News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by websites420 on Monday May 10, 2021 @08:32PM (#27112738)
Looking forward to the retractions from all those publications that strongly implied or outright claimed AP was involved.
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by jonas21 on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:00PM (#27113769)
Can you provide an example of a publication that "strongly implied or outright claimed" on their own that autopilot was involved?

At least in the mainstream press, they seem to have reported what the police were saying at the time, and indicated that they were quoting the police. For example, from the NYT [1]:

> Two men were killed in Texas after a Tesla they were in crashed on Saturday and caught fire with neither of the men behind the wheel, the authorities said.

> Mark Herman, the Harris County Precinct 4 constable, said that physical evidence from the scene and interviews with witnesses led officials “to believe no one was driving the vehicle at the time of the crash.”

They also attempted to get Tesla's side of the story, but Tesla didn't respond:

> Tesla, which has disbanded its public relations team, did not respond to a request for comment.

I'd be upset with the police for making such confident statements that were contradicted by later investigations. But the media, who may not have had access to the accident scene, seems to have done a reasonable job reporting, at least from what I've seen.

In an ideal world, maybe they'd do an independent investigation instead of relying on police statements, but it's a question of how to allocate resources across all things they could be reporting. It probably makes it more difficult to do this when Tesla won't talk to them.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/18/business/tesla-fatal-cras...

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by ajross on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:35PM (#27113954)
> They also attempted to get Tesla's side of the story, but Tesla didn't respond:

To be fair, that's a little disingenuous given that Musk was literally tweeting denials at press time. Tesla certainly didn't refuse to respond, they had lots of things to say. But the article didn't get them in time so went to press trying to imply they had something to hide.

As far as the media reporting the story: it's fine. It was newsworthy. The "there was no one driving the car" business from the fire chief seems in hindsight to have been the real failing. That quote seems to have been a lot jucier than was warranted. In fact it seems almost certain that someone was manually operating that car via some mechanism or another.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by jonas21 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:12AM (#27114134)
I don't think this was a case of them simply not getting a response in time. The NYT will usually add an update to the online article if they receive a response after it's published. And according to Electrek, Tesla refuses to comment on all press inquiries [1].

> Since dissolving the team at the beginning of the year, I had hoped that Tesla would try to build a new one, but it doesn’t seem to be the case.

> Instead, Tesla is leaving all press inquiries unanswered and doesn’t seem to comment on any story.

But I agree with you that the local authorities really screwed up here when communicating with the press.

[1] https://electrek.co/2020/10/06/tesla-dissolves-pr-department...

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @01:09AM (#27114419)
"We ignored the public statements the company was making because they didn't send it to us directly" is a pretty bad look.

Saying they didn't respond would be fine for almost any other topic, but it's bad reporting for this one.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by ajross on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @08:35AM (#27117306)
> The NYT will usually add an update to the online article if they receive a response after it's published

Then why didn't they update this article? Again, it's not like Tesla didn't say anything relevant. You're making what amounts to a process argument: Tesla didn't respond in the right way and so the Times is allowed to claim that they refused to comment because it's technically true.

But "technically true" isn't what journalism is supposed to be about, and the Times is usually pretty good about that in its hard news coverage. Which is why you can tell that this is really a business/investment story being pawned off as news.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by clouddrover on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @01:37AM (#27114579)
> To be fair, that's a little disingenuous given that Musk was literally tweeting denials at press time.

Tesla says that Musk's tweets about autopilot are disconnected from reality:

https://www.theverge.com/2021/5/7/22424592/tesla-elon-musk-a...

So why would and why should anyone else take his tweets seriously?

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by jiofih on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @03:10AM (#27115137)
“Two killed in Autopilot crash”

“A Fatal Crash Renews Concerns Over Tesla’s ‘Autopilot’ Claim” (Wired)

“2 Killed in Driverless Tesla Car Crash” … “no one was driving the vehicle” (NY Times)

“Tesla on Autopilot crashes in Texas” (driving.ca)

“Tesla crash: investigators ‘100% sure’ no one driving car in fatal Texas incident” (The Guardian)

Reporters have a duty to verify their sources and information and not report on rumors or hearsay.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by websites420 on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:36PM (#27113957)
>Can you provide an example of a publication that "strongly implied or outright claimed" on their own that autopilot was involved?

Sure. Here you go.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/04/19/tesla-texas...

Headline: A driverless Tesla crashed and burned for four hours, police said, killing two passengers in Texas.

Lede: "Just before midnight Saturday, a Tesla drove swiftly around a curve, veered off the road, struck a tree and burst into flames in The Woodlands, Tex., a suburb north of Houston, police said."

"Driverless" is used here to relate the reader to "Driverless cars," aka "self driving car." Note that the police only said that the driver wasn't in the driver's seat at the time of the crash.

The lede puts the agency for the driving on the car: "a Tesla drove..."

Looks like NBC did it too:

The vehicle, a 2019 Tesla Model S, was driving at high speed when it ran off the road, hit a tree and burst into flames, he said.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/2-dead-tesla-crash-afte...

Here's Yahoo News with a video, headline "2 killed after self-driving Tesla crashes into tree, bursts into flames":

https://news.yahoo.com/2-killed-fiery-tesla-crash-210032357....

But wait, isn't that "technically correct" (the best kind of correct) to what the original investigation said?

Sure! But then why did other news sources go to great lengths to avoid using the phrase? Here's The Verge:

https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/18/22390612/two-people-kille...

"Two people killed in fiery Tesla crash with no one driving"

"Preliminary reports suggest the car was traveling at a high rate of speed and failed to make a turn, then drove off the road into a tree."

Notice the hedging in the paragraph. Notice the use of passive voice "was traveling."

