News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by rsj_hn on Saturday April 10, 2021 @07:30PM (#26766274)
Strange to have non-researchers or non-mathematicians like Lewis Carrol, Ada Lovelace, or Anna Easly included while world-impacting researchers such as Shigefumi Mori, S.T. Yau, Yuri Manin, Stefan Banach, Simon Donaldson, R. Bott, M. Morse, H. Lebesgue, O. Heaviside, J. Leray, J. Tate, E. Calabi, M. Gromov, <strike>G. Perelman</strike>, F. Adams, H. Kunneth, are left out. Where are they getting their lists of people? It seems they classify anyone famous who was "technical" as a mathematician, which is the only reason why I can think of including people like Einstein, Lewis Carroll, or Ada Lovelace (none of whom made any contribution to math) as mathematicians, but leaving out those who made major advances.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by adrian_b on Sunday April 11, 2021 @03:22AM (#26768229)
Charles Lutwidge Dodgson a.k.a. Lewis Carrol was a mathematician and he published enough original mathematical research.

Of course, he is much more famous as a fiction writer than as a mathematician and it can be easily argued that much more important mathematicians (e.g. Grassmann & Clifford and many others) are missing from that timeline, but he certainly cannot be considered as a non-mathematician.

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by apricot on Saturday April 10, 2021 @10:40PM (#26767098)
It looks like they were trying to meet a dual quota of non-white, non-male people.

(Also, Yau is there.)

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by knolax on Sunday April 11, 2021 @03:28AM (#26768267)
Ah yes, famous non-white females Albert Einstein and Lewis Carrol.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by rmak on Sunday April 11, 2021 @03:50AM (#26768381)
Yeah and famous white males Nightingale and Katherine Johnson.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by canjobear on Saturday April 10, 2021 @09:24PM (#26766804)
It’s hard to imagine any finite list like this that doesn’t attract people complaining that their favorite figures were left out.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by xyzzyz on Saturday April 10, 2021 @09:47PM (#26766881)
It’s not so much about who was left out, but rather about who was put in. Some of the people on the list had pretty much zero impact on mathematics.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by justintho on Saturday April 10, 2021 @10:06PM (#26766971)
these figures give context to the average reader
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by monsieurbanana on Saturday April 10, 2021 @10:42PM (#26767114)
As an average reader, I'd rather not be mislead on
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by jzwinck on Saturday April 10, 2021 @08:11PM (#26766515)
Perelman is right there in the opening frame when I look. Maybe you just missed some of those people.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by rsj_hn on Saturday April 10, 2021 @09:09PM (#26766734)
Thanks I did miss Perelman. I don't think I missed others.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by guram11 on Saturday April 10, 2021 @11:39PM (#26767301)
Unfortunately, you did as others have to repeatedly pointed out
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by gaius_baltar on Sunday April 11, 2021 @03:04PM (#26772594)
Some names are complete nonsense: why is Benjamin Banneker there for building a mechanical clock in the 1800s (when such things were already everywhere) while Phillip Hahn (who build a four-operation mechanical calculator) in the 1700s is not?

They added Katherine Johnson who developed no new theories or applications on Math or Computer Science, but left Margaret Hamilton out (and she was the pioneer and creator of an entire new field!)

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by andi999 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:31AM (#26769885)
Personally I believe including Ada is actually a disservice. If I were female I would think wait what? Female accomplishments were so low that with that you already enter the hall of fame? I know the intention is in the other direction, but maybe it's just me overthinking stuff.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by pierrefermat1 on Saturday April 10, 2021 @11:28PM (#26767270)
Absolutely agree with you here, it's effectively positive discrimination and really a rather distasteful attempt at it.

Always bothers me the same happens in Civilization games with scientist lists.

