As a salaried worker you are expected to do a job, if that job takes you 20 hours this week and 45 next week that's fine as long as the job is done.
What is currently happening is most of the time people work 50-60 hours and get paid at basically a 40 hour a week version of their job. So they end up giving the company 10-20 hours free (as it's not every now and then but basically every single week).
There are other motivations that can be added, say if you get a percentage of the company then you working 10-20 hours extra is accounted for by some other benefit.
But as it stands (say you work as a manager at random fastfood) there is no benefit to you working 60 hour weeks. You don't get extra money, you don't get benefits (some long time employees may get stock options but most don't). What's excepted of you does not correlate to the amount you are paid (which for random fastfood is usually what an hourly rate at 40 hours a week would be plus a little extra). If you did the same job as hourly (only difference being termination is easier for hourly than salaried) you would get paid more.
It's a perfectly valid question and one most should be asking.
The whole article says that this is a fantasy.
Get your job done in 20 hours a week and say I’m out and see what happens at the vast majority of companies.
The employer gets the free extra 5 hours in a 45 hour week but the employee gets judged (at best) for working 20 hours the next week.
But some roles (such as say programming) if you have X tasks a week and you get them all done in half the time and piece out in my mind that should be acceptable.
It shouldn't be acceptable that if you get all your tasks done in half the time they just give you a bunch of other tasks until you work exactly 40 hours. And there are others that take 2x to do all their tasks so you end up getting half of their tasks.
Being good at your job should be rewarded and encouraged and if that means saying "get all these done and if you get them done earlier and just as good you get Friday off" is a perfect motivator.
I think the problem is people grew up expecting to work 40 hours and if you don't work 40 hours you're a slacker. And that can be true, but it can also be completely wrong.
Great! Start a company and make this acceptable. Because the whole point of the article is that in practice this is almost never acceptable in the real world, regardless of what the definition of “exempt” is.
I suspect the problem is with measuring what "job is done" means exactly when it comes to intellectual work in a team, so companies use a simplistic "X hours worked" as a proxy.
No such thing as job security.
If you're good, they won't throw you out even if you're a freelancer. If you're bad they will throw you out even if you're an employee.
I did both and the only difference I saw was the type of work you do. As a freelancer I have less hand-holding than an employee, but also more freedom.
Hiring, getting a headcount was hard. Exactly because employees were harder to let go and a bigger investment. We were 5-6 on our team over 6 years and had 4 contractors on and off on the side during that time. And it was as simple as: sorry guys, we won't need your service for the next 6 months, because this and that. (Our work was always planned ahead for 6 months, decision made 2x a year.)
Despite the horror stories, particular those in the game industry, most are not working 60 hours/week. The most surefire way to make good money and become wealthy is by working at one of the FAANGs and investing. I know the startup founder is romanticized here and in the media, and in the rare cases when it works, it can be great. But, if you look at the risk adjusted value, startups are not very good.
With that said, I prefer small companies/startups because I like the freedom and control that comes along. I know I'm leaving money on the table, but I'm getting things I value over money.
The risk and opportunity cost seem way to high. Then again I don't know how to measure that risk...
Sure, freelancer/consultant is a valid path, but only if you're good at (and enjoy) marketing & sales. Otherwise - you can get lucky to work for a startup that IPOs (or a company whose shares increase dramatically) and end up earning a lot more as salaried.
> You want the $ figure and job security of the salaried employee Yes. I don't see why I should have to live without job security because I am paid hourly.
> but not the duties. Nope. I want a healthy work-life balance and I don't think that has to mean not meating my duties.
> You don't want to be classified like a contract worker, subject to termination at any time Again, yes. I want to be respected and live without the looming terror of joblessness.
> you want the flexibility to work when and as you please. You want the freedom to not have your hours monitored, your steps and productivity measured Yes. I think I aught to be respected enough to not need micro-managing at every turn.
> but not the responsibilities that come with such autonomy. Again, nope.
> Wouldn't it be wonderful if we could create some parallel lalaland universe... It's not so far fetched. There are plenty of places the world over that already treat their employees like valuable, respected, worthy people.
Let's not pretend that employees woke up one day and decided to be more self-interested. Employers have been working on eroding job security and employee rights for years.
Countries with better rights for employees exist in this universe, on this planet.
You might have more job security in other countries, but your job might be theoretical.
You can't have it all.
> The US has high innovation.
> US employees have poor job security.
> Therefore high innovation must be caused by poor job security.
There are many historic and contemporary causes for the US's economic success. Arguably, the US was even more innovative in the 50s and 60s when job security was much better and unions were more powerful.
Europe has far less unemployment than the US.
Please stop.
You want the $ figure and job security of the salaried employee, but not the duties. You don't want to be classified like a contract worker, subject to termination at any time, but you want the flexibility to work when and as you please. You want the freedom to not have your hours monitored, your steps and productivity measured, but not the responsibilities that come with such autonomy.
Wouldn't it be wonderful if we could create some parallel lalaland universe where normal constraints no longer worked as they do. While we're at it, I want an airplane that's cheap, fast, doesn't use liquid fuel, and doesn't hurt the environment. I think we can all be billionaires.