News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by noobermin on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:11AM (#26579227)
People are focusing on the "liberal software" part but boy is the article full of dismissiveness of the real concerns of people who care about freedom and social justice where it connects with software. "Software vendors won’t usually be inserting spyware into their wares." Are you sure about that? It sounds like someone has been selectively reading the news for the last decade or so, somehow the author skipped the Snowden leaks and if you need something more recent, the controversy around Zoom.

This is a terrible document that is riddled with so many inaccuracies that it doesn't convince anyone other than the uninformed. If anything, the last few years have highlighted the need for Free Software and proved many of the alarmist warnings of advocates were prescient actually and not so alarmist.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by CaptainZapp on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:31AM (#26579408)
A bit further down the road you have Lenovo endangering their customers with the Superfish[1] spyware.

And please don't give me "that was on consumer models only". I really couldn't care less. A company pulling off such dirty shit winds up on my eternal shitlist. No matter how great their "professional" products are.

I'm sure there are countless other examples.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superfish

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:42AM (#26580145)
I'm reminded of Sony's rootkit that was, well, just awful, in every respect - ethically, engineering, etc.

Interesting that the founders of Superfish are both Israeli, I wonder if they both served with the Unit 8200 that was posted on here recently?

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by gluegadget on Thursday March 25, 2021 @12:10PM (#26582020)
But isn't this part of the point the author of the article is trying to make? In case of Superfish it was United States Department of Homeland Security who advised uninstalling it and in case of Sony's rootkit, a class-action lawsuit. In both cases higher authorities hired by people to protect them, protected them. Not FSF, nor the fact that the code wasn't GPL.

Even if Superfish was GPL licensed, the issue would've persisted. As article mentions even laptops coming with Linux pre-installed hardly come with the Kernel and userspace tools source code and you need to download them separately. Should Lenovo have preloaded Superfish as Linux kernel module and shipped it to its consumer laptops, United States Department of Homeland Security would have still advised removing it.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by boomboomsubban on Thursday March 25, 2021 @07:50PM (#26587154)
In both examples, a higher authority may have also acted but if they had done the same with free software things either would have been caught immediately or a lawsuit would have been possible for breach of license if they tried to hide it.

>In both cases higher authorities hired by people to protect them, protected them. Not FSF,

The FSF did a better job of protecting them with their unwavering stance. Neither would ever have caused an issue if you followed their advice to never use non-free software.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by arsome on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:38AM (#26579456)
It's like someone hasn't even picked up a phone in the past decade. Nearly every app on your phone would have been considered spyware or adware just years ago.

Pretty much the only things on my phone that aren't adware or spyware are free software apps.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by minikites on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:31AM (#26580752)
A web browser made by an advertising company is the currently the most popular web browser.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by GoblinSlayer on Thursday March 25, 2021 @12:51PM (#26582550)
It's basically a pirate ship.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by blablabla123 on Friday March 26, 2021 @06:44AM (#26590563)
That's why I have only few apps installed and if it's possible I opt for the paid version. (I do appreciate Fdroid though)

Still, I think it used to be much worse or at least more obvious in the early 2000s. At that time Shareware was still a thing and it was normal for installers to add completely unrelated 3rdparty software. Probably that's also half the explanation why Windows used to be so unreliable, half of the ecosystem around was just random stuff.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by npsimons on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:53AM (#26581016)
> "Software vendors won’t usually be inserting spyware into their wares."

JFC. I'm sorry, but this "article" can be dismissed on that alone. Software vendors already are inserting spyware into their "wares." Did the author do any research?

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by kazinator on Thursday March 25, 2021 @01:20PM (#26582876)
The article can be entirely dismissed on pompous pseudo-intellectual pontification such as:

> The Free Software coterie is fond of insisting that words mean what they say they mean, and that is a profound misunderstanding of the nature of language. Such linguistic naïveté is not an asset in pursuing political goals.

Uh, take your snooty diaeresis and shove it where l'accent aigu don't shine?

Defining terms is par for the course in the general intellectual sphere. Academic papers, data sheets for microchips and ISO standards for programming languages all define terms and insist on using them in the defined way.

