News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by Shenglong on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:05PM (#2663261)
If they succeed, wouldn't it be essentially overturning 17 USC 102(b)? If none of the graphics, code, or names are stolen, wouldn't this fall under a method of operation?
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by sehugg on Thursday June 16, 2011 @10:06PM (#2664045)
Courts have found in the past that copying a game design closely enough is a violation of copyright (http://itlaw.wikia.com/wiki/Atari_v._North_American_Philips) and they've also found the opposite (http://itlaw.wikia.com/wiki/Data_East_USA_v._EPYX).

Also see this discussion on misc.misc, circa 1990, re: the Lotus 123 spreadsheet wars:

  If the plaintiff cannot show that 
  the target customer audience is UNlikely to recognize that the defendant's 
  product is not the same as the plaintiff's then recovery is barred.  Mere 
  similarity between plaintiff's and defendant's products is   not sufficient 
  to support a successful lawsuit.
Zynga may have a case here if they can prove that there was intent to make users think these were Zynga's games.

(i am not a lawyer, i just cut-and-paste from USENET)

Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by hnsmurf on Friday June 17, 2011 @12:04AM (#2664277)
There's a trade dress issue here and I'd guess that's what Zynga's claiming. It seems rather clear that a consumer could confuse this company's products for one of Zynga's and that that is their intent. It's as if you made Cleanex Tissues and then copied the design of a Kleenex box.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by dangrossman on Thursday June 16, 2011 @09:34PM (#2663973)
The graphics are duplicated so closely... are they not derivative works? Only the copyright holder can creative derivative works.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by citricsquid on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:09PM (#2663288)
> and employee benefits

That seems mighty obscure and a weird thing to include.

Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by zatara on Thursday June 16, 2011 @07:44PM (#2663741)
Is the Brazilian detail relevant? Or maybe it is is more difficult to sue Vostu over there.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by lzm on Thursday June 16, 2011 @10:26PM (#2664090)
It isn't even Brazilian.

A comment from the article: "Vostu is an american company founded by former Harvard grads, with development studios in Argentina and targeting the biggest market for social games in LATAM, which is Brazil. JFYI."

Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by meterplech on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:05PM (#2663789)
IANAL: But, I bet Zynga ends up trying to buy them when the lawsuit settles. The huge IP threat certainly devalues the company. And regardless of their copycatting they have a big presence in a massive market that Zynga doesn't have.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by staunch on Thursday June 16, 2011 @07:18PM (#2663684)
/me lights up the grellas bat signal.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by LUTOPiA on Thursday June 16, 2011 @04:56PM (#2663230)
Zynga gets Zynga'd

>XD

Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by thomasgerbe on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:13PM (#2663301)
Yep. Pretty hypocritical of them to be outraged by copy-cats.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by fragsworth on Thursday June 16, 2011 @06:14PM (#2663499)
Well, Zynga did have to settle a lot of lawsuits that other companies brought up. Seems fair to expect the same from other companies.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by hammock on Thursday June 16, 2011 @06:30PM (#2663556)
I never understood why people think just because you are a hypocrite doesn't mean you still aren't entitled to all the rights everyone else is under the law.

It's a sad prospect to suggest that your basic property rights can be taken way for that. Doing one thing and saying another is a part of free speech, IMO.

Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by T_S_ on Thursday June 16, 2011 @06:38PM (#2663572)
The spectators can root for whoever they like as long as the outcome is in doubt. Your scold only applies to the judge.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by mootothemax on Thursday June 16, 2011 @07:43PM (#2663735)
Ideas are a dime a dozen; stealing the execution is another thing altogether.
Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by lwat on Thursday June 16, 2011 @07:50PM (#2663756)
http://www.allfacebook.com/zynga-farmville-2009-06

"If you’ve played Farm Town at any point in the past few months then you won’t need any education about how to use Zynga’s version of the game as it’s almost an exact duplicate."

Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by est on Thursday June 16, 2011 @11:58PM (#2664265)
Fun fact: farming games on Facebook were actually first made by Chinese

http://www.chinasocialgames.com/?p=400

> myFarm was the original farming game on Facebook. We launched Nov 1st 2008

It's a messy chain of copycats.

Re:Zynga Sues The Hell Out Of Brazilian Clone Vostu by hnsmurf on Friday June 17, 2011 @12:06AM (#2664280)
Farm Town was definitely not a copy of myFarm. MyFarm was (and probably still is) far inferior in almost every respect.

Farmville was more or less a clone of Farm Town, though it evolved at a much faster pace.