I'm partly joking here, but overall I've been trying to use Linux as a desktop environment for nearly 20 years now. It's come a long way but it feels fragile to me. I've been able to do something as simple as a reboot, only to find the graphics go wonky and I'm left with a terminal to debug it.
I even ran FreeBSD as a desktop OS too. That worked well but was also fragile (less so than Linux. The BSDs are solid options.)
Maybe as I get older, wiser (ha!) and more patient and I'll give these things a try again (because there are Apple/Mac related issues slowly cropping up) and perhaps they will work better.
I even gave Windows 10 a serious try recently, using all the latest console emulators to get a better (Linux/iTerm like) experience, VScode, etc. The "sub system for Linux" worked well for a bit before it didn't (file permissions, moving between the two operating systems, etc.)
Ideally I wish I could find the experience I desire within a FreeBSD based desktop environment because then so many hardware options become available to me. Old and new.
Meanwhile, my coworkers complain all the time about macOS. Definitely some of it is due to the poorly-written corporate management software they're required to run, but a lot of it is just them constantly fighting against the OS to get their work done. And then even after IT has finished testing the new major macOS release every year (which takes them like 4 months) and allows people to run it on their laptops, they still look at over an hour to upgrade, and a lot of post-install issues.
The one big caveat is that on occasion, say once every 2 years, I hit a big issue on Linux that I can fix, but an average non-technical user would probably not be able to figure out, and would end up having to do a full reinstall (or get their family techie person to do it). I do feel like MS and Apple have mostly eliminated that sort of issue (though I could be wrong).
The other problem I see is that most people have an existing laptop and want to try Linux on it, and run into hardware incompatibilities. Unfortunately that's just how things are going to be; if you really want to try to run Linux on a laptop, you need to make your purchasing decision with that in mind. You never really think about that when you run macOS or Windows, because Macs/PCs are designed to run that particular OS, and the manufacturer guarantees that everything will work. This phenomenon is especially bad for people with Mac laptops; at this point anything after 2016 means a lot of pain and things that just won't work. Even with a 2016 MacBook Pro you're going to be fighting to get things set up.
On the flip side, if you get something that's designed with Linux in mind (like the Dell XPS 13 or something from System76), you're going to have a much better time. But I totally get that most people won't want to buy a new laptop and would prefer to give Linux a spin on whatever they have already. It's just that results are going to be wildly mixed in that case.
> The other problem I see is that most people have an existing laptop and want to try Linux on it, and run into hardware incompatibilities.
Yes, a thousand times. I ran into that more often than I would have expected just trying to get Linux to run in a VM on various Macs over the years, and once in a while on more recent PC hardware that I was trying to do something with. (Then I would write something that suggested Linux was still hard to install and people would argue with me. If it ever comes up again, I should definitely remember to add your caveat about existing hardware!)
I get that these are in large part technically the fault of third-party developers, but it’s still pretty inconvenient as an end user to be unable expect to upgrade my OS without some major portion of my workflow being entirely non-functional for months.
Probably, but maybe not for the reasons you would think...
> so I had a credible "Works" style office suite (GoBe Productive)
Haiku has a LibreOffice port.
> a good text editor (Pe),
Pe is still around, or you can use Koder (a new Haiku-native app), Notepadqq, GVim, Kate, ...
> a good GUI mail client (Mail-It)
We have a few mail clients; the native one is alright but could use some work; there is also Trojita and some others like it.
> a surprisingly good object/bitmap hybrid graphics editor kind of like the old Macromedia Fireworks (e-Picture)
e-Picture has gone the way of the dodo (though you probably can still use it on 32-bit Haiku which has BeOS binary compatibility.) You can instead use WonderBrush (a native application), Krita, etc.
Sure, I could find something that would give me more familiar bindings at the system level, but I'd then also have to (hope that it's even possible to) also deal with all of the downstream apps that then have to use different ones, because the globals in macOS have superseded whatever they'd be using on other systems.
