. https://www.gov.uk/universal-credit/eligibility

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by NohatCoder on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:35AM (#27166131)
Not good, but at least that limit is better than the 10k DKK limit in Denmark, you basically can't even have a proper rainy day fund or own a car.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by mattowen_uk on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:42AM (#27166210)
This is not true. The new universal credit rules allow you a certain amount of savings.

A member of my family has just been on universal credit due to the pandemic impacting her work sector, and they still gave her benefits even with her having savings, it's slightly adjusted down, but she still got payments.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Al-Khwarizmi on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:21AM (#27165473)
In Spain it's similar, we already have de facto basic income, just much more complicated than it should be. When you lose your job you have unemployment payments, when it expires there is a "long-term unemployment aid" that in theory was a temporary measure for the 2008 crisis, but every government has kept extending and no one has dared to remove, even when the right had an absolute majority. And then there are regional aids for "social reinsertion". So basically everyone is covered by a safety net and can obtain some income except for people who actively refuse to do so.

Still, actual UBI here is an unpopular idea with most of the population, who say that people need to work for a living, that it's a "handout" for lazy people, it will make people stop working, etc. Funny when the two largest problems of our society are probably unemployment (lack of work for people who do want one) and lack of children. And both are problems that ask for less total hours worked, not more.

To me, it's a purely moralistic issue (and based on quite outdated morals). If we are already putting in the money to ensure that people have some basic needs covered, from a rational point of view I don't see the problem with turning it into an automatic right instead of something that people need to apply for and that we pretend is "temporary" (but not even the political right will remove it, no one wants the streets full of people with nothing to lose). And as a side effect, we could get rid of a lot of bureaucratic overhead in the process, plus no longer needing minimum wage and making the job market more dynamic.

I guess logic will triumph in the end, although it's difficult because there is a lot of purely irrational thinking. For example, most of the people who furiously oppose an UBI because in theory everyone should have to make an effort and earn a living for themselves are also the people who furiously oppose taxing large inheritances...

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by frankbreetz on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:54AM (#27164753)
What you are describing is very different from UBI. With UBI everyone gets a certain amount no matter what. There is nothing universal about what you are describing.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by wizzwizz4 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:58AM (#27164783)
That's the point of the comment. The UK pays the price of UBI without getting the benefits of UBI.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by leadingthenet on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:59AM (#27164790)
Well, no. Only a small minority of people are on Universal Credit.

I don’t get how this follows, at all.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by neom on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:18AM (#27164935)
If you take out pensions(~100b gbp), the UK spends (very) approx. 100 billion pounds a year on social assistance. I think OP is suggesting taking that 100 billion and dividing it evenly among the people of the UK vs specifically to the folks who have applied.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by woko on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:27AM (#27165010)
> specifically to the folks who have applied

I like how you distinguish between the people who are eligible and the people who have applied, because some eligible people do not know they are and therefore do not apply.

It is brought up in the press [1] from time to time, and the percentage in France is somewhere between 40% and 50% of the eligible people, which is huge!

[1] in French: https://www.leparisien.fr/economie/votre-argent/aides-social...

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by chrisseaton on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:52AM (#27165236)
Why not include pensions? Since your pension could be replaced by your basic income.

