News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by ALittleLight on Monday March 08, 2021 @05:29AM (#26384194)
The opening example this article gives is preposterous. Who would make an HR complaint over one ill-considered remark? Who would want to work with a person who would? I agree with Google here that you should assume good intent coming from other people until they prove that wrong, and I don't think that standard was applied here.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by emptysongglass on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:16AM (#26384502)
At this point I just don't discuss my personal life with anyone I work with or if I do it's to respond with an, "I'm doing great, thanks, and how are you?" No after-work drinks or else I'll have one for the sake of appearing affable.

I'm a nice person but that any comment is potentially a landmine to me professionally, I'd just rather not expose myself like that. I can't count on anyone assuming good intent with me because everyone is so fired up on their crusader trains.

I'll give a personal example: when I was a Buddhist renunciate--this was right at the beginning of cancel culture--someone I thought to be a close friend posted a negative experience she had with a man. It didn't stop there: she proceeded to blast all men for not immediately talking to every man they knew about their inherent violence. I commented that from the perspective of peace, her exhortation would result in more anger, more rage in the world, not less.

My last name on Facebook at that time was my own creation, for the sake of my privacy. Immediately after my call for calm, I was doxxed and Facebook locked me out of my account until I could prove my last name.

In hindsight, she did me a great favor as I never returned to Facebook, which I now see as poison to the human mind.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by jedimastert on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:37AM (#26384651)
> I'm a nice person but that any comment is potentially a landmine to me professionally, I'd just rather not expose myself like that.

The exact reason I don't have a Twitter

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by Cthulhu_ on Monday March 08, 2021 @10:23AM (#26386671)
Smort; make the wrong remark or reply to the wrong person and you'll get dogpiled and hounded off the platform, possibly doxxed if you haven't taken steps to hide your identity and employer.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by Hnrobert42 on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:09AM (#26384835)
It seems like you sort of poked the bear in your example. I had a similar experience with a woman I dated, but I don’t assume that because she was unreasonable that all people are similarly unreasonable.

Life is about calculated risk, and in my estimation, the rewards of friendship outweigh the risks of alienation, especially if you open up incrementally and judiciously.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by lumberingjack on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:47AM (#26385123)
Yes but can't we reasonably imagine multiple human beings maybe even a large portion of the pop having only negative experiences with these exact same people? Can't talk about that it becomes racist. Like if every interaction one has had in there entire 45 year long life with black man was super negative you might start to think one way about all of those people.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by matheusmoreira on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:36AM (#26384642)
> she proceeded to blast all men for not immediately talking to every man they knew about their inherent violence

How is this not sexism?

[dead]
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by matheusmoreira on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:02AM (#26384798)
The fact is people cannot even share an article these days without fear of getting cancelled. Meanwhile you have women and other protected individuals literally posting things like "kill all men" and not only suffering zero consequences for it but also openly laughing at anybody who tries to call them out.

I'm not exaggerating either. The exact situation I described above has happened. This is absolutely not OK.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by matsemann on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:21AM (#26384906)
That sounds more like a comment meant to further divide people, than a realistic picture of what normally happens. You're also being intentionally vague. What kind of articles are being shared and people then getting "cancelled"? "Top 10 cute dog photos"? It's never the act of "merely sharing something" that gets people in trouble.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by matheusmoreira on Monday March 08, 2021 @09:22AM (#26386022)
I was vague because it doesn't really matter. I could cite specific cases I observed throughout the years but I won't. Suffice it to say that people should be able to post stuff without fearing for their job security. Posting something absolutely should not result in some Twitter mob calling your employer and demanding that you be fired. It doesn't really matter to me what the person posted, nobody deserves to be harmed that way over an internet comment.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by Hnrobert42 on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:11AM (#26384850)
I upvoted you, but I think people who are downvoting you see your comment as a kind of victim-blaming. Namely that GP was the victim of a doxxing, and you are blaming them.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by matsemann on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:17AM (#26384878)
Thanks, yeah I can see that. I was mainly commenting in response to the first two paragraphs, which left me a bit dumbfounded as to what everyone is so up in arms about. But I can also understand that if one has innocently been targeted for something, one will be extra cautious going forward.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by wombatmobile on Monday March 08, 2021 @05:49AM (#26384333)
Is it preposterous?

We don't have enough information on the actual exchange, or the context from this article.

"a colleague told them that their skin was much darker than she expected."

That might be benign, or hostile, or just candid and clumsy. It's hard to tell.

It's also not clear whether Google was asked to put forward a defence to the accusations made in the article.

"Google said in a statement that the company is committed to supporting employees who raise concerns about workplace treatment."

Again, the article doesn't provide enough context for us to know. Was the statement in response to a request to answer the allegations in the article, or was it a generic statement made without the context of these specific allegations?