If that's not enough, there is outright misinformed claptrap:

> With all that said, the intent of the adherents to the term Free Software is to seek to promote certain freedoms for the users of software, by depriving the creators of software (at least in the United States) of the rights afforded them by Congress under Article I, Section VIII, Clause VIII.

What? Creators of software are deprived of freedoms by the Free Software Foundation? Not simply encouraged to copyleft their software, while retaining all rights to license it in other ways at the same time?

Crazy.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by kazinator on Friday March 26, 2021 @01:22PM (#26594634)
A grating distortion in the article is that Stallman and the FSF tried to take the credit for Linux. ("The Free Software Foundation is famously fixated on insisting that it be given credit for Linux.") Stallman just wanted recognition for the GNU part of Linux distributions based on a GNU user space. "GNU/Linux" not "GNU Linux". Stallman never, ever wanted to take credit for the Linux kernel; that is ridiculous.

More abhorrent than that is the position that free software should be done in such a way that nobody claims credit, justified by a glib quote from Harry Truman. Harry Truman was a politician and, for a time, president of the United States. Presidents rely on other people to execute plans, and implicitly get credit for everything good that happens during their reign anyway, as well as blame for the bad. So it's easy to make seemingly magnanimous statements of that sort. I would rather say that the absence of a blame environment is more conductive to getting things done, rather than the absence of credit.

Software is a creative work made by specific authors, who undeniably deserve credit. Credit transcends even copyright. To falsely claim authorship of a work in the public domain isn't a copyright violation, yet it is plagiarism. It will forever be plagiarism, even when the work is millennia old. Falsely claiming to have produced a cave painting that is 30,000 years old is plagiarism. Some unknown prehistoric person is credited with that.

The western intellectual tradition is heavily steeped in credit. Theories, equations, industrial processes, objects and phenomena in nature, and other entities connected to ideas and discovery, are often named after individuals. Maxwell's equations, Einstein's relativity, Rayleigh scattering, Bell's palsy, Fermat's Last Theorem, Pascal's Triangle, Haber-Bosch process for ammonia production, Early effect in transistors ... credit, credit everywhere in STEM, philosophy, the humanities.

I find it obnoxiously odious for someone to dare suggest that free software developers should disrobe themselves of claims to credit. In free software, credit is your only reward, more often than not.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by npsimons on Thursday March 25, 2021 @01:40PM (#26583136)
> the intent of the adherents to the term Free Software is to seek to promote certain freedoms for the users of software, by depriving the creators of software

Oh, he's one of that kind of cunts. Someone with an axe to grind against FLOSS because he obviously hasn't studied history of copyright in addition to his misunderstanding of FLOSS.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by TheCoelacanth on Thursday March 25, 2021 @11:14AM (#26581272)
Software vendors basically have to be dragged kicking and screaming into not inserting spyware into their wares.

Look at the giant tantrum basically every software vendor is throwing over the quite reasonable restrictions that the EU placed on spyware. I have to tell users about the spyware I'm inflicting on them and ask for consent first? End of the world.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by yellowapple on Friday March 26, 2021 @11:30PM (#26599677)
Yeah, that's the moment I stopped taking anything in the article seriously.

But hey, if this guy's really a software architect then he might've cured my Impostor Syndrome, so I guess he has my thanks.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by runiq on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:30AM (#26579397)
Just now we had a bit of a kerfuffle with telemetry being enabled in the most popular Lua language server[0].

I can't argue with the specific usecase presented in that GitHub issue, I'm going to keep telemetry enabled. But if you argue that vendors "usually won't be inserting spyware", in the face of evidence like free software products seeing value in phoning home with telemetry data, I think I have the moral right to reject your argument in full.

