News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by mindcrime on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:46PM (#2655630)
I would love a chance to see the Color founders doing office hours with pg! Or even just pgbot. I can see it now:

  Color guy:  We're building an app that lets you share photos with   
  your mobile phone, with people within 100 feet of you, but it uses 
  your social graph to make sure you see stuff you're interested in.

  pgbot:  WTF?

  Color guy:  I mean, it lets you share pictures that you just took, and   
  people within 100 feet of you will see that you just shared a picture.

  pgbot:  What problem does this solve? If they're 100 feet away, 
  wouldn't they have seen the same thing you saw, or even taken the 
  same picture anyway?

  Color guy: You don't get it, it's mobile... pictures and mobile, 
  together.  Like peanut butter and chocolate.

  pgbot:  Who wants this?

  Color guy:  Well, erm, I mean, erm, that is, aaahhh... um, you 
  know... like, um, aaaghh... well... uhhrrmmmm... college kids.  And 
  hipsters.  And hipster college kids. 

  pgbot: You mean the two classes of people least likely to either A. have 
  money, or b. spend money, unless it's on cheap beer, crappy clothes, 
  or Apple hardware?

  Color guy: But, but...  

  pgbot: Who's going to pay for this?

  Color guy:  Aaaah, well, you see... aaah... umm....

  pgbot: I worry, I worry...
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by byrneseyeview on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @11:40PM (#2655876)
It's a safe bet that if you can't articulate the position you're arguing against, you don't understand it well. That could mean it's such a crazily dumb idea that you would never have thought of it, but it could also mean that they're much smarter than you.

For what it's worth, I have no idea what their plan is, either.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by tygorius on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @04:50PM (#2658972)
Here's the thing, if you have no idea what their plan is, is it your fault for not understanding it or their fault for not articulating it well? I submit the pgbot scenario provides a third alternative: people can't understand their plan because it makes no freaking business sense.

And whatever that original plan was, I'd bet the pitch didn't include a PowerPoint slide point along the lines of "Two months after we go public, the president leaves and sales really take off!"

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by abbasmehdi on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:15PM (#2655698)
I see the value prop though. At parties, weddings, events etc, where you'd likely be in a picture, you'd wanna see what everyone else shot.

Haven't you been to a party where everybody took pics and you couldn't wait till they uploaded the pics on FB or something to see what they shot?

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by potatolicious on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @11:47PM (#2655889)
> "Haven't you been to a party where everybody took pics and you couldn't wait till they uploaded the pics on FB or something to see what they shot?"

yes, but I'm at the party for the party - I have no intention of spending the entire party staring into my smartphone and living vicariously through the pictures of the lives of people ten feet away from me.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by abbasmehdi on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @02:05PM (#2658300)
Just because you have access to the pictures does not mean you must consume/view them immediately. If many folks are taking pics, I might want to glance every once in a while at what might be going up on FB tomorrow (people, especially women, are very socially conscious, and FB has become the de facto personal brand management tool).

Or if I know someone is closer to the action. Or someone took a picture of me and my wife, or a bunch of people took a bunch of pictures in a group shot. At the game someone might have better seats, at school teenagers could go to town with this.

I think they had a great idea that helped them get $141 million from some of the biggest names in the VC world, but bungled execution badly.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by nl on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @12:02AM (#2655919)
This isn't necessarily true.

Have you seen how much people spend, and how much trouble they go to for wedding photos?

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by potatolicious on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:13AM (#2656071)
Wedding photos are still admired after the fact. There still isn't a use case for "hmm, I wonder what images people are taking within a 100' radius of me!".
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by btilly on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:15AM (#2656076)
There is a use case for, "I wonder what images were taken within 100' of me!"

If the app is on, and tracking photos that were taken, then can resolve it after the fact (and get those photos), I think a lot of people would be interested.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by potatolicious on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:27AM (#2656091)
Wouldn't that be in Facebook's territory? i.e., "Hey Facebook, I took these pictures at Bob's wedding. Based on the geotag, can you show me other pictures from nearby at the same time?"

It seems convoluted (not to mention a gigantic drag on your battery life) to do so on each and every device in real-time.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by btilly on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @04:25AM (#2656393)
Not quite the use case I was considering.

Your phone knows where you were, when. And says, "Here is where I was, what pictures were taken around me?" I want this information regardless of whether I was personally taking pictures.

Keeping a history of where you are can be done without much drain on your battery life. It can just log a location every few minutes.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by ryan_brunner on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @09:23AM (#2656954)
Is location really the key piece of data differentiating "pictures from Bob's wedding" from "the universe of pictures", though? I would think some concept of tagging that went beyond mere location would be far more useful.

