News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by djanogo on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:42PM (#27134933)
I don't know how Bitcoin transactions work, but can a company (like Paypal) buy bunch of bitcoins (10000), and then proceed to do all transaction internally with their own ledger mechanism without depending on other networks?, wouldn't this allow anybody within paypal network to send/receive super fast?
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by MereInterest on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:57PM (#27135064)
Correct. This adds a point of centralization, which defeats the entire purpose of cryptocurrency. As far as I can tell, cryptocurrency is based on wanting (1) a shared database that (2) can be updated by anyone within specific rules and (3) doesn't require anybody to trust anybody else. In the same way that low-trust societies have a much bigger overhead as a result of the lack of trust, I do not think cryptocurrencies are feasible while holding to (3) without massive, massive expenditure as a result.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by tshaddox on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @09:21PM (#27137371)
> This adds a point of centralization, which defeats the entire purpose of cryptocurrency.

I don't think you get to declare what "the entire purpose of cryptocurrency" is! People tend to get confused about what "trustlessness" actually means. It certainly doesn't mean that every single aspect of every transaction involving cryptocurrency must not require any party to place any trust in another party. If you're using cryptocurrency to buy bread you still need to trust that the baker hasn't poisoned your bread, and that need for trust must be addressed by some mechanism unrelated to cryptocurrency (like the baker's reputation, or laws against poisoning people). That doesn't illustrate some absurdity in the idea of cryptocurrency or "defeat the entire purpose of cryptocurrency."

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by MereInterest on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @10:00PM (#27137616)
We're in agreement that trust is needed at some point in the system. Cryptocurrencies can be completely internally consistent, but have no relationship to the real world. The only way for that relationship to be formed is by trust.

But, there is not a single thing in cryptocurrencies that make sense if you are willing to allow for centralization. If you have a centralized system, then you have a limited number of actors allowed to make changes to the ledger. You can establish trust out-of-band, whether that means by passing around gpg keys, by investigating previous banking practices, or by establishing common rules for auditing. After that, there's no need for Proof of Work/Stake/Space/etc, because you can trust the updates coming from the rest of the network.

The reason I say that the point of cryptocurrency is trustlessness and decentralization is because the only other alternative is that all the implementers of cryptocurrencies are utter fools not to see the simpler solution. I don't think that is the case. I think they have seen the simpler solution of trusted validators, and have dismissed it out of a fundamental difference in priorities from mine, but I don't think they are fools.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by tshaddox on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @10:37PM (#27137831)
I’m not sure what you mean. The centralization being discussed here is out of band and thus the trust is also out of band. It’s no different than your local bar opening a tab for you, or using an escrow service for a construction contract.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by MereInterest on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @10:57PM (#27137937)
Because once that centralization occurs, the remaining trustlessness doesn't serve a purpose. All that's happened is switching from one centralized system to another, but with a much, much greater overhead.

Mind you, I don't mind centralized systems, but the entire marketing of cryptocurrencies for the past decade has been how it is decentralized and outside of the the reach of any entity. We knew this wasn't the case in 2014, when Mt Gox folded and all signs pointed to fraud. We knew this wasn't the case in 2016, when the Dao smart contract was reversed by general appeal. We know it now as mining pools continue to rise. The decentralization is the main selling point of cryptocurrencies, and yet at every turn it is proven false.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CSSer on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:50PM (#27135580)
> without massive, massive expenditure as a result.

Could you elaborate on this?

The problem I foresee is that having someone you have to trust is not a bad thing because at least you're able to identify that entity's traits and act accordingly. If that entity is, for example, the world's largest military power, I might feel like I have a lot less to worry about than if they're, as another example, a publicly traded company about half the size of the average major U.S. bank.

Is this what you're alluding to?

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by MereInterest on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @09:43PM (#27137510)
In general, the more people cooperate, the better the results are overall. The downside is that the more people cooperate, the more they can be taken advantage of by defectors, by bad actors who decide to harm the public good in exchange for personal benefit. I absolutely agree that being able to trust particular actors is a huge benefit.

Part of the problem is language. "Trust" isn't just trust in a particular actor's intent, but also in their capabilities to carry through on a promise. In order to trust somebody to carry out a promise, you need to indirectly trust on others not to interfere with that promise. In this case, if you don't trust the US government to handle currency, then you certainly can't trust a publicly traded company that is beholding to work within and has assets that can be seized by the US government. If you assume ill-intent on the part of the government, then there's no reason to assume that a smaller actor wouldn't be influenced by the government.