https://github.com/sumneko/lua-language-server/issues/462

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by 3grdlurker on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:45AM (#26579528)
You can’t reject his argument in full because you’re already biting back at the wrong argument. OP isn’t saying that free, open-source software is untarnished by and incapable of crimes against consumer privacy, but the fact that it is FOSS allows concerned members of the public to inspect it so, whereas proprietary software does not. How do you reckon you are able to know of the very example that you cited, for instance?
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:43AM (#26580154)
I think you and runiq are in violent agreement :)
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by StupidOne on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:58AM (#26579648)
I think we should separate telemetry from spyware. It is not close the same. We all have telemetry is our cars, yet nobody is making any fuss about it. Even in software engineering profiling database queries or active memory is not something anew and I don't recall we had any problems with that.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by dhagz on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:15AM (#26579833)
I'd argue that if the telemetry is opt-out rather than opt-in it has (just _barely_) crossed the border into spyware. Sure it may not be tracking anything more than usage data, but I'd rather see a pop-up/dialog saying, "we'd like to track X, Y, and Z - we'll be using Q to identify your data. Is that okay?" And make a choice than to have that choice made for me.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by mindslight on Thursday March 25, 2021 @12:09PM (#26582012)
What is with this idea that software has some interactive install process where I would want to be asked questions every time? Blast from the oughts! If you have to ask, the answer is 'no'.

Your software is either trustworthy, part of that being that it doesn't perform surveillance on me, another part being that it installs through well-known automation (apt, nix, etc). Or it will never become part of my trusted computing base (yes, that term is another blast from the past).

If I am forced to use it, it will end up in some isolated VM or throwaway tablet, with the minimum of access required for the functionality I need. I will consider it a second class citizen and generally deprecate it as much as possible (eg for communication apps, work to move the conversation to a different medium).

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by dhagz on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:32PM (#26674359)
Nothing saying it can't be in a config file. Really all I care about is opt-in over opt-out.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:18AM (#26579874)
...do we all have telemetry in our cars, really? I mean, we have data that can be read via ODBII, but it's not exactly connecting via the cell network, it has to be retrieved with a plug.

I can't think of anyone I know who has a car that needs to phone home. But that's a very limited sample size, so you know. Also, I'm most likely in a different market to you, we've never had anything like OnStar make inroads here into domestic vehicles - some commercial operators are using telemetry on their trucks etc.

But rest assured, if all our cars were phoning home, I'd be making a massive fuss.

For example, an insurance company in my country has recently launched an app that will "measure" your driving and offer lower premiums if your driving is "safe" according to their algorithms. It's obviously opt-in, but at some point, the difference between a discount for opting in, and a penalty for opting out, becomes hard to differentiate.

You don't have any rights to review their algorithms if you feel that they got it wrong, it's a combination of Hail Corporate and Hail AI, and context is lost because it's impossible to capture that. E.g., does heavy braking indicate you were driving poorly, or did you encounter a situation where heavy braking was necessary, such as the damn cat down the road that thinks it's invincible deciding to make a sprint for it in front of you? Is acceleration in excess of their defined limit unsafe? Or were you accelerating more than you normally would, because someone gave you space to turn into the road and you didn't want to needlessly hold them up, given their courtesy?

And given what I've seen of the FAANG algorithms, I don't want algorithms from companies nowhere near FAANG level making decisions about me. A personal favourite of mine was FB removing a comment of mine, because my sister said she'd totally marry my wife, on account of how, well, pretty damn awesome my wife is, and I'd replied "Haha, I'll fight you" - and FB had flagged that as "hate speech/incitement to violence".

Anyway, thank you for coming to my TED rant.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by dahart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:25AM (#26580674)
> I can't think of anyone I know who has a car that needs to phone home.

You don’t know anyone with a Tesla? https://www.tesla.com/support/connectivity

Or a Honda? https://hondalink.honda.com/#/

Or a Bmw? https://connecteddrive.bmwusa.com/app/index.html#/portal

Or a Toyota? https://www.supraconnect.com/app/index.html#/portal

You don’t know anyone with a Chrysler, Dodge, Fiat, Jeep or Ram brand vehicle? https://www.driveuconnect.com/

You didn’t hear about the remote control vulnerability 6 years ago? Chrysler recalled their entire fleet to fix it. https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-hig...

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:48AM (#26580955)
No, I don't know anyone with a Tesla. I do know people with Hondas, Beamers, Nissan Leafs, and I own two Toyotas and a Mazda.

Definitely no Chryslers, Dodges, Fiats, or Rams. They are very limited in market reach indeed in NZ, unless we're talking vintage cars, then there's a few more.

I also had the, ahem, "privilege" of owning a GM built "Toyota" previously[1]. It was... shall we say, a cacophony of interesting and bemusing engineering choices - the boot/trunk lid was incredibly heavy, yet the latch mechanism was made entirely of plastic, and to turn on the interior lights, you had to turn the dashboard brightness dial all the way up, and then a bit more, and then the interior lights would turn on. Only took me 3 months to figure that out. Admittedly, was handy for turning on the interior lights without looking away while driving, but was not at all intuitive.