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by ALittleLight on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:08AM (#26384449)
Of course it might be any of those things. Any comment, even one that sounds completely innocuous, may have subtle malicious connotations that people without context cannot infer. As the Google HR person suggested though, we should assume good motives where we don't have evidence to the contrary. You can't effectively work with other people if you're always assuming what they say is a veiled insult.

If there is context that makes this clearly malicious then the article should provide it. It's not reasonable to assume that context exists though. While it is reasonable to acknowledge it might exist - there's no evidence of it. Perhaps a teapot is in space orbiting the sun by itself.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by psychiatrist24 on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:03AM (#26384411)
Yes it is.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by soneca on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:04AM (#26384419)
By your standards a lot of very toxic people would get a pass by saying toxic stuff and they later saying _”I was just joking”_, thus ever denying their bad intent. And that kind of toxic-then-deny people are very, very common in workplaces.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by ALittleLight on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:27AM (#26384578)
No, I don't think so. I think it's perfectly appropriate to say stuff like "Hey, comments about my skin color are kind of uncomfortable for me. I'd prefer we not discuss it." If the person keeps talking about your skin color you can say - "Hey, remember we talked before about how I feel this is inappropriate?" And if they can't stop bringing it up it seems like you've ruled out good intent, or based on how they react when you bring it up you might rule out good intent.

Assuming good intent at first doesn't mean you're infinitely gullible or a doormat for people to walk on. It just means not being a landmine that is going to try to get people in trouble.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by zimbatm on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:36AM (#26384640)
It's just as toxic as people seeing *ism everywhere. They create an atmosphere of suspicion that is not conducive to free thinking.

Unfortunately in big groups you will have both of those types and HR is not good at managing finer-grained inter-personal issues. Without all of the context it's hard to judge group dynamics.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by throwawaygulf on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:39PM (#26393729)
>Who would make an HR complaint over one ill-considered remark?

It's painfully obvious you haven't been exposed to Bay Area/West Coast start-up culture (I envy your lack of exposure).

I've seen people getting reported to HR for the following things:

- Using a photo of a Sherpa (an actual photo, not a character or drawing) in a presentation to describe the concept of guiding people and systems to their desired outcome and state. They were reported for using racist caricatures of marginalized minorities

- Discussing shooting sports in a thread about hobbies. They were reported for making people feel unsafe

- Someone posted a screen shot of a Tweet in support of BLM, but the screen shot was from Blacktivist, a Twitter account that was part of a Russian propaganda campaign. Someone replied to the screen shot that maybe it should be taken down since it was literally created and pushed from a propaganda account. They were reported for being insensitive to PoC employees

These are just a few out of the dozens upon dozens. I'm sure many others here on HN could provide examples.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by villasv on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:06AM (#26384436)
> I agree with Google here that you should assume good intent

That’s probably because you can afford to.

Imagine you’re someone who had to file a grave complaint but the person got off the hook because “it was a one time thing, it’s his first offense”.

It’s important to document all microagression if you really want something to happen out of these complaints.

The accuser maybe felt the perp would likely be a repeating offender and is not open to feedback, so the effort to pile up complaints got initiated. This is how it’s done. I’d be happy to work with this person.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by ALittleLight on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:19AM (#26384525)
No, it's not important to document all "microagressions". It sounds like it would be a nightmare to work with any person who thought or acted like that.

The concept of microagressions is backwards and pernicious. People are imperfect communicators. Getting offended at cryptic, imagined, or unintended slights is something that children and crazy people do. Adults, especially in the workplace, should be able to understand people have different ways of expressing themselves and that's not bad and you don't need to get HR involved.

One example comes to mind - I had a coworker who frequently wrote "..." After messages on our instant messenger. Once I asked him a question and he just replied "..." And then 20 minutes later told me the answer. I read this as kind of a sarcastic thing, like an exasperated sigh that he'd have to explain something so obvious. I thought this guy was a real jerk.

One day after he sent me a "..." I asked him what it meant. I said "What does '...' signify?" And the guy answered that it meant "More to follow" and I realized that he wasn't being a jerk, he was just trying to signal to me that he couldn't complete the answer at the moment, but would send more to follow.

The point of my little story is that it just doesn't make sense to assume hostile motives. Lots of times people just communicate differently. Trying to document all the times you can interpret someone as being negative is just a bad idea in addition to being unfair and unproductive. It's also way more likely to make people genuinely aggressive and hostile towards you.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by randomcarbloke on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:34AM (#26384627)
We already have politesse, "microagressions" is either misperception of impolitesse or a means to reframe perceived slights as far more malicious than they usually are.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by itronitron on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:51AM (#26384736)
Also, I hope people realize that as a workplace becomes more diverse the probability increases that one person will be offended by another person's casual turn of phrase. For example, the phrase 'went south' which means that something went badly might be deeply offensive to someone from the South.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by villasv on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:25AM (#26384568)
You definition of microagression isn’t usual or useful. That’s why the rest of the argument made sense, but missed the point.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by ALittleLight on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:33AM (#26384619)
Google defines microagression as -

"a statement, action, or incident regarded as an instance of indirect, subtle, or unintentional discrimination against members of a marginalized group such as a racial or ethnic minority"

That is consistent with the definition I had in mind when I wrote my comment. I do think trying to document unintended offenses is a bad idea. The recipient of the microagression should instead learn not to dwell on minor slights, ignore them, and/or assume good intent instead. It seems very toxic to live as if the people you talk to are secretly hurting you. Better to think of them as nice people with different methods of communication until they prove otherwise.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by villasv on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:45AM (#26384700)
As you can see in that definition, intent is irrelevant. Assuming good intent doesn’t change the fact it is regarded as an instance of discrimination. Might be unintentional, but it still is what is is.