It's like dealing with English grammar. Swap Cmd for Ctrl and Ctrl(?) for Alt, except when you're switching tabs or windows and it's the exact opposite, or when whatever operation you need is bound to Option for some reason.
The laptop is increasingly a thin client these days as everything I want to do is either inside a TLS session in a browser, or I'm controlling remote Xen, KVM hypervisors and virtual machines (either by SSH or VNC-over-SSH) that have much more cpu and ram resources than could ever be reasonably squeezed into a laptop.
The highly refined macbook touchpad user interface is also a part of it. Nothing matches it in the market space intended as Windows-10 laptops.
For me what makes Linux on a laptop a really bad and unreliable experience overall is a combination of poor quality/small touchpads, poor quality microphone built in near the keyboard, poor quality screens (you have to pay a LOT to get a screen anywhere near the quality of a macbook air or pro, and I absolutely detest 16:9 ratio laptop screens), and general unreliability in suspend/resume functionality.
Stability seems to have gone right out the window, with my machine crashing on a daily basis. It really doesn't like being plugged and unplugged from its Thunderbolt dock, which was a straight up non-problem prior to Mojave.
It's also slower. OSX never felt as immediate as Linux or BSD, but it's gotten even worse.
When I have some time, I'm going to toss a systemd-free Linux on my old Macbook Air with the garbage keyboard, and see how it feels as a desktop system.
Pretty sure I'll miss the consistency of the user interface. That's my biggest gripe about the FOSS world: the user experience is generally shit. And there are a few apps for which I don't have a good replacement yet (Dash being the biggie).
And I'm not sure what to do on the phone front: the iPhone is the best hardware by far, but I barely use mine for anything other than the web and watching videos. Will play with a Pinephone and see if it does the job.
But everything else I can do between a terminal and a browser, and given that I'm not happy with where Apple is going, it seems like it's time to start getting off the train.
I seriously doubt you will run into more problems with Ubuntu or Fedora than you would with FreeBSD. It’s been awhile since I’ve tried, but the BSDs are basically optionless if you want to take full advantage of modern graphics cards. You boot into Ubuntu and the graphics stack, WiFi or Ethernet, it all just works. BSD is like using Linux a decade ago at best.
I tried FreeBSD on the desktop and it was sparse and a PITA. I'm sure they can catch up to where Ubuntu was a few years ago, but I'm currently running AAA VR games on Steam on Linux -- no reason to change what I'm running now.
I've found if all you're doing is developing then FreeBSD is fine. If you bring simple multi-media use cases into the mix then things get a bit hairy.
Ubuntu certainly helps, but it's also hairy when things go wrong or get close to going wrong.
I just turn my Mac on and get on with working in a Unix environment.
Therefore I always use either nixos or freebsd for all my work.
I think sometimes choice is a problem. I like a walled garden for some things.
Which is great until they change how it all works. Something as simple as setting up a keyboard layout that applies for any login manager - first it was in xorg.conf, then it was in some HAL XML file, then it was a udev rule file, god knows where you can do it now. Connecting to the network - first it was ifconfig, then it was iwconfig, now it's some dbus NetworkManager incantation that doesn't work. Sound - first you learn a bunch of OSS commands, then everything gets switched to ALSA, then everything gets switched to PulseAudio and blows your eardrums...
FreeBSD may not be as "just works", but they don't keep changing everything. I'd far rather have a system that stays understandable, even if that means configuration is a little more manual.
But in terms of actually being able to get things done as a desktop workstation, and software I can run natively on it, I could replicate almost exactly the same setup starting from a bare bones debian bullseye (testing) install, then adding xorg and xfce4 and customizing xfce4.
That's the setup I'm using now - I ended up adding a ton of gnome and kde related libraries so that I can run software derived from both projects. Yes it uses multiple gigabytes of disk space, but now I have a solid setup that can run just about any Linux GUI application, and Windows 10 inside virtualbox full screen on a second monitor to the side.