News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by m_eiman on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:06AM (#26488872)
Having username+password+sms is strictly safer than having username+password.

To require the attacker to know your phone number and do costly and/or time consuming things to get access to it means moving from "script kiddie re-using username+password from leaked user databases" to "targeted attacks".

Sure, it's not Safe(tm), but it's a big step up from just username+password.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by dataflow on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:17AM (#26488955)
Not quite. It's only safer if your single priority in the world is protecting that one account. But you need to account for the larger blast radius too: it also turns your SMS, phone line, and other things that revolve around them into actual attack targets, when they weren't previously. The increased potential for collateral damage can very well not be worth it.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by MaxBarraclough on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:42AM (#26489126)
Also, it gains increased security at the cost increased chance of lockout. Water damage to your phone may now be enough to prevent you from signing in.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by alistairSH on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:16AM (#26490716)
Water damage would also prevent access to MFA apps like Google Authenticator. And many/most people (world-wide) are accessing the web through their mobile device anyways - so damaged phone = no web access.

That leaves us with physical keys, which the average consumer probably doesn't want to carry around all the time (easy enough to keep on keychain, but most people don't carry keys around their own home).

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by ghgdynb1 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:34PM (#26494382)
I use 1Password for my mfa; I can access my one time passcodes from any device I’m signed in on, and my passwords and secondary authentication are conveniently managed together. If issues like water damage or losing your device are concerns for you, their service might be worth checking out.

Disclaimer: I’m very far from a cybersecurity expert.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by alistairSH on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:42PM (#26494506)
Two problems I see with this approach...

1. Consumers are terrible at security. Asking them to subscribe to a password management/MFA tool is likely to fail. If this were baked into iOS/Android, this would be better.

2. Many banks don't support this MFA scheme. A quick poke around 2fa.directory shows a massive number that don't support MFA at all, and another huge bunch that do SMS/email but not software/hardware. This puts consumers in the position of juggling multiple MFA schemes to access various sites.

I don't disagree with you in principle. But until there's a more standard approach to MFA, people will continue to use SMS because it's easy and broadly available as an MFA scheme.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by ghgdynb1 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:37PM (#26495153)
On top of that 1Password is quite pricey, albeit fully featured. I probably wouldn't use it if not for my family's plan.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by falcolas on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:22AM (#26490818)
Google Auth can be backed up (via a QR code), and it works fine on two devices simultaneously.

Most places that offer 2FA auth apps also offer backup codes, which can be stored in any password manager, or offline in a little black book.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by jjav on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:28PM (#26495777)
> Water damage would also prevent access to MFA apps like Google Authenticator.

No, since you can back up the seed in a secure location.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by alistairSH on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:55PM (#26498668)
Which you access through the same broken phone (for most internet users).
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by ehnto on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:40AM (#26489660)
It's notoriously difficult to regain access to many types of accounts, but that's in part because of how little we verify ourselves in the first place.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by asiachick on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:53AM (#26489218)
It is? I thought the problem with SMS is you click "forgot password" and they send you a code via SMS to reset your password. Therefore username+password is safer than username+password+sms because username+password+sms = username (no password)
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by wccrawford on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:02AM (#26489305)
I think you mean:

username+password+sms = username+sms (no password)

But I agree, and would take it a step further:

username+password+sms = username+sms || username+password

And in the worst scenarios:

username+password+sms = sms || username+password

And the same goes for email instead of SMS as well, in most scenarios.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by 33Backpack33 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:36PM (#26493509)
username + unique password would be better than all the other options listed.

Adding SMS seems to add new points of attack that either hurt the user or just delays the hurting.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by hansel_der on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:58AM (#26489273)
i agree that username+sms is not good, but what are the other password reset vectors more secure than sms?
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by caskstrength on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:04AM (#26489324)
Almost anything (with exception of "3 easily googleable questions about you") is safer than sms. For example, emailing password reset link to my gmail account that is protected with real 2fa.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by lxgr on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:09AM (#26489380)
Yes, and besides being more secure it is also more available: I'm much more likely to be able to receive email when resetting a password than I am to have cell reception and have the correct SIM card in my phone. (Examples for access to email but not SMS include: International travel, airplane Wi-Fi, bad cell signal.)

I feel like much of what's wrong with SMS 2FA comes down to a misguided idea of "everyone has exactly one phone number", which is simply not true for a lot of people.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by scottmcdot on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:44AM (#26489698)
It's not safer if SMS can be used as a recovery method.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by HenryBemis on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:57AM (#26489818)
Yes, this. Is SMS used as a login/OTP (additional to your password - e.g. to make a bank transaction), or can be used as a 'trojan'/backdoor to compromise your account?
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by fanf2 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:32AM (#26490962)
And even if SMS starts off being just a second factor, it often gets changed to be used for account resets too, so it becomes a single vulnerable factor.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by gspr on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:32AM (#26490965)
> Having username+password+sms is strictly safer than having username+password.

As someone else pointed out: that's not true if the SMS authentication can be used to recover the password. But let's for the sake of discussion rule those cases out.

Then yes, SMS verification does perhaps add a tiny bit of "security" to the process for the reason you describe. But that tiny bit of security has to be weighed against the enormous extra burden placed on the users performing the (far more plentiful) legitimate logins. Than burden may well be worth it if a lot of extra security is gained. I think it's definitely not for the "security" provided by SMS.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by 33Backpack33 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:33PM (#26493469)
When you consider SMS 2FA is often used to fix the poor or reused password problem we see it's not helping much at all but only delaying the problem.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by ryanlol on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:09PM (#26495565)
That’s bullshit, nobody is going to bother with attacks like this to steal your uber or doordash account. SMS 2fa kills credential stuffing attacks for all but the highest value targets.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by 33Backpack33 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:37PM (#26495881)
You do know uber and doordash accounts are hacked all the time because of password reuse? There is a huge black market for hacked accounts from doordash and the like.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by ryanlol on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:39PM (#26498924)
That’s my point. These accounts are worth a couple of dollars, nobody would spend $50 on a hacked uber or doordash account.

These accounts are only worth anything as long as they’re cheaper and easier to use than stolen credit cards.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by 33Backpack33 on Thursday March 18, 2021 @06:16AM (#26501177)
The original VICE article said it was $16 and they can take as many accounts as they want. It seems worth it to me.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by ryanlol on Thursday March 18, 2021 @11:08AM (#26503460)
Yeah, because that $16 plan is totally going to last for long after people start abusing this at scale.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by jjav on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:27PM (#26495761)
> Having username+password+sms is strictly safer than having username+password.

No, it is unfortunately actually much worse.

If the account only has name+password and you use a properly good password, nobody will ever guess it (within the lifetime of the universe and all that).

But if the account also has a phone number and the attacker can trigger an SMS challenge to reset the password, now your wonderfully complex password is meaningless. The attackers just intercepts the SMS and done, they own the account.

It is equivalent to the problem of allowing "security questions" with trivially discoverable answers. A site may enforce 20+ character passwords (great!) but then forces user to enter the name of their best friend in high school (trivially findable in e.g. facebook for most people) and lets any attacker bypass the password with just the so-called security questions, rendering the strong password meaningless.

Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by rawfan on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:21AM (#26489483)
Nah. If I know your phone number, I hack you voicemail box in no time and then I can just access your Paypal account and you can do nothing against it. Just because you added a phone number to that account.
Re:Can We Stop Pretending SMS Is Secure Now? by hutzlibu on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:36AM (#26489611)
Yeah. That would be a targeted attack and not something a script kiddie can do.