News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by CivBase on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @08:56PM (#26801706)
I'm just going to repeat a question I posted earlier today on a similar article. Hopefully it will get more compelling answers.

Why should anyone believe they are pursuing a peaceful nuclear energy program when they do things like this? Surely the best way to convince people you are the peaceful victim is to continue to demonstrate peaceful intentions even when others don't reward you for it.

For better or for worse, the JCPOA was abandoned and the accompanying incentives for Iran to limit the scope of its nuclear research disappeared. But that doesn't mean Iran is incentivized to develop nuclear weapons. Continuing to adhere to the guidelines outlined by the JCPOA would help build trust from the rest of the world that Iran really just wanted a peaceful nuclear energy program. Instead, their recent actions only seem to build distrust.

After laying their intentions bare like this, why should anyone trust them with JCPOA 2.0?

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by pradn on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:15PM (#26801843)
I'll turn the tables here:

1) Why should Iran come to the negotiating table if the previous deal was scuttled so quickly? What even makes American treaties reliable any more? To put it another way, why should they even trust any treaty with the West? Why is Iran asked to turn the other cheek, vs America asked to provide concessions for overturning a treaty, or put hard checks on their client state, Israel.

2) If you have more to give up, wouldn't you have a stronger bargaining position? There's not much the West can do at this point in terms of tightening sanctions, and they, with the exception of Israel, have no interest in another long war in the Middle East.

3) Why should Iran not be able to develop a nuclear deterrent? It is surrounded by American bases in Iraq and Afghanistan, has Saudi and the Gulf monarchies against it close by, and is an enemy of Israel, which is known to have dozens to hundreds of nuclear warheads. Clearly, given MAD, launching nuclear weapons offensively is untenable. So, a nuclear deterrent might protect Iran from foreign attack. A deterrent means the US or its client states aren't allowed to unilaterally bomb Iran any more, which is the right they are currently claiming.

I'm simply asking you to consider their view, without considering them irrational or chaotic or evil a priori. Certainly, a great deal of prejudice, jingoistic nationalism, sectarian religiosity, and macho posturing are at play on their end, as well. I can say it's similar on the end of Israel, Saudi Arabia, and the US, as well. A more balanced view, understanding the motivations of all sides, may help arrive at an actual solution to this awful standoff, where innocents bear the brunt.

I sincerely wish all the countries of this region, and across the world, disarmed themselves of nuclear weapons. It's too easy for disaster to occur, accidentally or at will, and we forget that this guillotine is hanging over our head at every second.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by recuter on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:48PM (#26802043)
> has Saudi and the Gulf monarchies against it close by, and is an enemy of Israel

It is a self declared enemy of Israel. There is over a thousand miles and two countries between them. Israel has never threatened Iran and has no interest in attacking it.

As for the Saudis and Gulf monarchies, religious differences and hegemony struggles aside - as far as I know Iran are the sole aggressors supporting proxy wars and attacks in the gulf (they literally regularly blow up Saudi oil refineries). I don't think it is at all threatened by the Saudi and Gulf armies, which are not formidable, and has never been attacked by them.

This is some Scooby Doo villain level inversion. In case it isn't completely clear to you, Iran is an expansionist rising power competing with Turkey for control over the ME and Persian/Arabian gulf over a Shia/Sunni cold-religious-war type background, a centuries old holy war... their beef with the house of Saud is about who should control Mecca, feel free to read up about it.

> A more balanced view, understanding the motivations of all sides, may help arrive at an actual solution to this awful standoff, where innocents bear the brunt.

That would involve some knowledge of the history of the region and basic understanding of the cultures and actors involved.

Start by understanding what an Ayatollah is and why they have been ordering their own citizens to be hanged from construction cranes, disappeared, and tortured, for half a century.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by pradn on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @10:04PM (#26802146)
So the points are are "Iran started the enmity" and "Iran is worse than the other countries." I have a hard time buying either. Wouldn't the nakba be the original source of enmity created by the state of Israel between it and the Muslim nations? In any case, who started it doesn't change the ground geopolitical realties that must be solved for us to achieve a world with active peace.