In this case, I trust the US government to manage currency well, because it is in its best interest to do so.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by quadcore on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:47PM (#27134981)
This is basically the principle behind a tech on top of bitcoin called lighning network: https://lightning.network
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by lottin on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:37PM (#27135444)
The whole selling point of bitcoin is that it's a decentralised ledger that isn't owned by anybody. If the transactions are managed by a central entity, then that's no longer true. For example, what's to stop such an entity from creating bitcoins out of nothing and thus debasing the bitcoin currency?
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by MereInterest on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:52PM (#27137156)
Absolutely nothing is preventing it. Depending on your viewpoint, it happened back in 2014, and somehow the cryptocurrency community just sort of shrugged and got back to wildly speculating.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mt._Gox

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by unwoundmouse on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:46PM (#27134971)
Yeah that's how all centralized crypto exchanges do it
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CSSer on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:54PM (#27135040)
What if there's a run on the exchange?
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by ChainOfFools on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:11PM (#27135187)
they suddenly have a 'technical issue' and suspend trading until it is 'fixed.' sometimes its never fixed and the exchange founder mysteriously disappears to Thailand or dies, or claims to start an orphanage in india. sometimes all three.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by boc on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @11:28PM (#27138077)
Just in case you aren't catching on here, cryptocurrencies are not the future. They are just digital tulips - beautiful to look at and comprehend, but separate from any meaningful contribution to the economic system. You can still get rich from them by hyping and selling them before people catch on more broadly.

Civilization works because of laws that are interpreted by courts and norms which are broadly accepted but not often checked/enforced. Crypto is trying to create a "trustless" future where you do not need society to coordinate and regulate. Our modern financial system needs that squishiness/trust which you get from the legal system to operate at full capacity.

Picture the suspension of a car. In our modern financial world, the legal system and regulatory institutions serve as the shocks and struts of your car. It allows you to drive fast while not having to worry about every imperfection on the road. Cryptocurency is like driving a car where your wheels are attached directly to the axel - yes it's perfectly efficient and there's nothing between you and the road, but that also means you have to be exceptionally careful where you are driving, and you can't do it fast.

There's a reason all cars come with suspensions.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by smabie on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @10:13PM (#27137676)
They pause withdrawals while they get their coins out of cold storage.

Or if the exchange isn't fully collateralized, it's a scam and goes under.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by wmf on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:36PM (#27135440)
If the blockchain gets backed up it would take a few days to get money in/out of exchanges.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by beiller on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:14PM (#27135791)
I don't think there can theoretically be a run on the exchange because in theory all the deposits are there, in the exchange, in theory, unlike a bank which only had a fraction of the deposited money in reserve. A run on a crypto exchange would be great for them considering they usually charge a withdrawal fee.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CyberDildonics on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:47PM (#27136099)
Those aren't withdrawal fees, those are transaction fees for the network. Most cryptocurrencies cost next to nothing for each transaction, while bitcoin and ethereum cost from $20 - $60 USD for the average transaction.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by beiller on Thursday May 13, 2021 @04:37PM (#27147111)
No I'm not confusing it. My exchange and all other exchanges charge a fee to withdrawal money. Its usually quite large.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CyberDildonics on Thursday May 13, 2021 @09:23PM (#27149561)
Again, that fee is not something the exchange is charging you. The fee doesn't go to them.

If it is bitcoin or ethereum there are very high fees for each transaction. The exchange is showing you those fees in your native currency. They aren't getting that money, it is going to the miners.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by beiller on Friday May 14, 2021 @10:41AM (#27154816)
No you still are misunderstanding what I'm saying. The text on the exchange for me is like "We charge 0.05% fee on all withdrawals NOT INCLUDING the transaction fee to send to your wallet".
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CyberDildonics on Friday May 14, 2021 @04:08PM (#27159133)
If you are not talking about the spread between exchanging two currencies, that should be a GIANT red flag to not use that exchange.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CrLf on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:52PM (#27135022)
That’s how traditional financial systems work.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by hgfxgkgc on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:45PM (#27135527)
Paypal already does this with bitcoin.