80% of the time (walking down the street, sitting in my office, etc.), I don't care about pictures that were taken around me. For the 1% of the time that I DO care, I can probably easily name the thing that I want to see pictures of. Location is perhaps a handy filter for "tags that might be important to me", but it's hardly the sole determiner, or even a major factor, in whether any given picture will be one that's interesting to me.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by btilly on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @05:34PM (#2659121)
The point is that if you, say, go to a conference, you want to see the random pictures that strangers snapped which you might be in.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by SimHacker on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:33AM (#2660960)
And what is the chance that random stranger is using Color? 0.000001%. So why don't you just walk over there and ask him to send you a copy? Social networking at its finest, in real time, at a conference.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by ojbyrne on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:01AM (#2656042)
But typically those are taken with SLRs, which still take better pictures than phones or point & shoots, especially in low light. Plus they are still the only way (with a big lens) to get the shallow depth of field that people like.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by eftpotrm on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @09:58AM (#2657109)
Taken on phone cameras?

I have a phone camera and a fairly nice, if not exactly pro, DSLR. I'd never consider taking anything remotely important on the phone; the quality difference is enormous.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by nradov on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @12:50AM (#2656019)
No I've never felt like that at a party. What's the point of being at the party if you're going to spend half the time with your smart phone in front of your face looking at pictures someone took 10ft away? It just seems completely lame and pointless.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by roel_v on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @04:11AM (#2656373)
To be honest though, it seems that young people are doing just that.

(I'm 31 so an old geezer and I don't know wtf these crazy kids nowadays all do exactly, it's just that when I walk back from my office to home through the bar area in my city, I see many people frolicking about with their phones, taking pictures and doing things with it that suggest it's more than just sms'ing. Also I sometimes see small groups of people standing together, each of them doing things on their phones. It's surreal to me, but if that's how they use their phones...)

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by ghiculescu on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:28PM (#2655728)
It might be slightly useful but I can't see myself ever paying for the opportunity to see the photos a few hours before they'd appear on FB. So it might be slightly useful to some people, but that's hardly a business model.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by ctide on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @11:29PM (#2655860)
Are you paying for Facebook now? How is that even relevant?
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by kiiski on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @12:34AM (#2655989)
What? He didn't say anything about paying for Facebook. He was speaking about Color.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by ThomPete on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:10AM (#2656062)
Its relevant because the question is not whether you should pay money but whether color can make money on you.

If you are not paying for the product you are the product.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by SimHacker on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:36AM (#2660966)
You're paying with your time, which you're wasting. And that is much more precious than money.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by ctide on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:08AM (#2656058)
And Color costs the same amount as Facebook.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by abbasmehdi on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @11:21PM (#2655839)
Twitter?
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by jasonlotito on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @10:02AM (#2657123)
> Haven't you been to a party where everybody took pics and you couldn't wait till they uploaded the pics on FB or something to see what they shot?

During the party? No. Never. And I go to a fair share of events and weddings.

Normally at parties, we eat, talk, have fun, take pictures for later, take videos, dance, dance some more, drink, drink some more, run after the kids, eat, dance, and talk.

I'm not staring at my phone hoping that someone sitting at the other table across from me or across the room is going to share a picture of an even I just saw from another angle.

Now, let's say we are at an event where I'm not with people I know. Rather, I'm with a few friends or family, and we are doing things. Again, we'll be doing things. Taking pictures, videos, and doing things. Having fun. I'm probably not staring at my phone hoping someone uploads something at the even I'm currently attending. To show me something I could have seen if I wasn't staring at my phone.

I could meet this person. They obviously have the same interest as me: the event, where many other people are. The only other similar interest we share is that we both are using the same mobile app. Oh, and we also prefer looking at our phone rather than hang with our friends.

Or we are there alone trying to make friends. So yeah, I think I found the arget market that would get the most use out of it.

People without friends interested in going to events, not actually participating in them, but taking pictures in between staring at their mobile phone waiting for someone else to take a picture as well. And maybe meeting up. And talking about the app.

Maybe I"m just getting old.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by PakG1 on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @02:08AM (#2656160)
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by Splines on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:57AM (#2656144)
There's a certain amount of novelty in seeing what pictures other people took who were once standing where you were. Imagine seeing what your neighbourhood looked like 50 years ago.

Now, whether or not Color is the best place for that to happen, I don't know.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by arethuza on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @04:46AM (#2656420)
If I want to see pictures taken by other people of a particular location I just use this:

http://www.geograph.org.uk/

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by mindcrime on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:19PM (#2655704)
Honestly, I'm not a very photo oriented person, and I despise having my picture taken (I'm always blinking, or have one eye half open or am making a stupid face, or something right when the shutter clicks)... so it's not something that I personally would get much out of.

That said, I think you're right... for some people it does have value. Whether or not it has enough value, and an accompanying business model, to build a successful business, is TBD.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by abbasmehdi on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:22PM (#2655707)
I think people are mistakenly equating "poor exection" with "bad idea".

And come on, your pictures don't come out THAT bad: http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20071126170543/uncyclo...

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by jcromartie on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @08:28AM (#2656790)
What are you going to do? Stand up at the mic and say "They're a wonderful couple aren't they? Congratulations. Now, could you all please start up the Color photo sharing app on your smartphone, or download it from the Apple App Store or Android Marketplace if you don't already have it? I'd like to see the pictures you are taking RIGHT NOW. Thanks."
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by angrycoder on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @03:41AM (#2656323)
I am reminded of the late George Carlin...