But if you do, it's about £3.5k a year each I think. Not a lot of money. Certainly not enough to live on for a basic standard of living in our society.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by neom on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:05AM (#27165357)
I agree but I seperated it for whose who might not, this way you can choose how you think about it. :)
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by vageli on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:31AM (#27165045)
Is there surplus in these social assistance budgets going unused? How could you expect to spread the same budget over the entire population while maintaining the quality of benefits?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by neom on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:38AM (#27165106)
There is no surplus in the social assistance budget that I saw when I went and looked over the budgetary documents to post my original comment. I'm not an expert and I didn't dive deep, I just wanted to look for the numbers that the UK is associating to "welfare" and "social assistance". As far as I saw, the majority of the benefit is via tax rebate, tax reductions, and in some instances direct payment, so in that light, I'm not sure "quality" is much of a factor? The UK already has social healthcare iirc. I think in the UBI world, everyone pays tax normally, and then that money is distributed evenly vs specifically? (Edit: removed my math as it is wrong, as usual)
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by _qwfv on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:09AM (#27165375)
Some social assistance programs are probably worth keeping, rather than converting to dollars. Here in the states, for instance, I received regular updates on what to expect as my child developed, what vaccines they should have, what exercise and nutrition needs they have, and when to see a doctor. That info was really useful, much more so than getting mailed a couple bucks.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by waheoo on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:15AM (#27164909)
What don't you get? They pay the price of it but don't get it, may as well pay the price of it and get the benefits it provides.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by vageli on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:34AM (#27165068)
All things being equal, wouldn't that greatly reduce the benefit amount per person?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by _qwfv on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:06AM (#27165362)
Administration costs go way down. We're spending a ton on making sure that only the "right" people get benefits and policing the poor.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Turing_Machine on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:57AM (#27165293)
I don't know about the UK, but in the US a substantial portion of the budget is spent on bureaucrats ("caseworkers" and the like) who would be unnecessary with UBI.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by wizzwizz4 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:02AM (#27165329)
According to the radio (BBC), a substantial portion of the budget is going to contractors who've started rejecting perfectly good applications.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by pjc50 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:48AM (#27165197)
Universal Credit is very far from universal, of course. It has some deliberate bugs, like a lag in payments that drives people to loan sharks.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by dalbasal on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:50AM (#27165219)
This is true, or arguably true, but we need to remember that real-life policies are never clean, blackboard examples. They're not going to just swap out social welfare and council housing for UBI. It'll be layered in somehow.

Hell... you can "sell" politicians on UBI, have them nod along, and expect them to come back with a proposal for a conditional UBI. They like your idea, it just needed to be optimized it so that only those who need it get it.

That doesn't mean I'm against this. I think it's a positive development, for the reason you outline and others... just mitigating expectations.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by OJFord on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:20AM (#27165469)
> when this is precisely what would lift people out of poverty long term and reduce the costs on society.

How, if you disallow stopping the payment?

It seems like what you want to happen is exactly what did happen: she saved, had money, and then the cost on society was reduced.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by jscholes on Saturday May 15, 2021 @12:43PM (#27166745)
> A disabled lady thought saving some of her disability was the responsible thing to do, despite further impoverishing herself, once she built up some savings she was prosecuted for fraudently claiming benefits while having savings.

I don't know the specific case you're referencing, and it's possible that they were charged with fraud in relation to a benefit which does come with a savings/income cap. However, the two main disability-related benefits in the UK (Disability Living Allowance and Personal Independence Payment) are paid regardless of personal wealth. I don't disagree with the general gist of your comment, and as I say it's likely that the person was claiming additional benefits where your assets are taken into account.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by AlchemistCamp on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:09AM (#27165376)
What you describe very clearly isn't universal.

One of the major selling points of UBI is that it never disincentivizes recipients from earning, saving or investing in their futures.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by tastyfreeze on Saturday May 15, 2021 @12:21PM (#27166541)
A negative income tax would achieve the same goal without giving money to people that dont need it.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by anovikov on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:09AM (#27164870)
Except there is not enough redistributable capital around to let it happen. Even if all U.S. capital stock ($70T) was distributed to everyone evenly, it won't let people out of poverty (sustainable income derived from this will equal to about the minimum wage per adult). So even the most terribly unfair capital redistribution imaginable will ok, maybe pay for food stamps for everyone, but hardly much more.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:24AM (#27164978)
In the last year 33.8% of all personal income in the US came from the government. It’s crazy to think that number could go much higher but no wonder we are experiencing shortages of just about everything and inflation.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by imtringued on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:18AM (#27165981)
I'm not sure you understand your own comment because what you are saying is basically that people are asking for way too high wages. Why? Because governments don't force people to work for them, they have to hire them on the open market, which means that they have to pay the prevailing wage and that wage is too high for private companies, which forces them to raise their prices, in short, higher wages drive inflation, which means wage growth is leading inflation, which means workers are actually benefiting from the current situation.

