Re:Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture
by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2021 @02:10PM
(#26439604)
You are arguing from a radically different premise than I am; I didn't say Ta-Nehisi Coates was above reproach, or that there was anything intrinsically wrong with feuding with him. I think if we're this far apart to begin with, it's probably not going to be especially productive to try to hash things out further.
Huh? It seems like McWhorter genuinely has a lot of intellectual overlap with "IDW-types". McWhorter himself is often considered an "IDW-type" himself, no? Why should his association be remotely surprising?
Why should the existence of a feud with TNC be intrinsically concerning? Are feuds intrinsically concerning? Or is TNC simply beyond reproach?