I am absolutely no defender of the enormous amount of violence that Iran's supply of rebel groups and militias in the region has caused. But I have a hard time ranking these crimes, and their internal oppression vs Israel's apartheid state vs the Saudi's internal oppression and funding of militias and rebel groups vs the US's war in Iraq, where between half a million and a million people died.

It's unclear to me what you mean by the "culture" of Iran? Do you mean their political religiosity? I don't find that a convincing source of differentiation between them and other countries in the region. Israeli Zionism, Saudi Wahabbism, etc.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by recuter on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @10:10PM (#26802198)
The point is Israel is not threatening Iran. The nakba has zilch to do with Iran, prior to the Ayatollahs (and even briefly at the start of their reign) there was no enmity.

And world peace is certainly not the goal of the current Iranian regime. It is borderline willful ignorance to suggest that.

> It's unclear to me what you mean by the "culture" of Iran? Do you mean their political religiosity? I don't find that a convincing source of differentiation between them and other countries in the region. Israeli Zionism, Saudi Wahabbism, etc.

Why flaunt your ignorance?

Certainly without equivocating to whatever your beliefs might be or getting bogged down in metaphysics and moralities or saying one is somehow better than the other, if you want to understand the geopolitics you need to be able to differentiate between them.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by torstenvl on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @10:52PM (#26802411)
> What even makes American [foreign policy] reliable any more? ...Why should Iran not be able to develop a nuclear deterrent?

I strongly oppose Iran developing nuclear weapons, but your logic is unassailable here. Our foreign policy with WMDs has been abysmal. Our leaders fail to take into account one simple truth: You get what you incentivize.

Ghaddafi and Hussein disarmed and ended up dead. Meanwhile Pakistan and North Korea get treated with kid gloves. Given that, why should Iran stop its nuclear program?

The United States should adopt a bipartisan set of criteria for when it will intervene re WMDs and when it won't, and stick to it across administrations. That is the only way to maintain any credibility.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by GavinMcG on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:19PM (#26801872)
Yeah, the parent comment asked about "the best way to convince people you are the peaceful victim," but Iran isn't necessarily (wholly) emphasizing that narrative. They probably don't primarily care about being believed. If convincing people they're a peaceful victim were the strongest position to be in, they'd likely pursue that more seriously.
Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by kelnos on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:30PM (#26801938)
If you look at it from Iran's perspective, why should they be responsible for building trust? They got jerked around by the last administration. Their sworn enemy, Israel, has nuclear capability, and the US and other nuclear powers have military bases within striking range of Iran.

While I personally am in favor of nuclear disarmament and anti-proliferation, it's very easy for me to say that, living in a country with nuclear weapons serving as deterrent. Iran logically wants to own that deterrent as well.

And at its base, even if they don't have immediate plans to enrich to the point where they could have a viable nuclear weapon, it's also a case of showing strength (in the negotiation sense): "we're tired of being jerked around; if you want us to come to the table, you have to see us as strong and take us seriously". I don't think they really care about presenting themselves as the "peaceful victim".

> After laying their intentions bare like this, why should anyone trust [Iran] with JCPOA 2.0?

Given what happened with 1.0, why should Iran trust the US with JCPOA 2.0?

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by jlrubin on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @10:00PM (#26802117)
> Their sworn enemy, Israel, has nuclear capability

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/sworn... Sworn enemies are people who will always hate each other.

Israel has no issue with Iran or Iranians in general, nor are Israel's policies particularly harmful to Iran.

Iran doesn't want a deterrent, they want to commit an act of genocide against Israel and the Jewish people.

Don't make a false equivalence about this.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by adamcstephens on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:42AM (#26806253)
Israel openly brags about attacking Israel enrichment. They’ve clearly said the treaty is unacceptable and will strike at Iran.

Words and actions are different things, and the imbalance of power allows Israel to take more destructive actions. When was the last time Iran struck Israel?

I’m no fan of Iran, but Israel is far from a good actor or peaceful nation.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by jlrubin on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:15AM (#26807351)
Yes, Israel attacks Iranian enrichment. So does the US. Attacking enrichment centers that aim to produce warhead material is acceptable foreign policy, especially against a nation that calls Israel a cancerous tumor needing to be destroyed. These enrichment programs have a singular goal, and it is not clean energy.

