News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:09PM (#26438816)
Pinker is the wrong person to do it. A lot of baggage.

If this is a story you're generally enthusiastic about, a better person to pay attention to is probably John McWhorter (also a linguist!). I don't cosign all that much of what McWhorter has to say about this topic, but he has much better bona fides.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by rayiner on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:23PM (#26438993)
I kinda feel bad for John McWhorter. On Twitter, he gets attacked as a sell-out to his race (including by white people!) for strongly holding what are basically widely held center-left positions. It's thankless work.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:43PM (#26439261)
I wouldn't feel too bad. McWhorter has deliberately picked the fights he's in (see for instance his longstanding feud with Ta-Nehisi Coates) and deliberately associated with IDW-types specifically, I think, to troll leftists. It's too bad, because I think he's got a lot of important stuff to say about figures like Ibram X Kendi.

(Like I said, I think McWhorter is worth paying attention to. Also, he has one of the great podcasts.)

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by rayiner on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:05PM (#26439559)
I agree it doesn't help his cause. But I can totally empathize about his feud with TNC. It sticks in my craw when progressive asians claim the mantle of being asian, while pushing views that are in the minority among asians. My reaction is always "yeah, but what would your dad say?" I quite relate to this one of McWhorter's tweets: https://twitter.com/JohnHMcWhorter/status/112988149829800345....
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by yanderekko on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:54PM (#26439411)
>deliberately associated with IDW-types specifically, I think, to troll leftists.

Huh? It seems like McWhorter genuinely has a lot of intellectual overlap with "IDW-types". McWhorter himself is often considered an "IDW-type" himself, no? Why should his association be remotely surprising?

Why should the existence of a feud with TNC be intrinsically concerning? Are feuds intrinsically concerning? Or is TNC simply beyond reproach?

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:10PM (#26439604)
You are arguing from a radically different premise than I am; I didn't say Ta-Nehisi Coates was above reproach, or that there was anything intrinsically wrong with feuding with him. I think if we're this far apart to begin with, it's probably not going to be especially productive to try to hash things out further.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by pso on Friday March 12, 2021 @05:58PM (#26441992)
IDW - Intellectual Dark Web
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by andyxor on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:10PM (#26438829)
who's the right person to do it, with no 'baggage'?
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:12PM (#26438849)
It really is a lot of baggage. Another person who would strongly agree with the idea that campus culture has become corrupted is Charles Murray. But you can see immediately why Charles Murray couldn't be the figure that reform unified behind! Pinker is, like, 650-750 milliMurrays. He gave a statement that had the intended effect of getting Epstein his sweetheart sentence! Just fatally compromised, for a bunch of reasons.

Beyond the Epstein stuff, and to calibrate the Murrayometer, I'd suggest searches like [Pinker Hsu], [Pinker Bell Curve], [Pinker "Groups and Genes"], [Pinker UCSB shooting], [Pinker "Richard Haier"]. You might be fine with all these search results! I'm saying: you're not going to be building a lot of bridges with this resume.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by Natsu on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:53PM (#26439392)
It seems to me that these discussions always trend towards something like "why are all the people complaining about witch burning so witchey?"

I won't defend this guy, I believe you regarding the baggage, I just think that ignoring voices like that is part of the problem here.

I've disagreed with you many times on many things, but I still think it's worth listening to you because you have a point of view that merits serious consideration that should not be dismissed without looking past the speaker to the content of what is said.

We often talk about 'filter bubbles' but the most important one has always existed in our own minds. It becomes an issue when we end up marking serious points by serious thinkers as if they were mere spam that we don't want to do any intellectual work to deal with. This isn't to suggest that we can read and consider everything by everyone, attention is always going to be limited, but we need to be aware of our own spam filter that we're avoiding dealing with all the people saying X because we find the idea dislikeable, leaving us with a less-considered position on the subject.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:11PM (#26439630)
See, I'm not arguing about whether it's a good idea to rehabilitate people like Pinker. I'm saying that Pinker is going to have a hard time, in effect, rehabilitating himself, and so it's not necessarily newsworthy that he's attempting to do so (who wouldn't?) --- it won't get him anywhere. That's why I gave McWhorter as the counterexample, of someone who has a better chance at cutting through the noise.

(Cards on the table, I find Pinker odious. But I'm trying not to let my personal opinion of him color what I think is a pretty non-normative argument, at least not too much).

