This is by far the most common approach around the world - the same approach is taken in the UK, for example. It's in place for three reasons:
1. We worked out that about 90% of deaths in the first wave would have been prevented if we had been able to vaccinate the most vulnerable groups. This is A Good Thing, both in ite own terms, but also in terms of preventing healthcare systems being overwhelmed.
2. There was no evidence at the beginning that the vaccine prevented transmissibility - only that it prevented serious illness. So the preventing deaths strategy made sense.
3. It's simple to organise and roll-out at speed - and speed is of the essence. Doctors have people's ages and medical vulnerability on record, so you can very quickly draw up lists of who is eligible for vaccination in each cohort. Compare this with trying to arrange vaccination by (say) profession.
Regarding #2, I think no one seriously thinks the vaccine could fail to prevent spread (it surely is not 100% sterilizing, but everyone acts under the assumption it will vastly reduce spread). "There is no evidence for X" can be said for the vast majority of values of X, since most X are impossible and/or too time consuming to study. This includes, for example, X = "the best way to use the vaccine is to give a first round of second doses before a second round of first doses". But we often have to make decisions in the face of imperfect data.
#3 is ridiculous because the logic appears to be, "the best rollout plan is the one that's easiest to enforce". By this logic, we should line up by height, like we did in elementary school when heading to the toilet.
(Personally know someone who’d have gotten a diagnosis and treatment earlier by at least a couple of months if not for Covid)
You have to take a few factors into account when deciding if preventing the spread is your objective. Given the staggering number of cases already out there, the time it takes to vaccinate so many people, and the number of people not willing to be vaccinated, your preferred strategy would be slow (if it worked at all, due to some people refusing to be vaccinated).
In addition, people in the high-risk groups are not fully isolated. Some work, some walk around without masks, some travel. People tend to cluster in age groups, so if one person in the 65+ group gets it, they're going to interact with others in that age group. If a college student gets it, the probability of sustained interaction with someone over 65 is much lower.
If you want to pick a nit with US vaccination policy with better grounding, aim at the fact that, with the two-dose mRNA vaccines, we're prioritizing the second dose much more heavily than we should. Numbers after a first dose show something like 70% effectiveness[1]. We should be getting everyone their first dose NOW and not wasting all that effectiveness on the comparatively less impactful booster.
[1] Which is to say, a "1-dose" Pfizer or Moderna vaccine is almost exactly equivalent to the actually-single-dose J&J vaccine.
By the way, I've seen that the mRNA vaccines are even more effective than that after the first dose, if you just consider the period from about 10 days onward, ie after it has had a chance to kick in. Here in BC they're quoting a demonstrated efficacy of "up to 90%" from 10 days through to at least 3 months.
That part I'm not so sure about.
[1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-superspreadin...
If I was responsible for policy, I would ask (have asked) a scientist to model this rather than stating it as opinion.
I suspect that any model would just show you to be extremely wrong, for a virus which is already circulating freely.
Decisions made about people must have a feedback loop to learn from how people react to it. For example, the lockdown became ineffective when it was extended too long. People were initially very compliant. We were told it’s only till we can prepare our hospitals and prepare a contact tracing strategy. It was convenient for politicians to extend the lockdown than solve those two problems. Net result was that people started ignoring the lockdown more and more. Police can enforce bans on outdoor gatherings; people simply gather at home.
It’s precisely because we ignore the human element that we keep dragging this.
It is not even a guaranteed solution. It will bring back cases to almost zero. In some rare cases, incubation time can be way longer than 21 days, you are also going to have people with weak immune systems that can contain the infection but not eliminate it completely, plus all the bad things that can happen: mutations, animal transmission, etc...
Then, if we just go back to business as usual after the super-lockdown, it will spread again, just as it started. As long as R>1 there is no way to win. And for now the only way to keep R<1 is to make our lives more or less miserable (today's solution), herd immunity through infections (and let millions die), and herd immunity though vaccines (our goal).
I believe that no significant mutation has been sourced to any country with less than a million cases.
That's not a coincidence.
Increased cases = increased mutation incubators.
I agree it's a political problem - a political solution is proven by Asian democracies and Australasian democracies. As you say, it was pretty obvious that a 21-day lockdown with appropriate testing and follow-up would have resolved this issue in any country.
The people's right to have an opinion does not change the truth, that an indefinitely long half-lockdown is a bad compromise between opinions.
If the alternative is the imperfect half-lockdown then so be it. What matters now is a sharp focus on when normal life can resume.
In my view that point is when the elderly and people with comorbidities have been vaccinated, which is within reach now.
Why not? Just because a bunch of people hold that opinion? Political change happens despite groups of people not wanting it - that's almost the definition of politics.
Scientists working for the UK government at Imperial College rejected lockdown as a plan (even what we have now in the UK) because they found it not politically viable: that's a danger to everyone.
Many people agree with you. Vaccinating the most mobile people and isolating the most "immobile" (retirees, children, sick) is very logical.
My guess is politicians know it but they would never make such a decision. It'd be a political suicide.
Only if you know that the vaccine prevents or even reduces transmissibility - which we didn't until well after the vaccine roll-out
Given that's true, those older folk, at the most risk are the place to start.
(Also, sorry for the vaguely propagandist source -- I originally heard about this on a podcast and am having trouble determining which, and this doesn't seem to be getting much coverage in English-language print media.)
Because CCP is not worried about losing the next election.
I've always argued that preventing spread would as a byproduct prevent death, but I'm obviously not studied in the field.
Put shortly, I would have vaccinated college kids and working age folks first. They are not likely to die from it, but are far more likely to spread it than elderly and severely diseased folks.