This is true to some extent and it explains 2% inflation, but the boring answer is that gasoline prices are rising much much faster than wages which is another 2% for 4% inflation in total.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by vegetablepotpie on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:57AM (#27165292)
That is incredible, do you have a link by chance?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Pfhreak on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:12AM (#27165399)
I'm guessing it's a cherry picked statistic that is using covid relief to paint some broader picture that doesn't exist. Of course I'd expect government assistance to increase during the worst pandemic in a generation.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:29AM (#27165539)
How is that painting a picture that doesn’t exist? I never said that was in normal times. I said in the last year.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:28AM (#27165529)
https://twitter.com/biancoresearch/status/138937682791591936...

Can’t find a link to an article but here is a writer for Bloomberg with reference to his graphs from Bloomberg.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by lifeisstillgood on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:42AM (#27165145)
Just some back of the envelope work - with 70 million million divided amoung 300 million people, that's 233,333 per person. Assume 4 people per household that's about a million per household. Avg s&p dividend is 2.3% - That's minimum wage per 2 working adult household.

The math does seem to stack up. The problem is distribution, not total wealth it seems

Edit: Ok this is skewed as US stock markets are really a global stock market, but if you took for example global GDP (~115 Trn) and divided by 8 bn people or 4 person households you end up with 60k per household globally.

Here's a trick I was explaining to my son earlier. We really do live in the Matrix. An announcement comes on and they are resetting - everyone gets a new life starting tomorrow - but randomly allocated over the 8 billion possible "players". We can keep the current social order or we can design a new one.

Do you hope the 8 billion sided dice rolls in your favour and you land in Jeff Bezos body? Or do you think maybe we should redesign society ?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by anovikov on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:01AM (#27165323)
Yes but that way of splitting would very quickly destroy for the very very obvious reason - no money must be given to children... And dividing by adults, say over-15s, it's 70T per 257M, $272K per adult or $1044 per month for that family of 4 with 2 adults in it... That hardly solves any questions.

And you can't divide all of it, because it means destroying capitalism, taking the bottom out of society. Only a small fraction of capital stock can possibly be distributed this way.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by lifeisstillgood on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:28AM (#27165530)
I am not an advocate for UBI, I am an advocate for a fairer society. (And the intra-US wealth disparities are as nothing to globally)

I should not have assumed dividends were of total stock - that's nonsense. But even so stock market is not total wealth - far more wealth is in real estate for example.

First there is no destroying of society, I am assuming a different distribution of the dividends - assume something like the Norway Sovereign fund(s).

And while this is very back of the envelope I am assuming money goes to children (broad assumption that every household is two adults and two kids).

But let's look at say GDP distribution - that's 5.5 trn - which divided by 300 m people is 18k each.

I am just arguing against the idea that there is not enough wealth or money around, so we cannot share it.

There is enough. How we share it is politics.

And it's always worth nothing that history shows if you don't share for long enough, people take it away from you.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Pfhreak on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:18AM (#27165440)
> $272k per adult or $1044 per month for that family of 4 with 2 adults in it

Something fishy about your math here.

$272k per adult is $544k per family. If you paid it over one year that's $45k per month.

Edit: oh, I see, you are only giving people the interest on the capital and assuming a growth rate of ~2%. Both of which seem quite silly to me, but whatever.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by anovikov on Saturday May 15, 2021 @12:22PM (#27166553)
But we spoke about possibility of creation of sustainable income for everyone, not a one-off money grab? Not a growth rate, but yes, dividends rate - because growth in capital itself will go into inflation, population growth, and growth of living standards, so yeah, 2.3% is all we can realistically plan for.