When was the last time Iran struck Israel? Is that a joke? April 13th, 2021 Iran struck an Israeli ship. Iran funds and supplies terror groups -- see https://www.state.gov/reports/country-reports-on-terrorism-2.... These groups especially try to kill Israelis via rocket attacks, but also American Civilians (e.g., embassy attack).

Israel is absolutely a peaceful nation, as evidenced by numerous recent peace treaties in the region, but being peaceful does not obligate them to await armed conflict as opposed to taking defensive measure.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by adamcstephens on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:56AM (#26808850)
Ok, you’re right. They’re both hostile countries. They both fund the destruction of others, whether that’s through terrorism or stealing of land.

We should stop selling bombs to everyone in the region, and pull all of our support. If they want to fight each other, let them. As long as the US blindly supports Israel, they will feel empowered to continue not being peaceful. We won’t though, since Israel is the beachhead of the petrodollar into the region. Just like no US president will stop giving weapons to the Saudis.

Israel is like my chihuahua that is only tough when she is on the leash. Let her off the leash and she is much less vicious to other dogs.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by jlrubin on Sunday April 18, 2021 @11:31PM (#26858891)
It sounds like your gripe is more with the American system than with Israel.

For what it's worth, Israel may be a chihuahua, but the reason that a chihuahua holds it's own with the big dogs is because the chihuahua has more at stake in a confrontation. Israel is a Nuclear power, and that's not by America's influence. So the notion that Israel is only tough because of American force is patently false.

Further, the notion that Israel stole land (from who? the Iranians?) and that's the source of the aggression is absurd. Hint -- Iran doesn't recognize Israel's title to any land in the region, let alone contested territory. Iran and Israel further used to have friendly relations with Iran pre revolution. Why the policy change then, and not earlier?

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by adamcstephens on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:11PM (#26892462)
Israel steals land from the Palestinians. The entire creation of the state of Israel was the taking of land from the Palestinians and giving it to Israel, which continues today through the illegal settlements in Palestinian territory.
Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by COGlory on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:43PM (#26802016)
The real question is, why do they have to have a sworn enemy? Its not like israel is going to invade them.
Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by recuter on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:52PM (#26802069)
It never ceases to amaze me just how short memories are in the west.

Edit: The only enemy Iran ever had in the ME was Iraq, the decade long war between them was the stuff of nightmares. They sent tens of thousands of child soldiers into trench war fare, to be gassed by Saddam, and run over mines.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran–Iraq_War

You might be shocked at just how few Iranian citizens consider Israel to be an enemy.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by stunt on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:41AM (#26805692)
> The only enemy Iran ever had in the ME was Iraq

That's false.

Iran was neutral on both WWI and WWII, and yet it was invaded multiple time because their natural resources were needed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo-Soviet_invasion_of_Iran

Both the US and the UK have manipulated power in Iran in the past multiple times. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta...

Even the Ayatollahs themselves are in power now because we thought regime change is necessary in Iran, hence we did aid their revolution.

Saddam Hussein had direct support from the west for the Iraq invasion of Iran. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran–Iraq_War

And there are just so many other incidents in between that explains why their relationship with the west is so f...up and the most recent one is JCPOA and the killing of their general and scientists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Air_Flight_655

Of course they will focus on their defense capabilities and military strength knowing that their entire history was manipulated by others. What gives them a reason to trust anyone now?

> You might be shocked at just how few Iranian citizens consider Israel to be an enemy.

Yes, I read they were ally until the revolution in Iran. I think Israel is the enemy Iran needs to increase their political influence in the region. The same way the Iran is the enemy that the US needs to sell arms in the Middle East. The rest is BS.

Iranians are living a misery between a regime that doesn't give them freedom, and sanctions that don't allow them to live. All because we have God knows how much arms sell in the Middle East, and we want to control oil. It's all sad.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by adamcstephens on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:29AM (#26806144)
Very shocking that the pro-US dictatorship installed by US efforts to overthrow the democratically elected government in Iran was friendly with Israel. And that the inevitable blowback that replaced the dictator left the region with a county distrusting and hostile to the West and Israel. It’s almost like actions have consequences.

