News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by foolinaround on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @06:39PM (#26800346)
In Jan, there was a big outcry, i thought all would move to signal. I have about 25% of the conversations in signal, but especially for groups, whatsapp is so sticky, that they seem to have broadly failed in signal, and are back to whatsapp.

I continue to have individual conversations on signal with most friends, but the idea of being able to leave whatsapp seems to be much tougher than I thought.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by ryandrake on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @07:56PM (#26801242)
The way I see it, you can choose to be part of the problem or not. And with a product that gets stronger the more people use it, then using it is part of the problem. You can’t complain about how So-And-So company’s products are bad, but then say “but I can’t bear to stop using em!”

I cut all of FB and their ecosystem out of my life years ago. Can’t say this one person out of billions has had an effect on the company but at least I can honestly say I’m not even a tiny part of the problem.

I don't proselytize to normal people anymore because most just aren't receptive to the message. It's like an addiction. Even when they agree with me, everyone has their little excuses as to why they can't possibly quit. And at the end of the day your one-one-billionth share of the problem amounts to peanuts, anyway.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by chii on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @11:18PM (#26802561)
> “but I can’t bear to stop using em!”

well, it requires sacrifice on your part to stop messaging your friends. Most people would not give up their friends for "the greater good" of stopping privacy intrusion (which won't have an effect until the majority of people give up whatsapp first).

I can see why most people won't fight the good fight.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by emptysongglass on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @09:48AM (#26807005)
Your really good friends won't stop messaging you just because you've left Facebook.

If anything, leaving Facebook was a wake-up call as to who my very good friends were.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by patch_cable on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:59AM (#26808904)
“Really good friends” aren’t the only friends worth staying in touch with.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by emptysongglass on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:40PM (#26809543)
My life is rich in social engagements and I don't need Facebook to do it. And now that I'm off Facebook, the friendships I do have have grown immeasurably in closeness. My overall stress has plummeted.

I strongly believe that platforms like Facebook and Twitter are extremely harmful to social cohesion and mental health.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by chii on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:46PM (#26814549)
> My life is rich in social engagements

i don't care what or how your life is - this discussion is about the general case. Not everyone has a rich social life, and these messaging apps/services do help people engage with others which would otherwise have not.

And to change can be disruptive - casually dismissing these concerns is not the way to solve the problem connected with these platforms.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by emptysongglass on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:46AM (#26816891)
> i don't care what or how your life is

Please try and be a little kinder.

I'm not dismissing these concerns. The social harms of these platforms far outweigh whatever gains are wrung from them. They are a net negative to society and to public discourse, full stop. The longer we defend the legitimate reasons people have to stay netizens of these platforms, the darker their shadow weighs over our consciousness.

My country has a former prime minister on Facebook's oversight board because everyone here uses Facebook. That's not in anyone's interest but Facebook's because now it's convinced us that it can be brought to heel, as if it was Facebook, the company, that was the problem.

That's a treacherous misdiagnosis: the issue is the platform itself. It must be dismantled if society is going to heal from the psychic traumas unknowingly and knowingly caused by our participation.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by judge2020 on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @08:26PM (#26801477)
I think your over-generalization in the first paragraph doesn’t work for most situations. This can apply to a small messaging app in which there are many alternatives, but you can surely participate in something while still pointing out its flaws. https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by bla3 on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @06:55PM (#26800525)
If we're doing anecdata: All my contacts are on Signal now. I uninstalled WhatsApp back in Jan.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by sneak on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @08:55PM (#26801695)
They're back on WhatsApp because you and others still have an account there.

The migration to Signal has two parts: start using Signal, and delete your Facebook accounts.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by Vinnl on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:38AM (#26804830)
It works the other way around too though! Create Signal equivalents for your WhatsApp groups, add the subset of the WhatApp members that also have Signal, and then if you have something fun to share, do so in the Signal group. That way you're meeting people where they are, while simultaneously using an app you can get behind as well, leaving it to others (and their FOMO) to meet you where you are.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @07:11PM (#26800679)
And Signal saw that movement, and decided instead of focusing all their development effort in making sure the user experience for all these new users was top notch and developing in the open, instead to push a cryptocoin that no one has heard of before but one which their principals likely have a stash of.

Given Signal's behavior, I am not going to waste any friendship capital trying to convince my friends to switch to Signal.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by hjek on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @08:36PM (#26801554)
WhatsApp have been focusing on payments lately[0] so it only makes sense for Signal to put efforts into that, too.

[0]: https://blog.whatsapp.com/send-payments-in-india-with-whatsa...

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by Aeolun on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @11:20PM (#26802575)
If it’s actual payments, yes. If it’s some weird fully owned cryptocoin, no.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by jimkleiber on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:59AM (#26803098)
Not sure for you, but what makes WhatsApp the stickiest for me out of the chat apps is the statuses (stories). I start many of my conversations on WA by seeing someone's status (story). On Signal, Telegram, or even iMessage, there isn't that nudge to restart the conversation.

I think if those platforms made some story-like feature, I'd have an easier time leaving WhatsApp.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by marton78 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:57AM (#26803438)
That's funny, I don't know anyone who uses that feature.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by jimkleiber on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:46PM (#26809632)
Fascinating! Maybe it depends on the region...I have many friends in East Africa and they seem to use it all the time. This has inspired me to look more closely at which friends actually post and which ones view the statuses. Thanks!
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by josteink on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:28AM (#26806133)
> Not sure for you, but what makes WhatsApp the stickiest for me out of the chat apps is the statuses (stories).