You keep saying “imaginary”, but microagression is about what has been said, not relevant to dwell on what the person might have wanted to mean.

You keep coming back to this perceived paranoia: “as if people are secretly trying to hurt you”. This is not what this is about. This is people that got hurt, and no matter what others are trying, secretly or not, that hurt is better be documented.

It doesn’t mean that someone ought to be punished right away for each comment deemed offensive by anyone. It’s just that these occurrences might be relevant later on and if they’re not documented, it’s gone.

Documenting all offenses is a good idea for people who are at risk of finding themselves needing that later. And if you don’t think this happens frequently enough, you haven’t been paying attention.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by lordloki on Monday March 08, 2021 @08:28AM (#26385449)
It sounds to me like people get hurt by microagressions because they have been taught that microagressions exist in the first place. That is once you have been convinced that microaggressions are a problem you will find them everywhere, since they are primarily a matter of interpretation. The entire concept then creates a negative environment where everyone feels they need to walk on eggshells all the time. This is more unhealthy to society and groups, than the microaggressions. It creates distrust, where assuming the best fosters trust. I see the entire concept of "microaggressions" as a downward spiral.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by jfengel on Monday March 08, 2021 @11:07AM (#26387181)
Try looking at it in reverse: the stress you feel about "microaggressions" is similar to what people are complaining about. It's a minor thing, something you can live with individually, except that as a constant daily drumbeat.

Microaggressions do exactly what you say: force people to feel as if they're walking on eggshells. And telling them "Oh, just shake it off" gets exactly the same response as if I told you to just shake off the accusations of microaggressions.

The downward spiral already exists: people do exhibit a range of racist, sexist, etc. behavior on a spectrum every day, from outright asshole behavior to small, incidental assumptions about people that make them feel unwanted and singled out. It afflicts some people more than others. So you can take this as a thought experiment to see why it's a problem for them, and if "just ignore it" doesn't work for you, then maybe we can find a better answer.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by throwawaygulf on Monday March 08, 2021 @08:17PM (#26394098)
>It's a minor thing, something you can live with individually, except that as a constant daily drumbeat.

Your entire argument is based on this pretence that is demonstrably false.

Getting reported to HR by these neurotic professional victims is not something you can "just shake off", you literally can't "just ignore it".

It's asymmetrical warfare, and the externalities are all on you, the microagressor.

All of this reminds me of the 90s when Evangelicals wanted schools to ban students from talking about, wearing clothing with, or playing anything related to Pokemon, because it was an affront and a "microagression" to their religion.

Here we are, just a few decades later and leftists and SJWs are now the ones playing the victims, being "microagressed".

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by villasv on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @08:35AM (#26398581)
> It sounds to me like people get hurt by microagressions because they have been taught that microagressions exist in the first place.

And I can assure you that this is not the case. They've always been perceived and caused hurt. The difference is that we now have a name for it and decided that people deserve better.

> since they are primarily a matter of interpretation

They are not.

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by zo1 on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:03AM (#26384803)
This individual that made the complaint sounds like a bully and very toxic to any group/team they are a part of (no matter how genuine or well-meaning they sound or feel personally). Personally, I would find it very uncomfortable to work with them and I would not feel safe around them. Likewise I would worry about my coworkers being around them at the same time, especially those that aren't well-suited to deal with individuals such as this.

I mean look at how far this thing has escalated. Does that seem like healthy group behavior to you?

Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by villasv on Monday March 08, 2021 @08:06AM (#26385268)
Things have escalated because HR handled the matter badly. The behavior of creating documentation has nothing wrong with it, counting on it to be properly addressed.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by zo1 on Monday March 08, 2021 @12:25PM (#26388493)
So how could they have handled it better?
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by shark_laser on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:19AM (#26384891)
Can't help but think parent article and this perspective are related to this: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/black-unemployment-rate-rises...
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by ycombinete on Monday March 08, 2021 @06:39AM (#26384659)
Yet you’ve assumed so much good intent on behalf of the accuser; and bad intent on side of the accused.
Re:Google advised mental health care when workers complained... by villasv on Monday March 08, 2021 @08:03AM (#26385246)
I assumed nothing, I'm pointing out that there are plausible situations that justify the behavior condemned by parent comment. I'm not passing judgement on this particular instance being reported.