People in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones. Unfortunately, imperial hubris blinds people to their own state and its actions.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by recuter on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:58AM (#26808032)
Iran never had democracy. Soviets were in the picture as well. It's almost like the US is not omnipotent and there is more than one actor.

Historically, ordinary Persian citizens, regardless of regime, were perfectly fine with both Jews in general and Israel in particular. At worst they didn't care, why should they, the two places are very far apart.

Little spoken about in western press even the Ayatollahs initially were not hostile to Israel, as their interests aligned. That's how realpolitik works.

This changed and they made the calculation like any number of colorful despots and dictators in the ME and further afield to distract their populations from their failures with an external foe.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by adamcstephens on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:50AM (#26808754)
> The 1953 Iranian coup d'état, known in Iran as the 28 Mordad coup d'état (Persian: کودتای ۲۸ مرداد‎), was the overthrow of the democratically elected Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh in favour of strengthening the monarchical rule of the Shah, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi on 19 August 1953.

Just because the US, at the behest of the British, helped orchestrate a coup to reinstall a dictator, doesn’t mean they never had democracy. It’s just that said democracy wanted to profit off the oil in their own land, instead of letting the British continue their imperial theft.

The inevitable blowback from such a cravenly selfish act, means that we get the world the US created.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27état

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by recuter on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:54AM (#26807951)
Really, you're going back to WWII and the Anglo-Soviet invasion? Why not go back to the 19th and The Great Game? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Game

> Both the US and the UK have manipulated power in Iran in the past multiple times. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta...

I'll tell you a secret; it wasn't just the US and the UK but several other powers. And not just in Iran but all over the world. There was this little thing called the Cold War as a backdrop, from your own link:

"The British soldiers withdrew from Iran after the end of the war. However, under Stalin, the Soviet Union partly remained by sponsoring two "People's Democratic Republics" within Iran's borders."

> Even the Ayatollahs themselves are in power now because we thought regime change is necessary in Iran, hence we did aid their revolution.

So? What do you imagine this magical aid was? There was quite a lot going on in that part of the world at the time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1973_oil_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_Iranian_hostag...

I don't know who we is supposed to be, but if you mean the US, certainly it had interests and influence it tried to wield. Very unsuccessfully. Quite an interesting unsavory story to be sure, but scratch beneath the surface and you'll find a quite complicated one as well - it isn't black and white at all.

Iran never had democracy, it is cursed with oil as you point out and geography plays a role as well, as does religion, welcome to how the world actually works.

However Iran ended up with Ayatollahs, one could only ever so gently suggest that perhaps Iranians themselves had some agency and responsibility in this matter, or how North Korea ended up with the Kim dynasty - hardly a reason to be an apologist for these dangerous repressive regimes.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by fatbird on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:09AM (#26808183)
One is not an apologist for a repressive regime when one dispassionately analyzes the realpolitik of their circumstances. It's not a defense of the Ayatollahs to observe that, from the perspective of the Iranian gov't., the U.S. (among many others) has continuously been a hostile power since at least WW2, and it's silly to place expectations on them as a negotiating partner as if that weren't the case.
Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by recuter on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:27AM (#26808424)
One is an apologist for a repressive regime when one knowingly or unknowingly repeats their exaggerated talking points.

They are very adapt at exploiting western sensibilities. Their realpolitik is to stay in power at all costs and export terror to deflect from internal instability.

The US has attained energy independence and has been leaving the region.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/13/us/politics/biden-afghani...

Turkey, China, Russia, and now Iran will divvy up the spoils. Iran is an expansionist rising power vying for hegemony in the region and a repressive authoritarian religious dictatorship, it is silly to take their negotiations in good faith as if that weren't the case - whatever historical excuse they might try and shame you with.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by fatbird on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:02PM (#26808948)
Yes, they're an expansionist rising power and a repressive authoritarian religious dictatorship. So what? No one at the State Dep't thinks otherwise, or is shamed by Iranian propaganda, except insofar as that propaganda is effective PR that the U.S. has to counter--and PR is where the U.S. history is relevent and problematic, and where a clear-headed appraisal of the circumstances is necessary.