For me it's the other way around.

I've stopped using all platforms which offers that "feature", because I find it distracting and annoying.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by jimkleiber on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:46PM (#26809640)
Haha that makes sense, too. Thanks for sharing your perspective!
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by jcelerier on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:17AM (#26804371)
I have never ever seen anyone around me do a WhatsApp story
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by jimkleiber on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:48PM (#26809670)
As I mentioned in a different comment, maybe it depends on the region, with many of my friends who post being from East Africa. Would you mind sharing in which part of the world are most of your WhatsApp contacts living?
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by jcelerier on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:39PM (#26813450)
France
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by dalbasal on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @08:32PM (#26801519)
>> the idea of being able to leave whatsapp seems to be much tougher than I thought.

Network lock-in is real. I think a lot of people who disconnect from fb also disregard the difficulty. Even if you don't like the barman, your local is wherever your buddies hang out.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by godelski on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @08:50PM (#26801646)
It is difficult but not impossible. Everyone switched from Myspace to Facebook. Thing was the Facebook offered something different. But it did start small. The way you defeat network lock-in is by fighting against it hard. It definitely is not easy. I lost friends when I deleted my Facebook. But truth is, they weren't people I frequently talked to anyways so it is probably better to call them acquaintances. The thing is that I've contacted plenty of those people years after nothing and they are all happy to grab a beer. But we pretend that this isn't the case. We say "Yeah, I'd do that, but they wouldn't." Or something similar.

Though I'll admit, getting people to switch to Signal was a lot of work. People like Elon and Joe Rogan helped onboard a lot of the people that were holding out. One group chat has a member that is only there because everyone else bought in and he complains, but uses it (big WA user).

I don't think people calling for disconnecting are unaware of the difficulties. Ripping off a bandaid hurts, but the thought of ripping it off often is more painful than the actual experience.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by el_dev_hell on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @07:20PM (#26800809)
Throwing in my anecdotal experience.

I noticed something very similar. About 25% of one-on-one conversations are now in Signal. Another 25% are in iMessage, which is a very easy sell for iOS users.

I've had a terrible time with group chats. One large chat is occurring in iMessage (very poor experience). Another large chat is occurring in Discord, which has been fantastic, but it changes the dynamic and caused a few friends to ghost (the onboarding to Discord is harder for newcomers vs. iMessage, WhatsApp or Signal IMO).

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by sneak on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @08:56PM (#26801707)
Discord is not end to end encrypted, and thus should be actively avoided.

It is reasonable to assume that every single chat and every single DM is logged in plaintext by Discord for all time.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by hiq on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:29AM (#26804770)
> I've had a terrible time with group chats.

When was this? There was a migration from groupv1 to groupv2 which could explain it. I've always found it stable personally (including during migration). At any rate, it should be better now that there are less changes.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by Aeolun on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @11:18PM (#26802562)
I have absolutely no issues with Signal group chat? Where did this rainbow puke?
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by dx034 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:01AM (#26804618)
Most of my groups went to Signal. But until they support live location (something I use frequently, albeit less during Corona), I won't uninstall Whatsapp. For all their privacy faults, it's still the app with probably one of the best UX (so easy it's the only app my grandma can use) all features I'd want for a chat app without annoying extras.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by LordAtlas on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @10:43PM (#26802361)
The Signal UX for groups is truly terrible. It looks like a rainbow puked in there. And heaven help you if you use their crappy desktop client. It doesn't sync with your mobile client unless you open the app on your phone, and then syncs everything slowly, which messes up your group chats if you happen to send another message in between.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by lorenzhs on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:34AM (#26805631)
When is the last time you used it? Because I have none of these issues. None. Especially since "It doesn't sync with your mobile client unless you open the app on your phone" is architecturally completely wrong. The desktop client doesn't communicate through your phone. That's how WhatsApp web works, but Signal Desktop doesn't.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by codethief on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @09:40AM (#26806902)
Same here, both Signal groups and Signal desktop work flawlessly for me.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by spurgu on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:55AM (#26822049)
For me it went from 30% FB, 60% Whatsapp, 10% Signal in January to 0% FB, 10% Whatsapp, 90% Signal today. I might get rid of the 10% after May. So it's possible. That said I'm only talking about maybe 15-20 contacts, so small sample size.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by amanzi on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @07:26PM (#26800892)
Similar experience here, except most people who moved to Signal were tech-savvy, while all my family and closest friends have stuck with WhatsApp.

Given Signal's recent changes in direction, I'm considering just giving up on it and sticking with WhatsApp.

Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by pkulak on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @07:31PM (#26800956)
I set up a Matrix server for my family, and then bridged in everyone else I know who uses iMessage. Now at least I'm chatting in a single app.
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by dx034 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:03AM (#26804626)
That means your family can't communicate if your server is down?
Re:WhatsApp's new privacy policy is so bad it might be illegal by pkulak on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:47AM (#26808712)
Yup. Just like how we couldn't communicate for 2 days when Signal's servers went down a few weeks before I made the switch.

The difference with me is that my server has a dozen users and I could rebuild the whole thing from backups on a brand new provider in a couple hours if I needed to. I doubt I'll need to, though. It's not exactly working hard. :D