News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by dqpb on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:05PM (#26921198)
> it is immoral to create something sentient which has not been created by natural processes

I disagree on two parts:

1. I think it’s immoral to oppose the creation of sentient beings.

2. If we create sentient beings, those beings will have been created by a natural process, because we (and our actions) are natural processes.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by deertick1 on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:18PM (#26921288)
Interesting points. Personally, not sure I agree with 1. Lots of scenarios where creating a sentient being would be bad - like if that being can only experience endless pain.

On point 2 : well you got me there. Let me be more precise : its not the "natural processes" part that is important, but my point was rather that this type of hybridizing results in the creation of organisms which have not been time tested and weathered the refining pressures of evolution. We have no gaurantees of the probabability of a successful organism - could be, as I said, some fucked up abomination which only exists to plead for death. Quite tragic in my view if this is the outcome.

I just think we'd better not even go there.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by maroonblazer on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:39PM (#26921443)
> We have no gaurantees of the probabability of a successful organism - could be, as I said, some fucked up abomination which only exists to plead for death.

Although I think this is unlikely, let's accept it as true for the sake of argument.

Eventually I think it's fair to presume we'd come to understand which variations of the process produce your 'abomination' and solve that problem, such that we go on to produce many, many more organisms that don't suffer this same experience.

Would this not be a better outcome than 'not even going there'?

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by deertick1 on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:51PM (#26921520)
Personally, I think it would not be a better outcome, no.

What would be the point of creating new species? Sow more division and war and violence. I just dont see it turning out well. Inherently humans would be the "creators" of the other species. Sounds like a recipe for some horrible problems with speciesm.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by maroonblazer on Saturday April 24, 2021 @09:57AM (#26924860)
> What would be the point of creating new species?

I've not given it a lot of thought but off the top of my head:

Imagine a monkey or ape that possesses above-average (for an ape) intelligence that could be a home-health assistant, taking care of an elderly person who wishes to maintain some independence and not move into a nursing home. Or a disabled adult who needs special care throughout the day.

Speciesism seems a remote risk when you consider the fact that our moral circle of concern has only widened across history.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by catlifeonmars on Saturday April 24, 2021 @04:22AM (#26923257)
Just to be clear about what evolution optimizes for: It’s propagation of genetic information.

Evolution is not kind. And evolution doesn’t optimize for happiness or even health beyond reproductive.

Evolution has produced plenty of humans who plead for death. We treat it as a disorder and try to fix it.

I’m wholeheartedly on board with (1) not creating more suffering and (2) reducing suffering. However I’m not convinced that evolution does better on either of those two fronts than empathetic humans.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by dqpb on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:30PM (#26921381)
Both of your objections are true for natural evolution.

> “time tested and weathered the refining pressures of evolution”

Those refining pressures are not kind or gentle.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by deertick1 on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:49PM (#26921511)
Sure, but we can't stop those processes.

We can stop ourselves from being unkind, though

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by jerry1979 on Friday April 23, 2021 @11:00PM (#26921889)
For the purposes of moral evaluation, why would you say that our actions fall into the "natural process" bucket? I would place our actions in the "unnatural process" bucket because our actions involve unnatural language which comes from a combination of intention, objectivity, and abstraction.
Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by deertick1 on Friday April 23, 2021 @11:06PM (#26921917)
What is unnatural about the behaviour of humans. From a purely deterministic point of view, I totally see his point honestly.

Ive often thought that the dichitomy between human action and natural processes is a false one.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by jerry1979 on Friday April 23, 2021 @11:25PM (#26921992)
> What is unnatural about the behaviour of humans.

If we define "natural" to mean "things that happen", then sure, I would see no difference between natural things and human things. But we use the word "natural" to separate some of our actions from the actions of animals.

I think we could come up with a list of things that people do that animals don't do. Looking at actions from the standpoint of culpability, intentionality, objectivity, language, and planning might shed some light on what actions we would consider "natural". For example, feeling attracted to another person would fall under the "natural" category because we would not consider ourselves "culpable" or "use intention" for such an action. Another example: desire paths made by humans in the grass would probably fall under the "natural" category because people do not plan the paths with language or use objectivity to create the paths. We simply walk "mindlessly" and the paths spring up from under our feet. Another example: asking a stranger for directions would fall under the category of "unnatural" because we need to use language and an objective view of the world around us to engage with another person to share information.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by 0_gravitas on Saturday April 24, 2021 @12:43AM (#26922296)
Stealing from another response:

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/natural only one sub-item of these fifteen definitions of "natural" mentions a difference between human vs non-human.

Lets look at the definition for nature: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nature

Definition 2b is succint: "an inner force (such as instinct, appetite, desire) or the sum of such forces in an individual"

According to this, of course, something like murder is quite natural. Is the stranger giving you directions not following that "nature" within which makes him help you for nothing in return? Is your request for help not a natural thing?

