News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by qeternity on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:47AM (#26537860)
> and then test/monitor what is being sent back to the third party.

Trust, but verify. Especially FB.

I see a lot of comments about a paid service using tracking pixels. I understand the backlash but this is also how companies that are taking your hard earned money improve and iterate on their products. I know people don’t like tracking but usage analytics are invaluable to improving the product. There’s only so much customer engagement you can do, and often that leaves really unexpected outcomes in the dark (if you asked most customers, they’d ask for a faster horse).

The issue here is that Backblaze injected untrusted code into their core product which by its very nature is extremely sensitive. I’m not really sure what they were thinking. Rolling your own tracking is a pain, but some security contexts demand it.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by fabbari on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:43AM (#26540004)
Pet peeve of mine: "Trust but verify" is an oxymoron. If you "trust" someone/something you don't need to verify. I understand the sentiment, but it's based on a faulty assumption that trust is a binary state.

It's most exemplary case is the use done by the security teams in most IT shops: "Yes, we did put endpoint protection on your laptop, it's not that we don't trust you -- but you know what they say...". I wish they would simply say:"Of course we don't trust you, not on this. You are going to click on that shady link or download and run random executables from the interwebs. But we do trust you're good at your job".

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by PeterisP on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:14PM (#26543666)
The historical usage of the saying "trust but verify" is that the verification happens after they had the chance to do the thing (possibly badly), as opposed to mistrust where you'd verify everything that they'd do before allowing the thing to be done.

It's essentially "audits instead of pre-approval".

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by skinkestek on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:53AM (#26537905)
> Trust, but verify. Especially FB.

In the particular case of Facebook many of us simplify to "don't trust if not absolutely necessary" ;-)

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by bigiain on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:58AM (#26537944)
I totally trust Facebook. To fuck me over at every possible opportunity, even if they’ve pinky promised “we’d never do that!”. Because they have a track record of doing exactly that.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by qubex on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:47AM (#26538252)
‘Trust’ is defined as wilful forbearance toward those agencies that we can conceive of as being sources of harm to us.

If you “trust Facebook to fuck [you] over” then you’re not trusting Facebook. You’re expecting Facebook to fuck you over and minimising your exposure to that process.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by mnw21cam on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:54AM (#26538681)
If you ask a computing security (or indeed any security) professional, "trust" has a different definition. If A trusts B, then B has the capability of doing something bad to A. This is regardless of whether A has granted B that capability. So, when you drive down the road, you trust the oncoming car not to swerve into your path and crash into you. This is just another way of saying that the oncoming car has the capability to swerve into your path and crash into you. There's no wilful forbearance involved.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by qubex on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:24AM (#26539344)
I disagree insofar as the scenarios you describe (implicit trust in computer security, trust that another driver won’t swerve into your vehicle’s path) are perfectly good examples of the overall definition I posited above.

Indeed, if one didn’t have forbearance of (say) a software vendor or perhaps a dependency then one would be entirely free to not use that vendor’s product or that particular package. Similarly, if you don’t swerve right to prudentially make space for an approaching vehicle to serve into your path then you’re showing them forbearance and trusting them (or swerve left, depending on one’s location on the Earth what side of the road is legally mandate).

So, yep: those are perfect examples of Trust as embodied in the definition I presented above. And of course it lies at the root of initiatives such as Trusted Computing Initiative & cetera.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by happymellon on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:57AM (#26537933)
I removed all Facebook many years ago.

In the particular case of Facebook many of us simplify to "don't trust"

There is no upside for Facebook to have anything about me.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by qubex on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:49AM (#26538264)
Unfortunately Facebook has lots of information about you whether you have an account or not. You’re a big black hole with known characteristics inferred from those acquaintances of yours who interact with you in a manner Facebook can track. You might not have a name and an account, but there’s a big you-shaped golem in their data and there’s absolutely nothing you can do about it, unfortunately, and they’ll use it as they see fit with or without your consent.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by happymellon on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:54AM (#26538296)
Completely agree. I block Facebook at the router but I can't stop other people giving away my PII.

But I do make choices where I can.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by ljm on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:04AM (#26539189)
Makes me think of that Junji Ito comic with the person-shaped holes in the rock after an earthquake. Only now, it's an allegory for social media giants and their corrupting influence on the people they lure into their system.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by sofixa on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:35AM (#26539434)
You can I'd you live in a jurisdiction which gives you the right to demand for all information a company has on you, and the right to be forgotten ( GDPR in the EU, maybe California as well?)
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by qubex on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:45AM (#26538235)
A necessary evil is no less evil merely because it is necessary.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by tiborsaas on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:50AM (#26538266)
> I’m not really sure what they were thinking.

