EDIT: I am wrong: https://www.optionstaxguy.com/mark-to-market
> A trader must keep detailed records to distinguish the securities held for investment from the securities in the trading business. The securities held for investment must be identified as such in the trader's records on the day he or she acquires them (for example, by holding them in a separate brokerage account).
Edit: all that to say, I agree that it's clickbait.
Under trader rules, you must recognize gains (or losses) at the end of each year, and don't get capital gains rates, but you can offset income with losses all the way to $0, loss carryforward is time limited, but you can also carry back a few years.
I'll keep my tax deferral and long term capital gains rates, thanks; but if I were a frequent trader, it seems like the alternate regime is simpler.
Portfolio of a hundred names. Half went up, half went down. Sell the downs on 31 December and buy back in 1 January (spherical cow). On the off change nothing in your portfolio lost money, congratulations. Also you don’t get this.
It makes no sense.
How does this work for bot trading? Is that considered day trading?
Crypto bots are popular. When you trade cryptocurrency for another crypto, you are taxed on the value at which you sold it in USD, net the amount for which you purchased it in USD.
Would this be done mark-to-market?
I'd imagine a lot of traders thinking they can easily plug in the latest bot into their Binance account are in for a surprise when they see the size of the return they have to file.
I'm only talking about the US regulation here.
https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc429
He will need a good CPA to declare which assets were long term investments and which fall under mark-to-market day trading rules, but he won't need to pay $800k.
tl;dr: clickbait (mostly), but do read up on the wash-sale rule if you intend on day trading in order to save yourself an end of year headache.