News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:47AM (#26579542)
That Linux doesn’t itself contain any spyware doesn’t tell me how, in a world where everyone runs Linux, magically spyware would disappear.

Android is built on Linux. Android-based TVs and phones are sold to consumers every day with spyware preinstalled.

So we have broad adoption of GPL software. Spyware is still happening. What’s the next step?

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:53AM (#26580271)
You can't lump all GPL licenced software into one bucket. GPL <=2 is quite different to GPL 3. Which is why GPL 3 is anathema to many commercial companies.

I can pretty much guarantee that none of those "smart" TVs are running GPLv3 code.

Hehe, and then there's the Affero licence... https://opensource.google/docs/using/agpl-policy/

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by scoutt on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:38AM (#26580088)
To be pedantic, Android is under Apache[1] license, not GPL. And the apps you install in Android are (and can be) closed source (most of them).

The hypothetical scenario you describe is the one where you build Linux from scratch and you find a spyware. And this, AFAIK, is not happening right now, and one of the reasons is because it's open source and you can build it from the source code.

[1]: https://source.android.com/setup/start/licenses

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:45AM (#26580182)
Android incorporates a patched GPLv2 Linux kernel, and a stack of other stuff on top of it which includes GPL, LGPL and Apache and other licenses.

And a typical android distribution - eg the one installed on a TV - includes a bunch of other software too.

And the hypothetical scenario I want is where I buy a TV and it doesn’t contain spyware. It seems that the existence of Linux has, if anything, made that less possible, given that any old hardware company can grab a Linux kernel and shove whatever spyware they want on top of it before selling it to me.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by scoutt on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:02AM (#26580384)
> Android incorporates a patched GPLv2 Linux kernel.

This has nothing to do with "So we have broad adoption of GPL software". Android (AOSP) is Apache. We don't have "broad adoption of GPL software". This scenario doesn't exist.

If the software of the TV is GPLv2, you must have access to the source code (even with Apache this can happen to some extent). The TV manufacturer must give you the source code of the software running on the TV (with GPLv3 they should also guarantee that you can re-flash your devices). This of course is an ideal world, and it's the freedom FSF searches for.

This way, you (or someone else) can audit the source code and check for spywares. You might be able to rebuild and reflash the software.

Unfortunately not everything is open source. On Linux you have (for example) NVIDIA drivers that are closed source. You can put a spyware in there, even if Linux is GPLv2.

EDIT: btw, you first asked "What’s the next step?". I believe the next step is to raise awareness of the rights one has over GPLvX software and to be able to truly enforce those rights. Like if you ask Samsung for the source code of your TV and they don't give it to you, you can (like) go to the nearest police station and press charges.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by EdwardDiego on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:55AM (#26580293)
...if the Linux kernel was under GPLv3 though, that wouldn't be as easy for them.

I haven't quite grokked why Linus decided GPLv3 was bad, but he strikes me as a pragmatist vs. the FSF idealists.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by pieter_mj on Thursday March 25, 2021 @01:07PM (#26582732)
As far as I understood (maybe it was/is on groklaw.net somewhere), Linus didn't care as much about the users. His main concern is the developers, so he doesn't mind the users being tivoized out of their ability to run adapted code.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by GoblinSlayer on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:01PM (#26583383)
Not so long ago GPLv2 was anathema for corporations, but now they love it due to linux. What's left now is to gradually roll out GPLv3. It's embrace and extend tactics of sorts.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by lupire on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:31PM (#26583700)
Corporations love GPLv2 because they get free code, not because of Linux.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by lupire on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:28PM (#26583655)
Linus cares about his users (GPLv2). RMS cares about all the users (GPLv3).

Linux just wants anyone who changes the code to contribute back. He doesn't care how they exploit the software he gives them.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by kaba0 on Friday March 26, 2021 @07:48AM (#26590921)
It’s like arguing that buying quality ingredients for a meal, and fking up the cooking is somehow the mistake of that expensive Italian pasta.

Also, you seriously argue that availability of a great kernel is somehow a bad thing??

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by crazypython on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:34AM (#26580036)
> Android is built on Linux. Android-based TVs and phones are sold to consumers every day with spyware preinstalled.

Android is built on GPLv2 Linux. GPLv2 does not protect the user against locked down hardware and firmware. In contrast, GPLv3+ does protect the user. The user does not have the freedom to modify their software on their hardware, so there is much less freedom.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by User23 on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:56AM (#26579630)
Don’t straw man. The comment you’re replying to is referring to using free software exclusively. If you avoid all non-free software, including services that don’t share their source code, then you will not have to deal with any adware or spyware at all if you don’t wish to.

You’re really just supporting the FSF’s arguments against non-free software.

Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:05AM (#26579721)
But plot that path out for me. Explain to me how you make a world where the average consumer has access to a spyware free phone and TV because of free software. What societal or legislative or cultural levers do you plan to pull to bring about that utopia? Is the FSF pulling them?
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by yunohn on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:02AM (#26579688)
Who will fund this entirely free stack you are talking about?
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by sildur on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:56AM (#26579633)
No magic is needed. In a world where everything is free software, almost no spyware would happen. And the "almost" is because nobody can watch everything every time. But the most used software will be thoroughly reviewed.
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by jameshart on Thursday March 25, 2021 @09:10AM (#26579774)
But we don’t live in that world yet. We live in a world where, on the contrary, companies are able to make products that distribute their spyware and do so by actively exploiting the contributions of free software developers! The Linux devs whose contributions are in android are having their software used to build TVs that spy on people! Is free software advocacy alone actually helping advance a spyware-free world, then?
Re:Free Software: An idea whose time has passed? by fsflover on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:30AM (#26580733)
No, the eventual goal of the FSF (and Stallman himself) is to make all software free. You cannot achieve this goal at once, you need to make part of the software free first.