News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by Jyaif on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:27PM (#26975948)
> the game earned more than $700 million from iOS customers over the two years before it was pulled by Apple

I'll save you the math, 30% of $700 million is $210 millions.

$210 millions of pure profit (the bandwidth is essentially free).

It's insanity!

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by yrral on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:59PM (#26976233)
It's a bit more nuanced than that.

Per transaction costs:

They run 15% off sales on itunes gift cards, cc "swipe" charges, costs of credit card fraud (employee costs, management overhead).

Platform costs:

Infrastructure to deal with developers, distribution, tax compliance, refunds, policing local governmental policies, customer service, fraud monitoring, etc etc.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by realityking on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:40AM (#26979472)
This is a good point t I hadn’t considered. The App Store neatly abstracts sales tax/VAT for all markets in which the App Store operates. For a small to mid sized developer that’s a huge boon - especially for those with operations in the EU.

A large player like Epic obviously doesn’t care as they have to built that anyway for their PC store.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by ISL on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:48PM (#26976136)
Surely maintaining first-class hardware, software, and marketplace ecosystems has at least a little associated cost?
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by tapoxi on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:50PM (#26976156)
I mean, they're not exactly giving iPhones out for free
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by NoPicklez on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:05PM (#26976276)
Because earning money that contributes to R&D equates to giving away that technology for free? Surely when a business earns money that is allocated to R&D to enable them to earn more money?
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by croon on Thursday April 29, 2021 @05:41AM (#26979091)
GP suggested that they already get paid for that service, and that they're double dipping. You're simply stating that they should get paid, which they would be in either case.

Apple is charging what they are because they can (obviously). But equally obvious not everyone agrees that they are able to charge this because of product quality, but perhaps due to (partly) market monopoly.

Seeing as it's still in court, and various antitrust discussions, it's definitely not clear cut either way and cases can certainly be made both ways.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by gwd on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:34AM (#26979436)
Is the grocery store "double dipping" because it takes money from you to buy the food, and also takes money from companies to place products in special promotional end-of-aisle displays? Back when people bought physical newspapers, were newspapers "double dipping" because they charged both for the physical print copy, as well as charging companies to place advertisements there? Were Nintendo and Sony "double-dipping" because they charged consumers to buy their consoles, as well as charging cartridge makers for the chip required for the game to actually work?

Is Google "double-dipping" because they're selling you a phone and then using it to advertise to you?

The iPhone has the Apple Tax on apps priced into it already. If they didn't have the revenue from Epic, they'd have to either find sources of revenue (like spying on you to sell you more stuff) or reduce the quality of the software / hardware.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by croon on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:43AM (#26979491)
> Is the grocery store "double dipping" because it takes money from you to buy the food, and also takes money from companies to place products in special promotional end-of-aisle displays? Back when people bought physical newspapers, were newspapers "double dipping" because they charged both for the physical print copy, as well as charging companies to place advertisements there?

No.

> Were Nintendo and Sony "double-dipping" because they charged consumers to buy their consoles, as well as charging cartridge makers for the chip required for the game to actually work?

No.

> Is Google "double-dipping" because they're selling you a phone and then using it to advertise to you?

Yes.

I can go to any other store and get the same food at a price reflecting the competition between them where one gets kick-backs on the backend as well and another doesn't.

With consoles the game makers (non-exclusives) can take it or leave it in regards to specific consoles as long as there is enough of them.

Android and iOS are two separate phone makers (or at least OS in one case), but that isn't enough to sustain market competition on any granularity, so they can make arbitrary choices with regards to charging at all ends and still have a captive market. Consoles would probably be here without PC.

> The iPhone has the Apple Tax on apps priced into it already. If they didn't have the revenue from Epic, they'd have to either find sources of revenue (like spying on you to sell you more stuff) or reduce the quality of the software / hardware.

[citation needed]

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by gwd on Thursday April 29, 2021 @08:30AM (#26980289)
> With consoles the game makers (non-exclusives) can take it or leave it in regards to specific consoles as long as there is enough of them. ...Consoles would probably be here without PC.