Oh, I do know someone with a couple of Jeeps though, the poor bastards.

I guess you could rephrase my statement as "I don't know anyone with a car built after 2016", although as far as I can tell in NZ, Toyotas, at least, ship with telematics as an option for fleet management, rather than a default.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chevrolet_Cavalier#Toyota_Cava...

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by dahart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @11:50AM (#26581754)
I guess I've lost track of your point. You were trying to suggest cars don't phone home, based on your experience and assumptions, but the fact is that nearly all major manufacturers are selling cars today with systems that phone home for various reasons, whether you're aware of it or not. How does you not knowing anyone with new cars meaningfully inform this thread? The manufacturers are becoming aware of privacy issues, and trying to make some kinds of collection and access opt-in, but basically all of them now offer some services that phone home by default and are opt-out or not optional. Hopefully that data is reasonable and private and protected... hopefully.

A lot of consumers (I would guess most) prefer to have default-on connectivity to provide services like theft protection, automatic emergency support in case of accidents, and up-to-date navigation maps, among many other modern conveniences.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EricE on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:44AM (#26580904)
"I can't think of anyone I know who has a car that needs to phone home. "

As others point out, it's almost impossible to get a new car these days that isn't connected. Anything in the last five years in particular. It's pretty disgusting and one of the reasons I'm in no hurry to own anything new. I have a '97, '02 and '10 and they all work quite well for me and I intend to run them into the ground. And if I'm diligent they should last me until I am no longer fit to drive.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:51AM (#26580990)
Yeah, I think that's more likely the case - I don't know anyone with a car younger than 2016. My three vehicles are 2005, 2006 and 2008, and they're all sauntering along with nearly 300,000 km on them each. God bless Japanese engineering.

In NZ we tend to buy used Japanese imports because they're so damn cheap (IIRC, Japan has very strict rules about the age of a car for pollution control purposes, so they get shipped off to Australia and us after hitting that age limit, and we don't charge tariffs, unlike the Aussies), most people here would be lucky to buy a new car once or twice in their life.

Unless you go the usual route and start a building company, tick up a new Ford Ranger on the company's credit, transfer ownership to your spouse/partner, and then go into liquidation leaving behind devastated people who were trying to build their first home - and subcontractors who really need the $12k you owe them.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by ip34162 on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:52PM (#26583931)
In future, we are gonna have a blast. Some lucky ones already are. :) /s

Cars Have Your Location. This Spy Firm Wants to Sell It to the U.S. Military:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26492322

One company wants to sell the feds location data from every car on Earth:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26511649

Military Unit Conducting Drone Strikes Bought Location Data from Ordinary Apps:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26367747

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by danielsamuels on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:49AM (#26580233)
> ...do we all have telemetry in our cars, really? I mean, we have data that can be read via ODBII, but it's not exactly connecting via the cell network, it has to be retrieved with a plug.

Nissans do, my Leaf does. They connect to a mobile network or WiFi and upload data.

https://www.nissan.co.uk/ownership/nissan-infotainment-syste...

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by gabereiser on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:05AM (#26580424)
Yup. My Nissan gives me a monthly nag screen to accept terms in order to use my navigation map and audio system. The car has its own 4G connection (I don’t pay anything, it’s not usable to me) in order to download traffic data, send telemetry home, and I believe SiriusXM radio.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by Bishop_ on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:12AM (#26580509)
I'm currently imagining a nightmare scenario where those gas station tv ads are playing inside of the car. I sincerely hope that day never comes.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by steelframe on Sunday March 28, 2021 @10:53AM (#26610851)
> gas station tv ads

I've been driving EVs for the past 10 years (LEAF -> Model X -> I-PACE) during which time I haven't used a gas pump. After reading your comment I had to go searching for this thing about ads playing while you're filling up. I found this Reddit post about being forced to watch ads before being allowed to even start the pump!

https://www.reddit.com/r/assholedesign/comments/819tcf/forci...

Oh. My. God. I'm disappointed. Not surprised. But disappointed.

