News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by echelon on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:01AM (#26373843)
Why are we introducing scarcity to digital goods? That's not a good thing and shouldn't be praised!

We rail against companies selling cosmetic additions to games. It doesn't add value.

We already have "ownership". The legal framework of copyrights, purchase or goods, and licenses.

NFTs are barcodes. People are selling cryptographic barcodes.

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by distances on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:43AM (#26374049)
I fully agree. I hadn't heard of these NFTs before, but sounds like a dystopia to me, a perversion of the underpinnings of the digital world.
Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by jonwalch on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:42AM (#26376693)
There's tens of millions of people that disagree with you regarding cosmetics in games. Gamers largely have disposable income and are happy that they can support their favorite game developers and look "cool" (show off their status) while doing it.
Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by whateveracct on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:33AM (#26377225)
Cosmetics in games largely have value due to the game being online and multiplayer, which means NFTs aren't useful for them because there is already a central server to manage ownership.

They don't buy cosmetics just to show off their status, but to actually make their character look different when playing with a group of people who can see it. It's rarely "oh look - expensive" it's more "oh look - freaking Cowboy Ursa lmao"

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by nikisweeting on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:55PM (#26378577)
That will change when cosmetics can be shared across multiple games, which is already starting to grow with the onset of custom multi-game avatar+identity APIs being provided to game developers.

When you avatar persists across multiple different games, it makes sense to have an ownership mechanism that isn't managed by a single central authority.

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by echelon on Sunday March 07, 2021 @04:07PM (#26379769)
What economic incentive to game developers have to respect NFT ownership? Or anyone, for that matter?

In VRChat, you can be any model.

If I had a game, I wouldn't care who owned the NFT. It's not a value add. As far as I'm concerned, anybody could use it.

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by nikisweeting on Monday March 08, 2021 @12:30AM (#26382560)
The incentive is that the players care about it, and players will actively choose games that respect their avatar/NFT ownership because it allows them to show off their prized avatar and share their persona with a larger audience.
Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by echelon on Monday March 08, 2021 @12:57AM (#26382683)
Okay, but that doesn't mean companies will have economic incentive to support decentralization.

Games don't honor any fiat currency or stocks I hold, any unlocks I made on other platforms, or my Reddit upvotes.

This is going to go nowhere.

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by nikisweeting on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:10PM (#26393460)
Game platforms have been providing cross-game "unlocks" / achievements for years, and they're only moving more towards that (this is one of the whole reasons for Epic, Riot, etc. shipping their own launchers, it gives them a runtime on the client where they can securely share state between games).

It's going to be huge for VR in particular:

- https://www.roadtovr.com/getting-social-oculus-unifying-mult...

- https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8845288

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by Noos on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:08PM (#26377546)
It's more or less a small amount of whales that can actually buy meaningful amounts of cosmetics though. Cosmetics and digital content are EXPENSIVE; for a person to get many we're talking thousands of dollars. $30 US mounts are easy to make, and incredible profit.

Even granting people who buy limited amounts to show support, its very easy to price them out of the market fast.

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by gorbachev on Sunday March 07, 2021 @08:40AM (#26375740)
"We rail against companies selling cosmetic additions to games. It doesn't add value."

That's not quite true. There are sub-groups of gamers, in particular with racing games (e.g. Forza Motorsport), who do value cosmetic additions quite a bit.

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by drawkbox on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:48AM (#26374068)
Here's my Mr. Brightside view of it, there is a Black Mirror-esque side as well as some humans build towards utopias and some build toward dystopias. I look at the quality of life and good side of things where I can.

I agree with most of what you are saying but that is based on the current era. Created scarcity and exclusives are annoying but there are pros and cons. Putting value to something will create markets and digital markets you can take your stuff with you.

When we get to more augmented spaces it will change the world dramatically. There will have to be some sort of digital ownership that is transferrable preferably a standard outside walled platforms. For instance artists or entertainment events that are unique are collectible.

Uniqueness creates value, value creation makes markets, this would create massive amounts of jobs and quality of life/livelihood if done right. Already it is spawning some amazing art and assets. It is in a pump/bubble but new things always come out hot, rework, then in the end the best parts do live on and the initial bubble might have even been undervalued, like the internet, or mobile. The augmented space will have all sorts of network effects like that.

It is in the very early stages, like a sketch of a storyboard early on in pre-production, everything early on in a way sucks, but we do know that over time the world will be more augmented and in that space digital ownership and uniqueness will be a thing.

The market is there now for collectibles and stores of value and it will only grow.

Take for instance you participate in a launch AR game for a launch event that takes place in your own environment with others locally or virtually, where you are in maybe a Stranger Things Upside Down world and you have to kill Demogorgons. The winner gets to keep the Demogorgon from that event. That item has value, you can buy a regular copy of one, but the original may be worth value over time. Do that same thing with any Star Wars, Marvel or other property, you start to see people will want those.

Or let's say you go to a concert and an event gets a recording from a musician that you get to keep and show others who are sharing your augmented space but you own it. You own the unique view or access, but others can get copies of other parts.

Or you watch a piece of digital art be created and the piece is sold and traded.

Like right now if I got to buy some sort of collectible from the first Half-life that was unique and part of it was my house or a yard can be turned into a level like datacore or stalkyard and I could have friends play it with a unique character added in from the Half-life launch it would be pretty awesome. There can be copies, but to have the one specified by the creator has some value and some uniqueness that creates that value.

Collectors love this type of stuff. Think of it like comicbooks, baseball cards, movie poster one sheets and unique characters. The fact that a collectible has value makes it more fun in a way but also creates value that can employ people and make a digital market. Markets like this will help keep people happy and doing things. The more people in the digital market the more jobs and resources out there. There is value in creating a marketplace that people can participate in that doesn't require physical assets/resources or even location. It could be used to help inequality and create economic markets. Economics can solve lots of problems but also require resources, if the resource problem is solved then it can be very beneficial.

These were just game/entertainment examples but you get the idea.

The coming eras of augmented reality and shared spaces on that will probably refine this idea more and more.

The far end of this is like some of the tech in Blade Runner 2049, unique landscapes, augmented bots that are friends/assistants that learn, companions like virtual pets, and other valuables that gain unique knowledge that cannot be replicated because it learned from your experience/event, but that is way in the future.

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by iamben on Sunday March 07, 2021 @06:49AM (#26375137)
Few things - I think the whole AR world could end up pretty sad. Imagine I go to a friend's house and all the art on his walls is mine? Like a world I've chosen where I'm not exposed to anyone else's tastes and choices?

That aside - isn't this all still likely to rely on something central? I mean it sounds like you're talking about something pretty close to Ready Player One (which was owned by a central corporation)? Any AR world (in order to be successful) is going to need a whack of capital (Google, FB, Apple) and then vested interest in making it successful/profiting from it - at which point why do you need a Blockchain to own items? If you were the corporation running it, wouldn't you just implement your own "in space" ownership? Not saying it's better or worse - just isn't that more likely?

Re:NFTs Are a Dangerous Trap by echelon on Sunday March 07, 2021 @04:09PM (#26379779)
The web was supposed to be distributed.

But we wound up with Facebook and Google.

AR and the metaverse will be the same.