Your argument here seems to be something like this: "Game makers have an alternative to all consoles, in the form of PCs. They therefore have a legitimate choice to leave the platform entirely if they found console makers' charges abusive. The fact that they don't is evidence that the charges console makers make to game makers is not abusive; or at least, evidence that no intervention is required."

This thread is specifically about the ~$200M Apple get for Fortnite. In the case of Fortnite, they have at least two alternates to iOS: Consoles and PCs. So Epic certainly does have an option to leave the iOS platform entirely; and thus, by your logic, the fact that Epic chose to make an iOS version of Fortnite anyway is evidence that the "Apple tax" is not abusive -- or at least, evidence that no intervention is required.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by croon on Thursday April 29, 2021 @08:54AM (#26980547)
> The fact that they don't is evidence that the charges console makers make to game makers is not abusive; or at least, evidence that no intervention is required."

No, you have cause and effect backwards. They don't because they can't without losing out on cross-platform games.

Consoles have one job, games. They can capture consumers on exclusives, or being competitive on cross-platform games.

iOS have half (not percent-wise, but provider-wise) of a phone-market, in which games exist.

Gamers can't choose a gaming platform outside of what phone they already have, without switching phones and all the extra second-order effect that has. So much less elasticity there.

But as far as I'm concerned they can look into Sony/Nintendo/Microsoft anti-competitive behavior too, I wouldn't be hard to persuade the effect exists there too, albeit to a lesser extent.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by emsy on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:11PM (#26976320)
For $210 million (that's only Epic's contribution), they could've created a first-class marketplace ecosystem. In reality, it's neither first-class nor worth whatever they're paying to actually run that department.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by naikrovek on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:19PM (#26976380)
people forget how terrible steam was for its first 5 years, when compared to today. now, people are comparing the epic games store of today with the steam we have today, and convincing themselves that it's a fair comparison.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by throwaways885 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:35PM (#26976482)
I think the big difference between is how Epic treats its customers and how Valve treats its customers. Epic could've gone the GOG Galaxy route ("use it, or not, your choice"), but they decided to force people into their watered down launcher before it was ready. Even Xbox is being more open lately.

You can't just match your competition, you have to exceed it in some special way before people will switch.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by ramy_d on Thursday April 29, 2021 @03:11AM (#26978243)
how are they forcing anyone?
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by cdirkx on Thursday April 29, 2021 @07:01AM (#26979595)
There have been multiple instances of games being anounced to release on Steam/others and then some time later Epic signed an exclusive contract with them. This even happens with crowdfunded indie games [1] or games that had already started pre-orders. Even though moves like that are unpopular, Epic said they will remain a core part of their strategy [2].

(True the developers themselves agree to that exclusive contract, so they share some of the blame of disappointing people, but if you're an indie developer it is hard to say no to that much money)

[1] https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2019-07-03-epic-games-wil...

[2] https://www.pcgamer.com/epic-games-boss-defends-exclusivity-...

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by throwaways885 on Friday April 30, 2021 @11:21AM (#26994577)
I own Rocket League on Steam. They bought the game, took it off the Steam store and eventually my operating system entirely, to push their launcher. Not chuffed.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by rcxdude on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:39AM (#26979468)
with exclusives, including making games exclusive which were previously available on other platforms.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by naikrovek on Thursday April 29, 2021 @04:56PM (#26986587)
Epic can't do that alone... it requires cooperation from and agreement with the game publisher.

Don't blame Epic for spending money to bring customers to their product. Epic aren't using shady tactics to do this, and Valve is free to do everything Epic is doing.

Also, as a game buyer, you DEFINITELY want a multi-source purchasing ecosystem; you definitely want to avoid a monopoly if the price you pay for games is important to you.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by rcxdude on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:53AM (#27023219)
Exclusives are explicitly not multi-source. I want to be able to buy the games I want to play on the platform I want to play them on. This isn't always feasible, and that's OK, but it really grates when it's deliberately pushed in that direction.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by ThatMedicIsASpy on Thursday April 29, 2021 @05:51AM (#26979171)
they are trying by buying out publishers to only release it on epic or only release it on epic for the first year.