> playing inside of the car

Yeah, that's definitely going at the top of my list of car "misfeatures" that would make me run screaming to another brand.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by WrtCdEvrydy on Thursday March 25, 2021 @11:55AM (#26581837)
Speed = 0, Display Ad = True?

Goddamn, I don't want this post to be a screenshot for someone to point out that we can see the future.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by gabereiser on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:19PM (#26583567)
Speed=0,Fuel_Cap=OFF,Display_Ad=True. - well, if anyone is going to get it first, its those Tesla owners lol.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by WrtCdEvrydy on Friday March 26, 2021 @05:42AM (#26590260)
I was thinking more of running the ad at a red light but yeah...
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:18AM (#26580592)
Yeah, I'm unsurprised a Leaf does. I also remember that Nissan had a security hole back in 2016 that meant that a bad actor could drain your Leaf's battery with only a VIN.

It's definitely the way the industry wants to go - I mean, free data, why not? Bit like the FAANGs, dress up the data collection with some features people want.

Might just be a case that no-one I know owns a late model car :D We're big on older Japanese imports in NZ, god bless our lack of tariffs. Although RIP our local car manufacturing industry, god bless neoliberalism.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by Silhouette on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:28AM (#26580709)
We all have telemetry is our cars, yet nobody is making any fuss about it.

That is very much not true, on both counts.

There is a lot of nuance in this area.

Monitoring how well your own systems are working and how they're being used is one thing. It's obviously reasonable and necessary for a variety of practical reasons.

Monitoring how someone else's systems are being used, even if they happen to be running some of your software or incorporate some equipment you made, is something else. If you're no longer responsible for those systems and ownership has been handed over, including remote access or phone-home functionality means crossing some lines that maybe shouldn't be crossed, particularly not without the full knowledge and genuine consent of the person whose system you are communicating with.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by mindslight on Thursday March 25, 2021 @11:21AM (#26581363)
> We all have telemetry is our cars, yet nobody is making any fuss about it

This is like saying nobody cared about mass surveillance before Snowden. The problem is apparent, but the realization isn't evenly distributed.

The only difference between this Lua server and other Software Augmented with Additional Surveillance (SaaS) is your trust. You apparently trust them to not sell the data trove to a surveillance company (or to a VC who eventually will), but I see no reason to. Heck, I've been answering no to popcon for over a decade now, even though Debian is outstandingly trustworthy.

Even Backblaze, a company whose core product is securely storing your data, just recently suffered from an in house attack - apparently their security team didn't foresee the need to protect against javascript injection by their own marketing stooges. When data is there for the taking, most people cannot restrain themselves - the problem is endemic. The only solution is to assure the privacy of data, through means such as Free software, E2E encryption, and not collecting it in the first place.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by yellowapple on Friday March 26, 2021 @11:34PM (#26599692)
> We all have telemetry is our cars, yet nobody is making any fuss about it.

I sure as hell am making a fuss about it, which is exactly why I drive a car that's old enough to vote (and pretty soon will be old enough to drink, smoke, and/or buy a handgun in California).

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:28AM (#26579380)
You need to address the author’s points though: if you agree that spyware is a problem that impinges on user freedom, what agenda should we advance to solve it? is advocating for copyleft licensing actually helping? Do you really believe that a world where everyone only used GPL software would be free of spyware?
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by fsflover on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:30AM (#26579400)
> Do you really believe that a world where everyone only used GPL software would be free of spyware?

There is no need to believe. Just have a look at F-Droid and GNU/Linux repositories.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by Aldo_MX on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:55AM (#26579622)
I don't get your point, but I'm pretty sure that several GNU/Linux repos contain the version of Unity that pinged Amazon's servers to name an example.

Where do you draw the line between spyware and legitimate feature?

Where do you draw the line between malware and unintentional faulty code?

Review time is a scarce resource, and a bad actor will always find a way to bypass automated checks.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by laurent92 on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:11AM (#26579783)
We should really pay for open-source. The FSF has a page saying it’s correct to charge before delivering OSS software (and the user can redistribute the software with OSS license).