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by Natsu on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:33AM (#26462660)
I'm not really concerned about the people, I'm concerned about the trend of how much the talk about the person eclipses talk about their ideas... even as I realize that I'm falling into the same trap in this very comment.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by andyxor on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:14PM (#26438892)
I'm not sure how ad-hominem personal attacks suddenly became the primary way of debate.

Attack the speaker and undermine his credibility instead of arguing about what he has to say. I see it time after time in online and offline discussions.

Which kind of illustrates his point.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:17PM (#26438916)
I'm arguing substantively with you. The argument is about the trustworthiness of someone else. The concept of the ad hominem fallacy does not mean it is impossible to discuss someone else's credibility.

Perhaps we've had our wires crossed, and you think I'm arguing "because Pinker says campus culture is corrupted, campus culture must be fine, because Pinker is corrupted". That is not my argument.

A good resource on this is the "Ad Hominem Fallacy Fallacy" post, and I recommend it to you heartily.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by mushbino on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:22PM (#26438982)
At a certain point the messenger becomes the message. There is a big difference between isolated events and patterns.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by gpanders on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:19PM (#26438948)
What baggage, specifically?
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:20PM (#26438965)
See below (and ideally reply there, if you're moved to, thanks).
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by ojnabieoot on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:47PM (#26439321)
This is probably the most compelling reason to view Pinker as a less-than-good-faith actor here: https://newrepublic.com/article/68044/sex-ed

In 2005 then-Harvard president started a firestorm when he suggested that women were underrepresented in STEM fields because of genetic differences in academic ability. Pinker argued that people were being too politically correct, and suggested that the (true) fact of genetic differences between men implies that there could be a genetic difference in cognitive ability.

But the assumed “fact” that women were statistically less skilled than men in STEM fields was already starting to disintegrate in 2005, as boys were falling behind academically and girls were accelerating, a trend continuing in to 2021. It is ridiculous to think that women somehow got better STEM genes in the space of 40 years. Sociological and political/economic factors are clearly responsible for the change and current discrepancy.

So the idea that the difference is “genetic” is horseshit and has been horseshit since long before 2005. Specifically, it is a bold scientific claim that contradicted current and 2005-era understanding of human biology, and requires far more evidence than some economist’s musing. Summers was wrong (factually and morally) to suggest otherwise and Pinker was wrong to defend it.

Note that Pinker didn’t merely defend Summers’s right to make unfactual remarks. Pinker defended Summers on the merits. I think he continued to defend these views as recently as 2014. In my view this (along with Pinker’s general reactionary tendencies) gives people a good reason to suspect that he’s a sexist jerk who can’t be trusted to engage with “cancel culture” issues honestly.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by yanderekko on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:59PM (#26439482)
>But the assumed “fact” that women were statistically less skilled than men in STEM fields was already starting to disintegrate in 2005, as boys were falling behind academically and girls were accelerating, a trend continuing in to 2021.

Summers' claim is not incompatible with this observation. Not only disagreeing with Summers/Pinker but questioning their fundamental standing as "good faith actors" on these grounds is sad, but unfortunately pretty common. Your assertions about the grounding or lack thereof of these ideas in 2005 are simply false, and there's a reason why Summers is still remembered as an egregiously noteworthy case of incipient cancel culture.

This seems to be the standard middlebrow recourse for having to deal with uncomfortable ideas - find a shoddy, overconfident "debunking" of the inconvenient expert view from a trusted source (this will often rely on obvious misconstruals of the claims that the expert actually made), then call the experts "bad faith actors" when they continue to espouse said views.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by ojnabieoot on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:32PM (#26439889)
> why Summers is still remembered as an egregiously noteworthy case of incipient cancel culture.

Come on, man. If you’re the president of an organization and you get yourself into a situation where the majority of your women employees think you’re a reactionary bigoted jerk, then it doesn’t really matter if you actually deserved it or if you merely made a PR mistake. It doesn’t even matter if it’s due to an unfair media feeding frenzy! You are the president and you badly failed in your mission to lead that organization.

Summers absolutely deserved to lose his job as president (which was a voluntary resignation). Even if you give him the greatest possible benefit of the doubt, his actions were profoundly irresponsible leadership. And he didn’t lose tenure, he just lost a cushy side gig. Other university/corporate presidents have lost their job for far less.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by yanderekko on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:51PM (#26440115)
>If you’re the president of an organization and you get yourself into a situation where the majority of your women employees think you’re a reactionary bigoted jerk

If Summers' comments trigger this sentiment then I think it's fair to label this as "egregiously noteworthy." It's similar to the exaggerated claims we see with regularity nowadays that those with unpopular views must be punished because they're making their peers "feel unsafe" - there was in fact an (undoubtedly less-enlightened) time when this sort of teeth-gnashing was seen as unprofessional.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by hntrader on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:56PM (#26439445)
So you know the variability hypothesis to be false, then? Or you know it to have no real world consequences? How did you acquire such knowledge?