their client is super garbage. like battlenet if you leave it open it hogs your cpu. the fact that a game can turn the store color into a white client is insane to me.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by naikrovek on Thursday April 29, 2021 @04:58PM (#26986615)
they're free to pay for exclusives, just like Valve is free to pay for exclusives.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by throwaways885 on Friday April 30, 2021 @11:23AM (#26994611)
But Valve doesn't pay for exclusives. They just compete on their overall service. Epic is not making something that is actually better for customers.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by croon on Thursday April 29, 2021 @05:42AM (#26979104)
AFAIK Fortnite is not available on Steam (or elsewhere).
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by naikrovek on Thursday April 29, 2021 @04:57PM (#26986604)
Team Fortress 2 isn't available on the Epic Games Store (or elsewhere).

Epic aren't doing anything shady, here.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by croon on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:46AM (#26990790)
You're not making the counter-argument you think.

GGGP:

> I think the big difference between is how Epic treats its customers and how Valve treats its customers. Epic could've gone the GOG Galaxy route ("use it, or not, your choice"), but they decided to force people into their watered down launcher before it was ready. Even Xbox is being more open lately.

> You can't just match your competition, you have to exceed it in some special way before people will switch.

GGP:

> how are they forcing anyone?

I answered that question. That Steam is also doing it is whataboutism, but also entirely besides the point. Steam however is a much more full-featured client, which also factored into GGGP's argument.

But a more pointed answer to GGP would've been that Epic has paid external developers for (timed) exclusives.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by Xplune13 on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:33AM (#26979426)
It is a fair comparison in my opinion. Steam came into the market when it was one of the first ones to establish digital gaming scene. Now the situation is different, we have many launchers and with that knowledge of what things worked in older launchers (eg. steam, origin etc.) they could've easily pulled a better launcher. The amount of basic things missing from EGS is ridiculous (compared to other launchers that are available right now). At this point, it is a free game generator. Now that doesn't mean EGS can't fail or anything but they aren't even showing any interest in upgrading their platform whatsoever and for that they don't deserve anyone's attention in my opinion.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by FearlessNebula on Thursday April 29, 2021 @08:10AM (#26980129)
Does EGS even have a shopping cart yet lol
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by Xplune13 on Thursday April 29, 2021 @11:14AM (#26982231)
No it doesn't AFAIK. Last checked - don't even know when I logged in.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by emsy on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @10:06PM (#26976671)
I‘m talking about the AppStore!
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by paulmd on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:23PM (#26976415)
"apple bad"

counterpoint: no, it's fine, and it's actually better than the google play store, far less random trash and far less malicious apps/rootkits being distributed.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by emsy on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @10:08PM (#26976683)
I don‘t even disagree it’s better. But the AppStore is still an embarrassment for the money it brings in. I guess comfort does make complacent.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:00PM (#26976952)
In terms of marginal cost, there is essentially zero. The charge for this service bears no relationship to the cost to deliver it. That's why the app store is so enormously profitable, and it serves as de facto (to me) evidence of market power.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by MeinBlutIstBlau on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:56PM (#26976206)
No way it has 210 million dollars of cost and r&d. It's just a software center.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by arsome on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:15PM (#26976354)
And a kind of crappy one at that, you still can't even read reviews on a desktop browser last I checked.

EDIT: Looks like they're finally in the process of changing this in a "Preview" version now.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by jankyxenon on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:58PM (#26976224)
You gotta amortize that cost over all iphone revenue streams (not just one app)
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by paulmd on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:28PM (#26976430)
seems like there's an implication here that apple should be running the app store as a charity or at least at-cost.

that's always such a weird one with this site's libertarian/pro-business bent. it's good to make a successful business and make money... no not like that!

there is nothing stopping anyone from setting up their own competing ecosystem (another walled garden, even). Google did exactly that, featurephones still exist, etc. There are legitimate end-user reasons for doing it this way (namely, facebook and others would immediately start their own app stores to end-run around app review so they could exploit permissions and exploit user privacy for profit, just as they already got caught doing).

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/01/facebook-and-google-...

People are mad because they don't like Apple's business model, which doesn't involve them, so they want Apple to be forced to do business with them on their own terms. Very anti-libertarian, which is again ironic but not out of character for libertarians. Bioshock was right, libertarians are pro-freedom of business right up until someone else has a bigger business.