We could charge access to Debian repositories for example. For example one repo could have bugfixes, and the broader audience could have a 1-year-old repo. Sure your can build from source, get a zip from a torrent, or find someone who hosts a free mirror of the paid repo, but as a company it’s much easier to get it from the official source, for security compliance. (Btw I’ve always said I’d be happy to spend $200 per year per employee for a desktop OS of macOS quality, so probably much less for our servers).

This would offer price discrimination: - Free for individuals who want to spin off a small website, - Paid when you need to prove compliance to security regulations, - Developments still go to the pool of mankind’s marvels, instead of being locked with a commercial license and dying with the company, - Customer can still fork or fix a bug themselves by building from source.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by Aldo_MX on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:41PM (#26583805)
I agree with your point that we should look for a way to pay FOSS maintainers for their time, but my point was that Linux repos are not free of spyware naming the version of Unity that sent what you typed to Amazon Shopping as an example.

The line that separates legitimate features and spyware is blurry, especially when a bad default ends up leaking information of the user.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by kaba0 on Friday March 26, 2021 @07:34AM (#26590833)
It is enough for one person to notice something strange about a program and it is really easy to fork/revert back to a version with only the needed functionality if source is available. Of course the given bad faith actor responsible for the mischief will be “punished” and will be banned from contribution.

With the apparent lack of both viruses and telemetry and the like in libre software even with the laughable default security of linux distros (your home containing basically everything free to read/modify for any user app), I would say that FOSS has quite a good track record in this metric. Nonetheless, a stronger security should be developed/strived for because it still boils down to a trust based system, but it makes me happy that the default of most people is to not cause harm.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by fsflover on Friday March 26, 2021 @05:40AM (#26590246)
> I'm pretty sure that several GNU/Linux repos contain the version of Unity that pinged Amazon's servers to name an example.

FLOSS does not prevent malware from existing, but it makes it highly unprobable. You can always find bad examples, but how frequent are they?

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by GoblinSlayer on Thursday March 25, 2021 @01:48PM (#26583240)
Customization is what GPL ensures. You install and run reviewed code.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:47AM (#26579542)
That Linux doesn’t itself contain any spyware doesn’t tell me how, in a world where everyone runs Linux, magically spyware would disappear.

Android is built on Linux. Android-based TVs and phones are sold to consumers every day with spyware preinstalled.

So we have broad adoption of GPL software. Spyware is still happening. What’s the next step?

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:53AM (#26580271)
You can't lump all GPL licenced software into one bucket. GPL <=2 is quite different to GPL 3. Which is why GPL 3 is anathema to many commercial companies.

I can pretty much guarantee that none of those "smart" TVs are running GPLv3 code.

Hehe, and then there's the Affero licence... https://opensource.google/docs/using/agpl-policy/

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by scoutt on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:38AM (#26580088)
To be pedantic, Android is under Apache[1] license, not GPL. And the apps you install in Android are (and can be) closed source (most of them).

The hypothetical scenario you describe is the one where you build Linux from scratch and you find a spyware. And this, AFAIK, is not happening right now, and one of the reasons is because it's open source and you can build it from the source code.

[1]: https://source.android.com/setup/start/licenses

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:45AM (#26580182)
Android incorporates a patched GPLv2 Linux kernel, and a stack of other stuff on top of it which includes GPL, LGPL and Apache and other licenses.

And a typical android distribution - eg the one installed on a TV - includes a bunch of other software too.

And the hypothetical scenario I want is where I buy a TV and it doesn’t contain spyware. It seems that the existence of Linux has, if anything, made that less possible, given that any old hardware company can grab a Linux kernel and shove whatever spyware they want on top of it before selling it to me.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by scoutt on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:02AM (#26580384)
> Android incorporates a patched GPLv2 Linux kernel.

This has nothing to do with "So we have broad adoption of GPL software". Android (AOSP) is Apache. We don't have "broad adoption of GPL software". This scenario doesn't exist.

If the software of the TV is GPLv2, you must have access to the source code (even with Apache this can happen to some extent). The TV manufacturer must give you the source code of the software running on the TV (with GPLv3 they should also guarantee that you can re-flash your devices). This of course is an ideal world, and it's the freedom FSF searches for.

This way, you (or someone else) can audit the source code and check for spywares. You might be able to rebuild and reflash the software.

Unfortunately not everything is open source. On Linux you have (for example) NVIDIA drivers that are closed source. You can put a spyware in there, even if Linux is GPLv2.