When you're playing chess, you're not being an apologist for the other player by imagining their best move.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by trhway on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:30PM (#26801941)
>Surely the best way to convince people you are the peaceful victim

i'm not sure that convincing people of that would play well for domestic standing of an authoritarian regime. Even if there were no threat to the current Iranian regime from outside (which i suspect is a big if), a populist government, especially an authoritarian one, to stay in power has to play a strong national identity theme. So, one way or another, each step is making them closer to the bomb - only regime change from inside as the result of some rose/orange revolution may stop it, and it doesn't seem that there is any chance of it in the near decade or two (so delaying their progress until such a time is probably the best strategy, and that is what Obama's agreement was doing - delaying, not stopping/preventing, and the voting public's non-understanding of that approach is what tanked it as GOP were technically right in their attack of the agreement that it doesn't prevent the bomb in some decades down the road). Any bold external action i think would only fuel internal nationalist forces and thus would play into the regime hand.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by gizmo686 on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:50PM (#26802058)
Iran doesn't want the world to believe it's nuclear ambitions are peaceful. The threat of (and actual) progress towards a nuclear weapon is their negotiating power.

Iran doesn't need to build "trust" with the rest of the world. (Almost) everyone agrees that they were followed through on their commitments. What Iran needs is to maintain credability. Without that, the international community would walk all over them. Iran offered to keep following the JCPOA even after the US so blatantly voided it. They just needed the rest of the world to make up the difference. When this didn't happen (again, because the US flexed its muscles to make it not happen) Iran had no way to maintain credability without resuming their nuclear program.

In more concrete terms, Iran would still need to negotiate another treaty, only this time they would need to make additional consessions. A few years later, the rest of the worlds backs out of the new treaty and forces Iran to make another set of concessions.

> After laying their intentions bare like this, why should anyone trust them with JCPOA 2.0?

Because they complied with JCPOA 1.0. And JCPOA 2.0 would likely include monitoring. And we can reimpose sanctions quickly if Iran is found to be in violation. On the other hand, leaders in Iran would need to answer the same questions; only they will be faced with much worse answers. Their counter parties did not follow through on JCPOA 1.0. And rebuilding a nuclear program takes longer than reimposing sanctions.

It is easy to get stuck in the mindset that we are the only players. But geopolitics is a game; and our enemies get to make moves too.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by fatbird on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:50PM (#26802056)
Because treaties like JCPOA aren't based on trust, they're based on verification. Trust, in the sense you're describing it (the way a person might trust another based on their past behaviour) doesn't really exist between nation states.

And Iran is very incentivized to develop nuclear weapons. North Korea's bargaining position wrt to the U.S. improved immensely once they demonstrate a nuclear weapon; Pakistan and India have both enjoyed much less superpower pressure because they also have nukes. And more immediately, Israel has nukes and are Iran's primary regional rival. Israel has been a dominant regional entity largely because of it's military superiority over everyone else, which includes its nukes. Iran obtaining nukes is a potent counterweight to Israel's perceived freedom of military action.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by banannaise on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @09:53AM (#26807072)
> Surely the best way to convince people you are the peaceful victim is to continue to demonstrate peaceful intentions even when others don't reward you for it.

This is the international relations version of asking protestors to just show up unarmored and let police beat the shit out of them.

It is entirely ineffective in both cases for the same reason: there is an American news empire that centers the state's narrative. The state will attack, and will spin the resulting images of destruction as entirely provoked by the victim.

(Given that everyone knows that's what will happen, you might as well get what you paid for and show up ready for violence. That's what Iran is doing.)

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by websites2323 on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @10:27PM (#26802284)
US goal: Nuclear containment in Central Asia that threaten Israel. Iran goal: reversal of sanctions that cripple the economy.

US has no incentive to lift sanctions if Iran complies with sanctions in place. In a world where a bankrupt Iran abandons enrichment, Israel is not threatened.

Re:Iran Says It Will Enrich Uranium to 60% by dicomdan on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @09:00PM (#26801735)
It’s a fundamentalist regime, they are developing nuclear weapons and are open about it.