This is very much in the range of Apple's freedom of business. Go make your own software ecosystem and you can do whatever you want with your app store. Again, just like Google did.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by josephg on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:58PM (#26976621)
I don't think anyone here has any problem with Apple and Google (and others) competing on who can make the best phone.

The problem is that you need to compete in the market of smartphones to be able to compete in the market of app stores. Its quite similar to Microsoft pushing Internet Explorer with Windows a few decades ago - Microsoft was using a competitive advantage in one arena (operating systems) as leverage to gain a monopoly position in another arena (web browsers). The effect of that business strategy is it raises the cost of competition. Competitors now need to compete in both markets (OSes and browsers / phones and app stores). The expense of doing that knocks out almost all your competitors.

All else being equal, less competition is bad for innovation and bad for consumers.

Having both Steam and the Epic games store on windows is inconvenient, but both stores are forced to compete with each other on price and features to retain customers. In the long run this is means cheaper games and better platforms.

This is obvious in the smartphone market too - the iPhone forced Android to become a way better operating system to compete. (Early versions of android were awful.) And Android in turn innovated on notifications and widgets and lots of other stuff, which forced the iPhone to raise its game. There's no competition for the app stores - and predictably the iphone app store is fine, but it hasn't improved much in years.

Epic makes video games. They want to compete with the app store without competing with the iPhone. Whether you agree with them or not, I think they certainly have a case and deserve their day in court to argue it.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by paulmd on Thursday April 29, 2021 @12:07PM (#26982944)
Let me put it this way - Microsoft signed on to the suit too, but how many competing app stores does Microsoft allow on the Xbox?

They have their own twisted logic on why Apple should have to open up and they shouldn't, but none of these companies are doing it for the morals, they want to use the courts to lever open Apple's bank vault and will then immediately turn around and argue why those rules shouldn't apply to them. They also don't really care about the impact it will have on end-users w/r/t large apps immediately starting their own "app stores" to bypass app review and start exploiting user data.

Apple's an easy target because Apple as a corporation is far more unpopular than, say, Microsoft or Sony, but these other companies use the exact same business model, and when it comes down to it they will cite the exact same reasons. "Oh we wouldn't want malware, sexual content, or malicious software to take root on the Xbox" and so on.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by josephg on Thursday April 29, 2021 @03:31PM (#26985530)
I hear what you’re saying, but the business model is different on the Xbox and PlayStation. On those consoles the devices themselves are sold at a loss with the expectation that the user will buy at least a few games. That’s not true of the iPhone - you bought the thing. What you do with it should arguably not be up to Apple any more.

Maybe a better example would be the Nintendo switch - and I’m sympathetic to the idea that I should be able to install and run whatever software I want on my device. I wish I could install Netflix, but I can’t and that’s really annoying.

I hear you about big companies forcing you into their app stores so they can exploit your user data. That’s a real worry; and I’m not sure what the right approach is there. Does this happen on android, where you can enter dev mode and install other app stores? I love that aspect of the iPhone - although I also wish I could have sexual content on my phone without Apple judging me for it.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by paulmd on Saturday May 01, 2021 @05:35AM (#27004792)
This is all a far cry from grandparent's "it should be illegal to operate on a percentage-of-gross-revenue business model, only fixed prices". Why do you think it should be legal for clients to sue because they don't like the pricing model?

Apple only controls 13% of the smartphone market. They're not a monopoly here. They're in fact the minority player in the market, significantly so. Monopoly rules only come into play when a monopoly actually exists, and a business exploits that monopoly to their competitive advantage.

Is 13% a monopoly power?

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by josephg on Saturday May 01, 2021 @07:45PM (#27011001)
Apple owns and runs 100% of the iphone app marketplace, enforced digitally. They're charging monopoly rates (30% of any money spent in any app, including things like spotify subscriptions, which make no sense). With a discount to 15% for small apps.

100% is a monopoly power, yes.

The situation itself is nuanced. There are two extreme positions here, and I don't think the right answer belongs to either extreme view. We don't want the government to outlaw innovative business plans. And we don't want large, established companies using anticompetitive tactics to hurt competition and innovation.