Ultimately, I don't like arguments about definitions, because I think they're a cheap way out: "x is (not) bad because its y"; they also force discussions about all the wrong things, ignoring the core of what both parties care about regarding the issue.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by jerry1979 on Saturday April 24, 2021 @09:55AM (#26924850)
In my previous post I mentioned that I want to separate human actions from animal actions, and that we can actually do that using some sort of test. We have used the word "natural" and "unnatural" to talk about this difference, but I also used lots of other words.

I want to find what essential quality separates people actions from animal actions. It seems to me that all unnatural things got "affected by human discernment". Using that rubric, I find it interesting that all of the definitions of "natural" you provided fall into those categories of either "fundamentally affected" or "not affected" by human discernment where things left in their base state we call "natural" and things left in their affected state we call "unnatural".

Examples:

1. Natural justice - that humans have a kind of justice beyond what nature provide which also implies that humans have sussed out the various justices allotted by nature.

3. Adopted vs natural child - human convention creates long-lasting parent-child relationships without a birth connection.

10. Growing without human care

13. (a) Closely resembling an original, (b) freedom from artificiality -- both of which require a human to create the artificiality.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by throwanem on Saturday April 24, 2021 @05:56AM (#26923690)
Bee and wasp foragers give each other directions to food sources every day - not usually by pheromonic recruitment, although a few species including V. mandarinia do use that method, but by communicating. As far as we know, they don't have symbolic language or anything like the same level of abstraction we do, which is reasonable when our brains outsize theirs by eight orders of magnitude, but that doesn't stop them telling each other what they need to know. And that's just hymenopterans; we should also talk about corvids, who are well known to pass knowledge across populations and generations, and also to possess tool use and theory of mind.

The definition of "unnatural" toward which you're extensionally groping here is "things only humans, and no other animals, do". I suspect you are going to find it a considerably narrower category than you presently appear to imagine. I also don't think it is going to lead you anywhere useful; many anarchoprimitivists have trodden this ground before you, and if nothing else it may be worth familiarizing yourself with some of their work lest you find yourself in one of the same pitfalls they so often do.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by jerry1979 on Saturday April 24, 2021 @10:20AM (#26925002)
Human language and animal language also differ in that people use grammars which recurse which shows a sense of abstraction (as you stated) and also objectivity.

Do you see a narrow difference between human output and animal output? Would you consider that difference somehow not "useful"? I think the bird and bee examples do not provide a compelling sense of language in the same way human talking does because animal language appears tightly bounded and human language through its recursive features appears possibly limitless.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by throwanem on Saturday April 24, 2021 @12:04PM (#26925927)
You see a difference of kind where I see one merely of degree, and your confidence in the sufficient extent of knowledge of nonhuman language and communication, to draw such clear delineations as you do, strikes me as unwarranted. It is a relatively recent innovation in modern understanding even to recognize that any animals beyond our own species have language; where come you by this idea that we know enough about how nonhuman language works to even attempt so broad a conclusion? - or, for that matter, even enough about how human language works? Anyone who's ever tried to explain a complex idea to someone and have them comprehend it, or tried to become a polyglot beyond the age of about ten, should have a better sense of our own limitations than you evince here.
Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by em-bee on Friday April 23, 2021 @10:53PM (#26921851)
the common definition of a natural process is one that happens without human intervention.

you are applying a different definition that is problematic. by your definition murder could be considered natural

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by 0_gravitas on Saturday April 24, 2021 @12:12AM (#26922195)
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/natural only one sub-item of these fifteen definitions of natural say "no human intervention".

Lets look at the definition for nature: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nature

Definition 2b is succint: "an inner force (such as instinct, appetite, desire) or the sum of such forces in an individual"

According to this, murder is in fact quite natural.

I don't like arguments about definitions, because they're a cheap way out: "x is (not) bad because its y"; they also force discussions about all the wrong things, ignoring the core of what both parties care about regarding the issue.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by em-bee on Saturday April 24, 2021 @08:37AM (#26924449)
I don't like arguments about definitions

i agree. i do however like to clarify definitions so that we all know what we mean. i am quite happy to continue the discussion with OPs definition of natural, because now that we understand what that definition is we can get back to the actual core of the issue.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by dqpb on Friday April 23, 2021 @11:06PM (#26921915)
Murder is natural. I never said everything natural is good. I merely said that everything is natural.
Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by em-bee on Saturday April 24, 2021 @03:45AM (#26923088)
uhm, bringing up natural as an argument in defense of the creation of sentient beings heavily implies that you consider everything natural as good.

since we obviously agree that murder is not good, and you also agree that not everything natural (by your definition of natural) is good either, using natural in support of your argument no longer works.

this doesn't invalidate your argument. we can still discuss whether creating sentient beings is acceptable or not. just arguing whether it is natural or not does not help us here