"Can anyone explain to me the need for one-hour photo finishing? You just saw the fuckin' thing!"

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by Peaker on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:50PM (#2655642)
I find strawmen to be tasteless and unimaginative. I am not sure their idea has merit, but I would like to hear the supposed merit from their mouths.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by mindcrime on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:54PM (#2655651)
I would too, and hopefully they'll post in this thread. In the meantime, or if they don't, I find it rather amusing to imagine how an interaction with the Color guy and pgbot would go. YMMV.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by Peaker on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:59PM (#2655660)
I don't see why you think that's how an interaction would go. Do you assume you have them all figured out, and they have nothing new to tell you that you haven't thought of?
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by mindcrime on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:06PM (#2655678)
Of course not. I think you're taking this way too seriously. It was an imagination of how an interaction might go, with a dash of hyperbole mixed in, designed to both amuse, and make reference to pg's flair for directing people to focus on those important, fundamental questions like "Who needs this" and "what problem does this solve?"

Color may yet turn out to be wildly successful, I don't know... I'm no fortune teller. <shrug />

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by freshfunk on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:27PM (#2655726)
I'm with you. $41MM or no, Pham is still an entrepreneur trying to build something he believes in. In that sense, he's no different than many here. It sucks to leave something you tried so hard at, something you believed in. Some ideas work out, most don't.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by jamesaguilar on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @11:05PM (#2655799)
If they had something new to tell us, you'd hope they'd have done it by now via the product. Time's 'a wastin'.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by RyanMcGreal on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:26PM (#2655724)
satire != strawman.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by ajross on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:27AM (#2656089)
Well... no. I'd say satire is strawman expressed as art.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by sawyer on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:50PM (#2655644)
Sequoia should definitely hire pgbot to keep them from making blunders like this.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by mindcrime on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:56PM (#2655657)
All joking aside, imagine if pg did try and build a real expert system combined with a chat-bot style interface, that could represent his expertise. He could probably sell access to something like that for a few bucks.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by nostrademons on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:51PM (#2655777)
Didn't the AI winter teach us that rules-based expert systems can only get you so far?

I can just see pgbot turning down Google because its founders were too weakly committed - they wanted to sell the whole thing for <$1M and go back to their grad studies.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by true_religion on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @12:09AM (#2655937)
I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that no one could have predicted the success of Google simply by looking at the founders and what they had at the time.

It was their 2nd invention---highly relevant advertisement that made them an explosively profitable company.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by nostrademons on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @12:28AM (#2655977)
But some people did - Andy Bechtolsheim, David Sheriton, Ram Shriram, Ron Conway, Sequoia & KPCB. And given their track record on other investments, I don't think this was due to pure chance.

I'd posit that people like the investors mentioned above have a highly intuitive "pattern matching" system for finding promising startups. The lack of any one quality won't disqualify a startup; rather, they can unconsciously evaluate the whole startup as a package and decide whether it's likely to be a winner.

Hence, the win of probabilistic AI systems over rule-based ones.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by cheez on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @12:36AM (#2655993)
I think you overestimate the prescience of these investors. They are probably very good at increasing their chances by investing in a lot of stuff and letting the winners run.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by pasbesoin on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @12:47AM (#2656013)
All you had to do was use it, and you were hooked. As to the eventual size of Google, maybe not. As to the product, yes.

(And that might be a lesson to those guestimating future valuations.)

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by phlux on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:04PM (#2655675)
Who wants this?
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by mgkimsal on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:14PM (#2655694)
um, you know... like, um, aaaghh... well... uhhrrmmmm... college kids. And hipsters. And hipster college kids.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by daniel-cussen on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:47PM (#2655769)
They did invest in YC.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by glassx on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @01:42AM (#2656113)
This fictional talk reminds me of Joey Spolsky's article on "architecture astronauts", people trying to solve a non-existant problem for pure geek pleasure.

http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000018.html

I admit it must be one of the coolest app to work on these days: it has geotagging, social graphs, it's mobile, but it's hard to see a real use, yes.

Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by felipemnoa on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:56PM (#2655656)
Sorry for the ignorance but could you please explain what is pgbot? I searched in google but could not find a reasonable explanation.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by mindcrime on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:57PM (#2655658)
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by felipemnoa on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:02PM (#2655671)
Hilarious, thanks! Sounds like an interesting project to do just for kicks.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by gacba on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @09:58PM (#2655659)
pg = Paul Graham, pgbot = Paul Graham AI program that would answer like he would in a YC interview
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by felipemnoa on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @10:03PM (#2655673)
Thanks! I imagined it was something like that but I wasn't sure.
Re:Troubled Startup Color Loses Cofounder Peter Pham by joshbert on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @12:42AM (#2656003)
I can't possibly be the only one that read your text in a pitch perfect Paul Graham voice, can I?