But as I understand it, the precedent here is based on the question of "Are smartphone apps the same business / marketplace as phones". For an xbox, I could imagine the courts saying that the product is essentially a games service, competing with other games services (eg the playstation). So thats acceptable. But microsoft bundling IE with windows a few decades ago is different - those are two marketplaces. One for operating systems, and another for web browsers. In that case, its anticompetitive to use OS dominance to unfairly outcompete in the web browser marketplace.

Are phones more like windows, or are phones more like an xbox? I see your point, but personally I think they're more like windows. And the law should treat them as such. Competition is good for users in the short term, and generally good for an industry in the long term too.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by astrange on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @10:53PM (#26976917)
> seems like there's an implication here that apple should be running the app store as a charity or at least at-cost.

Apple actually claimed they did this until recently, right?

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by echelon on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @10:28PM (#26976802)
The App Store is a gravy train of zero innovation and complete imposition against the rest of the world. The government will eventually step in and shut it down.

Before Steve Jobs decided to control everything, most devices and operating systems supported downloading software from 3rd party sources and running it. After all, you owned the device and you licensed the OS to run your tasks and applications.

Jobs was the villain that came up with this robber baron scheme. It's parasitic.

Tightly and artificially control anything that gets put on the devices your company sells? Genius evil.

Next up we're going to be paying for the content we stream on the Internet. Just wait for the next wave of tech land owners. You'll pay more for certain classes of traffic.

Before you rush to defend it, ask yourself if you'd still be happy if Microsoft had won the war and there was no iPhone.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by realityking on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:38AM (#26979459)
> Before Steve Jobs decided to control everything, most devices and operating systems supported downloading software from 3rd party sources and running it.

Game consoles are the canonical counter example. Even consoles without cartridges, never supported software that didn’t pay a cut to the console manufacturer (+ a really expensive dev kit). It’s not some evil genius idea that Jobs just cooked up.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by echelon on Thursday April 29, 2021 @12:18PM (#26983078)
Game consoles aren't personal computers. They're toys.

You have over a dozen platforms to choose from when you want to play Assassin's Creed. You only have two choices for the computing device you use most frequently.

The pocket computer you have is where you do banking, calls, photos, dating, research, social networking. A lot of people spend most of their lives on these computers.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by jbverschoor on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:07AM (#26979287)
Fortnite is selling digital items. PURE PROFIT. How is that not insanity?
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by selfhoster11 on Thursday April 29, 2021 @07:12AM (#26979669)
That too, is insanity. Two negatives don't cancel out, they are both just as insane.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by jbverschoor on Thursday April 29, 2021 @07:56AM (#26980004)
Both insane, case closed ;-)
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by teruakohatu on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:34PM (#26976021)
At $100 million/year of almost pure profit it is almost a business unit of Apple in and of itself.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by ZephyrBlu on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:05PM (#26976275)
Eh, I don't know. I think Apple's profit is in the tens of billions. On that scale, $100M/yr is peanuts.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by Retric on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:44PM (#26976107)
At a minimum their paying over 2% in credit card fees so that’s another 14+ million in expenses.

However, it’s also clear their fixed fees favor independent developers at the cost of major companies. So, finding their actual profit is more complicated than just a fixed percentage of revenue.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by donmcronald on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:55PM (#26976198)
> At a minimum their paying over 2% in credit card fees

I’d be shocked if that were true.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by Retric on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:31PM (#26976455)
While sheer number of transactions lowers fees the likely small transaction size raises them. Best number I saw was consumers averaging 14$ transaction sizes with freemium games, though fortnight may be unusual sub 2% fees seems extremely unlikely.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by cinntaile on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:50PM (#26976154)
Do companies the size of Apple really pay 2%? I'd be surprised if they don't have special, cheaper rates that they contractually agreed upon.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by dangrossman on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:03PM (#26976263)
They probably pay some fixed markup over interchange, e.g. "cost plus" pricing, which means it'll be over 2% for some types of credit cards still. Even Apple is not going to get their processor to take a loss on charging cards. Top rewards cards pay out 2% or more as cash back, so the cost to charge that card is going to be over 2%. Charging a basic checking account debit card, on the other hand, can be as low as 0.05% plus $0.21. For an average card mix, their processing cost averaged over every transaction is probably under 2% however.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by Retric on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:22PM (#26976402)
Even 0.05% + $0.21 >= 2% on any transaction of 14$ or less.

