Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by doki_pen on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @11:04AM
(#2657385)
A little competition for http://hn.embed.ly? Heh. We think rich data makes much better previews then screenshots. What does HN think about this site vs. hn.embed.ly?
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by buza on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @02:50PM
(#2658503)
I've been playing with visual (screenshot-based) readers for a few years now, with my most recent effort being 'Percolater', a visual reader for the iPad. When demoing Percolater to current iPad users that are used to 'intelligent' content re-arrangers like Flipboard, Pulse, and hn.embed.ly, the people that tend to prefer a screenshot representation tend to be those that are more on the design end of the spectrum. There is a tremendous amount of context contained within the layout of a given page, and we've become very good at determining the likelihood that a page will be worth reading purely based on layout cues. Snapshots have the ability to further allow us to pre-filter what's important. There are a great many people that feel that ad removal is unequivocally a good thing, and for them, pulling out some text and an image and shoving it in a box is perfectly suitable for their browsing needs. I don't happen to be one of those people, hence the thing I've made.
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by Hovertruck on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @11:32AM
(#2657491)
I think this would benefit greatly from some sort of collapse feature. The nice thing about browsing titles-only ("vanilla") HN is that things that I don't want to read take up very minimal screen space. With this, I had to work too hard to scroll past this entry: http://i.imgur.com/Z9t67.png
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by unfasten on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @08:01PM
(#2659595)
You can also fold the article with 'd', and show the top comment with 'c'. Shift+C opens the comment thread too. Pressing '?' will bring up a box that lists all the shortcuts:
j or → Select next article
k or ← Select previous article
c Toggle Hacker News top comment
shift + c Open Hacker News comments page in a new window
d Toggle article content
enter Follow the article link in this window
shift + enter Follow the article link in a new window
? Show this keyboard shortcuts dialog
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by mmahemoff on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @10:49AM
(#2657320)
This kind of UI would work well on other HN-like sites, e.g. links to pretty web designs, but the nature of HN links means the screenshots are almost all the same thing: an article, a possible image, some ads or links on the side.
Because of the extra space taken up by screenshots, the most important thing - link title - has to be truncated, and it's not showing vote/comment counts.
It's always good to experiment with UIs, but in this case, I think the experiment shows the UI is more suited to other kinds of links.
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by kilian on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @10:58AM
(#2657353)
I think url2png is really cool, but I was a bit pissed when from one day to the next they went to a subscription model and added sign-up links to all screenshots. Their fair right, of course, but no fun if you just started using it.
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by rokhayakebe on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @11:33AM
(#2657496)
I have been using the service for over 3 months and I remember telling the founder I would pay for it. Well. looks like I am going to send my check now :). Gladly.
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by bgraves on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @10:28AM
(#2657229)
I agree. This is more of a proof-of-concept / demo of the url2png api. If the post looks interesting to you, just hover over the image thumbnail to view the title.
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by petercooper on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @10:40AM
(#2657278)
I usually enjoy visual browsers like this, but here the previews are too small for it to click for me. Just to provide a counterexample, this one is pretty cool and along similar lines: http://news.peepcode.com/
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by matmann2001 on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @11:58AM
(#2657609)
I love the concept, but I'd rather have the links open in the same window. Just change your target attributes and I will switch over to this solution permanently.
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by bgraves on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @10:58AM
(#2657361)
perhaps a Google Instant Preview style extension where you hover over the default view link and a screenshot is displayed on the side? That would be a great browser extension!
Re:HackRSS - browse HN posts visually
by recoiledsnake on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @11:38AM
(#2657515)
Can we have a place that lists all the HN related sites? Or maybe PG can create such a page and link it at the top/bottom. That would be useful instead of them getting lost in the old posts and people who haven't seen the posts missing them.
Any chance you could include more of the title text and the link to the comments?
http://i.imgur.com/KdOR5.jpg
Because of the extra space taken up by screenshots, the most important thing - link title - has to be truncated, and it's not showing vote/comment counts.
It's always good to experiment with UIs, but in this case, I think the experiment shows the UI is more suited to other kinds of links.
and now that we have this, I realize that the end result is that I will now end up reading articles that have nice designs. i.e. judging by the cover.