EDIT: btw, you first asked "What’s the next step?". I believe the next step is to raise awareness of the rights one has over GPLvX software and to be able to truly enforce those rights. Like if you ask Samsung for the source code of your TV and they don't give it to you, you can (like) go to the nearest police station and press charges.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:55AM (#26580293)
...if the Linux kernel was under GPLv3 though, that wouldn't be as easy for them.

I haven't quite grokked why Linus decided GPLv3 was bad, but he strikes me as a pragmatist vs. the FSF idealists.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by pieter_mj on Thursday March 25, 2021 @01:07PM (#26582732)
As far as I understood (maybe it was/is on groklaw.net somewhere), Linus didn't care as much about the users. His main concern is the developers, so he doesn't mind the users being tivoized out of their ability to run adapted code.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by GoblinSlayer on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:01PM (#26583383)
Not so long ago GPLv2 was anathema for corporations, but now they love it due to linux. What's left now is to gradually roll out GPLv3. It's embrace and extend tactics of sorts.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by lupire on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:31PM (#26583700)
Corporations love GPLv2 because they get free code, not because of Linux.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by lupire on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:28PM (#26583655)
Linus cares about his users (GPLv2). RMS cares about all the users (GPLv3).

Linux just wants anyone who changes the code to contribute back. He doesn't care how they exploit the software he gives them.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by kaba0 on Friday March 26, 2021 @07:48AM (#26590921)
It’s like arguing that buying quality ingredients for a meal, and fking up the cooking is somehow the mistake of that expensive Italian pasta.

Also, you seriously argue that availability of a great kernel is somehow a bad thing??

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by crazypython on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:34AM (#26580036)
> Android is built on Linux. Android-based TVs and phones are sold to consumers every day with spyware preinstalled.

Android is built on GPLv2 Linux. GPLv2 does not protect the user against locked down hardware and firmware. In contrast, GPLv3+ does protect the user. The user does not have the freedom to modify their software on their hardware, so there is much less freedom.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by User23 on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:56AM (#26579630)
Don’t straw man. The comment you’re replying to is referring to using free software exclusively. If you avoid all non-free software, including services that don’t share their source code, then you will not have to deal with any adware or spyware at all if you don’t wish to.

You’re really just supporting the FSF’s arguments against non-free software.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:05AM (#26579721)
But plot that path out for me. Explain to me how you make a world where the average consumer has access to a spyware free phone and TV because of free software. What societal or legislative or cultural levers do you plan to pull to bring about that utopia? Is the FSF pulling them?
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by yunohn on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:02AM (#26579688)
Who will fund this entirely free stack you are talking about?
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by sildur on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:56AM (#26579633)
No magic is needed. In a world where everything is free software, almost no spyware would happen. And the "almost" is because nobody can watch everything every time. But the most used software will be thoroughly reviewed.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:10AM (#26579774)
But we don’t live in that world yet. We live in a world where, on the contrary, companies are able to make products that distribute their spyware and do so by actively exploiting the contributions of free software developers! The Linux devs whose contributions are in android are having their software used to build TVs that spy on people! Is free software advocacy alone actually helping advance a spyware-free world, then?
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by fsflover on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:30AM (#26580733)
No, the eventual goal of the FSF (and Stallman himself) is to make all software free. You cannot achieve this goal at once, you need to make part of the software free first.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by slightwinder on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:43AM (#26580162)
Those repositories are used by a very small minority of users, which are also highly competent and constantly looking out for scatchy things. Yet, those scatchy things do happen occasionally on small scale be.

But it's kinda obvious that the lack ob a big and serious actor is the main reason why nothing seriously bad ever happend in linux-land so far. Everyone switching to Open Source would change this and the watchmen would likely be unable to protect their world.

I mean just look at the mildly bad things happening on mainstream-systems, which everyone knows about and still ignores them, because "that's just how it is". At the end people willingly use bad software & services, because their subjective gain is higher than the small price they pay.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by boudin on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:08AM (#26579747)
It doesn't systematically free people of spywares but allows to do so. Projects already get forked for that purpose like vscode, chromium. It also allows to audit and at least see what a software does.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by GoblinSlayer on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:09PM (#26583465)
vscodium