I am not sure of the mix of transactions their dealing with but sub 2% seems unlikely, when freemium games average transaction is ~14$.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by martin_bech on Thursday April 29, 2021 @07:23AM (#26979742)
US Creditcards are crazy...

A completely normal creditcard fee in Denmark is $0.1 + 0.19% Taken from this official slide https://images.ctfassets.net/r8xjjnzwpfxs/3lLnB85SDDj5FTDmzY...

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by cinntaile on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:04AM (#27014523)
I thought the main reason for this is because there are a lot of lucrative cashback regimes in the US? I assume Denmark doesn't have those.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by high_priest on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:54PM (#26976193)
If it wasn't for the predatoric practices with device obsolescence I would disagree.

Apple created the platform that allows this service (Fortnite) to exist and earn it's share of revenue. The fee that is paid is not only for current maintenance and upkeep of the distribution platform (which is their store), but also research, development, security measures and most importantly, it is shared with other departments, giving us the Apple M1 chips in return!

Much worse offender is Valve and Steam, where they don't really have many places to allocate revenue from not only store sales, but also the second-hand market.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by donmcronald on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:02PM (#26976253)
> The fee that is paid is not only for current maintenance and upkeep of the distribution platform (which is their store), but also research, development, security measures

There are lots of updaters for the PC that can run from a web server. You can put the update files on Cloudflare or AWS for redundant, highly scalable distribution. The infrastructure is worth basically $0 and there is nothing complex about an updater, especially for a company that already integrates payment processing on so many other platforms.

Apple makes it sound complex and uses it to justify their toll taking.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by vultour on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:28PM (#26976431)
$0 for a bandwidth heavy service on AWS? Yeah... no.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by donmcronald on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:38PM (#26976500)
I said the infrastructure was worth $0. You need to pay for bandwidth no matter where you host your updates. It’s not free from Apple either. It’s just dwarfed by the App Store toll and isn’t split out as an individual cost.

What kind of bandwidth cost do you think there will be for something like an in app purchase of 100 vbucks? It’s $0.0000005 if you do it in a Cloudflare Worker.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by 8note on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:00PM (#26976236)
You can say the same about TSMC though, yet they don't extort a tax for every transaction done on a chip they manufactured.

Apple handles the second hand market by not allowing one, don't they? I can't give an app I've bought to my friend

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by eganist on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:00PM (#26976244)
> The fee that is paid is [...] shared with other departments, giving us the Apple M1 chips in return!

Do you have a source on the claim that profits from the app store explicitly funded development of the m1 chip? That's an interesting claim, and it implies that Apple's hardware division alone is in the red and can't sustain its own r&d.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by astrange on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @10:55PM (#26976923)
Apple officially only has one P&L.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by stock_toaster on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:55PM (#26976195)
And how does that compare to Sony or Microsoft in this case?
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by guidedlight on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:08PM (#26976300)
Exactly. Sony and Microsoft likely take similar 30% cuts. I suspect that contracts with those companies forbid disclosure of that information, which is why Apple is the scapegoat here.
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by tedunangst on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:06PM (#26976282)
How much profit did Epic make on their $490 million cut?
Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by croon on Thursday April 29, 2021 @05:53AM (#26979185)
You mean on their product over every other product on the appstore?

Compared to the appstore over.... nothing else on that platform.

One is profit from a product, one is profit from capture.

Re:Fortnite’s cash cow is Playstation, not iOS, court docume... by azinman2 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:02PM (#26976257)
And how much do agents make representing talent? Or middle men make to distribute liquor?

You’re ignoring the entire history of distribution companies for software (especially games!) and their historical charges. 30% (1st year only then drops to 15%) is way less than the historical price. The fact that the product experience is so good and seem less makes it SEEM like it should be free, but you’re ignoring the entire history and all the work done to get to this point.