My guess would be that developers installed a single Google Tag Manager script and left the tracking to the marketing/analytics team. From that point they manage what third party scripts are added to the site, not engineers.

This situation cases a tunnel vision which can unfortunately lead to situations like this.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by borispavlovic on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:38AM (#26538179)
Fine, then use Matomo (https://matomo.org/) which even offers a free tier.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by stefan_ on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:34AM (#26538928)
Facebook doesn't make an usage analytics service. And I really, really doubt 99.9% of the people using these abundance of tracking services ever discover any worthwhile corner cases you extol their virtues for. "Analytics" is just the 2000 word for "Reporting" - clueless middlemanagers demand shiny graphics.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by happymellon on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:56AM (#26537925)
> I know people don’t like tracking but usage analytics are invaluable to improving the product.

I wasn't aware that Facebook offered a Google Analytics style service, I was only aware of the Facebook Analytics for your Facebook page.

Can you provide links to this service, as my Google-fu doesn't return anything.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by wildy on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:05AM (#26537977)
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by happymellon on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:34AM (#26538158)
Could be, I wouldn't touch a Facebook property to test it, but the description implies this is all advertising tracking rather than usage analytics.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by goatinaboat on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:47AM (#26538641)
this is also how companies that are taking your hard earned money improve and iterate on their products.

What analytics do you think they can do using Facebook that they cannot do from their own httpd access logs, a technology that's 30 years old at this point?

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by dnzm on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @11:58AM (#26556553)
Or, if that is not sufficient, one of the increasing number of ethical and/or self-hosted services, like Plausible? There is no need whatsoever to ship this kind of data to an outside party.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by deadbytes on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:56AM (#26539115)
Tracking is not ethical. Corporations only get away with it because most users don't realise it's even happening.

If you went into a retail store and an employee followed you around the whole time with a notebook and stopwatch writing down everywhere you walked and every product you looked at, you would rightly be creeped the fuck out and tell him to stop.

This is exactly what online tracking is, but done virtually.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by sbarre on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:50AM (#26539535)
> If you went into a retail store and an employee followed you around the whole time with a notebook and stopwatch writing down everywhere you walked and every product you looked at

I hate to break it to you, but retail companies are doing this today using security camera footage, to figure out what parts of the store customers start at, or spend the most time in..

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by prirun on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:29AM (#26542209)
They're also doing it with Bluetooth beacons / pings, explaining why every store has an app they want you to install:

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/14/opinion/bluet...

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by PeterisP on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:13PM (#26543640)
This is one of key applications of GDPR in Europe - the fact that you can collect data for one purpose (e.g. security cameras) does not necessarily imply that you're permitted to use the same data for any other purpose (e.g. marketing analysis of customer movements).

For the former purpose, it would generally be sufficient to inform visitors with a sign on the entrance with legitimate interest clause; for the latter example IMHO the only practical compliant solution would require anonymization of the data, so you could make and store density data iff you don't have any way to tie them back to customer identities including the purchases they made, which is a key difference from the facebook example, which (as far as I understand) uses unique IDs to link the conversions to specific FB accounts.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by charcircuit on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:58AM (#26539591)
The difference is that with a human near by I feel like I am being judged and when they are not I do not feel that kind of pressure. The grocery store I've gone to my whole life has always had security cameras tracking people for reasons I assume to deal with theft. It does not effect me at all and the store has useful data that they can use. It benefits all parties.
Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by deadbytes on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:57AM (#26540142)
>The difference is that with a human near by I feel like I am being judged and when they are not I do not feel that kind of pressure

I will offer you another perspective to consider.

Technology is extremely subversive in that it bypasses all of our brain's instinctual responses. Someone or something monitoring and tracking you should be setting off warning sirens in your brain. At best they are trying to study you, at worse they are trying to exploit or harm you.

Through hundreds of thousands of years of evolution our brains have built up warning systems to make us feel fear and unease when we realise we are being tracked. But since humans have spent 99.99% of evolution entirely in the physical world these systems have no concept of the digital.

The reason you feel extremely uneasy when being monitored by a person, but not when being monitored by a computer system that is collecting the exact same information (or more), is that your subconscious brain doesn't understand computers.

Re:Backblaze submitting names and sizes of files in B2 bucke... by charcircuit on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:15PM (#26545392)
>our brains have built up warning systems to make us feel fear and unease when we realise we are being tracked

>The reason you feel extremely uneasy when being monitored by a person

I don't though. If someone walked up to me and asked me what my favorite color was and they wrote it down I don't feel any negative feeling.

Even if it was a true thing just because we have a warning system that doesn't mean that something is actually bad. Tracking just gives people more information to allow for better decisions to be made and it can make things more efficient.