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by rsj_hn on Saturday April 10, 2021 @09:12PM (#26766746)
You're kinda making my point. None of these are actually contributions to mathematical research. A computer program is not mathematical research, nor are field equations in physics. Which is not to say that they are not noteworthy achievements, but it is to say that they are not achievements in mathematics. These three made contributions in other fields. I am not saying they don't deserve fame in the fields of physics or computer science or literature. They certainly do. But they deserve no fame in the field of mathematics, anymore than Morse deserves fame in the field of computer science, or Gromov deserves fame in the field of literature (but he did write books!). The only person in your list of three who could even be called a mathematician was Dodgson, but his contributions are not considered noteworthy enough to make any kind of timeline.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by meiji163 on Saturday April 10, 2021 @09:47PM (#26766882)
I have to disagree on Einstein, without the field equations it's doubtful psuedo-Riemannian geometry or so-called "Einstein manifolds" would be so big in math. There is also his work on Brownian motion and diffusion. Even if you deny he did "mathematical research" his importance for mathematics justifies him being on a timeline of mathematics .. imho
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by rsj_hn on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:06AM (#26768743)
You can argue that Einstein spurred interest in Geometry, but he himself made no contributions to this field. In fact it was pretty famous that he kept bugging Ricci to help him frame his ideas in mathematical terms. Einstein was a physicist through and through, and not even a mathematical physicist. Now someone like Ed Witten is a completely different beast.
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by plurinshael on Sunday April 11, 2021 @02:15AM (#26767871)
Did computer science as a field exist in Lady Ada's time? No, it did not. And where did computing science get its formal beginnings? In mathematics departments.

I guess I just have an inclusionist mindset with these matters. Popularizers, esotericists, eccentrics, early pioneers of new thought-tech, and people in closely associated fields should at least be considered in projects like this. Contributing to mathematics culture seems important to me, not just contributing to mathematics achievements.

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by rsj_hn on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:16AM (#26768809)
> "And where did computing science get its formal beginnings? In mathematics departments."

Citation needed. You might be able to argue that it had its beginning in EE departments, but CS as a field did not spring from math at all. Seriously there is a difference between formalizing something in mathematical language - which happens to almost every technical field - and having that formalization be considered an advancement in math itself. This is exactly my point about throwing everyone "technical" into the mix. After all, the formalization of chemistry requires lots of math, so Marie Curie must be on the list of mathematicians, too!

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by JadeNB on Sunday April 11, 2021 @12:39AM (#26767505)
> Dodgson, but his contributions are not considered noteworthy enough to make any kind of timeline.

By whom? Obviously the poster did. Lots of people think of him in connection with his work in logic, which isn't research-level, but I think of him in the context of, e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodgson_condensation , which to my somewhat amateurish knowledge of the subject was a research-level contribution for its time.

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by perilunar on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:05AM (#26769407)
> None of these are actually contributions to mathematical research

So what? The site is a Timeline of Mathematics, not a Timeline of Mathematical Research. Surely notable new applications of mathematics belong on the timeline, regardless of whether they involved new research or not.

[dead]
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by dang on Sunday April 11, 2021 @12:50AM (#26767553)
Please stop taking HN threads into flamewar.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by User23 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:35AM (#26770262)
I didn't mean to flame, just calling it as I see it. That said your house your rules thank you for the guidance.
[dead]
Re:Timeline of Mathematics by burk96 on Saturday April 10, 2021 @09:27PM (#26766821)
>Einstein is probably the most famous fraud of the 20th century. Strange how many people don’t realize he plagiarized his own wife.

Could you provide a source on this? DDG only shows youtube videos and conspiracy websites when searching.

Re:Timeline of Mathematics by User23 on Saturday April 10, 2021 @10:03PM (#26766956)
Using a query like [Einstein fraud] or whatever is going to get you crap results. Try something like [Mileva Marić] instead to get results from mainstream sources like SA[1]. And obviously those sources aren't going to throw words like "fraud" around, but you don't even have to read between the lines to see my claim is plausible if not entirely justified. It's yet more evidence that women in STEM have been erased by men taking credit for their work.

[1] https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/the-forgotte...