Professional writers know the meaning of words. They know what those words mean to readers. They use them deliberately.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by herbstein on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @04:53AM (#27115804)
Your whole argument hinges on the fact that the publications are intentionally trying to smear Tesla and their AutoPilot feature. The fact of the matter is that those articles very clearly state that they're quoting what the police say about the crash.

From your The Verge article, that supposedly is the example of trying very hard not to divulge this fact.

> Authorities in Texas say two people were killed when a Tesla with no one in the driver’s seat crashed into a tree and burst into flames, Houston television station KPRC 2 reported.

It's the first line of the article.

> Preliminary reports suggest the car was traveling at a high rate of speed and failed to make a turn, then drove off the road into a tree. One of the men killed was in the front passenger seat of the car, the other was in the back seat, according to KHOU. Harris County Precinct 4 Constable Mark Herman told KPRC that “no one was driving” the fully-electric 2019 Tesla at the time of the crash. It’s not yet clear whether the car had its Autopilot driver assist system activated.

That's the third paragraph. I don't think they're hiding that they're parroting police officials.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by websites420 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @02:07PM (#27121396)
>Your whole argument hinges on the fact that the publications are intentionally trying to smear Tesla and their AutoPilot feature. The fact of the matter is that those articles very clearly state that they're quoting what the police say about the crash.

I don't think it has anything to do with smearing Tesla. I think that people have anxiety about self-driving cars and publications know that, so they play to that. This isn’t about Tesla, or AutoPilot. It’s about getting the details right.

If these publications are claiming to quote the police, they're doing a shitty job of it, because the police said only that there wasn't anyone in the driver's seat at the time of the crash. The police didn't comment on auto pilot, didn't comment on the car being "driverless" (which would imply that it never had a driver to start with, which it did. If someone takes their hands of the wheel to stop their kids in the back seat from fighting, does the car become driverless for that moment? If so, where are all the other news stories calling those crashes driverless? Car accidents happen all the time while the car is cruise control. Is that driverless? Why not? It's essentially the same technology that Tesla has for adaptive cruise control).

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by JPKab on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @02:47AM (#27114954)
I'm not going to dig up the article but you should be able to find it very easily:

A writer in the LA times straight up called for federal regulators to step in based off this. I've seen newspapers go full activist before in the past but this was shocking because they were doing so based off of what is obviously a false premise.

It doesn't take long to speak to a few Tesla owners and realize that autopilot even the non-FSD doesn't operate this way.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by myfavoritedog on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:47PM (#27113211)
These days, the cycle with the fake news is long gone by the time anyone knows any facts. The facts arrive too late. The clicks have been clicked. The damage has been done.

The media moves on to its next money-making event. No real repercussions are to be found.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by threeseed on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:29PM (#27113921)
> No real repercussions are to be found

This is simply not true.

Almost every day media around the world are subject to libel lawsuits. Recently, Newsmax and Fox News were sued by Dominion Voting Systems and their employees and Meghan Markle sued Daily Mail for publishing personal letters.

And most of the respectable news organisations still abide by the core tenets of journalism e.g. multiple, vetted sources.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by meragrin on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:48PM (#27114017)
> And most of the respectable news organisations still abide by the core tenets of journalism e.g. multiple, vetted sources.

And which ones are those?

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by adgjlsfhk1 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:14AM (#27114151)
The ones that don't claim that no reasonable person would take them seriously when someone sues them for defamation (Fox has done this multiple times).
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by myfavoritedog on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:15AM (#27117671)
Every opinion host out there uses this defense when the inevitable suit is levied.

https://www.bizpacreview.com/2019/12/28/rachel-maddows-defen...

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by bourgwaletariat on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:01AM (#27114084)
"Respectable news organizations" is a logical fallacy called "no true scotsman."
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by grecy on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:41AM (#27114281)
It would also be great if we got retractions of all the "burned uncontrollably for hours" reports where the firemen "couldn't put it out, and Tesla didn't respond to calls to help".

Turns out, that was all nonsense too:

https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a36189237/tesla-model-s-fi...

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by josefx on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @03:18AM (#27115194)
Seems like its actually worse then what I read. Basically says they would be screwed if they had to deal with a battery fire on a highway.
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by itsoktocry on Monday May 10, 2021 @08:40PM (#27112794)
It was "strongly implied" because no one was in the driver's seat. Now there is evidence there was a driver, after an investigation. Why should they retract anything?
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by SllX on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:16PM (#27113016)
Would be good form after a reactionary piece prior to the results of the NTSB investigation to see the publications that published such pieces take some responsibility for what they publish.

Better form would have been not publishing reactionary articles in the first place.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by prophesi on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:10PM (#27112978)
The actual reason they don't need to retract anything is that the sensational articles already paid off, and they're now off to write another unsubstantiated claim of a headline on something else.
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by NikolaeVarius on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:16PM (#27113014)
Because lying tends to reduce trust.
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by adolph on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:29PM (#27113084)
So you are saying in the absence of evidence they claimed that there was no driver and they have no reason to correct that misinformation?
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by Jordrok on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:37AM (#27114257)
You do realize that it was the police who originally stated that there was no driver?
Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by adolph on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @06:27PM (#27124397)
Why would a serious publication take statements of the police at face value much less as evidence of anything?

> It was "strongly implied" because no one was in the driver's seat. Now there is evidence there was a driver, after an investigation. Why should they retract anything?

A publication which does not retract or correct misinformation is a key part of the problem.

Re:NTSB: Tesla Model S in Crash Couldn't Have Been Using Aut... by justicezyx on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:30PM (#27113094)
Oh, I don't know that AP was invented as a car feature for so long, I mean dozing and drunken drivers must "strongly implied" because no one was driving...