And then the big question is: how is this society different from Soviet Union? Literally, i am not exaggerating: an economy where capital is, by law, owned only by the government, and private ownership of means of production is a felony (or how else you will take all capital away)? Or if you want to literally give shares to individuals, not to some immense state fund which will do the redistribution job, what will prevent these people from drinking and gambling these shares away? If American rich will be robbed off all their money so they won't be able to buy, to the Chinese rich (they will be able to afford as people will be running to sell off - if they were attracted by 2.3% returns they'd be buying stock now as it is, only reason why they don't is that they don't see it as attractive - so they WILL sell - and stock will be dirt cheap)

It all sounds like a way to kill capitalism, or sell it off to foreigners...

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by lifeisstillgood on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:37AM (#27165595)
The numbers are silly - but I am not advocating some massive one off redistribution - I am just trying to argue against the idea there is not enough money to go around.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by imtringued on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:26AM (#27166035)
>$272k per adult is $544k per family. If you paid it over one year that's $45k per month.

If it was paid out, you would lose your job.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by hogFeast on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:31AM (#27165547)
> A disabled lady thought saving some of her disability was the responsible thing to do, despite further impoverishing herself

???

So if I earn £100k/year, and I choose to save all of my income then I am impoverishing myself. Do you understand what saving is?

The UK has this terrible habit, like the US, where people are infinitely jealous of other people. Any benefit that someone else is getting, I want it. You get tax credits, I want them too (even though I am making £50k/year). The result of this situation was/is a "welfare" state that primarily gives money to those who don't need help.

Yes, if you have £18k in savings...you don't need help. Do you understand what being poor is? You are not poor if you have £18k in savings.

In the pandemic, it was utterly appalling to see middle-class people who earn substantial amounts of money complain about not being able to claim benefits. How greedy can you possibly get? And then the Tories bring out a huge wage subsidy scheme that lavishes support on the middle-class support, not five or so years after they tried to squeeze £100/week out of people dying of cancer or who literally cannot work to feed themselves. £4000/month to a middle-class person on hard times...no problem. £70/week to someone dying of cancer or someone is homeless...what a scrounger, unbelievable scrounging, greed.

I am British but Britain is a truly amazing place. In the US, everyone seems to think they are middle-class, even if they are in a two-person household earning $400k/year, they seem to resent being forced to pay for anything. The UK is heading this way quickly but from the other way: Blair introduced universal benefits, everyone has their hand out now, no matter how wealthy.

Also, the purpose of benefits is not to get someone out of poverty. It is to help people who need help. The system has been totally debauched by middle-class people who think it is their "leg up". It is not. Spending should be focused entirely upon people who cannot help themselves (for whatever reason).

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by imtringued on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:58AM (#27165751)
>So if I earn £100k/year, and I choose to save all of my income then I am impoverishing myself. Do you understand what saving is?

You are still living the life of a poor person. You are homeless. You don't have a car. You don't have a smartphone. You have nothing except your savings. The crucial difference is that the disabled lady apparently didn't even own the savings she sacrificed her living standards for.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by zozbot234 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:48AM (#27165677)
> Yes, if you have £18k in savings...you don't need help. Do you understand what being poor is? You are not poor if you have £18k in savings.

Savings is not income. One is a stock, the other is a flow. People might be in need of income support even if they've been saving responsibly for a while.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by hogFeast on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:59AM (#27165761)
Yes, you can use your savings. Savings are income. The only reason for savings is to consume in the future. Believing that you should have permanent savings that can't be used for consumption is just out of this world...I would speak to someone who has no money. The welfare state exists for people who need help, not those who wish the state to keep them in a luxury to which they have become accustomed.

EDIT: most benefits pay out £4-5k/year, saying £18k is "peanuts" is...a little sickening...it is a monumental amount of money to people on benefits. I would talking to someone who is homeless and tell them that £18k is "peanuts" to you. What an utterly middle-class/greedy sentiment.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by zozbot234 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:19AM (#27165987)
> The only reason for savings is to consume in the future.

Yes, but try amortizing £18k over any number of years. It's peanuts when judged on an income basis. This person is just as much in need of help, whether or not they're prudent enough to keep £18k in the bank as a precautionary buffer.