  "boys were falling behind academically"
This also follows from the variability hypothesis, since grades have negative skewness instead of metrics like citations which have positive skewness.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by ojnabieoot on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:15PM (#26439670)
This is what I said:

> Specifically, [the “variability hypothesis”] is a bold scientific claim that contradicted current and 2005-era understanding of human biology, and requires far more evidence than some economist’s musing. Summers was wrong (factually and morally) to suggest otherwise and Pinker was wrong to defend it.

It is very much a Flying Spaghetti Monster problem: at this point the preponderance of evidence is that there is no inherent difference in the reasoning abilities of men and women, and that any measured difference is much more easily explained by societal factors than genetics. The default hypothesis is that there is no difference and I have not seen any convincing evidence otherwise - evidence which purports to show a difference is always tainted beyond usefulness.

Your argument is equivalent to the observation that I haven’t personally mapped out all of Earth’s orbit so how can I prove there’s no Flying Spaghetti Monster? It is not very convincing!

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by hntrader on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:24PM (#26439772)
Everyone already agrees that there aren't meaningful mean-level differences between the sexes, aside from in a small handful of personality traits or irrelevant physical traits.

You still haven't addressed why different variances (for which there is a lot of evidence) in one or more of interests/traits/skills are a nonstarter as an explanation for an outcome gap at extreme percentiles.

I'd be the first to agree that the burden of proof is on Pinker and Summers as far as advancing it from hypothesis to theory goes. But that's distinct from claiming the hypothesis itself is a nonstarter.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by pseudalopex on Friday March 12, 2021 @04:20PM (#26441089)
Pinker talked up mean level differences for 2 paragraphs before turning to variance.

Who said anything about extreme percentiles?

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by hntrader on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:35AM (#26445039)
Summers did, read his exact words. He's not only talking about gender balance in science but about top performers specifically.

Also now that you mention it, there are mean level differences at a young age in interests (people vs things), which is also a plausible explanation for gender disparity in STEM, whether that difference is genetic or cultural or both.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by pseudalopex on Saturday March 13, 2021 @08:46AM (#26446519)
The documented median and variability differences are modest. They're enough to explain 20% women at the +4 SD level if I recall correctly. But there are too many people in STEM fields for them to be so selective.

That seems to be in line with what Summers said. Pinker talked about gender balance specifically though.

Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by hntrader on Saturday March 13, 2021 @10:08AM (#26447033)
> They're enough to explain 20% women at the +4 SD level if I recall correctly

That's right if we're looking at univariable distributions.

> But there are too many people in STEM fields for them to be so selective.

Actually I agree now that the variability hypothesis is insufficient to explain why there's so many more men than women that self-select into STEM.

I think a more plausible explanation is mean differences in interests (which may or may not be genetic).

The variability hypothesis can possibly help to explain things like why most chess champions are men, but it can't explain why most people that play chess in the first place are men.

[dead]
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by dang on Friday March 12, 2021 @03:32PM (#26440534)
Ok, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by MisterBastahrd on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:38PM (#26439182)
McWhorter is a cultural hobbyist who throws bombs for attention.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @01:44PM (#26439275)
I think that's also a little bit true, yes.
Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture by notahacker on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:11PM (#26439618)
Aside from baggage, the article strongly suggests that Pinker has no clue about how to do it. Not only does he not offer a solution, but he hasn't even diagnosed the problem correctly. No Steven, your students are not signalling hostility to certain viewpoints because of 'Marxist critical theory and postmodernism'... even most politics students don't bother to read Adorno or Derrida and if they did they wouldn't find any suggestions to deplatform Charles Murray. And then he apparently suggests the discussion of these very marginal theories he dislikes within universities is also why some conservatives and libertarians don't find scientific consensus on global warming credible, as if the other side of the political spectrum had always trusted scientific theories whose implications conflicted with their core values until the woke left came along!

Complaining that students are being 'indoctrinated' by ideas he thinks are bad doesn't half sound like the censorious elements he's complaining about as well...

Edit: I do wish people who apparently disagree with my post would venture a defence of Pinker's "its the postmodernists" thesis. It's a marketplace of ideas...